Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

De Aza Claimed by White Sox

Featured Replies

You are wrong. I stated that Andino's ability to help out a team cannot be put on a stat sheet. Don't try to trivialize the accomplishments of Robert Andino, because his greatness is too great for your puny brains to comprehend.

Though I think what Dim says is half-tongue-in-cheek and very comical and the same goes to what FishDynasty said, I just have to mention that Baserunning Analysis from Bill James Online has Andino as an above average baserunner.

 

(I feel that's poorly worded... reads strangely.)

Though I think what Dim says is half-tongue-in-cheek and very comical and the same goes to what FishDynasty said, I just have to mention that Baserunning Analysis from Bill James Online has Andino as an above average baserunner.

 

(I feel that's poorly worded... reads strangely.)

 

Nah, I get what you're saying.

Never said that De Aza and Nunez were similar players. The "comparison" was actually a jab on how deceitful a hot streak in spring can be. Nunez was awarded a spot on the roster that he might not have otherwise have earned and De Aza was awarded a starting spot that he might not have otherwise earned. How injured was he during the last two months of the season when he hit .207/.246/.270/.516 in over 100 PA? Injury or no injury, nine games to start the season is not a healthy sampling size.

 

 

Nobody said you did. What you compared was their "career" up to this point. That's what I find to be unfair. As players they are totally different. I think ADA makes a name for himself. Not AS caliber, but he will be head and shoulders above what Nunez was ever capable of.

You are wrong. I stated that Andino's ability to help out a team cannot be put on a stat sheet. Don't try to trivialize the accomplishments of Robert Andino, because his greatness is too great for your puny brains to comprehend.

 

 

 

His greatness must also be too great for the puny minds of just about every ML FO out there as he was on the trading block for quite some time. Most were saying what alot here saw; slick glove but can't handle ML pitching. Or, and I'm just throwing this one out there, maybe the world is right and you are wrong. Let's see where his "greatness" takes him from here.

Never said that De Aza and Nunez were similar players. The "comparison" was actually a jab on how deceitful a hot streak in spring can be. Nunez was awarded a spot on the roster that he might not have otherwise have earned and De Aza was awarded a starting spot that he might not have otherwise earned. How injured was he during the last two months of the season when he hit .207/.246/.270/.516 in over 100 PA? Injury or no injury, nine games to start the season is not a healthy sampling size.

 

 

Most thought he had come back too soon from his injuries in '07. But we were pretty much between a rock and a hard place that year for CFers. Heck, upgrade that to OFers. Too bad the stats don't show that.

You are wrong. I stated that Andino's ability to help out a team cannot be put on a stat sheet. Don't try to trivialize the accomplishments of Robert Andino, because his greatness is too great for your puny brains to comprehend.

 

 

 

His greatness must also be too great for the puny minds of just about every ML FO out there as he was on the trading block for quite some time. Most were saying what alot here saw; slick glove but can't handle ML pitching. Or, and I'm just throwing this one out there, maybe the world is right and you are wrong. Let's see where his "greatness" takes him from here.

 

 

I think it was sarcasm.

I hate to see ADA going to another organization but he was a very fragile player. I wouldn't call him AAAA player because he seemed snake bitten. It is a good move for ADA because he has a chance of making the ChiSox. I am not so sure if he would have made the Marlin's 25 man roster, I love BC as our 4th Outfielder. I guess a lot would have to do with CC if he gets moved back to the Infield, Fredi has hinted he prefers to keep him in the Outfield, Hermida is almost a certainty to be gone. We have Maybin, Ross in the Outfield for 2010, after that who knows? Maybe losing ADA was not so meaningless as it seems. It all depends if the young guns like Morrison, Stanton and Peterson are ready to take over. I am starting to believe Beinfest is hedging his bets on them

I'd like to post in defense of anyone who was angry about the Andino situation. I for one did not think Andino was going to emerge as an all-star or anything, but a lot of the frustration in getting rid of him came from the fact that we all knew we were handing a significant role to a player who wasn't worth a flip either in Bonifacio. At least Andino played good defense. Bonifacio couldn't even do that. His one strength, speed, is a pretty useless skill if you can't get on base regularly and haven't developed the skill to actually steal a base. Bonfiacio OPSed .611, Andino .562. They both sucked, and the Marlins (composed of people whose job is to make baseball decisions) were as wrong about Bonifacio as boardies here were about Andino. And I really think that nobody on the board really wanted either to be starting anyway.

 

Given that we had a complete surplus of offensive players to end the 2008 season, I still find it absolutely ridiculous that we went from that to having an offensive void at a premium offensive position. And as I've said before, it has nothing to do with payroll when you give away talented players like Josh Willingham. On a team that has so few resources, it is imperative that we not squander the little talent that we have.

You are wrong. I stated that Andino's ability to help out a team cannot be put on a stat sheet. Don't try to trivialize the accomplishments of Robert Andino, because his greatness is too great for your puny brains to comprehend.

 

 

 

His greatness must also be too great for the puny minds of just about every ML FO out there as he was on the trading block for quite some time. Most were saying what alot here saw; slick glove but can't handle ML pitching. Or, and I'm just throwing this one out there, maybe the world is right and you are wrong. Let's see where his "greatness" takes him from here.

 

 

I think it was sarcasm.

 

So was mine.

Never said that De Aza and Nunez were similar players. The "comparison" was actually a jab on how deceitful a hot streak in spring can be. Nunez was awarded a spot on the roster that he might not have otherwise have earned and De Aza was awarded a starting spot that he might not have otherwise earned. How injured was he during the last two months of the season when he hit .207/.246/.270/.516 in over 100 PA? Injury or no injury, nine games to start the season is not a healthy sampling size.

 

 

Most thought he had come back too soon from his injuries in '07. But we were pretty much between a rock and a hard place that year for CFers. Heck, upgrade that to OFers. Too bad the stats don't show that.

How were the stats wrong?

 

The Marlins had an .830 OPS in Willingham and an .870 OPS in Hermida. They were fine in the corner outfield positions.

 

CF was lacking a tad but a Ross/Amezaga platoon was serviceable enough if it had been administered properly. There was no real need to rush De Aza back; I doubt anyone really thought he could match the production of the platoon, even if healthy.

 

Stop putting words in my mouth. Never said the stats were wrong. What I said was that you have to look beyond the stats sometimes. Going back a couple years and JUST looking at the stats dosen't tell the entire picture. This case in point.

 

But I do agree. There was no reason to rush him back. That platoon was fine. And at the time I thought it would be a good idea to let him get in better "game shape" at the AAA level for a bit longer. But the powers that be seemed to want an every day CFer. So what happened happened. Crying about it or claiming to be smarter than the powers that be in hindsight is pretty useless at this point.

 

Bottom line is that we couldn't protect everybody. And right now I'm looking forward to ST to see why we opted to protect Jai instead of ADA.

Before the Marlins acquired Bonifacio I think there was enough ground for skepticism over Andino. He certainly showed no indications of ever being a viable starter at the major league level should Dan Uggla be traded. I would even argue that there should have been skepticism that he could hit well enough to warrant earning a spot as a utility player no matter how good is defense appeared to be.

 

I cannot speak for Beinfest and am uncertain what he saw in Bonifacio, but I suspect that he saw greater potential in him than he did in Andino. Payroll absolutely was a factor in in the Willingham trade (at least in part). The Marlins likely foresaw the possibility of Maybin starting in centerfield and were forced to keep two out of Willingham, Ross, and Hermida. Willingham's bad back and the Marlins' reluctance to give up on Hermida made Josh the odd man out. I don't think we can speculate how highly valued Bonifacio was in the deal, but I think it is safe to assume that Beinfest wanted to add depth for the 3B/2B positions and decide from there.

 

Don't forget that Andino was dealt late into spring training after he had been outhit by Bonifacio. Bonifacio "earned" the job and Amezaga was promised a spot on the roster so Andino became expendable. If Andino hadn't played so terribly in spring training when his job was on the line, then I don't think he would have been so readily replaced with Bonifacio.

 

The Marlins made the right decisions. They added depth to those positions and then let the players duke it out. Unfortunately, the player Bonifacio went on to play only slightly better than Andino did in the regular season.

 

Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't remember anyone here saying that Bonifacio "wasn't worth a lick" until the the latter weeks of April.

 

 

I don't think that's the right assumption. You are overlooking way too much. Boni was playing the OF in most of Winter Ball. I think they figured him to be more of a utility 2B, SS, and OFer going into ST. But the absolute failures of Gaby and Dallas in ST warranted a different approach. I believe the wrong decision was putting too much faith in Gaby being able to handle the majors without very much to back it up. Had he worked out, Cantu would have been at 3B. Even if he hadn't and Cantu was at 1B, then Dallas working out would have had him at 3B and Boni working the bench. But neither did with their bat or glove. Dallas was released, Gaby sent to AAA, and we were left filling a hole at 3B with someone very unfamiliar with the role and learning on the fly. Not a good thing most of the time. And aside from maybe The Amazing, no one else was better equiped to handle the spot. Unfortunetly. At the time it happened it left me thinking we were just biding our time, waiting for our real 3B to work his way up through the minors while hoping Boni would develope defensively at third more like Cantu did the year before.

Well if he had to go anywhere, I am glad he went to the White Sox. Bet he will do great there....

Never said that De Aza and Nunez were similar players. The "comparison" was actually a jab on how deceitful a hot streak in spring can be. Nunez was awarded a spot on the roster that he might not have otherwise have earned and De Aza was awarded a starting spot that he might not have otherwise earned. How injured was he during the last two months of the season when he hit .207/.246/.270/.516 in over 100 PA? Injury or no injury, nine games to start the season is not a healthy sampling size.

 

 

Most thought he had come back too soon from his injuries in '07. But we were pretty much between a rock and a hard place that year for CFers. Heck, upgrade that to OFers. Too bad the stats don't show that.

 

CF was lacking a tad but a Ross/Amezaga platoon was serviceable enough if it had been administered properly. There was no real need to rush De Aza back; I doubt anyone really thought he could match the production of the platoon, even if healthy.

 

Ross really never factored into the CF equation until opening day '08, a couple days after De Aza got the injury in the last ST game. Its obvious that the Marlins liked Cody's bat because he did get semi-consistent starts in place of Willingham and other players, but seeing as he didn't really play a game in CF in 2006 (when we were truly lacking there) or 2007, I think Cody's effectiveness in CF was a surprise to the organization. He surely doesn't seem like the prototypical CFer at all, but he has great instincts and thats hard to measure. They threw him out there as the lesser side of the platoon with Amezaga, why they when they hadn't before I don't know, and he gradually earned more PT for himself and proved that he could really the handle the position. Cody had both more potential and production than any player who had played CF from 2006-2008, and there is no way that this organization trots out guys like Amezaga, Jacque Jones, De Aza, and Abercrombie if they knew that Cody could have handled center. As a corner OF he is nothing special, but a .260 hitter with good power great run production is a plus in CF.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.