August 22Aug 22 Let's keep trotting Tyler Zuber and Cade Gibson out there and pretending they are major league pitchers.You can wish in one hand and SH*T in another and come to the same conclusion.Career WAR:farmer-fran 0.0Tyler Zuber -0.5What are we even doing?
August 22Aug 22 31 years old with a small positive variance in a short sample size. Im sure he won't regress and his future value is more negative than Starling Marte's right now. But yeah, let's not pitch 17 guys in the minors who would be better.Third-grade math classes can figure out he will suck going forward.But yeah, here's Gibson.
August 22Aug 22 What is the Marlins BA when swinging at the first pitch? This is pathetic to watch this team time and time again when a reliever comes in and they swing away.
August 22Aug 22 We do forget that we score more runs in the 8th and 9th than we do in any other innings
August 22Aug 22 Honestly don't get the Sielaff hate. Guy is as passionate as it comes.They had an announcer poll and the Marlins ranked 27th, fyi.
August 22Aug 22 0-2, 2 outs, then walk the tying run.Then 2 disengagements and an easy jump to steal to get in scoring position.IT"S THE LITTLE THINGS!
August 22Aug 22 2 hours ago, TheMarlinsProject said:Honestly don't get the Sielaff hate. Guy is as passionate as it comes.They had an announcer poll and the Marlins ranked 27th, fyi.I like Sielaff. He seems much more like a “hometown” guy than Severino, which is why I wasn’t big on him…..he always felt like a national announcer covering a local team for a game
August 22Aug 22 Sieloff only got the job because Geffner was critical of ownership and wasn’t the company man ownership wanted.Kyle plays the company man role perfectly. It’s his cringey smugness and screamo voice that makes some us cringe.
August 22Aug 22 Author I like Sielaff. He's not perfect but he's also very young and will learn from his mistakes. At least he has a personality unlike Severino. I have listened to our radio guys here and there and his series he got on TV, but I may like Jack McMullen even more than Sielaff. I like the Radio broadcast even when Rod Allen is on there, who I don't care for. You know who I thought was very good on Radio? Last year when Griffin Conine was hurt for like the whole year, they had him on the radio broadcasts sometimes as like a secondary color guy. I thought he was great, very funny and his insight into the team actually added to the broadcast.They need to figure out the color analyst situation. Pick 1 guy, but they have to go outside their current crop of guys, especially with Tommy retiring. Gaby is ok, but the rest I don't care for.
August 22Aug 22 16 hours ago, DTrain said:Sieloff only got the job because Geffner was critical of ownership and wasn’t the company man ownership wanted.Kyle plays the company man role perfectly. It’s his cringey smugness and screamo voice that makes some us cringe.His enthusiasm sounds fake and manufactured sometimes which is my only issue. I think when he’s with Tommy he can be very good though but he’s mediocre with all the other very below average guys they pair him with. He also does overdo the slobbing Bendix knob thing all the time. Hes young and I like his energy and could see him really growing into it with consistent color commentary guy
August 24Aug 24 On 8/22/2026 at 7:56 AM, farmer_fran said:I like Sielaff. He's not perfect but he's also very young and will learn from his mistakes. At least he has a personality unlike Severino. I have listened to our radio guys here and there and his series he got on TV, but I may like Jack McMullen even more than Sielaff. I like the Radio broadcast even when Rod Allen is on there, who I don't care for. You know who I thought was very good on Radio? Last year when Griffin Conine was hurt for like the whole year, they had him on the radio broadcasts sometimes as like a secondary color guy. I thought he was great, very funny and his insight into the team actually added to the broadcast.They need to figure out the color analyst situation. Pick 1 guy, but they have to go outside their current crop of guys, especially with Tommy retiring. Gaby is ok, but the rest I don't care for.Yeah, they definitely need to find the next Tommy......the current crop isn't doing it.I did hear McMullen when he filled in for a few games. He was pretty good......IIRC that was to prep for him being the fill in guy next year when Sielaff is out.On 8/22/2026 at 4:23 PM, pollythewog said:His enthusiasm sounds fake and manufactured sometimes which is my only issue. I think when he’s with Tommy he can be very good though but he’s mediocre with all the other very below average guys they pair him with.He also does overdo the slobbing Bendix knob thing all the time.Hes young and I like his energy and could see him really growing into it with consistent color commentary guyEh, I feel like I'd take some occasional fake enthusiasm over a monotone "national" sounding broadcast.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.