Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

PUDGE 4 for 40!

Featured Replies

New lineup

 

Vina 2b

Guillen SS

Pudge C

Young Dh

White Cf

Pena 1b

Higginson Rf

Palmer 3b (275 career HR's, and 849 career RBI's)

Sanchez Cf

Why in the world would Sanchez not be leading off?

 

Vina would bat second, and Guillen would bat toward the end of the order. munson is at 3rd and hes gonna be raw

Still no word from pudge....

 

Tigers get no budge by Pudge

 

Four years, $40 million still catcher's best offer

January 19, 2004

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

BY GENE GUIDI

FREE PRESS SPORTS WRITER

 

 

 

 

We found out Sunday which teams will be playing in the Super Bowl, but we still don't know if Ivan Rodriguez will be playing for the Tigers this season.

 

The free-agent catcher and his agent, Scott Boras, are weighing the Tigers' four-year, $40-million offer, which the Free Press learned is accurate.

 

With the team's offices closed today for the Martin Luther King Jr. holiday and Boras busy finalizing arbitration cases for other clients, it's likely we won't know Rodriguez's decision until Wednesday or Thursday.

 

Boras has said another team or teams expressed interest in Rodriguez, but they've yet to surface publicly.

 

And based on the offers made to Rodriguez earlier this off-season -- $24 million for three years from the Marlins and Orioles -- it's hard to imagine that any team at this juncture would top the Tigers' offer.

 

The Tigers' four-year offer to a 32-year-old catcher surprised many because that hasn't been the norm this off-season.

 

Since last season ended, six players have signed for more than three years: Javier Vazquez, Bartolo Colon, Miguel Tejada, Keith Foulke, Ichiro Suzuki and Vladimir Guerrero.

 

But the Tigers knew the only way they could get a name free agent was to overpay.

 

Now that the deal is on the table, the Tigers hope Rodriguez doesn't get cold feet -- literally and figuratively -- after visiting cold and snowy Detroit last week

 

http://www.freep.com/sports/tigers/horn19_20040119.htm

Where's the love??

 

Okay, okay... so the Tigers stunk it up pretty bad last year, but the way some of your guys are talking you'd think the Tigers haven't won a thing ever!

 

To refresh some of those memories, Detroit still holds the record as the best team through 40 games (35-5 in 1984). Sure, we've stunk for the last 15 years, but we still have a number of WS rings from the past. The Tigers are been pretty meek kitties the last few years, but that doesn't mean we will never have teeth!

 

DD has made some nice off season moves I think, and Pudge would be a great pickup. We'd really need to overachieve to make it even to the AL Central, but I do expect some real improvement this year. When looking at the pickups we've made, you need to realize that even average level MLB players are improvements over those whom they are replaceing.

 

Here's how things have changed:

LF: Rondell White replaces Craig Monroe

While Monroe showed a some nice bat and glove work, he still needs some seasoning. White will be an improvement offensively.

 

CF: Alex Sanchez -- No change

 

RF: Bobby Higginson -- No change

Hopefully Higgy will be back to 100% as he was nursing a sore hammy pretty much all of last year. He could also see some platoon time with Monroe, especially if his hammy is still a problem.

 

3B: Eric Munson -- No change

Munson was a question mark defensively... he never played 3B until he was moved there last year to replace the oft injuried Dean Palmer. Munson will likely be manning the hot corner again unless Palmer is a MAJOR suprise in SprTrn. Munson was pretty good for a rookie offensively...needs to improve defensively.

 

SS: Carlos Guillen replaces Ramon Santiago

Guillen has been reported as a slightly above average SS offensively and defensively. This is a HUGE upgrade over a VERY weak offensive position for us last year. And while Santiago was adequite defensively, Guillen should be better.

 

2B: Frenado Vina replaces Morris

Vina isn't a very big upgrade offensively, unless he starts to return to his 2001 type offensive form. He also isn't a huge upgrade defensively, but hopefully he'll be a little of both. He will certainly bring more experience.

 

1B: Carlos Pena -- No change

There is hope that with better performers around him, Pena will improve offensively... that he won't feel like he needs to carry the whole load on his shoulders and can relax at the plate. Pena has a lot of potential and needs to start showing it this year.

 

C: Pudge replaces Brandon Inge

This would be a MAJOR offensive upgrade for the Tigers. Inge is extremely inconsistant offensively...occasional weeks of fantastic bat work followed by months of dribbling ground balls and weak fly outs.

 

DH: Dmitri Young -- No change

Young had a career year last year. Hopefully he'll continue it this year, but it's likely he'll slip a bit. We'll have to see.

 

Now, while it doesn't seem like there's is that much of a change, the important thing to realize is that two of the upgrades have changed from worst to near first...

Last year's lineup:

 

1. Sanchez

2. Morris

3. Higginson

4. Young

5. Pena

6. Monroe

7. Munson

8. Santiago

9. Inge

 

Now, this years possible lineup (assuming Pudge signs):

 

1. Sanchez

2. Vina

3. Higginson

4. Young

5. Pudge

6. White

7. Pena

8. Munson

9. Guillen

 

That's just one possible lineup... it's hard to say with so many new people what the lineup will be. But the important thing to look at is that we get new legitimate 4-6 hitters in White and IRod. That means that Munson and Pena, who were barely holding their own as hitters in that 4-6 range get bumped to 7-9 stange, where their MORE than average. Our 1-3 range improves (slightly) 4-6 range improves (nicely), and our 7-9 range improves (substantially).

 

Okay, this turned out to be a MUCH bigger post that I originally intended, and I didn't even touch on the pitchers, which is a whole different story. But I hope I've identified why Tigers fans are a bit more excited by this year, and how Pudge will be a bit help for us.

The fact that Pudge hasn't accepted the deal that he was waiting for all of the offseason has a MAJOR red flag raised for me right now.

Just take the money like you know you want to Pudge. I've always been a Tigers fan (closet, I was born there) and I'd still like to see him sign. If he doesn't take this offer then he's just retarded. The Tigers have publicly said they are willing to overpay for free agents and every big name so far has spurned them. Pudge may not want to be the only star on the team maybe? Nah, he's just waiting until Bor-ass tells him to sign, puppet.

 

At least the Tigers won't lose 119. Alan Trammel should be worth about 15 wins and a decent year by Pudge should be worth 10.

Just why is it that Pudge/Borass haven't jumped all over the 4 yr/$40M offer from the Tigers? Isn't it just what he has been asking this entire off-season?

 

There is only one explanation really. Boras/Pudge have been insincere in their discussions with the Tigers. Pudge doesn't want to go Detroit. But Borass realizes the Tigers must overpay to attract big name players. So he gets Dombrowski to meet his demands, and then uses that as leverage to get any other interested team to match the Tiger's offer. What a slimeball. My hope is that it fails, the Tigers become impatient and send Pudge packing.

I can think of at least two other reasons:

 

1. The owner wants to pay it but Dombrowski says no he'll quit if forced to make the deal.

 

2. The offer isn't really there, it's what Borass has told the Tigers Pudge will sign for.

Just why is it that Pudge/Borass haven't jumped all over the 4 yr/$40M offer from the Tigers? Isn't it just what he has been asking this entire off-season?

 

There is only one explanation really. Boras/Pudge have been insincere in their discussions with the Tigers. Pudge doesn't want to go Detroit. But Borass realizes the Tigers must overpay to attract big name players. So he gets Dombrowski to meet his demands, and then uses that as leverage to get any other interested team to match the Tiger's offer. What a slimeball. My hope is that it fails, the Tigers become impatient and send Pudge packing.

Good point. Pudge seems like he don't want to go to Detroit.

 

Are we seeing a similar situation like Vlad and the O's?

No, I don't believe so. Vlad never wanted to go to O's, and he wasn't exactly being offered top dollar there anyways. He ended up getting more. Pudge is looking at the best offer he is going to get if we are hearing the truth, and he isn't going to get close to that from any team.

 

Possibilities:

A) Offer doesn't exist

B) Offer exists but is complicated and needs to be worked out

C) Offer exists, and Pudge has realized that it isn't all about the money

D) Offer exists, and Boras is trying one last time to save his job by putting Pudge on a better team

No, I don't believe so. Vlad never wanted to go to O's, and he wasn't exactly being offered top dollar there anyways. He ended up getting more. Pudge is looking at the best offer he is going to get if we are hearing the truth, and he isn't going to get close to that from any team.

 

Possibilities:

A) Offer doesn't exist

B) Offer exists but is complicated and needs to be worked out

C) Offer exists, and Pudge has realized that it isn't all about the money

D) Offer exists, and Boras is trying one last time to save his job by putting Pudge on a better team

yeah, I have to agree with you

No, I don't believe so. Vlad never wanted to go to O's, and he wasn't exactly being offered top dollar there anyways. He ended up getting more. Pudge is looking at the best offer he is going to get if we are hearing the truth, and he isn't going to get close to that from any team.

 

Possibilities:

A) Offer doesn't exist

B) Offer exists but is complicated and needs to be worked out

C) Offer exists, and Pudge has realized that it isn't all about the money

D) Offer exists, and Boras is trying one last time to save his job by putting Pudge on a better team

I'm going to pick a hybrid of A and B.

 

I just get kind of hesitant whenever I hear a "major league source" cited when negotiations with Boras "heat up."

 

Hmmm, could Boras be that source?

No, I don't believe so. Vlad never wanted to go to O's, and he wasn't exactly being offered top dollar there anyways. He ended up getting more. Pudge is looking at the best offer he is going to get if we are hearing the truth, and he isn't going to get close to that from any team.

 

Possibilities:

A) Offer doesn't exist

B) Offer exists but is complicated and needs to be worked out

C) Offer exists, and Pudge has realized that it isn't all about the money

D) Offer exists, and Boras is trying one last time to save his job by putting Pudge on a better team

I think the offer exists but is so complicated that Pudge won't do it. Owner is insisting that he is trying really hard to get top talent. Really he is making it impossibe for Pudge to do it. But Boras is in a bind, his mouth got him in trouble. Pudge will keep looking. Probably until someones Top catcher goes down with an injury.

No, I don't believe so. Vlad never wanted to go to O's, and he wasn't exactly being offered top dollar there anyways. He ended up getting more. Pudge is looking at the best offer he is going to get if we are hearing the truth, and he isn't going to get close to that from any team.

 

Possibilities:

A) Offer doesn't exist

B) Offer exists but is complicated and needs to be worked out

C) Offer exists, and Pudge has realized that it isn't all about the money

D) Offer exists, and Boras is trying one last time to save his job by putting Pudge on a better team

I think the offer exists but is so complicated that Pudge won't do it. Owner is insisting that he is trying really hard to get top talent. Really he is making it impossibe for Pudge to do it. But Boras is in a bind, his mouth got him in trouble. Pudge will keep looking. Probably until someones Top catcher goes down with an injury. If he does that he's sitting out past spring training so he might as well come back here...

quickie from FREEP.com:

 

Ilitch seizes key role to get Pudge

 

January 20, 2004

 

 

 

 

 

BY GENE GUIDI

FREE PRESS SPORTS WRITER

 

 

 

 

The key player in ongoing negotiations between the Tigers and free-agent catcher Ivan Rodriguez has become owner Mike Ilitch.

 

Those close to the situation say that a strong interest on both sides remains and an agreement is tantalizingly close -- so close that ESPN on Monday reported, and then quickly doused, a story that it was a done deal. So close that all it might take to get Pudge to budge is a push from Ilitch in the right direction -- maybe even a quick trip by the owner to Rodriguez's off-season home in Florida. Or maybe just a couple of phone calls will do.

 

Ilitch certainly got Rodriguez's attention with a four-year, $40-million offer, which easily tops the previous best deals of three years for $24 million offered by the Marlins and Orioles, both of which Rodriguez rejected.

 

Rodriguez and Ilitch had a fruitful one-hour meeting in Detroit last week when the catcher took a physical at the request of the owner. If Ilitch continues to follow up on that face-to-face talk, people close to Pudge think that will improve the Tigers' chances of landing Rodriguez.

 

At 32, Rodriguez doesn't necessarily need to play for a ready-made contender this season, but he no doubt would like assurances that Ilitch and the Tigers are committed to continuing their improvement after a 119-loss season in 2003. If Ilitch can convince Rodriguez that he would be the centerpiece of a rebirth of baseball in Detroit, a deal could get done in a hurry.

 

What the owner thinks is very important to Rodriguez, who felt he kept his end of the bargain in Florida by helping deliver a World Series championship with the Marlins. He thought ownership didn't do its part because it offered less money per year on a three-year deal than on the one-year, $10-million contract he signed before the 2003 season.

 

As it stands, talks continue between Rodriguez's agent, Scott Boras, and Tigers president and general manager Dave Dombrowski, which is a positive sign. The men have a good relationship and combined to get catcher Charles Johnson signed to a five-year, $35-million contract with the Marlins when Dombrowski was their GM.

 

There was speculation that the Mariners might look to upgrade their catching with Rodriguez, a 10-time All-Star. They have extra money because reliever Kazuhiro Sasaki decided to forgo the remaining $9.5 million of his contract to stay home in Japan.

:banghead

I can't understand how pudge is not back. He kept his end of his deal, helping the Marlins become the Champions. He did. I think he is worth the $40 m. for the 4 years. maybe if the Marlins would have offered 30 million for3 years. He is the best catcher there is.

 

Detroit, well its not a good ballclub, but they are willing to pay to get back in the game. the Marlins were in the same situation last year, if it wouldnt have been for Jack nor Pudge and the rest that are not there, they would not have been Champions.

 

Even Jack said in an interview, it is going to be hard this year. He knows. He is not blind. He has to start all over again. If the Marlins don't bring Pudge back I don't think it will. And I really hope that with being such a cheapsakes, a new curse will arise. For not keeping Pudge.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.