Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. I mentioned his name (Eric Reed) to make the point that if Ross and/or Hermida are unable to open the season our options are somewhat limited, certainly not suggesting he's our Opening Day centerfielder.
  2. Not worth a new thread, but... Here's some good news of sorts. The Mets just announced their starting rotation and John Maine pitches fourth, meaning he'll not pitch against us in the opening series. Considering his success I am quite pleased.
  3. Part of it depends on Mr. Hermida and when he'll be back. Unless you want to see Alfredo Amezaga platooning in either center or right with great frequency (as I would guess although it's early in the year you might not want Gonzalez out there every game), assuming the general consensus is correct and Maybin goes to Carolina, and how quickly Ross comes back the options are probably limited to Eric Reed and Brett Carroll.
  4. You look at their stats and they are virtually identical give or take a few percentage points. The Marlins could have brought both up last September but instead brought only Hoover up which might be some indicator but with these things you don't know how banged up Baker was, or some other factor out of our sphere of knowledge, so in the end, and it is just a guess, the Marlins if the they need a replacement catcher will go with Hoover until Rabelo is healed.
  5. Joe Capozzi in his blog suggests something about Castillo's demeanor "spooked" the Marlins, and Beinfest is quoted elsewhere as saying they were unsure how he would have taken to being anything other than a starter (shades of Pittsburgh).
  6. What's interesting is that there has been zero press confirmation of anything, up, down or sideways. You would think since the entire press corps was there to see Hendrickson prep for Opening Day someone would have something on the wires by now. This is some kind of work in progress, not your usual waivering of a player. For those who listened on the radio Frisaro was on the pre-game/rain relay broadcast and before he could bring up Castillo which i thought was the next subject to be discussed was literall in mid-sentence yanked off the air by someone Marlins-related. Van Horne had to kind of vamp for a minute that Joe had been called a away... And so far not a word from on the Marlins website either. Interestingly the story reporting the canceled game that appears just now on the Marlins website is written by one of Orioles' MLB reporters. As of this writing, if we use the post above for a timeline, Castillo left spoke to reporters and left camp before or around noon, and here it is after 4:30pm and nothing has appeared as of yet. Nothing. Interesting...
  7. Go do some research on the subject before you talk about it again, please. You are coming off as really ignorant right now. It's the typical get in line and goosestep with the rest of us or you're ignorant response I would expect from statheads. My complaint is not with production stats - BA, OBP, SLG, there are too many legitimate ones to list here - but rather with the theoretical ones, and what goes with it, all players are the same, we could put a uniform on a number and it could play second base just as well a human being, is that they are the product of an immature set of theories masquerading as fact. There are two basic problems, the obsession and absolutism of those who probably know the least about it as evidenced here and that there simply are not enough variables invloved in formula construction to make most of it valid. By not taking enough factors into account the end-product is doomed to be nothing more than a cute number in a tutu dancing accross a computer screen. I'm not anti-stat, they have their place as "a" tool, "a" consideration in the mix in the decision-making process, people forget a lot of what they are trying to quantify the brain is doing on the fly and much more effficiently only their frustration comes from not being able to deconstruct that cerebral analysis and get it down on paper. That's why to a person virtually everyone who plays baseball professionally say the word "clutch" represents something real, and of course the national anthem of statheads is "there's no such thing as clutch" and when confronted with the fact that players, the people actually doing the work not the bean-counters with their calculators see it differently, the universal, absolute, there is no wiggle room, it's our way or the highway, you moron get out of the way our bus is coming through stat-head answer is every baseball player is wrong. Or, not making myself to be on the same league as professional players, I'm simply ignorant because I don't buy your propaganda and agree to sign up in your war against baseball as a sport and not a video game. It's not enough that I find value in some of it, if I don't subscribe 100% to this I am as you called me ignorant, and I've been called worse by your type. If I were to reach out my hand and say let's agree on this much at least the typical response is to slap me back for not accepting as gospel everything. So after a number of tmes watching that happen my solution to ignore all but straight production stats. But getting back to the subject at hand, if somehow Jorge Cantu was able in 2008 to mimic his 2005 performance of 171 hits, 40 doubles, 28 homeruns and 117 RBIs and only 70 strikeouts in 600 ABs, I would be thrilled with that performance and gladly accept all his flaws like not getting on base as much as we'd like as part of the whole package. And you know what his OPS was that hot that season either but nothing beats driving in 117 runs in 162 games, except maybe driving in 118 runs in 162 games.
  8. Except that stats are nothing more than a record of production. Stats are "sometimes" a record of production, sometimes they only show a sliver of the whole of a player's production, especially when you have an aberrance like Cantu's offensive production vs walks that season. Stats are meant to be relevant within certain ranges. There are all kinds of scenarios where some number is so far outside of the norm that it skews everything. It's like taking the average of .229,.235,.410 and .380 and saying the guy is a .315 hitter when clearly its not illustrative of what kind of hitter he is. In the case of Cantu he makes an extrordinary high amount of contact and it skews his numbers. He plays in a different park and hits less doubles and homeruns and his number fall to sh*t as probably do his rbis and his .310 obp remains the constant. Theres just too many factors at work to say this stat or that defines everything you need to know about a particular player. I don't care if he hits deep flyballs that allow runners to move up or someone scores on a fielder's choice because he made contact. The run score, the runners advanced, you win baseball games because you score more runs than the other team, not because one team's OBP is is higher than the others. As Marlins fans we should be acutely aware of that as how many times have we seen the team leave a dozen runners on base and lose ballgames? Too many. I can forgive or even ignore a lower than I'd like OBP if there's a guy who finds a way to bring those guys we've left stranded on the bases home to score. I'm sorry, but you are all kinds of wrong here, man. Cantu isn't a productive ball player both because of his low OBP and because he just doesn't do many other things well. In his best ML season he had a .497 SLG. RBI are a pretty meaningless statistic, since they are dependent more on where a player hits in the lineup than what he does. If Hanley bats 3rd last year and puts up the same OPS, he's a 120 RBI guy. And you're whole point in the 3rd paragraph actually works against Cantu. His value is almost entirely dependent on him making contact and having those balls find holes in the defense. If he gets lucky and his balls find the holes in the outfield, he's a decent hitter, as 2005 showed. But anyone whose value is based entirely on balls in play is going to fluctuate too much to every be anything more than a marginal player. And your last point is wrong as well. Yeah, you win baseball games because you score more runs, but there is almost a %100 correlation between a team's OBP and it's runs scored. The top 5 teams in runs scored and OBP will almost always be very similar every year. Since you feel the need like so many staheads who think the game is played by numbers and not people let me be absolutist too. No. You are wrong. 117 RBIs is not a meaningless number it represents real people crossing a real plate scoring real runs in real games. So no, you're wrong. You say 170 hits, 40 doubles, 27 homeruns and 117 RBis are not a good season regardless of anything else. You ask 100 real professional baseball players, members of the MLBPA, not statmasters sitting behind their computers if they would feel like they had a good season putting up those numbers and if 100 out of 100 don't say they'd love to put up those numbers it's because you asked a Miguel Cabrera who puts up even better numbers, and the other 95% of the players playing today only wish they could ever achieve. The usual stathead answer is that baseball players don't know what they're talking about they just play the game, they're not half as smart as we are because we can show you you aren't doing this or its clear the result is a bear in a tree or neutral D or whatever the new buzzword is. Sorry no, you're wrong the game is played by real people who are trying to win games not flesh out their stats because in the game of baseball winning is vastly more important than win shares or OBP or any of this stuff that passes for anaylsis. So as long as you (not you really just your camp) speak as if players don't matter and only numbers that you say count matter. That real, tangible production means nothing because a formula hasn't been created to quantify it (which is of course the biggest problem with baseball stats, it's the equivalent of a basement do-it-yourself kit, in its infancy, and still needs to be burped like a baby, but the people who practice it think its a mature science) the correct answer for all real baseball fans is to reject all of it out of hand and say no, it might be great on your nintendo but it doesn't mean sh*t on the ballfield other than as an indicator that should be factored in as part of the decision-making process by people who understand the game is much more than that.
  9. I'm not going to argue with you but the very fact you feel you have to respond paragraph by paragraph really makes my point about micro-managing other people's posts and thoughts. The objective was to start a thread "about" baseball not to dedicate a page to dissecting the sub-head of a post about baseball. And I know it's a difficult concept for you to get your arms around but just because you read something a certain way doesn't mean that's the it's meant to, or should be read, even when a chorus of people who would have never given it a second thought read your comments and see something that isn't there too. "Spring 2008" just as it says is the period, the season (in the spring, summer fall, winter sense) and if you actually read what was written (I included links to and indicators that there was more to each story) you would see that along with being a retelling of today's (really yesterday's considering the time) performances each article focuses on each players collective spring training. Writers often use a day's events as a metaphor for the a longer period of time, and my snapshot was meant to do that. It's a day, it's all of spring training, it's two players who have now been thrown together forever because the enormity of the trade they we both a part of.
  10. Except that stats are nothing more than a record of production. Stats are "sometimes" a record of production, sometimes they only show a sliver of the whole of a player's production, especially when you have an aberrance like Cantu's offensive production vs walks that season. Stats are meant to be relevant within certain ranges. There are all kinds of scenarios where some number is so far outside of the norm that it skews everything. It's like taking the average of .229,.235,.410 and .380 and saying the guy is a .315 hitter when clearly its not illustrative of what kind of hitter he is. In the case of Cantu he makes an extrordinary high amount of contact and it skews his numbers. He plays in a different park and hits less doubles and homeruns and his number fall to sh*t as probably do his rbis and his .310 obp remains the constant. Theres just too many factors at work to say this stat or that defines everything you need to know about a particular player. I don't care if he hits deep flyballs that allow runners to move up or someone scores on a fielder's choice because he made contact. The run score, the runners advanced, you win baseball games because you score more runs than the other team, not because one team's OBP is is higher than the others. As Marlins fans we should be acutely aware of that as how many times have we seen the team leave a dozen runners on base and lose ballgames? Too many. I can forgive or even ignore a lower than I'd like OBP if there's a guy who finds a way to bring those guys we've left stranded on the bases home to score.
  11. He only walked 19 times all season. Why? Because he makes good contact almost every at bat. It's why you can't always trust stats (not a shot at stats folks, just making the point some players some years don't fit the mold).
  12. The .311 bobbob was referring to was in fact Cantu's OBP the season he put up the numbers I posted above. Hard to believe I know but frankly as I said give me the production and I'll ignore the stats thank you very very much.
  13. I wonder Rabb how you would have reacted if the performances of the two ballplayers was the the opposite and the headline and sub-head read the same way without comment on my part? Respectfully, I think your over-thinking this one and perhaps just a little bit micro-managing the sub-head (not even the headline) of a message board post. Really, look at some of the stuff posted here, I try to at least bring a little wit or a literary reference or "something" to threads I start, and I just can't please everyone or worry over how someone is going take every little word I use. I didn't call either player names. I let the words written by others speak for themselves as I had planned all day. I appreciate your words above but I honestly feel you're off-base, as I always say (and people hate it when I say it) this is a message board and people can post what they want and think what they want and form the opinions that they want. But it's also a two-way street.
  14. For the record, I had planned to do it this morning when I realized they were both pitching today. I had the headline in my head right from the get go. I've never said a single bad word about Dontrelle here or anywhere and in fact for much of spring training I've said it wouldn't be the worst thing if Miller sharpened his control with a stint in the minors. I would have done this if the opposite result had occurred. If you notice I posted the two stories without any comment on my part. As I said above it was meant to be a snapshot, a day in the life, a portrait of two players. So to suggest the comparison is unfounded is in reality just a roll of the dice.
  15. "If" (operative word) Jorge Cantu can give this team 170 hits, 40 doubles, 28 homeruns and 117 RBIs in place of Miguel Cabrera while striking out less than 90 times in almost 600 at bats I don't really care what his OPS or any other stat is, especially at the price point. :notworthy He does that and he's a candidate for National League Comeback Player of the Year.
  16. Willis has also had some good outings and Miller has had some bad ones. You can't compare the two on 1 day. It's called a snapshot. a day in the life. no more. no less.
  17. Dontrelle Willis remains inconsistent as Detroit Tigers lose to Toronto Blue Jays 5-3 The Associated Press Published: March 21, 2008 Tigers manager Jim Leyland knows Dontrelle Willis can succeed with his funky delivery. He just wants to see the same funky delivery each time. Willis gave up five runs and seven hits with four walks in 3 1-3 innings in Detroit's 5-3 loss to the Toronto Blue Jays on Friday. Willis didn't seem overly concerned. Leyland was, however, and said that Willis needs to develop more consistency. The left-hander, acquired with Miguel Cabrera during the offseason from the Florida Marlins, has a 6.59 earned run average and has been battling control problems. "He's not doing his mechanics the right way," Leyland said. "I don't mind his funky delivery, but not all the different types of funkiness I've been seeing this spring." Willis said he feels fine. (more) http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2008/03/21/...Jays-Tigers.php Andrew Miller has strong outing in Marlins' 8-3 win over Astros KISSIMMEE, Fla. ? Florida's Andrew Miller picked a great time to have one of his best outings of the spring. The 22-year-old lefty, still in the running to be Florida's opening day starter, allowed six hits and two runs in 5 2-3 innings of the Marlins 8-3 win over Houston on Friday. Miller, who came to the Marlins as part of the trade that sent Dontrelle Willis to Detroit, is competing with Mark Hendrickson, Rick VandenHurk and Ricky Nolasco to start Florida's opener March 31 against the Mets... ..."That was a very good outing for him," Marlins manager Fredi Gonzalez said of the sixth overall pick in the 2006 draft. "He is getting better every time out. He's making adjustments." Miller was encouraged to have a solid outing with many of Houston's top hitters, including Carlos Lee and Lance Berkman, in the lineup. "They had the lineup for the most part you've got to agree that they're going to go with," he said. "I think that's one of the good things of a game like this is that they're playing all their big guys." Miller, who is from Gainesville, Fla., had a personal cheering section of more than a dozen friends and relatives on Friday. "There's so many people here it's unbelievable," he said. "My family is pretty much all in the central and south Florida area. I left a lot of tickets." (edited and more) http://canadianpress.google.com/article/AL...NmGPlxY8nOJSIUA
  18. If in fact the Marlins put him on waivers yesterday the waiver period will run out sometime Tuesday as waivers are three business days. It should be noted that neither the Marlins or MLB site have him listed as being on waivers under transactions. I don't think this kind of "waivers" is ever really recorded in the transaction log. Unless someone is being put on waivers "For the purpose of giving him his unconditional release," that is. Around trade deadline time, players like Manny Ramirez, and sometimes entire rosters are placed on waivers to see if there is interest, and those are never in the transaction logs either. You know, it looks like you're right. All the transactions are "reassigned" "transfered" "outrighted" etc. there are no waivers listed. You learn something new every day :thumbup
  19. If in fact the Marlins put him on waivers yesterday the waiver period will run out sometime Tuesday as waivers are three business days. It should be noted that neither the Marlins or MLB site have him listed as being on waivers under transactions.
  20. I believe the reason third base is seen as important defensively is because a good and mobile third baseman (the thinking goes), makes Hanley a better shortstop so it's sort of a two'fer.
  21. news is Ross had to be helped off the field. i'm guessing it makes it more likely Maybin stays
  22. If they signed him for $650, what were they looking for that they didn't get from him? He pretty much came exactly as advertised. Solid defense, not much bat. Maybe they figured Cantu wouldn't make the roster.... but still I'd be hesitant to make a decision based solely on a couple weeks of spring training stats. Especially when money is so tight and they've got a half mill+ invested in him. As you said '03, they're probably hoping to get that back, but I'm still not sure what else they expected from him. You're preaching to choir Hot, I still am not clear on what's happening here.
  23. A few thoughts: 1. he's still not listed even on the MLB website has having been waived @ almost 3pm today. 2. the marlins may be shopping him to get their $650,000 back in $$$ or talent. 3. McPherson (on the 40 man) has options and signed a split contract so you don't need to waive Castillo to make room for Cantu on the roster. 4. Jimmy might be right it's a prelude to something except, usually you don't want to take a chance on a guy you're going to trade to be injured by playing him. 5. He's staying and this whole thing is a technical player movement chess move that Frisaro doesn't get or doesn't want to get because it makes him look foolish after yesterday's column. 6. What does Ross' injury mean in the scheme of things? (the domino effect scenario) 7. I went back and read this a couple of times and Frisaro's tone is much different than yesterday. Yesterday's was not let the door hit you in the butt on the way out, today is replete with quotes from the player and manager about wanting to stay and his good defense.
  24. Hey Polo, thanks for the good read :thumbup Anyways Castillo is the starting third baseman today. For this story to come out last night and him starting today is really strange, at least to me. it isn't like Frisaro gave the reader the impression that Castillo wasn't making the team, he gave the impression the decision had already been made and if it has why not just give the playing time to Cantu. Any other team who wanted to see what Castillo had to offer (ex. Dodgers) already know or have had scouts watchng him already. Tres' bizarre this whole thing.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.