Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. And once again Dan Uggla comes through in the clutch (my bad ) with a three run homerun to tie up the game after doubling in his first at bat. 3-3 top of the fourth miller has only walked one, unfortunately it led to a run for dodgers
  2. Count me in for the 16th straight year... ditto
  3. That ring really is quite a monument to 2003 isn't it. :thumbup
  4. I was thinking because we start the season with 4 SPs then give the slot to Dutchboy because he has some MLB experience and slip Burke into the long relief role for the first couple weeks. Gives him some experience at this level and makes it easier on him to slide into a SP role if need be later. Nolasco apparently is still having some control issues. AAA might be the better place for him at the start of the season just so he can get the playing time. The one comment I'd make Bob in choosing between the two is that Badenhop has a history of going deeper into games (including a complete game last season) that Vanden Hurk who I think has only gone six innings twice in seventeen starts and was as likely as not to make it three innings or less. Now does the kid look improved this season? Yes. If he can throw five or six innings his next start then certainly he's in the mix (and equally as important is the upcoming start Fredi is giving Badenhop in a few days who as everyone knows threw four scoreless innings last week with four strikeouts and six groundouts out of twelve). They have to know they're competing for the same roster spot unless something happens to one of the guys pretty much already penciled in so there's pressure on both of them.
  5. They all either have options or signed split contracts, but certainly from what's been written appears to be in no condition to be playing anywhere, here or Albuquerque. The Marlins may even hold him over for a few weeks in Jupiter for conditioning purposes as they've done with players in the past. But let's see what the next couple weeks left in ST hold for the guy, it's conceivable he could play a little before being shipped out. As for Castillo and Cantu, since starting spring training 0-11 Jose Castillo is batting over .370 and playing excellent defense at third so if he keeps it up you have to think Cantu has a fight on his hands if he expects to be at third for Opening Day regardless of what he's batting. The question is can Castillo stay hot or conversely, can Cantu start showing enough at third that the manager and coaches have some kind of comfort level with him playing the position and not making things worse for Hanley at shortstop?
  6. Sure. BTW, the word pragmatic is exactly the word I wanted to use - the word pragmatic having to do with being practical as opposed to the usual pie in the sky "let's trade Mike Jacobs for Johan Santana" trade proposals - and if you are language challenged I'll be glad to tutor you. I fear your tutoring. Language comprehension is a wonderful thing, try it sometime.
  7. it's great seeing the Marlins whack Trachsel around after years of watching the "human rain delay" drive Marlins hitters nuts.
  8. ....they have a problem that you think there is even a tiny chance that Cody won't be on the team. So, if I understand correctly Cody was handed the job the moment he arrived in camp this spring. I get it now, how silly of me. :banghead Rabb, it's not you. The thing is I never said Ross won't wind up with the job. I thought, I guess mistakenly, he had to compete for it like every other second tier player. But if there's not even a "tiny chance" someone else could win the job, maybe someone should tell them they'd be better off over in the minor league camp. (being as facetious as hell )
  9. Sure. BTW, the word pragmatic is exactly the word I wanted to use - the word pragmatic having to do with being practical as opposed to the usual pie in the sky "let's trade Mike Jacobs for Johan Santana" trade proposals - and if you are language challenged I'll be glad to tutor you.
  10. The reading comprehension level here goes further down every day. Here's what I actually said above: "I voted for Maybin for obvious reasons but with the caveat that he has to finish what he's started this spring before the job is handed to him. And I'm not all together sure Ross is on the Opening Day roster if both Cantu and Castillo are, it's going to be a fight to the finish between Cody, Carroll and de Aza. If you start the season with twelve pitchers which seems a reasonable assumption all things considered, two of the three won't be wearing Marlins uniforms come the start of the season." Somehow that becomes "he said Cody isn't making the team...wow did he really say that?...Geesus, what is this guy thinking?"... then you throw in a few insulting names like moron and stupid and what you said takes on a life of its own. Then I posted, "It's just the math. If Mabin, Cantu and Castillo are on the 25 man roster (which was the hypothesis) that will leave one roster spot left for the three outfielders to fight over. So far Ross isn't even hitting close to his weight and Carroll and De Aza have been flirting with .400 most of spring training. Who goes, who stays may not be settled until the last minute." I never said Cody Ross isn't making the team but of course some people because, well, because that's what they want to read. Maybe if some of you read what's written out loud that would help, or try reading what's posted really, really slowly and maybe three or four times, maybe then you'll start to understand what other people's post(s) actually say. The scenario went like this: 1. Maybin has to win the job first. 2. Castillo and Cantu both have to be on the roster plus 12 pitchers. 3. Ross, Carroll and de Aza have to fight it out to determine who gets the final roster spot. 4. However you look at it two of the three won't be with the team come Opening Day. I guess that's controversial, or sadly some people want to make it so.
  11. I don't know about anyone else but as I read through the mornings news articles on Maybin and the Marlins it really seems that they (the manager and FO) are still leaning towards sending him down. Maybe I read between the lines incorrectly but I do get that feeling. Maybe they're just daring Maybin to work even harder, to see what happens when he's under the microscope or in pressure-filled situations, or maybe it's about roster management which would be a shame if he's otherwise ready, but the Marlins are being very stingy with their words of praise about the kid, I suspect to not heighten expectations, for him or the fans when Opening Day rolls around. By no means though do I think the final decision has been made though. There's a lot riding on the decision for a number of players.
  12. Your suggestion is beyond ridiculous. It's in no way a suggestion, I'm not endorsing anything. It's called an "observation", based on the math, you only have 25 roster spots. I realize that's a difficult concept for some to grasp but there is a difference recognizing something could occur and wanting it to happen. It's all about whether Maybin stays with the parent club or goes to the minors. If he stays there is one roster spot, if he goes there are two. As for Hermida I guess you missed the point there too. I was celebrating the job he did last season and put him on a pedestal as the most valuable trade commodity on the team (putting aside the obvious). The rest was purely in the hypothetical, I think I used the word a number of times - if you want a particular result (securing a young, experienced quality arm who could be counted on for a number of years or dangled for tradebait when the time was right because you feel the team right now is lacking quality starting pitching), this is the best way to go about achieving it. I don't think I ever said, or even implied I wanted Jeremy Hermida traded, nor did I disparage him in any way. It was just a quality for quality hypothesis. Don't get your panties in a wad because I have an opinion.
  13. It's just the math. If Mabin, Cantu and Castillo are on the 25 man roster (which was the hypothesis) that will leave one roster spot left for the three outfielders to fight over. So far Ross isn't even hitting close to his weight and Carroll and De Aza have been flirting with .400 most of spring training. Who goes, who stays may not be settled until the last minute. By the way troll, if you need any help fitting that iron safe to your swelled head let me know, for that I can make time and I'd even do it pro bono.
  14. Just like those early 20th century scientists who thought they had all the right answers eventually they were discredited. You make exactly the same mistake they did. You treat all players the same. All have the same skills, all have the same desire, all have the same coordination, all have the same abilities. You quoted me out of context. I said you can't expect players to perform if the message is we don't care about losing now and you shouldn't either because when we start getting better we're replacing you. That's much different than how you twisted my words. But it appears that is your core belief. All players are merely pawns to be used and abused and cast aside when the stats say its time for wonderboy to turn the franchise around. And why will wonderboy turn the team around? Because the stats say he will. I suppose it's easy for you to ignore a person's drive to succeed or do their personal best because someone hasn't come up with a formula to quantify it but if you have ever (and I seriously doubt you have) played an organized sport you have to know losing sucks and being told no one cares if you win or lose sucks even more. But you expect players to act as if they are lab rats. Your comparison of Dan Uggla and Alfredo Amezaga was I guess you grasping at straws so weak is your argument. I don't know how to respond except to say there is a talent component you're ignoring, willfully or by mistake I don't know. It isn't that one wants it more than the other, it's how their individual contributions furthers the desire of the "team" to win. And why you keep dragging out your favorite straw men for your fallicois argument David Eckstein and Scott Posednick, I guess because it gives you the opportunity to belittle them once again even when you know that's not what I'm talking about. I really liked the Mike Huckabee thing too it really showed to what depths you are willing to go to make your flatulent arguments. I mean really. As for the word clutch I carefully picked Ted Williams a prime example, a guy who built a career out of not only being clutch on the ballfield but clutch when it came to protecting his fellow pilots in not one but two wars. I carefully stayed away from the one play career highlight type of thing by centering my comments on one of the greatest ballplayers that ever lived. There is world of difference between the clutch play and a player who is clutch but you obviously need to lump them all together to make your hocus pocus seem reasonable. I have to assume you didn't bother to read Williams obit or the laundry list of accomplishments he has during his careers in and out of the sport. Those are the facts you should be focusing on not these ever more complex isolated instance game deconstruction stats with which you're in love with. Tell me do they keep you warm at night? It's the nuances you miss. Not all clutch plays happen close and late, they aren't all exclusively on the offensive side of the ledger either. It doesn't matter if you've just hit your eighth game winning ninth inning homerun of the season that RISP doesn't apply unless someone was on base. Now you need a new stat that supersedes RISP because it's not always applicable. Damn the luck. :banghead And baseball is an individual sport? Wow. There you go. Until now I never realized how little you respect the idea of collaboration and team effort. Baseball is a game where the sum of the parts is often outweighed by the whole. You've never quite gotten that. I'll leave you with one thought. You believe in baseball it is you versus the pitcher. In reality in that moment it's you, your manager and your third base coach versus the pitcher and eight over guys. They are called teammates, you may not be familiar with the phrase, from the catcher calling the pitches to the position players fielding their positions. Ask Anibal Sanchez if he threw a no-hitter all by himself. But you can't see that and I doubt you ever will. Here's an excerpt from one news story about the game. "Those teammates helped Sanchez with some nifty glove work. Left fielder Josh Willingham made a diving catch, and shortstop Hanley Ramirez ranged left for a grounder and whirled to make the throw from behind second base. Dan Uggla, Mike Jacobs and Ramirez combined on a rare 4-3-6 double play to end the eighth inning." And who can forget the play that ended it in the ninth? Teamwork my friend. Teamwork. Baseball is and always been been a colloborative effort, THAT is what makes the game so beautiful.
  15. About halfway through the article I asked myself if Maybin stays, and if he continues playing the way he is it's hard to say send him down for more seasoning when he's winning ballgames with homeruns and batting over .300, anyways, considering Ramirez wants to stay at the top of the lineup does Fredi take a page out of Tony LaRussa's playbook and bat the pitcher eighth so Maybin bats ninth and ahead of Ramirez? It's sort of one of those "Riddle me this Batman" questions. I don't know the answer myself.
  16. Lou, you can use all the arbitrary stat stuff you want but in the end it's meaningless. Baseball stats are like studying the universe, there's never any answers, only each time a new one is invented all you wind up with is more questions. I read an article yesterday in National Geographic that I thought about posting here because it was so powerful it moved me and I wanted to share it, and especially the part I've excerpted below. The subject is cognitive learning in animals. I wish for one day I could write as well as its author, I really hope people put aside a half hour to read the article in its entirety I promise it is life-changing, well at least perception changing. See if you can grok the analogy to stat vs experiential baseball analysis: "Charles Darwin, who attempted to explain how human intelligence developed, extended his theory of evolution to the human brain: Like the rest of our physiology, intelligence must have evolved from simpler organisms, since all animals face the same general challenges of life. They need to find mates, food, and a path through the woods, sea, or sky?tasks that Darwin argued require problem-solving and categorizing abilities. Indeed, Darwin went so far as to suggest that earthworms are cognitive beings because, based on his close observations, they have to make judgments about the kinds of leafy matter they use to block their tunnels. He hadn't expected to find thinking invertebrates and remarked that the hint of earthworm intelligence "has surprised me more than anything else in regard to worms." To Darwin, the earthworm discovery demonstrated that degrees of intelligence could be found throughout the animal kingdom. But the Darwinian approach to animal intelligence was cast aside in the early 20th century, when researchers decided that field observations were simply "anecdotes," usually tainted by anthropomorphism. In an effort to be more rigorous, many embraced behaviorism, which regarded animals as little more than machines, and focused their studies on the laboratory white rat?since one "machine" would behave like any other. But if animals are simply machines, how can the appearance of human intelligence be explained? Without Darwin's evolutionary perspective, the greater cognitive skills of people did not make sense biologically. Slowly the pendulum has swung away from the animal-as-machine model and back toward Darwin. A whole range of animal studies now suggest that the roots of cognition are deep, widespread, and highly malleable. " http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2008/03/...a-morell-text/4 I've come to understand that for you winning ballgames just gets in the way of your belief system built around these number sets. When you suggest you can replace Uggla, his 31 homeruns and fifty doubles after losing Cabrera's bat with a combination of Andino and Amezaga, and still win games, which is why the sport is played in the first place, it makes me respect statistical analysis less than I did yesterday, and slowly up until this one, you had been winning me over to at least being more open to your way of thinking. Ballplayers work their whole lives to be ballplayers because they love winning ballgames. Everything they do is about is about winning, not their XBH or playing neutral D. You can't tell a ballplayer go out there and lose a couple hundred times over the next two years and it doesn't matter because three years from now wow, these stats say we're going to have a helluva season when the guy we really want playing your position comes up and takes your job. People aren't machines and as scientists have found this out treating them as such leads to false conclusions. As the article correctly points out the whole scientific world is moving away from where baseball statisticians are leading their flock, and sooner or later they will too when they realize that just because they can't quantify desire and will and the drive to succeed, it doesn't mean it isn't there. My favorite of course is "there's no such thing as clutch" which has to be one of the dumbest, most misguided pieces of cockeyed logic ever invented. It's funny that every ballplayer in every sport believes in it, it's the statisticians who can't empirically formulate it that deny its existence. What statisticians don't now how to calculate is competing, simultaneous "clutch" events - one on the offense, the other defensive. And because they can't create the formula that can pre-determine which side wins out, in effect whose will is greater, they deny its existence completely and ridicule it every chance they get. They are the "world is flat" crowd, convinced "if it were anything but" we'd all fall off. From the time you start playing baseball in t-ball to Ted Williams' last at bat homerun, every teammate knows there is one (or of you're lucky two) guys on every team that are the go to guys, the guys who you know are coming to the plate in the ninth inning understanding exactly what it is they have to do, or conversely the kid who is not going to be intimidated by the batters he has to face or the ballplayer who "knows", no matter what no one is driving a ball over my head. That's why you see some guy climbing a wall, digging his cleats in, elevating himself high enough to fulfill his promise to himself that "no one hits a ball over my head today". I've seen it in Little League and beer leagues, scores wrote about it when Williams finished his career that to a man his teammates, hell everyone there and I am lucky enough to say I was among them (at one time literally millions claimed to have been in Fenway that day and the place was half empty. but in those days half empty epitomized every Red Sox game) knew what he was going to do. His teammates to a player said it best, "of course he was going out with a homerun, he's Ted Williams". You can pile all the Alfredo Amezagas and Robert Andinos as high as you want (and everyone here knows I really like both guys) you still aren't going to replace what you get from Dan Uggla when it comes to winning ball games, if you care about winning ballgames. I really hope people read the whole article. Parrots who "think". Dogs who can recognize three dimensional items from two dimensional black and white pictures, lemurs who push their noses against computer screens to teach themselves new systems, it's fascinating sh*t that makes you realize watching a lab rat run through a maze really doesn't tell you anything about the rat at all because it isn't that they do it, it's the why and how they do it that's important. (and since I brought up the greatest ballplayer that ever lived here's his obituary of sort and courtesy of You Tube, his last homerun : The Ted Williams story His last homerun
  17. Let's just leave the troll out of this. What I said I believe myself. I think Willis will be missed even if he has a year like he had last year. We need the innings eater to protect the young arms. Otherwise we perpetuate this cycle of illness. Just taking you at your thought...I would disagree. Willis was worth more than de la cruz, badenhop, and trahern. We don't know what these players will do, but we do know that Willis would have at least offered some innings, and most likely would have improved. Any improvement is really irrelevant though in terms of wins. What's the difference if we win 60 or 65 games. The value lies in the protection he would have offered to the starters and the bullpen. Fair enough. I may choke on Lou's idea of bringing in Horacio Ramirez but he has been an innings eater in the past and if and when he dons a Marlins uniform he's my guy. And I want to protect young arms as much if not more than the next guy (if you read what I said I'd do if I was the MLB rulemaker) but at the same time Volstad for example, if he continues to perform as he has this spring, how does the organization look him in the eyes and say "Best job we saw all spring kid. Enjoy Albuquerque." BTW, maybe it will help a little that Badenhop just threw four scoreless innings against the Mets in the face of an 8-0 Mets lead, threw 23 consecutive strikes (according to Gameday) and now has thrown 10 scoreless innings in a row this spring. Plus he's the only guy in camp with a complete game last season. So maybe there's some value in that part of the trade for you to reconsider. So yeah, I'm down with your Willis thoughts, want to save the kids arms but maybe not so much. We really aren't that far apart.
  18. badenhop done for the day, 4 scoreless innings 3 hits, 4 strikeouts gardner in
  19. badenhop, four cstraight scoreless innings gameday says 23 straight strikes
  20. talk about pounding the strike zone :thumbup
  21. first seventeen pitches were strikes
  22. third scoreless inning in a row for bandenhop still 7-0 mets
  23. a little note : badenhop's first thirteen pitches were all strikes
  24. badenhop pitches 2nd consecutive scoreless inning against the mets (I must say it's a lot harder to come into a game where you're down 7-0 especially against a team like the Mets and shut them down than a lot of other situations)
  25. badenhop holds mets hitless in the fourth

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.