March 14, 200818 yr I did not put Cody or Amezaga because they'll make the team anyways and if any of these guys wins the every day job and then struggle, one of them (or a platoon) will take over CF. I still think it is Maybin's job to lose.
March 14, 200818 yr Obviously Maybin is the guy they want to take over but De Aza has earned consideration after his second strong spring. I like having another lefty in the order too especially one with speed.
March 14, 200818 yr No love for Brett? My vote is for DeAza. Like mountainfish mentioned, a speedy lefty is a valuable commodity.
March 14, 200818 yr I voted for Maybin for obvious reasons but with the caveat that he has to finish what he's started this spring before the job is handed to him. And I'm not all together sure Ross is on the Opening Day roster if both Cantu and Castillo are, it's going to be a fight to the finish between Cody, Carroll and de Aza. If you start the season with twelve pitchers which seems a reasonable assumption all things considered, two of the three won't be wearing Marlins uniforms come the start of the season.
March 15, 200818 yr I voted for Maybin for obvious reasons but with the caveat that he has to finish what he's started this spring before the job is handed to him. And I'm not all together sure Ross is on the Opening Day roster if both Cantu and Castillo are, it's going to be a fight to the finish between Cody, Carroll and de Aza. If you start the season with twelve pitchers which seems a reasonable assumption all things considered, two of the three won't be wearing Marlins uniforms come the start of the season. There's no way that Ross doesn't make the team. Unless he is traded to improve us in some way. DeAza, and Carol won't make it over Ross.
March 15, 200818 yr It's just the math. If Mabin, Cantu and Castillo are on the 25 man roster (which was the hypothesis) that will leave one roster spot left for the three outfielders to fight over. So far Ross isn't even hitting close to his weight and Carroll and De Aza have been flirting with .400 most of spring training. Who goes, who stays may not be settled until the last minute. By the way troll, if you need any help fitting that iron safe to your swelled head let me know, for that I can make time and I'd even do it pro bono.
March 15, 200818 yr I can't imagine Ross getting beaten out of a roster spot based on spring training.
March 15, 200818 yr Your suggestion is beyond ridiculous. It's in no way a suggestion, I'm not endorsing anything. It's called an "observation", based on the math, you only have 25 roster spots. I realize that's a difficult concept for some to grasp but there is a difference recognizing something could occur and wanting it to happen. It's all about whether Maybin stays with the parent club or goes to the minors. If he stays there is one roster spot, if he goes there are two. As for Hermida I guess you missed the point there too. I was celebrating the job he did last season and put him on a pedestal as the most valuable trade commodity on the team (putting aside the obvious). The rest was purely in the hypothetical, I think I used the word a number of times - if you want a particular result (securing a young, experienced quality arm who could be counted on for a number of years or dangled for tradebait when the time was right because you feel the team right now is lacking quality starting pitching), this is the best way to go about achieving it. I don't think I ever said, or even implied I wanted Jeremy Hermida traded, nor did I disparage him in any way. It was just a quality for quality hypothesis. Don't get your panties in a wad because I have an opinion.
March 15, 200818 yr Just saying this. Ross had a horrible spring training last year and look what happened when the season started.
March 15, 200818 yr I can't imagine Ross getting beaten out of a roster spot based on spring training. 100% This is probably the most horrifying week of posts I've ever seen on this board with people freaking about nothing.
March 15, 200818 yr And I'm not all together sure Ross is on the Opening Day roster if both Cantu and Castillo are. Great observation. I also agree that two guys taking up two infield spots is of major impact as to wether Cody gets an outfield spot.
March 15, 200818 yr Jesus. The roster is C - Rabelo/Treanor 1B - Jacobs 2B - Uggla 3B - Cantu/Castillo SS - Hanley LF - Hammer CF - X RF - Hermida B - Amezaga, Gonzalez, Treanor, Cody, Castillo Amezaga and Cody are going to serve as the backup CF's and outfielders. Who do you have starting? That is the only question. If it's De Aza, Maybin, or Carroll, no problem. If it's Cody, then you'd expect De Aza or Carroll will be the backup and Maybin sent to AA. How can they do anything differently? They need the two infielders because Amezaga can't be the primary backup at every position besides first base. I don't see why this is such a huge posturing question this year. Whose starting in center? Done.
March 15, 200818 yr Considering Ross is out of options (Well like 90% sure on that haha) and would definitely get claimed if put on waivers, I severly doubt Carrol or De Aza make the team over him.
March 15, 200818 yr The reading comprehension level here goes further down every day. Here's what I actually said above: "I voted for Maybin for obvious reasons but with the caveat that he has to finish what he's started this spring before the job is handed to him. And I'm not all together sure Ross is on the Opening Day roster if both Cantu and Castillo are, it's going to be a fight to the finish between Cody, Carroll and de Aza. If you start the season with twelve pitchers which seems a reasonable assumption all things considered, two of the three won't be wearing Marlins uniforms come the start of the season." Somehow that becomes "he said Cody isn't making the team...wow did he really say that?...Geesus, what is this guy thinking?"... then you throw in a few insulting names like moron and stupid and what you said takes on a life of its own. Then I posted, "It's just the math. If Mabin, Cantu and Castillo are on the 25 man roster (which was the hypothesis) that will leave one roster spot left for the three outfielders to fight over. So far Ross isn't even hitting close to his weight and Carroll and De Aza have been flirting with .400 most of spring training. Who goes, who stays may not be settled until the last minute." I never said Cody Ross isn't making the team but of course some people because, well, because that's what they want to read. Maybe if some of you read what's written out loud that would help, or try reading what's posted really, really slowly and maybe three or four times, maybe then you'll start to understand what other people's post(s) actually say. The scenario went like this: 1. Maybin has to win the job first. 2. Castillo and Cantu both have to be on the roster plus 12 pitchers. 3. Ross, Carroll and de Aza have to fight it out to determine who gets the final roster spot. 4. However you look at it two of the three won't be with the team come Opening Day. I guess that's controversial, or sadly some people want to make it so.
March 15, 200818 yr The scenario went like this: 1. Maybin has to win the job first. 2. Castillo and Cantu both have to be on the roster plus 12 pitchers. 3. Ross, Carroll and de Aza have to fight it out to determine who gets the final roster spot. 4. However you look at it two of the three won't be with the team come Opening Day. I guess that's controversial, or sadly some people want to make it so. Yeah, but the problem with that scenario that most people are having is part 3. Most of us think it is rediculous, given what those three have done in the regular season, to put Cody off the team, no matter how anyone hits in Spring Training. If Maybin is on the team, the majority of the people on this board think that the "two of the three" that won't make the cut will have to be Brett and De Aza, even if De Aza end up hitting .600 at the end of the damned thing and Cody sits a chilly .200. Noone has said that they have a problem with you saying Cody won't be on that team....they have a problem that you think there is even a tiny chance that Cody won't be on the team.
March 15, 200818 yr ....they have a problem that you think there is even a tiny chance that Cody won't be on the team. So, if I understand correctly Cody was handed the job the moment he arrived in camp this spring. I get it now, how silly of me. :banghead Rabb, it's not you. The thing is I never said Ross won't wind up with the job. I thought, I guess mistakenly, he had to compete for it like every other second tier player. But if there's not even a "tiny chance" someone else could win the job, maybe someone should tell them they'd be better off over in the minor league camp. (being as facetious as hell )
March 15, 200818 yr If Brett Carroll is a major league caliber starting center fielder, then I am too.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.