Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
The New York Times take on FanFest and the Stadium Situation
Thank you Karen Crouse. I see your attitude about the Marlins hasn't changed from your days at PB Post. What I don't get is the two-faced argument that goes - depending on the point you want to make - the Marlins can't afford to keep Willis and Cabrera they are so cash-strapped but then when you want to impune their motives and call them greedy the same writer will argue they put $70 million in their pockets last year before they sold a ticket. Can't have it both ways.
-
FanFest 2007
If the Marlins had set their figure far lower (say $5.75 million) they'd have a great chance of winning. They would have a 0% chance of winning at $5.75. It really says something that Lou and I are on the same page here. People seem to think the Marlins just picked numbers out of the air. The Marlins have employed for years some of the best consultants in the business and have been pretty good at figuring what the top number the arbiters will go for. The logic behind $5.75 being a better number than $6.7 boogles the mind. :banghead
-
FO disappointed Cabrera skipped Fanfest
Based off a rumor that some dude heard on the radio with no in print evidence of that statement ever being made? Over something so silly as arbitration. Get a hold of your life. UC24, hope you don't mind me jumping off your post. I just got home and listened to 790 for a good part of the last hour. I heard nothing like that although I did hear a caller suggest something to that effect. I just checked Google News (8:30pm) and nothing either. While I'm at it I have a few other things to say. I've read through this thread. What an embarrassment it is. Some of these arguments are unbelievable and based more on people's personal hatred of all things Marlins than any kind of logic. All arguments should start and end with one incontrovertible point ... ...Cabrera was legally obligated to be at FanFest according to the terms of the contract he signed in December 2006. End of discussion. No "personal interest", no new representation gives Cabrera the right to unilaterally decide not to attend. If he had a legitimate excuse my guess is the Marlins would have fallen on the sword for him rather than having little kids standing in lines for hours waiting to get autograph passes for a player who was a no-show. The only reason for all this is SFX understands that the first year of arbitration results sets a base for subsequent years. This IS the year to play hardball and try to bully the Marlins into caving in. For SFX if they don't deliver they won't be around representing Cabrera by the time free agency rolls around. Oh btw, a quick correction. I suggested somewhere that there was one only arbiter when three is correct. Shame on me for not getting out of the cave more often. For about twenty years until the mid-1990's arbitration was with a single arbiter, I somehow missed the change. My bad.
-
Interesting bits from today's Palm Beach Post
It's funny, depending on the factoid you can tell who went to what town meeting. That quote came from the 10:30 am TM.
-
FanFest 2007
Here's a more annoying quote from that same article: Cabrera is going through the arbitration process. His hearing is set for Friday in Arizona. Cabrera is seeking $7.4 million, while the Marlins are offering, $6.7 million. "We're being very fair," Beinfest said. "It's business. I think both parties know if we can't reach a settlement that he has a right to have an arbitrator determine his salary. From our perspective, when you are talking about the accomplishments he has, it's a fair number. We'll see what happens." And this is why I maintain that Beinfest is being a moron and I have no faith in his ability to build anything long term once we pass the point of simple talent evaluation. You're splitting hairs over $700,000!!!! Less than 1/10 the value of the contract. There's no conceivable way you can tell me that you're going to go into an arbitration hearing, sit down and explain to the three person panel that this guy should be the beneficiary of a raise in excess of 300% (or whatever ungodly amount he's receiving) but we're absolutely, positively drawing the line at that last 10%, especially when the person has the resume of Miguel Cabrera. If we were talking about several millions apart, like say Cabrera asking for $8.5, then this line in the sand mentality is fine, but Beinfest is trying to fight a battle he can't possibly win. And that's just stupid, because as we saw with AJ Burnett, that arbitration meeting really breeds bad feelings...or does no one else see the alarming similarities, even down to the corny "we'll all leave together and head to spring training" comments. Next time you call someone a moron take a look in the mirror first. I believe it's one arbiter not three. And you're using AJ Burnett as an example??? OMG :whistle If Cabrera's team doesn't come to their senses and agree to split the difference the Marlins will go in, say Miggy simply is the greatest thing since sliced bread, and walk out the winners. The Marlins, knowing they are going to be rebutted by SFX, will take the high road having no doubt picked the highest possible number they believe (and their consultants believe) the arbiter will agree to leaving Cabrera's newly hired henchmen looking impotent. It was ridiculously selfish of SFX to keep Cabrera away from FanFest.
-
What I learned..
If Volstad and Gaby are seriously being considered for call ups "no later" than September, I honestly cannot figure out the hesitancy to deal one of our starters (*cough* Nolasco *cough*) for a real CFer. That means the FO is confident that these guys will actually be summoned to contribute, not just ride the pine for a cup of coffee. I don't really think too highly (as long-term starters) for the likes of Mitre, Petit, Pinto, etc., so I'm not broken up by the FO's desire to keep its current rotation intact. However, where do you stick Volstad and Gaby if the Marlins call them up earlier then when the rosters expand? Someone has got to go. I'd rather a real CFer start the entire season with the a progression of Mitre/Petit/Volstad/Gaby for the 5th spot, than have Nolasco with no CFer. I know the Nolasco (or insert other 5th starter candidate) for a CFer debate has been exhausted, but this just adds a bit of confusion (at least for me) to the entire process. Without attempting to put words in Ramp's mouth, I suspect that either a) Chris and Gaby have the best "chance" of making it up this season "if" they pitch at the level that is exected of them and/or b) being called up after pitching 120+ innings in the minors probably means they will be getting an expanded "taste" of the bigs ala Garcia in 2006 and Johnson or maybe Olsen in 2005 and may see only few starts interspersed with a few bullpen appearances. Nolasco isn't going anywhere (at least in my opinion, which of course means he'll probably be traded tonight :lol ) until things at closer and fifth starter work themselves out and the first four guys prove to be healthy.
-
What I learned..
Everyone got a big laugh out of Mitre's caveman look...lolol.
-
Beinfest`prepared to go as is right now.'
This is of course Clark Spencer's spin, when you hear Beinfest actually speak at length on the subject he makes a much sounder case for not rushing off and making trades of players who haven't come close to approaching their ability, which is what I think he was really saying. It's no secret and Beinfest confirmed today everyone this off-season wanted a piece of the Marlins starting rotation in whatever trade was being discussed, and he has made up his mind not to go down that road, at least not now. I think Mitre being hurt had something to do with that as well as his inability to acquire a closer putting a premium on Nolasco's value to the team. If we go into spring training and some of the kids really look impressive enough to earn a starter's job, or Benitez or someone appears on the horizon, all of a sudden we're then in a position to do something, but for the time being he's not going to break up the starting five without a significant reason. And frankly, I'm down with that. I also liked his answer to an Alzegary question regarding players not being here long enough for fans to become attached to them, referencing Willis and Cabrera and implying the Marlins should sign both to longterm deals. Beinfest's comment was "they're part of this team for at least three more seasons" (end of 2009).
-
What I learned..
And to add to the FanFest Tidbit Database Sergio Mitre is healthy now and will be 100% for spring training. He's already throwing off the mound and his shoulder is sound. I mention this for a number of reasons, not the least of which is if he has a good spring training and everyone else stays healthy, as Beinfest said today, at the end of spring training it's alot harder to find a starting pitcher than it is a position player (I forget if he specifically said CFer). With six starting pitchers ready to go, we may be in a good position to finally make the move we've all anticipated this off-season. In the alternative his continued good health may make it easier to transition Nolasco into the closer role or open up other options on the roster.
-
Bernie back on the table?
I dunno that Bernie can patrol DS effectively anymore, but I'd offer him a guaranteed spot on the Fish! I understand why you like and respect the guy's career, and I agree he's couldn't play everyday in CF at DS but short of major shakeup or injury, all Bernie would be is the baseball equivalent of a trophy wife sitting at the end of the bench so the Marlins could say "look who we picked up". He doesn't want that for himself and I respect him even more for it.
-
Marlins Awards Dinner
Great pics!! Does anyone else notice that with the possible exception of Dontrelle, it appears EVERY Marlins player now dons some facial hair? Personally, I can draw any number of conclusions from this, but I'll leave you to draw your own. Nonetheless I find it interesting and perhaps illustrative of the player's true feelings regarding their former skipper.
-
Low payroll even during construction of new stadium
For the record, I said nothing about any "keg party" analogy, only commenting that ignoring requisite tax and municipal (local and county) requirements is a mistake and leads people to the wrong conclusions. It seems to me it isn't the educated Marlins fans who are insulted, rather it's the uneducated ones who want the rules to be different than they are. I really wish we had an accountant among us who was familiar with how government financing works so he or she could independently explain why things work the way they do. SoFlaFish is the closest we have, a lawyer with governmental land use experience who tries to give impartial comment, who I don't think has ever presented himself as a "friend" of ownership, but rather a fan of the Marlins and that's all. I've been trying for three years to do it but obviously I've failed miserably if people don't understand that municipalities just can't give away public land or the tax consequences of government issued bonds or why government must "own" the stadium and why the tenant has to pay "rent" (which is really a lease backed by the security of the underlieing asset, in this case the franchise itself) or the role of an unrecognized but highly influential bond-underwriting constituency, not to mention the banking community, various local, county, state and federal agencies who all become part of the mix, bureaucrats of every description, planners, movers and shakers, political cronies, the GMCVB, the Beacon Council, the list is endless. The fact is about the last people pulling the strings here or shaping policy are the Marlins. And to suggest otherwise is ridiculous. I really feel if people don't get it by now it's because they don't want to get it.
-
Yet ANOTHER option gone
The thing is Polo, he's only going to be a part-time player for the A's and he hasn't played CF since 2000 and even then not exclusively. I share your frustration more moves haven't been made but I still think this probably wasn't the right one in any event.
-
Yet ANOTHER option gone
I couldn't NOT post this... Stewart could be another bargain A's told his foot problems over Susan Slusser, Chronicle Staff Writer Friday, February 9, 2007 Without a lot of notice, Jay Payton was one of the A's most valuable players last season. While Frank Thomas' departure as a free agent got a lot of attention, Payton's didn't, and it appeared that Oakland might go into spring training without replacing the versatile outfielder that led the team in hitting. On Thursday, however -- with just over a week until pitchers and catchers report -- the A's came to terms with Shannon Stewart on a one-year, $1 million deal. The contract is incentive-laden -- much like Thomas' last year -- and the potential total value is $2.5 million. Like Thomas, Stewart has been hampered by foot problems, but in Stewart's case, the issue has been plantar fasciitis, most recently in his left foot. That limited him to 44 games last season; the same problem in the other foot cost him time during the 2004 season. According to David Forst, the A's assistant GM, Stewart's physical in Florida on Thursday went well, and Marlins team doctor Dan Kanell told the A's that the plantar fasciitis is behind Stewart. Stewart, who turns 33 at the end of the month, has been pain free for three months since going to the Hospital for Special Surgery in New York, where an ultrasound pinpointed the problem. A cortisone shot in the heel calmed things down, Stewart said, and he's had no sign of the injury since. He's running four days a week and working out five days a week. Now he's joining a team whose medical staff defied expectations and kept Thomas on the field. Another possible plus: Stewart will be playing home games on grass for the first time in his career. "That's going to feel good,'' he said. "I've always wanted to, but it seems like for some reason, I was a dome ballplayer.'' Stewart hit .293 last year and has a lifetime average of .299. In 2003, he hit .307 and drove in 73 runs combined for Toronto and Minnesota and finished fourth in the MVP voting. "He's like Jay Payton, but better,'' said Stewart's agent, Greg Genske. "As long as he's healthy, the A's have just upgraded.'' Stewart's playing time is expected to be similar to Payton's (he'll probably just be in left, however) and his presence combined with Nick Swisher's versatility means that new manager Bob Geren will have more opportunity to rest center fielder Mark Kotsay and right fielder Milton Bradley. How that all breaks down will be decided during the spring, Forst said. The A's had little interest in Stewart initially, according to Genske, who said they were focused on another of his clients, Darin Erstad. It was erroneously reported that the A's were one of the teams that had watched Stewart work out in Florida recently; they did not have anyone on hand for that. "It's weird when it came down to it -- Oakland was the one team that nobody saw me,'' Stewart said. As Stewart remained on the market, however, he became more attractive to the bargain-hunting A's. And a year after pulling off a huge steal with Thomas, Oakland might have another. "The good thing is that this team is willing to give a player a chance, with a medical history and everything,'' Stewart said. "The A's were willing to do that for Frank and myself. A lot of teams, when you're injured, are skeptical. I think it's a good gamble.'' "I don't want to draw the exact parallel, but let's hope, like Frank's did, that this works out for both sides,'' Forst said. Stewart will earn an additional $200,000 when he reaches 200 at-bats, and another $100,000 for each of these milestones: 220, 245, 265, 290, 310, 335, 355, 380, 400, 425, 450, 475, 500. He has a standard awards package, except that he would get $200,000 for winning the Comeback Player of the Year award. To make room for Stewart on the 40-man roster, the A's designated outfielder Charles Thomas for assignment. http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c...SPGEDO1HHM1.DTL
-
Low payroll even during construction of new stadium
No offense to Rferry, I couldn't follow it either Don. It just becomes a blur at some point.
-
Low payroll even during construction of new stadium
The general assumption I've heard is the Marlins final contribution will be in the vicinity of $250 million and was referring to 20% of their share, or approximately $50 million.
-
Yet ANOTHER option gone
:banghead
-
Yet ANOTHER option gone
He wasn't an option. Im going to search around today for the article. But for 2 weeks the MARLINS and STEWART were talking and someone even posted on here that we were considering him as a option. so YES he was an option. Ill prove it later I think you're going to find out that Shannon Stewart (probably through his agent) "reached out" to the Marlins and not vice versa, and most likely as a courtesy to a hometown boy (and an agent they might want something from in the future) the Marlins listened and gave his client the benefit of the doubt.
-
Low payroll even during construction of new stadium
Regarding rent: I understand, created money is created money and earmarking it for rent is an opportunity cost, but it's not like a simple construction loan at all. Moreover, the Marlins make it appears that what they are doing is overly generous when in truth it is pretty standard practice among teams that receive public financing for the stadium. I still stand by my analogy, they're asking for a huge handout, intending to pay back only a percentage over a very long period of time and then acting as if they're paying for all of it. As for the rankings, I misspoke, I said it was off the top of my head, I guess I was wrong. Personally, I'd love to see sources as I swear the MLB Marlins media gives them a larger base market than Boston, of that I am almost certain, because that's the kind of thing that sticks with you. You don't understand how the financing mechanism works and you're ignoring the Marlins are pledging the franchise against their payments. There is no handout, this is no different than any municipal project financed by tax free municipal bonds, for which there is a market. All the money the state, city and county would put in comes from either tourist related taxes which by law can only be spent on professional franchise stadium construction or a portion of sales taxes that wouldn't be collected unless the stadium is built. You (the collective "you") have to understand the stadium will not belong to the Marlins, they are merely tenants. They can't own the stadium because it sits on city/county land (among several reasons). Swift, really, this is a very complex deal with a huge number of parts to it. If you don't want to believe me, talk to SoFlaFish who has the right credentials and can explain it to your satisfaction. Loria isn't screwing anyone by putting 20% down and the rest in rent, in fact doing it that way makes the whole deal work (providing a predictable and guaranteed - by pledging the franchise - flow of cash to pay off the bonds). They just aren't asking for a huge handout. This is a very good deal for everyone concerned - the city, state, county and the Marlins. The marketing value to the city of Miami and the GMVCB of having the name "Miami" mentioned a hundred times a day all over the world over the next 30 years is probably worth more than the price of the stadium when it comes to tourism alone.
-
Yet ANOTHER option gone
He is better than what we have. With his injuries and inability to play CF, how he better than Ross, Amezaga and Borchard? Well lets take a look at last years numbers. Ross 269 at bats .227 average Borchard 239 at bats .239 average Amenzaga 334 at bats .260 average Forgive me if I am not impressed by that. Stewart 174 at bats .293 average He missed alot of time last season. However 7 out of the 8 previous seasons be played 130+ games. He is also a career .299 hitter. He may not have power but he wont be an automatic out like the three options we currently have. What don't you understand about the fact he physically is unable to play centerfield? Really, not looking for a fight here but it isn't all about his offensive skils. No one is arguing over his career he was a helluva hitter. He has chronic problems in his feet and couldn't play CF at DS regradless of the size of his heart or his strength of character he possesses. Not to mention he hasn't played the position for six years or so. That's why we are saying he wasn't an option. Not because you're wrong but because physically he's unable to play there. Here's how Rotoworld put it this morning: " ESPN's Buster Olney reports that the A's and Shannon Stewart have agreed to terms on a one-year deal. The contract could be worth $2.5 million if Stewart reaches incentives. The A's needed to bring in some additional competiton with Jay Payton gone. Stewart may no longer be able to play regularly because of his foot problems, but he could still be an asset at the top of the lineup playing three or four times per week. He'll battle Dan Johnson for at-bats, with Nick Swisher possibly alternating between first base and left field. The A's could also use Swisher in right and Milton Bradley in center when Mark Kotsay rests his sore back." From MLB: "Stewart, 32, has been limited by plantar fasciitis in both feet over the past three years; he played in 44 games with the Twins in 2006 and 92 games in '04." From AP: The Oakland Athletics have reached an agreement with free agent outfielder Shannon Stewart for a one-year deal that could be worth as much as $2.5 million with incentives, pending a physical, ESPN The Magazine's Buster Olney has learned. Stewart, 32, is a .299 career hitter with 102 home runs in 11 seasons with Toronto and Minnesota. His best year came in 2000, when he hit 21 homers and drove in 69 runs for the Blue Jays. Stewart has had plantar fasciitis problems in both feet over the past three years, limiting him to 92 games in 2004 and only 44 last season with the Minnesota Twins. The plantar fascia is a long tissue that connects the heel bone to the base of the toes. The Twins transferred Stewart to the 60-day disabled list on Sept. 1 after acquiring infielder Phil Nevin from the Chicago Cubs for a player to be named or cash considerations. The injury-prone Stewart is perhaps best known for sparking the Twins to a come-from-behind AL Central title in 2003 after his All-Star break arrival in a trade with the Blue Jays.
-
Marlins have baseball's hottest infield
100 homeruns for Mike Jacobs?! Where did they come up with that? He only has 31. Either way...I couldn't agree more with the article. What makes me even more excited is the fact that they're only talking about their offense. With Perry Hill teaching them, we've probably got a couple gold glovers in the making as well. Brain freeze. Probably looked at the 11 homeruns in 100 ABs with Mets, number stuck, next thing you know...so much for fact-checking at ESPN. :whistle
-
Which hitters are ready to rise in 2007?
From my perspective, it isn't so much who will have a higher BA or HRs or whatever stat you focus on as who can put the ball in play more often, strikes out less (we forget how strike-out prone the 2006 team was), walks more, move runners over more, in short has smarter at bats. If Ramirez or Uggla's numbers (or any other player) more or less stayed the same but they did more "smart" things with their at bats (see above) this would be a fundamentally better team. I had forgotten about Hermida's almost unbelievable 111 walks one season in the minors. I'd rather a guy hit twenty homeruns, struck out fifty times and walked a hundred than 20 homeruns, 100 strikeouts and fifty walks. It's so obviously true I almost didn't *bother posting it*, but with some great numbers put up by alot of youngsters last season I thought it worthwhile to point out one area where improvement isn't always recognized in the stats. * = edit
-
Yet ANOTHER option gone
Shannon Stewart was never a legitimate option in centerfield for the Marlins. Why someone would think he was is beyond me? The guy hasn't stepped foot in centerfield in six or seven years.
-
Miguel Cabrera's Nickname
He is also known as "Caballo Grande" That's it...has something to do with being the horse of all horses or something.
-
Which hitters are ready to rise in 2007?
a healthy hermida in the 2 hole makes this team very very scary Hopefully Fredi understands that and doesn't put him 7th. I have a feeling Gonzalez has a much better idea how to construct a lineup than any one of us here.