Everything posted by Valid
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
That isn't going to change the fact that the guy doesn't walk. Again,, he's a lifetime .232/.417/.427 hitter. That isn't good, and I highly doubt the shift rule changes are going to suddenly turn him into a consistently productive hitter. It's also a matter of trading Pablo. It's not like we would be taking a flier on Kepler.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
Yeah trading Pablo for Kepler would just be making a trade for the sake of making a trade. Heck, Kepler's lifetime numbers aren't any better than Avisail's.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
Eh, I would expect more for Lopez. Kepler had one good season four years ago. Otherwise, he kind of stinks offensively (lifetime .232/.317/.427 slash line over seven seasons). Sometimes you are what you are regardless of what the peripherals say. We can look at peripherals all we want, but if the actual results don't reflect them for an extended period of time, it doesn't matter all that much. Polanco is a decent hitter, but he is pretty bad defensively and is coming off of a really crappy year. If Arraez isn't involved, Kim shouldn't want anything to do with the Twins.
-
Carlos Correa - Giants - 13/350
The Rays have been unable to get over the hump specifically because their owner doesn't spend money, so if anything that example actually proves the point that you need an owner who isn't a skinflint. The Rays might have multiple WS titles now if they actually spent money. The Marlins have had plenty of elite talent come through their franchise over the last two decades, ranging from Cabrera to Hanley to Stanton, so it's not like the FO wasn't able to identify talent. They were just a.) unable to keep that talent because they didn't want to pay the money required to do so (e.g. Cabrera), or b.) they were unable to put the necessary pieces around said talent to actually win because they didn't want to spend. Beinfest, for instance, did a terrific job here in 2003 and actually wasn't bad during his stint here. Aside from one year of Delgado, Loria just didn't spend enough to actually put the team into legitimate contention.
-
Carlos Correa - Giants - 13/350
For a short stint, yes. But in terms of prolonged success? You need an owner who spends money to actually keep the guys you draft/acquire.
-
Marlins SIGN Chi Chi Gonzalez
I'm not saying he'll forget how to pitch, but I think it stands to reason that he will see some regression. Look what happened to Gerrit Cole when he got to NY. Yes he's obviously still really good, but not even close to as dominant as he was during his two-year stretch in Houston. And Verlander is also 40. I can't imagine he has that much left in the tank.
-
Carlos Correa - Giants - 13/350
To be perfectly honest, I'm not even sure it matters who fills Kim's role as long as Sherman is at the helm. Yeah it would definitely be nice to have a GM who has some sort of a clue (like Beinfest), but at the end of the day, Sherman will never spend enough money to ensure that this team is consistently competitive. Maybe they'll have a lucky year somewhere, but sustainability just isn't happening under this regime.
-
Marlins SIGN Chi Chi Gonzalez
If they have 2022 Verlander, yes, but let's keep in mind that Verlander missed two years in a row prior to that, is 40 years old and is no longer in Houston. It remains to be seen how he actually performs as a Met. Not so sure he's an actual upgrade over deGrom.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
I think the only way the Mets land Correa is if he somehow gets far below what is expected. Bogaerts got 11/280 and Turner got 11/300, and they're both older than Correa. Have to figure Correa gets at least 10/300. I'm not even sure Cohen would be willing to eat that tax hit. And what would they do? Put Correa at third base?
-
Marlins SIGN Chi Chi Gonzalez
I actually agree with this. I think even if everything breaks right, they top out at 80 wins with this current offense. Have the Mets actually improved though? Yes, they've spent a ton of money, but it seems like they've just been maintaining rather than improving. Yes, they signed Verlander, but they lost deGrom. Yes, they signed Quintana, but they lost Taijuan Walker and Chris Bassitt. They also re-signed Brandon Nimmo and Edwin Diaz. As far as I can recall, the only pieces they've really "added" have been David Robertson (who had a good 2022 but basically missed three years in a row due to injury before that and will be 38 in April) and Koudai Senga. Pretty much everything they've done has been replacing guys or re-signing guys they already had.
-
Do you miss Jeffrey Loria and Mike Hill?
The fact that this thread actually exists just goes to show how horrific Sherman has been as an owner. I will say what I do miss, though: the old pinstripe jerseys.
-
Marlins SIGN Chi Chi Gonzalez
Well they only lost 93 this past year, and I don't think the 2023 team will be worse. But yeah. The chances of this club actually contending with its current roster are zero.
-
Brandon Nimmo Returns to Mets - 8/162
The AAV isn't bad, but EIGHT YEARS for a guy who has only played 100 games twice is insanity.
-
Three Front Office Additions
And good thing. 8/162 for Nimmo is insanity.
-
Three Front Office Additions
I have no issues with Nimmo as a player. I think he is very solid. My issue is with his inability to stay on the field. If the cost is something like 6/132 like Lou suggested, then I would happily pass. If it's something like 3/70 or maybe even 4/80 (which is pushing it), then sure.
-
Three Front Office Additions
Jayson Werth played in over 130 games for three straight seasons before the Nationals signed him, including over 150 games twice. He also hit 24, 36 and 27 home runs in those three seasons. Nimmo's career high is 16. It's a bad comparison. If we're going to be spending big money on a FA, it needs to be on someone like Correa. As far as the cultural aspect, I find it hard to believe the Marlins will suddenly become big spenders if they sign Nimmo. They went balls to the wall in during the 2011-12 offseason and haven't spent seriously since. Different ownership, yes, but Sherman seems even stingier than Loria, if that's possible.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
What's with your affinity for guys who constantly miss games? Buxton has a lifetime .244/.301/.473 slash line and has played 100 games once in eight seasons. The Marlins need consistent bats and guys who can actually stay on the field. Trading Pablo for Buxton would be insane.
-
Three Front Office Additions
There is a gargantuan difference between paying Joc Pederson $19 million for one season and paying Nimmo $132 million for six. I would actually be okay with that AAV on a two or three-year deal, but at six years? Heck no. At least Joc stays on the field and you know what you're going to get from him. I agree that the team has to do something, but Nimmo at 6/132 is not it.
-
Three Front Office Additions
Kim: "We were just unlucky with injuries this year."
-
Three Front Office Additions
My issue with Nimmo is that his career has been defined by injuries (he has only played 100 games twice). Isn't he looking for over $100 million? That's a whole lot for a guy who can't stay on the field and doesn't have great power. I do like him as a player, but he's more of a complementary piece than he is a big fish.
-
Three Front Office Additions
Going a step further, remember when the Marlins could have had Cabrera, Hanley and Stanton all in the same lineup (like, this literally could have happened) but instead opted not to buy out Cabrera's arbitration years and traded him? Lol good times. So much elite talent has come and gone through this franchise and yet the Marlins haven't managed to make anything out of it in two decades. Unreal stuff.
-
Three Front Office Additions
That's my name. Don't wear it out.
-
2022-2023 Offseason Thread
People can't even use the "players don't want to come here" excuse anymore considering the Padres have managed to sign Eric Hosmer (didn't work out but was still a top FA at the time), Manny Machado and Xander Bogaerts over the last four or five years. Yeah I know guys like Judge and Turner passed on their money, but the fact that they've landed three major guys (not to mention trading for Juan Soto, who they'll probably extend) shows that actually trying does yield results. No one ever thought of San Diego as a marquee free-agent destination, and yet, the Padres have become one because they have been willing to spend the money. Funny how simple the solution is.
-
Three Front Office Additions
Either that or the prospects will pan out and will just end up being traded at some point because the team couldn't put the necessary pieces around them to actually compete.
-
Three Front Office Additions
Isn't it hilarious how the Marlins somehow blew this? Not to mention the other talent (like Ozuna) they had on the roster at the time. I mean I know Fernandez passed away, but even before then, they clearly weren't taking any major steps forward and he probably would have ended up getting traded like Stanton anyway.