Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Tee Ball Bunt Machine

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Tee Ball Bunt Machine

  1. Trade Dontrelle for Crawford, pick up a cheap 5th starter or plug Petit in the 5th spot and let's roll. Stuffing crap into a rotation spot (Ismael Valdez, Brian Moehler) is exactly why the Marlins haven't been in the playoffs last few years. If Hermida realizes all that potential he'll be putting up those numbers. All we need is some actual defense in CF, not a corner OFer who will cost us our number 1 pitcher. Our needs can be met for much cheaper. Sure, they may not have Crawford's offensive numbers, but it also won't require us to give up anything close to Dontrelle.
  2. I'd sooner figure Vargas into the bullpen than Mitre. Just my personal opinion, even though both struggled bad in the pen and are naturally starters. Some people might be concerned about having 3 LHP in the pen, but looking at Tank & Pinto, I think it would only be a question of if Vargas can pull it together. Also, 2 of our division rivals (Mets & Phillies) are really centered/dependent on big Lefty bats w/ a few switch hitters. A good group of LHPs leading to the closer might not be the worst thing.
  3. Unless we bring in some outside help, I'd expect Messenger there in that spot for Volstad.
  4. He has put up great numbers every year till this year. He is far from a bust so far. He wasnt used properly this year even and then sent down to a hitter paradise. I guess Mickey Mantle was a bust because he sucked so bad he got booed and sent down his first year. :whistle So now he's Mickey Mantle... W/e. He wouldn't be the first guy to have good minor league numbers that never translate to the Majors. Maybe he'll develop...I hope for the team's sake he does. But I don't know that you can sell teams on his 3.08 Minor League Career ERA next to his big league 9.57 anymore than you can show off Eric Reed's Minor League career OBP over 340 while having to admit that in the majors his OBP was under 200. I guess I just don't look at minor league numbers as insurance that he will become an ace or whatever you think he will be. But I figure teams trading big name players want to get players in return that they can be confident will help their Major League team win. Petit hasn't shown it at that level yet.
  5. Yea Petit, the 22 year old bust One does need more than youth to succeed.
  6. if we can land Crawford by dealing away Jacobs and just Petit / Pinto then that would be fine. I like Pinto, and we would have to pay them to take Petit.
  7. Ok, he's started in CF 49 times total in 5 ML Seasons. He's not even the best guy for that job on his own team, trading any of our corner-stone talents for him is a mistake. Even entertaining the idea of trading Willis for him is insulting.
  8. We discussing something that's not real. The Marlins' 2007 season hasn't started yet. Yes. But we aren't sitting here comparing it saying "the team in 2007 was/will be better than 2003". Comparing something real to something not real is what I'm talking about. Why is that so complicated?
  9. He's not even a CF. it wouldn't be worth it for us.
  10. Indeed. This team began with a knuckleballer on the mound. It should be a part of the tradition. :thumbup
  11. RA Dickey, RHP: all hail the knuckleball! In the National League, he might just get enough guys out to make it work. :notworthy
  12. What guy? I started this thread because the response to every suggested defensive upgrade in CF is "he would be an offensive downgrade and give the team no net improvement", so I proposed an offensive CF platoon of Borchard and Ross, which realistically can't be that much worse defensively than Amezaga considering that both of these guys are OFers by trade, and represent a signiificant improvement offensively. But whatever. Whenever someone suggests another CF be pursued they are compared to the platoon that never existed and will never exist of AA & Ross. The offense from CF during the second half of the season was for all intents and purposes, exclusively coming from Amezaga, and someone like Taveras wouldn't be downgrade in comparison. It might be if you compare it to a Ross/ Amezaga platoon, but then there was no platoon. So it's not like we were getting so much from it last year, because it didn't happen. We wouldn't become an inferior run-scoring team in that scenario. And it's not as though you couldn't still fit Cody in vs LHP. Aside from platooning him Hermida, who is also less than spectacular vs LHP, you could plug Cody into LF and move Hammer to 1B vs LHP with Jacobs sitting.
  13. See I don't care what's good for Joe Borowski. I care what's good for the Marlins and in my opinion his services weren't that valuable. OK, how many closers did better in 06 that were in the same price range?
  14. So what's the point of even making the point that Girardi did not use platoon players in a platoon situation? I fail to see your logic. Ok let me try to explain this a different way. Suppose I were to ask people to compare Reggie Abercrombie's big HR in Cincy with the HR Scott Olsen hit in LA, asking which was more impressive and went further - there would be a problem. Scott Olsen never hit a HR, in LA or elsewhere. I am comparing something real (Reggie's HR) to something that doesn't/didn't exist/never happened. Something that is not real. That's what it's like to compare a Ross/Amezaga CF platoon (something not real, and that will probably never be real) to other CFs around the league (something real). Does that help? I disagree with you about Nolasco, but that's another discussion entirely.
  15. Borowski had more saves this year than any previous, after 2 really bad injury filled seasons. What else would it take to qualify as a "rebirth" comparable to Jones and Benitez? Yes, Borowski is not as good as either of those 2 in general, but relative to his abilities, I don't think you caould ask for more. I still am amazed at this resurrected closer phenomenon here though...like maybe it's the weather or something that helps these guys' arms. Cause really, the same thing has happened the last 3 seasons and all with different pitching coaches (Rosey, Wiley, & Kranitz).
  16. There will be no deal worth it. No prospect, or 5 prospects are worth as much as Dontrelle. Any established player that is close to his value will cost us enough to not really save a significant amount. Again, Dontrelle is much more than a spot in the rotation for us. No trade.
  17. If the team can't land a proven CF (who doesn't need to be platooned) then I wouldn't mind Choo being among a few cheap options acquired. No, I don't think he should be our chosen target. But it might be worth a look for the right price. Now, I'm not trying to argue that the combo should be the CF answer for next year, but I'm saying they are indeed platoon players even though Girardi didn't use them properly. It's not a question about whether or not they are "platoon players". What I am saying is that there was NO PLATOON. Whenever people talk about the CF platoon, or comparing other CFs in the league to our CF platoon, they are talking about/comparing something that never existed and will probably never exist (a full time Amezaga/Cody platoon in CF). About Nolasco, he got hurt, and then tired by season's end. Not much different from JJ & Olsen if you look at it. He had a few worse games, but he still won 11 starts in his rookie year without even being in the rotation for a good chunk of it. Most of his problems were toward the end of the season when (lets face it) we expected all the rookies to hit a wall. He's not an ace, but for a #5, I think he's quite a bit better than adequate.
  18. No. There is no one on the block so-to-speak that we are going to get that will be worth Dontrelle. And then suppose another team actually wanted to trade a top-shelf player for Dontrelle, will we actually be saving any money? We may not have to pay Dontrelle, but whatever talent we get for him (assuming they are worth it, proven talent) will likely cost us as much or more. Keep Dontrelle. He is a rare breed, and while they might be able to replace an ERA below 3 or 4, you can't easily replace all that he brings to the table. As a leader, a face of the franchise, an ace, and hell, even just being a pitcher who can field and hit. The only idea I've heard that I thought was worth a second thought would be Dontrelle for Andruw Jones. But besides the fact that I think both teams would be reluctant to make that big a trade within the division, it wouldn't really save us any money either. It would simply sure up CF and add a big bat while diminishing our starting pitching (don't delude yourselves into thinking it wouldn't. You cannot assume that all that pitching depth will inevitably produce ML 20-game winners). Willis belongs here. I was on board for all the moves made last off-season, they did make sense. But I would be embarassed if they traded Dontrelle.
  19. Yeah. I should have said Zimmerman hit behind Johnson, thus accounting for his RBI totals... Sorry. So you don't think it's relevant that his batting average goes up tons with runners on base? No I don't. RISP is one of those stats that is meaningless unless it is consistent over 6-7 seasons. There are no enough PAs in that situation to merit anything. BA (worthless stat anyhow) with RISP is far more likely to reflect a small number of hits against a favorable matchup than it is to represent some kind of talent. Frankly, if a hitter hits .200 normally and .350 with RISP, then I would wonder why the hell he can't just hit all the time. He batted 287. And had 198 ABs with RISP, over which he batted 323. Is that not enough ABs? A hitter might hit better with RISP because he will get better pitches as the pitcher should have even more urgency in trying to get out the batter and not allow any further damage in advancing runners. Still, I think it's strange that you feel a stat which basically reflects the player's likelyhood of driving in a baserunner is irrelevant. Haven't we had enough games where we load bases with no outs and scored nothing to see the value of a guy who is pretty good at taking advantage of these types of opportunities. Hey, since you all love OPS so much more, his OPS w/ RISP is 913 (836 overall).
  20. I never said the name Carl Crawford anywhere. That's a pipe dream because the Devil Rays would ask far too much and the Marlins are too smart to bite. I have no problem dealing Jacobs and Nolasco because I'm too high on either of them and I say sell them while their stock is high. And it sounds like Choo would be an offensive downgrade from the platoon... Answer this question for me: Do you actually expect the Marlins expect the Marlins to risk the entire CF position on some scrub in the Mexican leagues who is already 27 years old and the Rockies are desperately trying to dump him? Do you think the Marlins will go after someone so unproven, take the risk of him amounting to absolutely nothing, and be placed into the very same situation as they were in 2006 (Reggie Abercrombie)? Basically I'm saying that even if they acquire this guy, they will need to pick up a legitimate CF for insurance. And that will involve ML talent. You have to give up talent to get talent. Dan Ugglas don't grow on trees. There was NO CF Platoon in 2006. There was Reggie batting under 215 the first half of the season and Amezaga batting under 100 vs LHP through the second half. Cody started 18 games in CF, and his OBP (vs LHP) is 281. I assumed the DRays because everyone and their mother likes to point out that the DRays want a power lefty bat at 1B. But anyway, if not from them, who eactly do you expect to give us a "legitimate" CF for Jacobs & Nolasco. But then there's the problem of filling the new holes left over...either you need a new 1B or you move Hammer there and you need a new LF. Maybe you can fill that spot by platooning Borchard & Cody, but then you better have a CF who can play vs LHP & RHP. And the 5th Starter spot....what should we do then? Let Pinto start? Throw another rookie with no MLB experience into the rotation? or heaven forbid, have to resort to a "veteran" pitcher ala Ismael Valdez and Brian Moehler to fill in that spot? Needless to say (I hope) that I would prefer to have Nolasco back than tinker with the rotation.
  21. Yeah. I should have said Zimmerman hit behind Johnson, thus accounting for his RBI totals... Sorry. So you don't think it's relevant that his batting average goes up tons with runners on base? 323 with RISP, 417 with runners on the corners, 350 with men on 2B & 3B, 313 with bases loaded. Not saying Zim is my pick, but I understand why he gets props. More than simply having people on base ahead of him, he actually does pretty good at getting hits with men on base. I'd still pick Hanley or Uggla, but Zimmerman isn't an illegitimate contender.
  22. He sounds like an only marginally better version of Reggie Abercrombie (aka Reggie 2.0). I'll pass. Let's deal Jacobs and Nolasco and get a real CFer. So let me get this right - you want to get rid of Jacobs and Nolasco when ther could be cheaper options? Or do you really expect the DRays to take that deal? After watching about 30 or so of his at bats this year, he look exactly like Reggie at the plate. They are a very similar player, with Choo putting up some better numbers, but not much better. I'd pass on him. So because he "looks" like Reggie we should pass. His numbers look a lot better. And lets face it, if Reggie could hit around 280 consistently, we would have a lot less problems with him. If we can fill CF defensively without downgrading offense or giving up major talent, why not?
  23. How comparable is the talent in the Mexican Winter leagues? Those numbers are nasty, and I think if he's doing it against a high-enough level of competition, we should go for it. If he only hits 2/3rds of that at the MLB level it should still be good.
  24. Aside from the RBI, which are hugely due to batting in front of Nick Johnson's ridiculous .428 OBP, Zimmerman's numbers are about average for his position. You could say something similar about Uggla batting in front of Cabrera, who well, you know how good Cabrera is. You could possibly make a similar case with Hanley - they will pitch to get him out because they don't want him on base when Cabrera comes up to hit.
  25. I'd only pick Hanley or Uggla over Zimmerman. Unless you're stuck on the wow factor of the no-hitter and like Sanchez, I think those 3 have to be on top. I would say JJ hands down though if he had finished the season better and kept his ERA under 3. When he was on from through till August he was amazing.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.