Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Tee Ball Bunt Machine

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Tee Ball Bunt Machine

  1. Cabrera, Hermida Cabrera, Olivo Helms, Abercrombie JJ, Mitre Tank, Mitre Olivo wasn't the worst defender by a long shot. The defense holes were in CF. I'll buy Mitre as the worst reliever since I can barely remember him having a good relief appearance. But I don't see how you can have him over Moehler as the worst starter.
  2. Just wanted to mention that A-Rod, who everyone loves, Ked more times than any Marlin this year.
  3. About 638 the first half, 566 the 2nd, just a slight drop. Not sure how much you can attribute it to removing certain SO prone players from regular play during the 2nd half (very little Reggie, Reed, etc)
  4. Who was the best offensive position player of 2006? The worst? Who was the best defensive position player of 2006? The worst? Who was the best bench player of 2006? The worst? Who was the best starting pitcher of 2006? The worst? Who was the best relief pitcher of 2006? The worst? Whats everyones opinion? Cabrera. Eric Reed or Amezaga (vs LHP). (at least Reggie scored some big hits, like off Clemens). Uggla. Abercrombie? Helms. not sure... JJ. Moehler. Tank. Messenger.
  5. I don't know, maybe someone with at least an inning of work at some professional level in CF? Ideally a career CFer, be they an established player via a trade, a Free Agent, or even a decent prospect we trade for. I love Hanley, but there's no need to force him out of his comfort zone in the IF. If the Phillies can pull out someone like Victorino in Rowand's absence and the Nationals can find Nook Logan then surely there has to be some decent CF prospects out there who actually play CF.
  6. Good idea, but where do we place Hanley. CF because putting a SS in CF worked so well this season.
  7. And first base is a lot easier to play than center. Generally, first base is a good place to put a sub-par defensive player. Cabs fits that category. Ask Gary Sheffield how easy is it to play 1B (Hope you watched the mess there the Yankees had vs Detroit). Cabrera is not sub-par. He may never be a gold glover, but that cannon he has makes a lot of plays that others wouldn't, and it would be wasted at 1B. And it's not like we have a better 3B now, nor would we have one if we traded for A-Rod.
  8. Well....he'd probably do a lot better than Willy did at catcher, or any other position he's played at. But saying someone will be a better defensive player than Willy isn't saying much. Anyway, if the deal was to go down, I'd think that Cabs would move to first base where he'd likely be better at than he is at third. We'd have the best offensive infield in MLB, and a horrible defensive outfield(again). Why would Cabrera be better at 1B? And why would we want to replace him at 3B with the AL leader in errors at 3B this season? Cabrera isn't that bad a 3B. A-Rod was his league's worst starting 3B. And does it make sense to spend all this money and still end up with horrible OF defense? Don't you think priority should go to fixing the problems before just adding extras "just because"?
  9. First of all, Hanley is fine in CF. No worries. ... First of all, there is no guarantees of Hanley succeeding in CF. He hasn't played OF at all in A, AA, or AAA. Let alone the hardest OF position, and to top it off, at a place like Dolphins Stadium. You don't get ARod if you are not contending. Was Texas ever contending when they had him? Do you honestly think the Yankees wouldn't be able to contend without him? Moehler, Mitre, and Petit is who you bring up to replace Dontrelle?Ownership would easily go out and obtain a 5th starter from somewhere else and not deal with the those clowns, plus obtain bullpen/bench help to create a team. That is chump change compared to A-Rod, and it would signal organizational change in payroll. The Marlins can easily fill all their needs via free agency, sign Cabrera to a 7 year mega contract, and still be in the $40 If it was all that easy it would be done. But obtaining a 5th (usually veteran) Starter to replace a lost young arm had brought us the likes of Valdez, Moehler, & Leiter, and I hope I don't need to tell you the success rate that strategy has had here. I'd rather keep our rotation 5 strong and all young.
  10. your cf would be Hanley Ramirez, arguably just as good as anyone available. How is a guy who has played strictly infield and almost exclusively SS his entire professional career at every minor league level arguably as good as career CFs? Especially if the idea is to spend money, you could try a FA like Edmonds or Hunter. Not saying they are likely, but they would be Available per se, especially if we are willing to break out the same checkbook we would for A-Rod, and they are much better options than Hanley at CF.
  11. Whether it happens or not, it seems like I am one of the few or the only person who has problems with the idea of trading Dontrelle & pitching prospects for A-Rod, so someone please explain to me what it is I'm missing cause it seems like a terrible move when I look at the big picture. #1 - Starting pitching is/was our strength. Sending off Dontrelle & prospects isn't likely to improve the rotation, and he is the most reliable of the 5 (as of now). Also just looking at his 4 years so far, he should be up for another good year since he seems to go on & off every other year. I could also go on about how Dontrelle's a leader and (to the best of my knowledge) A-Rod isn't, but that's besides the point. I want to stay away from a situation where our rotation gets weighed down by an older Moehler or Ismael Valdez type pushing an ERA over 5 that we need to fill a slot in the rotation. #2 - Offense wasn't our problem. For all the harping on about protecting Cabrera, he still hit around 340 and was in the race for the batting title into the last game of the season. The team as a whole hit more HRs than any previous Marlins squad. You had what? 4 guys over 20 HRs with Hanley close behind at 17. The only protection Cabrera really needs is from opposing pitcher plunking him. A-Rod would help offensive production, but it's not a critical need. #3 - Defense, especially at CF, was a problem. While Amezaga got the job over time, a converted utility middle infielder doesn't really cut it defensively. The A-Rod trade would force us to move Hanley to CF. And given the amount we would paying for A-Rod and what we would be giving up in pitching, the result of such an expensive move should give us something better defensively (or at least more reliable) than another converted SS. For that cost, we should be filling the hole in CF properly. Nevermind the problems that could come up if Hanley really struggles there defensively. #4 - Bullpen is another problem. Giving up decent pitching prospects also means giving up future potential bullpen arms. And even if that's a stretch, we're still paying a lot and not addressing this problem. #5 - He's not the superstar Shaq is, and even Shaq wouldn't be able to fill DS 81 times a year in the Summer. He may help attendance some, and make some press, but unless he's gonna put up his own money to make up that $120 million funding gap, all the stadium problems that keep people watching games from home on TV will continue. If he does put up the money I'll love him and call it A-Rod Stadium no matter what it is officially. But would anyone expect that? So anyway, I feel that the move would weaken the starting pitching significantly (barring another suprising rookie lifting the rotation) without fixing any problems and mainly being a boost in an area (offense) that wasn't a problem to begin with. What am I missing? is it just the "oooh, it's A-Rod" factor?
  12. good pitching > good hitting. LOL @ A-Rod's 4 HR WS Game.
  13. Maybe this is a dumb question, but who plays 3B for the Yanks if Arod goes?? Wes Helms Now that's a good answer.
  14. He moved to Miami when he was three years old. I consider him a native. My mistake on saying he was born here. I'm pretty sure he was at least 7 or 8. But anyways...you can consider him whatever you want. Just avoid outright false statements. You could make a strong argument that Shaq is not a top 10 player in the NBA anymore. You can't make that argument with Arod. He was the AL MVP just last year. Argue all you want about being a top 10 player. But that response was about him being as big a deal as Shaq. Shaq is a bigger star, a bigger name, and a champion. The TV ratings are better than the Miami Heat this year despite the awful firesale and the Heat's championship. You can't be serious. How about comparing attendance at games? Do those ratings also include the local ratings for the nationally televised games, or just on Sun Sports? Delgado signing caused a bump of about 400,000 people in '05. I find it hard to believe that an Arod to Marlins deal wouldn't cause an even bigger wave than that. Do you mean to say the Marlins had good attendance in 2005? Texas and the Yankees struggled because of poor pitching, not Arod. We have the pitching, even minus a Dontrelle. The Yankees struggle because they expected to win with offense. Giving up Dontrelle for a bat would be doing exactly the same thing. Sorry if I'm not amped about the prospects of our 4 sophmores sharing the rotation with a Brian Moehler or some other dead weight. We have a solid rotation in place without a real weak link. Not something we need to screw up. I wouldn't be excited about seeing Dontrelle go, but getting A-Rod? I mean, seriously, our problems on offense would be solved forever, and we still have a crapload of prospects in the minors who can fill in for Dontrelle, according to our scouts, etc. So pitching should not decline. What offense problems? We had 3 rookies with over 20 HRs, Cabrera batting around 340, and more HRs than any Marlins team before. Our offense wasn't the problem at all. The only problem you can maybe say the offense had was striking out too often. BTW, A-Rod struck out more times than any of the Marlins this year (and that's saying a lot). We would have to give up Dontrelle & prospects. Not worth it.
  15. He made the playoffs 3 times with the Mariners, twice got to the ALCS with them. Even with his well documented failures with the Yankees, he's still got a .305 career post season average. How about something this century? That's not unfair to bring up, do you think? Is it not simply possible that the guy is washed up, regardless of his personal numbers? He was the Man on the Ranger and they couldn't do a thing. The Yankees picked him up and they got worse. A .305 career postseason average. Nevermind that the last two postseasons he's been under .150, and under .100 this year. Again, this team doesn't need extra offense. And adding more offense while sacrificing pitching (we don't have 5 good starters without Dontrelle and we don't want another Ismael Valdez or Brian Moehler in our rotation) and not fixing the defense isn't going to cut it. We should be trading to fix our weaknesses, not creating new ones and ignoring the old.
  16. I think it's a great move and I think he would make a huge splash on this organization and get a lot of common baseball fans excited. First i think he'd be great protection for Cabs and would be a great addition to the offense and yes i know he personally doesn't fill the need at CF or in the bullpen but he is one of the elite players in the game i think it would also get the common fan excited about baseball and that's what we need Miami and the rest of South Florida is an area of common fans and when the Heat signed Shaq people were excited, went to games and became fans and I truly believe that A-rod would have that effect in South Florida. Cabs did fine without "protection". Fill the needs first. And unless A-Rod is going to pay for a stadium, that's not going to change all the reasons that attendance is low.
  17. Arod at 4 years 66 million is an absolute bargain. A steal for a player with his talent/marketing abilty. Someone said in the other thread that this would not make a bigger splash than the Shaq deal to the heat. I disagree. Arod is probably the best athlete born and raised in the South Florida area ever, he is hispanic, baseball is more popular than basketball in South Florida, and this town always has embraced spanish athletes, but never really had a superstar. He would be huge down and is the perfect fit. It just makes too much damn sense. First off, he wasn't born in South Florida. He was born in NY. He is not a Miami native. Second, he is nowhere near the star Shaq is, being a borderline icon and *gasp* a champion. Third, Basketball is more popular, at least right now. Fourth, all the reasons that people don't go to the stadium aren't going to change as a result of this. It won't affect regular attendance significantly. As far as it being a steal, I'd like to remind everyone of how well A-Rod has rewarded every team that picked up part of his contract: Texas continued to stay in last place and the Yankees have had their 3 worst consecutive finishes of the last 10 years since having A-Rod. Do you really want the Marlins on that list? He picks up big numbers in blow out games, but he doesn't step up to win games the teams need. The richest, highest payed player in history on the lowest payed team playing the poorest city in the country isn't a "perfect fit". Not by a long shot.
  18. The geniuses at ESPN.... Because they also knew the 15 different team Soriano was going to and that we were trading Dontrelle at the beginning of this season. It'll take a little more for this to be taken seriously.
  19. As long as he doesn't call for a bunt with 2 strikes I am fine.
  20. Like I said in finheaven.com, Alex Rodriguez in South Florida will be similar to Shaq's arrival in South Florida, where people will start buying tickets and come to the games to watch him play. So this might be good, and he will definitely be away from the pressure of the media. Only difference between him and Shaq are the rings, but they are both heavily 20 million dollar talents. The Rings are important, and the ability (perceived or real) to bring a championship. Not to mention that A-Rod won't improve the stadium issue. And A-Rod is nowhere near the character & icon that Shaq is. Well, if it's been mentioned on National TV twice, I guess it might not be TOO much of a pipe dream. If it's like "the Marlins will trade Willis to the _________s" rumors this past season, then it's close enough to a pipe dream.
  21. I think Alex has a no-trade clause and I don't see him waving it to go to any other team than the Marlins. If he waves it to go someplace else his reputation would take another hit as he would be viewed as if he quit on NY but if he comes here it would be viewed in part at least as if he's coming home. I don't think he'd "lose face" (at least anymore than he already has) if he went back to Seattle. He'd probably also be more "at home" there than here, but I guess that's just a matter of opinion. Anyway, he doesn't solve any of our problems. Even if he could pad our leads by 3 runs, it won't matter if our defense is like in that extra-innings game in Atlanta. You know which one. We have problems that need fixing. Offense wasn't one of them. And no matter what "the scouts have been saying for years", there is no guarantee of a smooth transition. Especially when you're talking about playing CF at Dolphins Stadium. Wow, it would certainly put some people on the seats. Maybe for opening day, not long term though. Nobody said that the reason they weren't coming to games was that we didn't have any big name stars. It wouldn't cure any of the causes for low attendance.
  22. Hermida was hurt all season long If he was "hurt" he shouldn't have sucked up almost 400 plate appearance. Those are some REALLY intelligent responses. This is coming from the guy who wrote that anyone who disagrees with them is a moron. And that playing CF is THAT SIMPLE. If it were that simple, then it wouldn't have been an issue all season long.
  23. Not really... I've been an outfielder most of my life, you catch the ball and throw it back. Not very difficult. I think you guys are reading way too much into it. It REALLY is THAT simple. Maybe you should play CF for the Marlins. Because so many error-prone rookie SS go on to play well in CF? Or because he "runs fast and has a strong arm?" Reggie runs fast and is strong too. Probably faster and stronger than Hanley. And if that were all it took, we wouldn't need someone else to play CF. He has a very high percentage of being successful because he runs fast and has a strong arm, sure. Those are the two god-given talents that you can't teach. You can teach a player everything else. They've done a great job teaching Reggie.
  24. Anybody who questions Hanley being able to move to CF is a moron. Because so many error-prone rookie SS go on to play well in CF? Or because he "runs fast and has a strong arm?" Reggie runs fast and is strong too. Probably faster and stronger than Hanley. And if that were all it took, we wouldn't need someone else to play CF. And what you heard were talking heads on ESPN and the radio. What I heard were from scouts, and others working with player personnel OK, did your infallible scouts also predict Jeremy Hermida would be an NL ROTY front runner? Not that that was a terrible prediction to make. Just saying that observations are worth a lot more than predictions.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.