Everything posted by Tee Ball Bunt Machine
-
Astros not looking to trade Taveras
hmmm...I had remebered they were also after Gary Matthews. Anyway, I imagine their willingness to trade Taveras will depend on who else they have to put out in CF.
-
Great Offseason Plan
I was mostly responding to the fact you called him garbage. And it's good he already had TJ surgey because with his windup and delivery, you could see it coming anyway Fair enough...garbage may be a bit much. But he is/was horribly overrated.
-
Hanley stats question
Maybe an adjustment was made later - like a hit being changed to an error?
-
Josh Johnson trade bait?
wow...no No matter how bad we need a CF, Milledge isn't worth any of our starters. or any of our starting position players for that matter. New York seems like another planet everytime I read this stuff.
-
Great Offseason Plan
And one last thing, about the trio of Halladay, Willis, and Burnett - it wouldn't be that good because Burnett is garbage. He will end his career with sub-500 record. I honestly can't imagine the thought process of the Jays when they paid him what they did. The fact that he has already had Tommy John surgery and how absolutely filthy his stuff is. It makes sense why they gave him that much. His main concern is health, but when he is healthy he can be as good as anyone. How does already having had Tommy John increase his value? The guy's career record is one game over 500, and part of that was having some good run support behind him this year. He's never been consitently domininant, just overrated because of how hard he can throw. And it would be one thing if he was 22-25 where you can talk about his potential and say that he is still developing - but the guy will be 30 when the next season starts. People discuss him like if he is/was an ace caliber pitcher, but he never was or will be. I'm not saying he's a bad pitcher, just that he's also not some feared monster that teams will hate having to face, and the only way he would make a rotation look fearsome is if everyone else is good enough to make him #5. He gets knocked around like everyone. For all his talent, he is still average.
-
Very good Marlins assessment for 2007
Hermida is going to hit 15+ home runs, .285+ BA, .350+ OBP, 80+ RBI, 90+ R next season. Bank on it. What did you bank on him having in 06?
-
Great Offseason Plan
Trade #1: Sounds all nice and good, but the DRays would want more. These are the people who wanted Olsen for Joey Gathright. Trade #2: very confusing - but no. Alex Rios would be nice, but he doesn't fill any of our needs (until you dump Hermida in a later trade.) If you want to give up DTrain & Jake we should. We have enough good SP in house, and we shouldn't be sacrificing SP for RP. Trade #3: Hermida can't replace Gary Matthews and the organization hasn't given up on him. there may be a desire for catcher prospects, but it's not a desperate need that would get us to trade someone with Hermida's potential. Trade #4: All that just to get one reliever? All in all, I don't understand why you want to trade half the team. And one last thing, about the trio of Halladay, Willis, and Burnett - it wouldn't be that good because Burnett is garbage. He will end his career with sub-500 record. I honestly can't imagine the thought process of the Jays when they paid him what they did.
-
Bonds to Fish?
I don't think so unless it went really bad. I think those 2 feel connected enough to the team that they'd see it as a move to build a championship contender team, at least at first. If things went well, it would re-affirm that thought and we'd probably help Bonds break the record and finally get a ring, so everyone would be happy. If Bonds spends a ton of time on the DL and doesn't pull his weight, then I could imagine some bad feelings developing.
-
Most Overrated Marlin
I'm shocked that people think of others before AJ. Guy was and still is a sub-500 career pitcher, and people talk about him as if he's an ace because he can throw hard. I guess I can see why someone would say Pavano thinking back to how he won a few games back in his big 04. Can't understand the people calling DTrain though. No pitcher has ever had a better season as a Marlin and no pitcher has won more games for the Marlins. He was robbed of the Cy Young in 05 and even if he never has that good a season again, he has earned as much praise as we give any pitcher. Seriously, what else would he have to do to justify how highly he is regarded?
-
Most Overrated Marlin
AJ Burnett
-
Bonds to Fish?
We all want to go down to the county fairgrounds when the freak show comes to town but one would think for the money we would have to pay to sign the guy (and as much as I respect Ramp, it's still hard for me to fathom this theoretical move), couldn't we actually get someone who is healthy? The thing is how many healthy (and available) players are there who can produce what he can? Not to mention the reputation and how it would affect the lineup in general and Cabrera specifically. The only comparably imposing bats are nowhere near available.
-
Bonds to Fish?
I'd move Jacobs, Nolasco, and prospect for Baldelli. Tampa would probably still want more and I'm not sure Baldelli's worth that much.
-
Marlin's hot stove talk from USA Today
And when Zimmerman wins the rookie of the year today, he will be one step closer to earning his place in DC.
-
Shopping Spree not very likely for the Marlins
I especially liked Baxter's concern that there's not enough money to "bring back" free agents Mat Herges and Brian Moehler :banghead :lol :lol
-
Marlin's hot stove talk from USA Today
Why would we want Milledge? New York hype is at it again. If we make a trade for a centerfielder and it involves Dontrelle Willis, you better believe it's going to be a household name player. I have no doubt in my mind! That's the reason why I think they're simply not going to trade Dontrelle. You can't trade Dontrelle for prospects and scrubs. It would have to be a big name to justify it, but getting that big name would likely more than negate the only "benefit" to trading Dontrelle - saving money. Any such player will cost as much or more.
-
Shopping Spree not very likely for the Marlins
One possible trade partner is the Tampa Bay Devil Rays, who are desperate for pitching and who previously have expressed interest in Marlins pitcher Sergio Mitre and Jason Vargas, among others. Tampa has a surplus of young outfield prospects it could offer. Give me Baldelli, Crawford or Dukes please Tampa......again, these are the people who wanted Scott Olsen for Joey Gathright last year... It would probably take Dontrelle (and maybe more) to take either of the first two (and those trades wouldn't save much money either). Maybe we could get Dukes for those two, but Dukes is well, what Dukes has been so far. Could potentially be good, but that is significant trade filler to give for a guy who's (good) potential is offset by some way too significant discipline problems.
-
CF, Bullpen Top on Marlins Wish List
Taveras has probably been mentioned more often than any other for a CF target. And while everyone here was saying what a bad idea that was from the start and how bad Taveras is, he did set a record for his club with a 30-game hitting streak. I doubt writers with direct connections to the team are pulling names out of a hat while writing articles. It's not speculation.
-
No Major Payroll Hike expected...
Owner Jeffrey Loria has provided his front office with the 2007 budget. Last year, the Marlins spent about $19.6 million (including deferred payments) on the major league roster. The 2007 figure is expected to remain in that area. This does not mean there will be no increase in payroll. A "Major Payroll Hike" is relative. With no new numbers, this article is meaningless. If they were going to trade Cabrera or Willis, they would have done it last season or last offseason. Between one, the other or both, I think you could literally have any group of players you want. I actually *gasp* believe it that they intended to build a young talented team that will be competetive (with DTrain & Cabs as the core) without the inflated salaries rather than just dump salary, and the 06 season is proof.
-
Juan Pierre..."A Very Good Defensive Centerfielder"
Well of course, there's no better judge of player's defensive abilities than Joe Schmoe on the message board. A pitcher depending on a fielder for defense behind him has no business trying to assess that fielder's abilities.
-
Veteran Leadership For Next Year
Maybe if Helms go elsewhere and the price is right. How much would Counsell be expecting?
-
Marlins situation for 2007
Ramirez and Uggla are more than likely to undergo considerable sophomore slumps. I don't see Ramirez getting on base as consistently so the leadoff spot could very well be compromised, so unless you expect to put Hermida or Willingham there, it would be in good interests of the Marlins to acquire a Dave Roberts type player who can actually get on base (as opposed to a Taveras who isn't good for anything offensively). I never asked for a power hitting CF, only a better hitter than Taveras (which is not asking much at all). You are expecting too much next season from unproven rookie players who are likely to slump. I think it's extremely likely that Uggla will have an off year and that alone could severely damage this offense that you claim needs absolutely no upgrading. I've been saying all along, don't overpay for a player who ONLY brings you defense. So, at one moment you are saying that the CF offense will be fine and the next you say there is no way to downgrade from the current situation. The only players next year I would count on to have good years are Cabrera and Willingham, meaning there are a lot of question marks and a few likely failures (Olivo, Amezaga, Ross). And look at it this way, almost any player the Marlins acquire as an offensive upgrade will also be a defensive upgrade. There are plenty of player (particularly over priced FA power-hitters) who would be defensive downgrades. But regardless... What exactly makes them "more than likely" to have big slumps? I understand that it's a possiblity and that sort of thing happens, but I don't see what makes it likely. They all played an entire season as starters. Its not as though they have to make significant adjustments to being an everyday player all season long. You really can't predict a slump anymore than you can predict a streak. Remember all the predictions about 06, and I'm not talking the ESPN 120+ losses. I mean everyone here who thought Hermida would be ROTY and Uggla wouldn't last.
-
I hate MLB.com
No, I agree that the article was stupid. You'd think sometihng like that wouldn't make to the main page on MLB.com. Or at least you'd like to think... They're not going to do something crazy like send us Beltran and pay most of his salary. No reason to trade within the division when we don't need to.
-
I hate MLB.com
You tell em Mr. Loria :notworthy :notworthy Sorry, when I saw Jeffrey I couldn't resist
-
Marlins situation for 2007
1. It depends on what the Marlins are really after offensively. Rferry makes some valid points...a player like Crawford while not a good candidate for the leadoff spot in my mind will still be valuable to the team. However, I think he isn't worth what he will cost. Taveras is hard to justify acquiring for his bat, however because he isn't really good offensively in any respect. And as you say the Marlins will have limitations and that is precisely why I think they should pass on Taveras, Lidge, Crawford, Edmonds, etc. 2. I was talking about a CF filling needs for that position alone. 1. I don't think Marlins have real offensive needs. We have a good lead-off hitter coming off a year (w/ over 45 2B and over 50 SB) that would be career year for any similar player. We have a hitting machine with plenty of power in the middle of the order, and a good amount of power spread out around him. There will be questions at the bottom of the order no matter what - if Olivo's performance in 06 was a fluke, will Hermida live up to the promise this year, etc. But the offense this year was as good as you can hope for, given where we play - we will simply never have 40-50 HR guys up and down our lineup. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. Not saying that I would be opposed to an easy (and reliable) upgrade, but it's not a need or a priority that we need to actively seek at the expense of any other need. 2. The CF doesn't need to fill any other needs. They're not going to pitch, and it would be almost inconceivable to offensively downgrade from Reggie and Amezaga. We don't NEED to find protection for Cabrera. He batted around 340 pretty much all season, scored over 110 RBIs, and was one or two good games away from a batting title. Could it conceivably be better with a big bat behind him? Absolutely. But is that really a problem is desperate need of a fix? No.
-
Marlins situation for 2007
It is certainly possible to get a player that will upgrade both the offense and defense. You are ignoring that part for some reason. I fail to see the logic behind overpaying for a player like Taveras when their are likely to be more affordable options out there. My point is that if you are going to be giving up good talent you should go out there and fulfills some needs another than a defensive upgrade from Amezaga or Ross. On the first point, I believe that we'll have to pay more to get more in terms of a player who also upgrades our offense along with the defense significantly. I don't expect better players to come cheaper. And while I figure there's nothing really wrong with spending more to get more, I think that we need to keep in mind that this team only has so much to give/spend, and much of what we have should (IMO) be considered untouchable. On the second point - we have no bigger need than for defensive improvement in CF except the bullpen (and it's close). But you can't solve the bullpen in a single trade/with a single player. And I figure the bullpen issues will more likely be solved by young developing pitchers like Tank & Pinto along with low-cost FAs, rather than with trades. Beyond that, this team has no glaring weaknesses or desperate needs.