Everything posted by dim
-
Marlins trade/FA talk
Stanton's not going anywhere until NEXT offseason. And even then the Marlins will grab a couple starting pitching prospects in the deal.
-
2014 Slogan Nominations
Breaking New Ground :mike2
-
Marlins trade/FA talk
I still think the draft comes down to Gatewood or Turner. I'm not buying all the Alex Jackson talk right now. Right now I'd love to grab Turner. A+++ speed, decent to above average defense at SS (with the ability to play 3B and probably 2B as well), and has the potential to add some power to his repertoire. Gatewood is a Stanton style high school prospect. Scouting reports have him as a guy with 30+ home run a season power as a SS, but not the best contact guy (and he's likely a meh fielder and slow baserunner). The enticing thing about Gatewood is he's coming right out of high school and has potential to gain some plate discipline, build into his frame and become an even better hitter over time. But we'll all have this conversation in June. Still got months until baseball starts back up again.
-
McGehee Signs One Year Deal
I don't think Salty got all that money NOT to bat cleanup or 3rd.
-
Marlins trade/FA talk
I didn't know where to put this, but I still think at some point we're gonna have to trade that starting pitching depth we have for hitters. I see that the Marlins have gone with a few stopgaps for next season (Jones/Furcal/McGehee), and I'm fine with that for what will probably be a 70-75 win season next year. But to succeed in 2015, which should be the ultimate goal anyway at this point, we're going to need more than just Stanton and everybody else. Long term solutions HAVE to be found at every infield spot after this upcoming season is over. By 2015, we're going to have more starting pitchers ready to join the majors than we'll have slots available. I'm sure internally the Marlins understand that the playoffs aren't a realistic goal for next year. But our major league and minor league position player depth is pretty damn barren. Until we field a lineup that can realistically produce more than two everyday players who can OPS over .750 in a 162 game season, this team isn't going to contend. On a minor side note, I hope I'm wrong on this, but I still despise that this front office seems like they're going to let Hechavarria start at SS for years to come.
- 25 Man Roster
-
25 Man Roster
Heaney's obviously a better prospect than Conley. But Conley could definitely make the rotation if pitchers fail to live up to expectation or injuries occur (and this is likely to happen to at least two of our starting pitchers). Fernandez Eovaldi Turner Alvarez Koehler I don't believe Eovaldi/Turner/Alvarez, if they all begin the season still on the Marlins, are all going to post mid 3 ERA's again next season. When some of them get injured or falter (and obviously Koehler gets replaced) I'd go Conley before Heaney. Heaney's the better pitcher and the better prospect, but Conley's got more innings logged in the minors. Heaney has barely over 100 IP in the minors, while Conley has over 250 IP. When a starting pitcher needs to come up, I'd rather let Conley take his place early. Honestly, I'd rather let Heaney pitch the whole season in AA/AAA ball and come up in 2015.
- 25 Man Roster
-
McGehee Signs One Year Deal
And everybody mentions Moran. I think Moran is further away from the majors than many people are expecting. He's not nearly as polished as other guys (like Kris Bryant) are coming out of college, and he'll need all of 2014 and likely at least part of 2015 to work out the kinks in the minors. Absolutely no need to rush a guy like Moran with the product the Marlins are currently putting out on the field.
-
McGehee Signs One Year Deal
There's not even high reward. McGehee is a below average player who will perform like he has his entire career sans one season. This is a sh*t, we ran out of options, lets go grab that guy out of Japan and make him our starting 3B signing. Not upset, as at this point a 1 year deal doesn't mean crap when the team will suck next year, but it's whatever. I'd rather have Eric Chavez, but I think he wants to go back to Arizona anyway.
-
Marlins trade/FA talk
And he won't be selected because no team likely views Canha as major league ready. At 25 years old in February, if you're not major league ready by now... Not saying it can't happen, and I like Mark Canha more than most, but I don't think the Marlins view him as highly as me or Bender views him.
-
2013/14 offseason signings/trades
That's a LOT of money, even for a short term deal. I wouldn't want even half that much money tied into the payroll over the next two years. Napoli isn't THAT good of a hitter that he's worth $16 million per year.
-
Marlins trade/FA talk
Well the + in that scenario is more important than the LoMo. So it would be something like "Eovaldi or Henderson Alvarez+"
-
Marlins trade/FA talk
Lucas or Canha? I just mentioned Canha because the Marlins not protecting him shows they don't see Canha as having any real future with the team.
-
Marlins trade/FA talk
If the Marlins could somehow trade LoMo+ for Garin Cecchini, I would be ecstatic. That would make all of this worth it. That kid's something to get excited about. Red Sox said they're not trading prospects (and specifically mentioned Cecchini. Plus, it would take more than Morrison to get Cecchini. The Sox would want a major league starting pitcher in return for a good prospect like Cecchini if they even were considering trading him.
-
Marlins trade/FA talk
Guys...Ed Lucas is OPS'ing over .880 against LHP in both his minor league and major league career. Platoon him at 1B or do it at 3B, but Ed Lucas should DEFINITELY be starting against any and all lefty pitchers next season. And BenderRobot, the Marlins didn't protect Mark Canha in the Rule 5 Draft, so he'll either go to another team or be stashed back into the minor league system for next season.
-
Marlins trade/FA talk
Why are people entertaining the thought of this team contending next season? And I don't get the love for Middlebrooks. I really really don't.. You'd trade for him based on his potential. Really solid rookie year followed by a below average sophomore season. Try and grab him when his value is low and hope he goes back to the guy he was in the minors/rookie season. Plus, right now we have absolutely NOBODY (or Dietrich if you wanna) at 3B, so Middlebrooks would be a nice improvement over nothing.
-
Marlins trade/FA talk
LoMo has hit lefties better than righties throughout his career. Platoon him and Jones wouldn't be a bad idea. If it's destined that Morrison gets traded, I actually don't mind the thought of Canha coming up as a platoon guy at 1B. I always saw Canha as a Gaby Sanchez lite kind of hitter, and as Bender showed his stats in the minors against LHP are really nice. Whatever happens, Jones has to be platooned because his splits are crazy. Jones could also play the outfield if the Marlins decide to get a Trumbo or decide that Ozuna/Marisnick need more seasoning and they don't want to start Ruggiano.
- 2014 Lineup Projections
-
Marlins to sign Furcal
A Chavez/Lucas platoon at 3rd base would have been better than Furcal at 2nd and Dietrich at 3rd. Or trading for Middlebrooks. Or Uribe, even as a last resort on a 2 year deal. Maybe Chavez doesn't want to sign here? We've probably tried like 4 times over the last 5 years. Maybe the asking price for Middlebrooks is too high? A 2 year deal for Uribe is even worse with Moran coming. Or the Marlins have been too stupid to sign him. He's literally signed for minor league deals and incentive laden deals over the last three or so years. A guy in Chavez's situation the last few years doesn't get to be choosy about what team he signs with. He goes wherever the best offer is at, and I'm pretty sure that the Marlins never gave him a real offer.
-
Marlins to sign Furcal
If I gave you a starting infield of... 1B: Morrison 2B: Furcal/Solano SS: Hechavarria 3B: Dietrich Would you initially guess that this is a starting infield for the Miami Marlins on opening day 2014, or the starting infield of the New Orleans Zephyrs on opening day 2014? I would say it should be the latter.
- 2014 Lineup Projections
-
Marlins to sign Furcal
I hate Dietrich as a 3rd baseman. It's in the same vein of the talk of putting Coghlan at 3B not too long ago. Put players where they are likely to thrive. Dietrich doesn't belong at 3rd base. It's stupid that Diietrich can't mature at his natural position because we have to give playing time to a 36 year old has been (sorry Furcal, but that's what you are).
-
Marlins to sign Furcal
As for the good on base thing with Furcal. 2012: .325 OBP 2011: .298 OBP Uh...This is the part where I say you can't judge players because there past was awesome. I can say "hey, Furcal was awesome when he was younger and playing for the Dodgers/Braves" and I would be right. I'd also be right saying "hey, Furcal is 36 years old, coming off a serious injury, and hasn't been anything resembling a good player since 2010".
-
Marlins to sign Furcal
Dietrich is a power hitting 2nd baseman. At third base he's got average to below average power. Furcal at 2B and Dietrich at 3B doesn't make this team better. With this current lineup we'd likely still be far below average offensively and may not be able to hit 100 home runs AGAIN. I understood a stopgap at 3B. Somebody like Eric Chavez or even a Brandon Inge might've been fine. Furcal is just Juan Pierre at 2nd base. I doubt Furcal makes it to August as an everyday starter. Furcal DOES make the team better. Does he make it great? No, but he is absolutely better than Donovan Solano, offensively and defensively. Furcal is nothing like Pierre. He has always had decent pop. Furcal had a grand total of 26 XBH's in 477 AB's the last time he played regularly. He had even less the year before with the Dodgers. Furcal has no power. Every player in the league has more power than Pierre, but that doesn't mean Furcal has any real power at all. And this isn't about Solano. Solano shouldn't be starting everyday and Dietrich would've been the starting 2B without a Furcal signing (we'd find a 3B somewhere, any likely still will). Furcal hasn't been a good player since 2010. We can't justify useless signings because our bad starting 2B (Solano) last season is SLIGHTLY worse than the bad starting 2B we just signed. It's a dumb signing, plain and simple. It's especially dumb since we're not going to be good next year. When you suck as a team, you start your younger players and see what you have with them. THAT is how you do a rebuild.