Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

dim

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by dim

  1. In terms of Skipworth, what mystikol said. The hoopla around Realmuto was because he had a really good season in Greensboro (800+ OPS for a catcher) at 20 years old. I don't know if he wasn't ready for the call up or what, but he's not on the radar too much anymore. Barnes overtook him by a long shot.
  2. Zack Cox succeeding is super, super important considering we literally have no other option at 3B to reach the majors in the near future.
  3. LUCAS!
  4. Jeff Mathis has has over 1400 at bats in his career...and a batting average under .200 I'm not even mad, just impressed that he can keep a job for eight years hitting like that.
  5. Wow. Turner might go 8.
  6. uhhhh Disclaimer: the opinions of SomethingFishy does NOT reflect the opinions held by dim. We apologize and hope to continue posting original content on this message board.
  7. We had no interest in trading Willis in 05. If the trade would have improved the team (and it clearly would have at the time), then the Marlins absolutely had an interest in trading Willis after the 2005 season. That's the thing. I don't think the Marlins front office thought it would've CLEARLY helped us. I don't think the public opinion at the time was that Granderson/Verlander>Willis. It was that cut and dry. Nobody was saying that without a doubt two players with barely any time spent in the majors were CLEARLY better than a two time all star and reigning Cy Young runner up.
  8. BTW, that thread was posted two months into the season after Dontrelle stunk, skewing public opinion, and I'm assuming that offer was made in the offseason before Dontrelle's implosion to start the season. If you told Marlins fans the trade offer was made in the offseason when the offer was reporting given to the Marlins, I guarantee you opinion would've been far more split. Hell, there were people still questioning whether it would've been the right move even after Dontrelle's terrible start.
  9. Marlins fans also got excited when they heard Texas offered Justin Smoak for Josh Johnson. We get excited easily. That LA trade was a different story. THAT is the trade that Marlins fans should forever regret not making, considering it made sense at the time as we were obviously looking to trade Cabrera. We had no interest in trading Willis in 05.
  10. Again, we're playing the game of hindsight. There weren't people touting the Marlins to trade Willis after that 05 season. Again, the offer from the Tigers reporting came after or during the 05 season, not 06. I'm sure the Marlins would've made the deal after the '06 season, but even during a fire sale, it's hard to justify trading a 23 year old pitcher who had been consistently great for his first three seasons, just finished second in the Cy Young voting, and was under contract for many more years for cheap. It's not hindsight, though. That's what I'm saying. The circumstances at the time make it a no-brainer for the Marlins to pull the trigger. It's definitely a wise move when you are being offered the best pitching prospect in baseball and a solid centerfielder (when you don't have one in your system) for a pitcher who had only one dominant season that likely owed a lot to an unconventional delivery. You don't need to think in hindsight. It made perfect sense at the time. I'd say 2003 was also pretty dominant, but that's somewhat irrelevant. He had two all star seasons in his first three years. That's not somebody you look to trade so early in his career. And most scouts highly, highly touted Maybin and Miller prior to 2007. It was realized at the time just how rushed they were and how flawed as prospects they were. Verlander would've been very highly ranked, but Granderson was nowhere near a sure thing as a prospect.
  11. Verlander and Granderson were also much more highly thought off than Miller and Maybin at the peaks of the respective prospect statuses. http://www.baseballamerica.com/today/prospects/rankings/top-100-prospects/2007/263445.html Miller 10, Maybin 6. http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=3773 Granderson 30, Verlander not listed because he didn't spend much time in the minors.
  12. I don't know who Lucas is.
  13. Again, we're playing the game of hindsight. There weren't people touting the Marlins to trade Willis after that 05 season. Again, the offer from the Tigers reporting came after or during the 05 season, not 06. I'm sure the Marlins would've made the deal after the '06 season, but even during a fire sale, it's hard to justify trading a 23 year old pitcher who had been consistently great for his first three seasons, just finished second in the Cy Young voting, and was under contract for many more years for cheap.
  14. It wasn't an issue of PR. It was the fact that in 2006 it would've been damn near impossible to find a pitcher who can give you a mid 2 ERA and 236 innings at 23 years old. Verlander was 22 and had pitched a whopping 11 innings in the majors at that point. Granderson had proven to be a good player both in the majors and minors, but again he had less than a full season's worth of AB's in the majors. It's a bit hypocritical to bash the Marlins for taking Maybin/Miller+ for Cabrera/Willis because we gave up a proven superstar for unknown commodities, yet we are going to trash the front office in hindsight for not giving up what was at that point a proven young superstar for two mostly unproven commodities in 2005.
  15. Yelich is a five tool player. He'll be consistently good in just about everything. He'll steal some bases, hit for average, show some pop and play stellar defense, but he doesn't exactly excel in any one thing. Back when he was a 1st base prospect out of high school there were high end comparisons to John Olerud as a hitter. I wouldn't be shocked in the slightest if Yelich's ceiling is in the mold of where John Olerud's career was at. I forgot to mention in my original post that this team has a ton of options. If Marisnick starts to produce amazing stats in the minor at some point and Morrison doesn't work out (and we decide NOT to trade Stanton), it wouldn't surprise me if Stanton is moved to 1st base at some point IF he continues to suffer from injuries. Another option is to put Yelich there considering he's played 1st base before (although I prefer Yelich in the outfield as it adds to his value). We have a great deal of options long term, and some of these options will bust out. The important part is to find the few players who bust out. Find the one guy who bursts onto the scene unexpectedly and becomes a star for your team. Whatever I wrote earlier is going to turn out wrong, because minor league prospects are completely unpredictable. That's one of the biggest problems with what the Marlins did (other than giving up on a long term plan and giving a big middle finger to the fan base). They're banking their long term future on prospects, many of them middle of the line prospects currently who we have no idea whether they'll become major leaguers or bust out in the minors.
  16. While it's easy to argue that first part regarding Eovaldi being wrong (he'll be a back end of the rotation guy most likely or be sent to the pen once he can't figure it out), I actually agree (please kill me) with SomethingFishy about Dontrelle Willis. We can look in hindsight and talk about how we all obviously would've pulled the trigger on a Verlander/Granderson trade, but when that trade was being discussed Willis had just had the best season of his career, finished second in the Cy Young Voting, and was looking like he'd be one of the best pitchers in baseball for a LONG time. Everybody had concerns about his pitching delivery hindering him at some point, but I don't think anybody had a clue about anxiety being his downfall. Dontrelle was too good to trade in 2005. However, we basically gave up prior to the 2006 season (say whatever you want about the final result and the near playoff push. Ownership didn't give a rats ass about 2006). If there was a time to trade Willis at his peak value, it was 2006 when the fan base had already started to hate this franchise after another fire sale (sounds very familiar). Still, no GM would've traded Willis at that time.
  17. Did I not already show you that this team needs to play nearly .500 ball the rest of the season to avoid 100 losses? Not happening. Yelich isn't a superstar. He's going to be an average outfielder when he first gets called up and will eventually develop into a really nice outfield prospect. He's not Stanton when he was getting called up (aka a game changer). He's not going to change the complexion of this team. There are only two stars who are on this team. They are Giancarlo Stanton and Jose Fernandez. One of those guys is injured and probably out for a long time, and the other is a rookie and isn't going to see his numbers match his potential until at least year 3. At catcher we are below average (Brantly is a below average catcher currently. At his plateau he's a league average catcher). Long term Austin Barnes will probably be our starting catcher, but he's only at A+ ball and has a long way to go. Logan Morrison is a below average starting first baseman (Even at his best, he doesn't have nearly the power to compare to even league average 1B, and he stopped getting on base a lot when he left the minors). Donovan Solano is a bench player disguising himself as a starter. Derek Dietrich is a rookie who is currently going through tough stretches like he should and will do, and he should end the season near a low .700 OPS, but he's the guy who is our future starting 2B. Adeiny Hechavarria is batting .183. He's easily the worst hitting everyday player in baseball currently and doesn't belong anywhere near a starting lineup even with above average defensive abilities. Polanco is a waste at third base and is just there to fill time until we learn if Zack Cox can prove capable in the minors. Pierre is useless and will be gone once Yelich is ready or Stanton comes back from injury. Ruggiano is a 4th outfielder on a mediocre team and a starter caliber on a bad one like us. He's a poor man's Cody Ross and serves value as a platoon guy for some team next year that needs an extra outfielder. Marcel Ozuna is part of the team's future core, but he's obviously playing WAY over his head right now (just look at his minor league splits. He's a strike out machine). I like Ozuna, but he'll regress and it'll take at least a year or two for him to get his footing in the big leagues. Our starting pitching is filled with at least two guys who will be traded by July (Nolasco and Slowey) and a bunch of guys who belong in the minors or in the bullpen (Koehler, LeBlanc, Sanabia). Jacob Turner is raw as hell, but he is young and he'll learn. Still, his ceiling is as a #2 starter, more likely a 3 or 4. Alvarez is an unknown commodity, but based on his numbers for Toronto and in the minors he's probably another #3 starter long term. Jose Fernandez is a great young pitcher who will be our ace within the next year. Our bullpen is filled with guys who will be traded at the deadline (Webb/Dunn) and really young guys who are in no way sure things (Cishek/Ramos/Jennings). The best team we're going to put out on the major league roster isn't coming until mid 2014 or early 2015, and it might look like this... C: Barnes/Brantly 1B: Morrison (Probably somebody new) 2B: Dietrich SS: Some new Guy 3B: Cox LF: Ozuna/Marisnick CF: Yelich RF: Stanton SP: Fernandez/Rodon/Heaney/Turner/Nicolino Bullpen filled with guys like Ramos, Cishek, Eovaldi, Morey, Flynn, Descalfini, Hope, Conley, etc... And tons of these guys won't work out, so plans will obviously change. This team is in complete rebuild mode. There's probably only a handful of guys on the current roster that factor into the team's long term plans period. This also doesn't factor in the players we'll take in the 2013 draft (especially the 6th pick. I did factor Rodon #1 in 2014 to us already).
  18. He was absolutely meh in Spring Training and in the minors, but in 42+ innings (7 starts) he put up a 3.38 ERA for us. Turner's a part of our long term rotation plans. Hope he succeeds. I expect him to be good enough to at least stay in the rotation until the end of the season.
  19. Hechavarria (Ozzie Smith 2.0). David Samson, is that you? PS: I liked the post for how insane it is. Not only did you misspell six names (Morrison, Coghlan, Eovaldi, Alvarez, LeBlanc and Hechavarria), but you compared a player who can't hit the Mendoza line to the greatest shortstop in history, you called Cishek the best closer in baseball, Ozuna a monster... You know what. I started reading and suddenly I just now realized I'm feeding the troll...I should just stop now As for the "this team has no way of losing 100 games". We have to go 50-59 the rest of the season to lose 99 games. We're currently 13-40, or roughly 27 games under .500 and we haven't even reached the two month mark yet. It's not being pessimistic to say this team will lose 100 games, it's just obvious.
  20. He was DFA'd. Let him hit waivers and then snag him, considering we are first on the waiver wire and don't have to worry about other team's taking him beforehand.
  21. I'd also like to point out how disappointing Realmuto has been the last two seasons. He's moving up the system fast, and at 22 he's going to have another three years as a legitimate prospect to prove himself at catcher, but he can't even muster a .600 OPS at this point. Barnes has jumped him as the candidate to replace Brantly in the future (although Barnes has been on a big cold streak as of late. Still OPS'ing over .800 though).
  22. If Zack Cox can maintain an .800+ OPS into June, I'd like to see him called up to AAA and eventually get a shot to start at 3B in September if he performs well at AAA. I wouldn't be shocked in the least if we start with Cox at 3B in 2014, whether he's ready or not (although he'll be a month shy of 25 on Opening Day 2014. It wouldn't really be rushing him to call him up if he maintains an .800+ OPS into June this season and call him up to start ahead of Polanco). We all know Cox would probably OPS under .700 at the beginning, but it would be good learning experience for him to get called up in a month.
  23. I don't mean any of that as a Loria bash. There's enough of that around. I know what Loria is and expect it. It's more of statement on reality than a complaint at this point. The Marlins becoming competitive would be in spite of everything Loria has done to tear this team down. It's obvious that Loria wanted to build a winner last season. He just tried it in the worst way possible, grabbing old, whiny, injury prone players with a loud mouth manager and expecting everything to magically mesh. That team last season wasn't sustainable, and this team isn't going to be competitive until 2016 at the earliest.
  24. Beinfest has done fine, given the fact that he's always worked with a payroll in the bottom two in the league for over a decade, has an owner that micromanages every decision he makes, and the one time he does get some money to use, they use it on old, some injury prone players (with Loria pushing Beinfest's hand on some of those signings). We can obviously go through some of the bad trades Beinfest has done, and how the Marlins as a whole have been selling players at the lowest points of their value in recent years, but he's still a mid caliber GM in baseball. He can build a playoff team if given the right tools to use. But Loria's way always wins over. And as long as Loria is owner of this team, it's going to be incredibly hard for any GM to build a winning team when his owner hands him a budget of pennies so he can pocket the revenue sharing money. We could fire Beinfest, and he probably should be fired at this point given some poor recent decisions and the lack of a real major league squad at the moment. But I doubt there's going to be any GM that can be productive here while Loria's around.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.