Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

dim

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by dim

  1. http-~~-//www.youtube.com/watch?v=crYDOdZ2LC4 Sanabia vs Derek http-~~-//www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDAaevTq51I Forecast
  2. And my problem with Skipworth is catchers are so volatile you NEVER EVER EVER take them in the first round that high unless its Joe Mauer, Matt Wieters, or Buster Posey. Those occur every 4-5 years if you are blessed with a pick to select them with. I don't think Skipworth was that level of safe as a 17 year old, even if considered a top 12-15 talent overall. Skipworth was just to risky, even for baseball draft terms, based on his position. That's exactly what I have been saying this entire thread (except longer and not to the point like this).
  3. The Braves and Giants series are crucial. If we can go 5-2 during the next 7 games and get 2 games over .500 and stay within 4 or 5 games of the wild card lead, I'd say this team needs to trade for a middle reliever. I think if we are buying that we should just trade an "Aaron Thompson" kind of prospect for a middle reliever. If we go 3-4 or 2-5 during this stretch, may be time to part ways with Cantu and Ross. I still wouldn't trade Uggla or Nunez unless we get totally blown away with an offer.
  4. New Note: Reds are losing 7-1. Looks like we are going to be 5 games back or 5.5 back if the Giants win.
  5. Note: If the Reds lose tonight, the Marlins are only 5 games back in the Wild Card Race. You can say all you want that the season if over, but statistically we are right in this thing.
  6. The Caveman ends this with an RBI single. Oh happy day. This team needed to take 3 of 4 to keep the season alive, and they did it.
  7. THIS IS THE GREATEST WEEK OF BONIFACIO'S CAREER!!!!!!!!!!! i still think it was last year when he had the inside the park home run and hit like .460 to begin the season. THIS IS THE SECOND GREATEST WEEK OF BONIFACIO'S CAREER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  8. , Walking the bases loaded.
  9. THIS IS THE GREATEST WEEK OF BONIFACIO'S CAREER!!!!!!!!!!!
  10. Guess we gotta win by a Mike Stanton walk off homer.
  11. Let's compare. Ubaldo Jimenez- 5.1 IP, 6 runs allowed, 4 ER, No Decision Josh Johnson- 6.1 IP, 1 ER, No Decision
  12. But you know...Wins and Losses are totally an important stat. JJ totally didn't deserve to get the win today giving up only 1 run
  13. Oh sh*t, that was so f*cking lucky. The Baseball Gods are definitely on our side today.
  14. With the game starting at 12:10, this game thread may not make it to 2 pages today, so no point in going all detailed. Marlins lineup coghlan, lf murphy, ss sanchez, 1b uggla, 2b cantu, 3b ross, cf stanton, rf paulino, c johnson, p
  15. I just posted links to like 5 articles from BEFORE the draft that said he was a 5-10 player, and one in which BaseballAmerica called him the best prep catcher since Joe Mauer, but it got deleted. If you want to say "Don't ever draft a high school catcher", that's one thing. But I don't know if either one of you is saying that. You both seem to be saying "We shouldn't have drafted THIS high school catcher", which is foolish because by all accounts, this was THE high school catcher to draft. That it didn't work out doesn't change that. That's why this argument lacks in perspective. You are using hindsight to judge a pick, which isn't fair. This wasn't considered a reach, and his bat was supposed to play, and EVERYONE agreed on that. You can't say "Well, since it hasn't worked out, it was the wrong pick", because so few first round picks do work out. No, I'm more of the opinion of not drafting high school catchers, hence the reason I mentioned Jason Castro who also went top 10 (also was considered a reach for what it's worth, but he was definitely the safer pick). You're right in saying that it's difficult to complain though, considering the majority of the Marlins top picks have been high school players over the years. Exactly the way I've been thinking. I'm not totally against the high school approach when drafting, but catcher is one of those positions where there is very little success rate in high school catchers making it to the majors. My point is the Marlins took a bigger risk than they needed to make with Brett Wallace and Justin Smoak right there for the taking as well. The Marlins went for need position over best player imo and it went against us. And the majority of the high school players the Marlins tend to draft are high school pitchers, and usually those pitchers are extremely projectable. Tall pitchers, clean mechanics and slated as a middle of the rotation guy as best in the majors. Although they aren't safe picks, they are about as safe of picks you are going to get when drafting high school players. A high school catcher like Skipworth is just so hard to project at the major league level that you need to make sure you are drafting the next Joe Mauer at that spot, otherwise you don't touch any high school catcher anywhere within the first couple rounds or at all. And yeah Erick, I think my mind may be a tiny bit skewed too after reading Moneyball. Just a lot of good points made within the book that changed my viewpoint towards generally wanting to take more proven players (college players), although even Beane has changed his approach in recent years and started to draft high school guys.
  16. JJ is facing some dude.
  17. But bob, you tend to over exaggerate certain posts and make them seem more panicky and insane than they really are with nearly every poster.
  18. Way to totally twist around my post and trying to make it look like I'm incompetent in what I say. I'm not denying that top picks don't pan out, but considering this scouting team has been praised as one of the best in the majors for years, and the fact they had everybody in the ENTIRE DRAFT to choose from save for 5 players, a better player should've been selected. Their job is to go out, find out every little detail about these players, and make sure they grab the right guy. I understand when you pick somewhere in the high 20's the guys you truly like will probably be gone, but when you pick #6 overall you can't just take a player who produces like Kyle Skipworth and say "Whoops, my bad. Everybody makes mistakes in the draft!" We should've drafted guys like Justin Smoak and Brett Wallace who had actually proven themselves IN COLLEGE and were much safer bets to not turn out as busts. I've always taken to the idea that high school talents should usually be prioritized ahead of college talents because of upside, but when you look at that draft there was a BIG drop off catcher wise between Buster Posey and the rest of the group. Kyle Skipworth was nowhere near the class Posey was in and everybody knew at the time and still knows now that those kind of players shouldn't be going back to back in the draft. You can try to cover for the mistakes of the scouting team and front office all you want, they f*cked up bad on picking Skipworth and there's no excuse for it, not even the "OH EVERYBODY MAKES MISTAKES IN THE DRAFT, MOST DON'T EVEN MAKE THE MAJORS!!!!" excuse.
  19. There really isn't much positive to take from this season for Skipworth, except for the fact that he isn't OPS'ing in the low .600's like he was his first two seasons. Sure the power is up, but he's striking out at a Mark Reynolds rate. The only way his amount of strikeouts is acceptable is if he is putting up Mike Stanton kind of power numbers. Obviously it's only his third season, but it would take a DRASTIC turnaround for him to not become a bust. I think he's got basically his entire body spare for a finger inside the "Bust" door. I'm more upset at the fact that we rarely draft that early and to completely whiff on him is unacceptable. The draft is a crap shoot, but when you have more sure prospects like Justin Smoak and Brett Wallace available at that spot, you don't draft a 17 year old catcher who has a propensity for strikeouts. It wasn't as much a knock on Skipworth as it was a knock on the Marlins scouting team and for screwing up a pick where obviously surer picks were available.
  20. Should be reminded that Andrew Miller was to pitching prospects in 2007 what Buster Posey is to hitting prospects today (both basically dominated college opposition). If you look at Maybin, in his minor league stats you aren't going to find a place he went where he didn't have an OBP at or above .375, and he used to have power where he was projected to have 25-30 home runs per season in the majors. If you look his power numbers have declined each year since the day the Tigers called him up to the majors (aka a product of the Tigers rushing him). Marlins just got caught in some terrible luck. Guys who just never lived up to the bill and were very poorly brought up by the Tigers and were given to us as basically damaged goods. There's still hope for Maybin no doubt, but he REALLY needs to stop striking out so much.
  21. twitter. google either JCRMarlinsbeat, Joe Frisaro, Clark Spencer, or Joe Capozzi and you should find a lineup before the game starts.
  22. Wasn't planning on making a game thread.
  23. Hammel vs Nolasco Prediction: Nolasco throws a perfect game. Lineup coghlan, lf; sanchez, 1b; ramirez, ss; uggla, 2b; cantu, 3b; ross, cf; stanton, rf; davis, c; nolasco, p. Coghlan back in the lineup today.
  24. No point in interviewing Fredi. He's already made his mark within the Braves organization and is just waiting for Cox to get out of the way to take his dream job.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.