Everything posted by EricWiener
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
So.....Jorge Cantu...... Is a pleasant suprise!
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
The stat with the strong correlation to runs scored is OPS, not OBP. OBP is almost as strong a correlation as OPS. The best correlation I've seen is a figure of OBP*1.5+SLG. It is almost as good a stat for ranking run production as... well... runs!
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
mmm sorry, I thought you'd have known about run values (I realize that might come off "offensively" but I don't mean it that way). Don't ever worry about that, I am fundamentally impossible to offend over the internet. It is an interesting read, though the first citation deals largely with pitchers, and the second make several assumptions that make the data suspect in a practical manner. In fact, they speak about the very flaw in their data excersize in excluding certain players from the analysis As for Run Values being used as a term, I've seen it refer to mean dozenss of things. The one with some traction in SABR circles is VORP + UZL, which doesn't have an particular impact from Ks. If the .01 runs per out holds up, I would like to see it controlled for OPS, because it is a rarity to have the high-production OPS on a player that doesn't strikeout at least near the league average rate (the 2 that come to mind are Chipper and Pujols - hall of famers as far as I am concerned) and I am not quick to disgregard that trend.
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
I just showed how there is a negative effect...I don't even know what to respond with after showing that and yet you continue to ignore it. You didn't show anything, you claimed that an average number of strikeouts costs a team runs. To support that claim, you offer.... nothing.
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
I'm undecided at the moment but something sounds off to me regarding the argument "there is no correlation between runs scored and strikeouts, so strikeouts are inconsequential." While I agree that studies have found no such correlation, I'm having my doubts that it is a definitive response to the problem. Basically I'm saying even if there is a worthy reason, I'm having trouble finding one. Of course, as we know there is such a correlation between runs scored and OBP. Many OBP leaders strikeout a lot. If one were to dial down all the way, and find two otherwise nearly identical line drive hitters, then maybe, just maybe, I may want the guy that strikes out less because he has a .37% greater chance to reach on an error. Except that he is probably more than .37% more likely to ground into a double play, and there are 30%+ more DPs than errors.
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
Except the part where you completely ignored my saying UNLESS you hit into a double play. If it is an out one way or another, then unless there is a DP striking out is worse. Not by a lot, but slightly. Obviously with no-one on it doesn't matter. However with two outs putting the ball in play is FAR superior because you give yourself a chance to reach base. Where as on a strikeout you don't. I didn't ignore it, I disregarded it as spurious. Except for death, people live forever. Double plays are more common than errors... by a lot. Putting the ball in play with 2-outs is not "FAR superior" when you compare 'in play outs/errors' to strikeouts, at best it is marginally better and that advantage is easily devoured by GDP numbers with < 2 outs.
-
Chris Volstad
Volstad will not be called up until after that will accellerate his arbitration
-
Scott Olsen
I wouldn't mess with it at all.
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
Experiments need control and everthing you're posting has no control. Scientific method goes far beyond just science class. I am no equipped to perform a population study on run production while at work, but such studies have been performed, and strikeouts have not been found to have a correlation one way or the other. The examples I point out are merely reasons why I think that there is no correlation.
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
The only hole in your theory is that, especially with 2 outs or nobody on, striking out gives the batter zero chance to get on base, whereas, any other situation runs the chance of producing a base runner. So lining out, flying out, grounding out all give the chance of prolonging an inning, striking out does not. So it's anything but "the same" It is exactly the same as any other out. At most, your premise is that there is a chance that a ball in play, that is not a hit, has a chace to be an error.
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
Overstated? Yes. Still a negative effect? Yes. Except that it is not a negative effect. There is no correlation. If there was a negative effect, there would be a correlation. Teams with similar OPS totals do no show a run production difference due to strikeouts. Therefore, strikeouts do not impact runs except on individual plays, and there are just as many plays where a strikeout makes no difference or is even preferable to putting a ball into play in a certain manner. Nobody on: the same 2-outs: the same man on first: potentially less harmful, mostly the same. man on second < 2 outs: sometimes worse, mostly the same. man on third < 2 outs: sometimes worse, mostly the same. Players are far more likely to be on first than on 2nd or 3rd... it is enough of a wash to not matter.
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
The only way striking out can be better than not striking out, is if not striking out means hitting into a double play. In a hypothetical situation. Nice... completely pointless, but nice. Here's a hypothetical Player on 2nd, one out. Strikout, next player gets a shot. Hot smash caught by the shortstop, toss to 2nd baseman... double play. Hey, my hypothetica is just as pointless as yours. A strikeout is the same as any other out with nobody on, and with 2 outs. A strikeout is better than a ground out with a man on first. So for upwards of 70% of PAs, a SO is better or at least not worse than any other out.
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
There's no contradiction. There's a difference betweens teams runs scored and the run value of a play. Then it is a distinction without merit. Runs scored is the metric to look at. Dialing it down to an individual play is worthless, because there are tens of thousands of plays per year.
-
John Adams
I'll admit, since those dinosaur years, Showtime & Cinemax & other channels have eclipsed them somewhat, but they're still the origin. And I think they've made significant contributions with their mini-series, both John Adams & the ones before it. Now, Showtime is getting into the act with, "The Tudors". I also find that extremely interesting. The Tudors is just a recycled BBC series. HBO is still king, though I do enjoy Dexter.
-
Post Road Trip thread
Miller is starting to look like the pitcher we want. He is not going to get past 6 IP while he is this wild and we are determined to keep him at 100 pitches. Our RISP problem is still an open question. 25 games does not generate enough PAs to look at. Even still, the team is drawing walks with RISP, so I'd have to expect that the hits will come.
-
So...Jorge Cantu.......
Actually striking out has a lower run value than not striking out. Overstated but still negative. Although if you meant a correlation with runs scored (for instance, a high strikeout team will score less than a low strikeout team), then yeah, there is no correlation, there's more important things than (not) striking out. But when it comes to run value, it's still a negative. You just contradicted yourself. If there is no correlation between strikeouts and run scoring, then there is no correlation between strikeouts and run scoring.
-
4/26 Marlins @ Brewers - 7:05 PM
We're not good coming back like this. A HR is our only prayer. This team doesn't hit with .RISP. Yeah, I know that you didn't see the game last night. Hey, it wasn't on TV
-
4/26 Marlins @ Brewers - 7:05 PM
Damn sucks that we lost this game. WTF? It is only 1 run
-
4/26 Marlins @ Brewers - 7:05 PM
What just happened?
-
4/26 Marlins @ Brewers - 7:05 PM
Hendrickson looking solid. Yeah he escaped the trouble and has settled down nicely.
-
4/26 Marlins @ Brewers - 7:05 PM
OK, it appears that we are escaping true disaster. Hendrickson is entirely without control and the Brewers aren't able to put up a big inning.
-
4/26 Marlins @ Brewers - 7:05 PM
Big inning time, none of the sacrifice crap... 3 more hits! Sac would have been nice. It would have been acceptable, as opposed to the nada we just saw.
-
4/26 Marlins @ Brewers - 7:05 PM
Big inning time, none of the sacrifice crap... 3 more hits! Edit: Yo Jeremy I said hit.
-
4/26 Marlins @ Brewers - 7:05 PM
Hanley's just gonna have to hit another one to make amends.
-
4/26 Marlins @ Brewers - 7:05 PM
He's now officially wild!