DT, you have to see both sides of the story. Here is an objective article from the South Florida Business Journal.
EXCLUSIVE REPORTS
South Florida braces for new overtime law
John T. Fakler
They say bad things come in threes.
As if the economy and new smoking ban weren't enough for area restaurants and bars to handle, a new wage and overtime law is slated to begin July 1.
More than 1.3 million Americans will become eligible for overtime pay under new U.S. Labor Department rules on what types of jobs are eligible for overtime - the first major revision since 1975. The proposed changes would affect 6.5 million businesses and cost up to $1.57 billion nationally.
In South Florida, the most prominent changes will be at service-based businesses that pay "manager"-level workers less than the new $22,100 annual base salary for professionals. An employee paid less than that is likely eligible for overtime.
Pay boosts are in the offing, and may be unavoidable in the face of mounting class action legislation, legal sources say.
"It's going to have a huge impact on the service industry," said Joe Santoro, an employment attorney with Gunster Yoakley & Stewart in West Palm Beach.
So long, $13,000 manager
"Raising salaries from $13,000 a year to $22,000 will affect many employers in South Florida because they employ many lower level managers at considerably less than the minimum," Santoro said.
Many middle and low management positions pay far below the $22,100 standard, especially in the hospitality and tourism sectors, he said. Employers must increase salaries to meet that minimum or pay them overtime.
"It will create a class no longer eligible for overtime," he said. "You see these positions in the hospitality industry the most, with lower level managers paid $18,000 a year working 60 hours a week. If you have 20 or 30 workers, that's a big hit."
April Boyer, an employment attorney with Kirkpatrick & Lockhart in Miami, sees a significant impact on the service and hospitality industry because the salary cap is being increased. That may make low-paid employees that currently are exempt not entitled to overtime, "resulting in increased costs for employers."
Many area business owners are unaware of how the guidelines will impact them - whether negatively, or positively in some cases, legal sources say.
One positive for owners is that the new law also expands the number of positions that can be considered exempt from overtime pay. The exemption expansion was designed by the Labor Department as a relief of sorts.
"What they are trying to do is a trade-off, by simplifying the duties test to apply to a broader base of employee, making it easier to apply the exemption," Santoro said.
"These are some significant changes," Santoro said.
A comments period held by the Labor Department ends June 30. While the law could take effect as early as July 1, he expects tweaking to the exemption language will likely delay enactment until the end of the year.
"No one knows how this will play out," he said.
Class-action suits
The resulting ambiguity over which employees are exempt from overtime requirements and which are not has led to a pile of class-action lawsuits, Santoro said.
South Florida leads the nation in wage and hour suits, he said, because of the high number of service jobs in the region. He put the number of cases generated in the region at a staggering 25 percent of all cases nationwide.
"These law suits are not over a lot of money, sometimes nominal amounts, and recover attorney fees if successful," Santoro said "You may wind up in litigation over a few thousand [dollars] worth of overtime. That's scary [for businesses]."
The litigation costs far exceed the monetary claim in an overtime suit, except in a class action, Boyer said.
"There is significant time and resources to defending the litigation as opposed to operating a business," she said. "I advise my mid-sized clients without in-house lawyers to consider an overtime audit so that employees are properly classified."
Santoro said the new rules apply to every business regardless of size, as long as they "have an impact in interstate commerce."
That is virtually all businesses, including mom-and-pops that might face a federal lawsuit, Santoro said.
Still, he doesn't expect early compliance. "Employers will just wait and see," he said.
Santoro expects the reaction will run the gamut - from the creation of new positions to a shifting of job responsibilities.
"There are a lot of ways companies can react," he said. "If you can't afford to pay an assistant manager, you may decide you can do without an assistant manager. More likely we'll see some shifting."
Mid-level employees may also become expendable, he added, though widespread job cuts are unlikely.
Labor and employment lawyer Joe Z. Fleming of Greenberg Traurig in Miami said the new rule will be positive for employers "because it's a great deal of certainty."
But, "if you make a mistake, you are in a lot of trouble," he said.
While higher salaries will affect employers' bottom lines in a negative way, the rule doesn't increase the minimum wage, so it's not necessarily inflationary, he said. "You can bring in another shift, or part-timers."
What makes the overtime rule tricky for employers, "is they don't understand the laws, they think they are exempt and they wind up in court."
To avoid court, Fleming suggested companies audit themselves and educate themselves about changes in the law through Web sites such as the Labor Department's.
Under the current rules, someone who earns as little as $155 a week can be classified as white collar and be exempt from overtime. The Labor Department would raise that minimum to $425 a week. That is the largest increase in the minimum since the law was signed in 1934.
The proposal would further define executive, administrative and professional duties, and would eliminate a rule that restricted exempt employees from devoting more than 20 percent of their time each week performing non-exempt duties.
Instead, the rules would rely on the employee's primary duties.
One economic analysis by the Labor Department in March found that the proposed changes would increase direct payroll costs $334 million to $895 million nationwide. Another department model puts the change in cost from $870 million to more than $1.57 billion in additional compensation. Implementation costs alone are estimated at $680 million, the agency said.
The rules are supposed to provide clarity and reduce overtime pay litigation. But, ironically, defense attorney Santoro said it would likely spark legal battles.
Court opinions have generally favored workers, he said. "Courts look to make sure that employees get paid by whatever mechanisms are there."
E-mail Senior Writer John T. Fakler at jfakler@bizjournals.com.
? 2003 American City Business Journals Inc.
I see both sides Cape.
Problem is this law means... lots of low-income workers (5.15, 6, 7, 8 dollars an hour) who depend on overtime for an extra amount of income is being taken away from them.
Businesses are using this as another excuse to screw the mid/poor class for more profits.