Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins looking at Todd Pratt?

Featured Replies

Or an outfielder who was injured and due a $2M raise.

Or a catcher who had a tendency to wear down late in the season.

Or a reliever who had been overused two of the past years.

Or many a slap-hitters being paid over $4M.

 

There's very few things that have soured me on the Loria ownership, but Loria/Beinfest evaluation talent is ridiculous. They're dedicated individuals and all. However I wouldn't exactly scrap the scouting department quite yet.

 

I know many here would like to commend Beinfest for his efforts in building a competitive club despite the small payroll, or for the simple fact that he's a Marlin, but we've got the worst GM when it comes to showing personnel respect (as in actually calling current players/coaches/scouts and letting them know if they intend to re-sign them or not). Many pro ballplayers are pampered. They have been since they were the star player on their elemetary school squad. You can't expect to re-sign a player, or any friend of that player or any player under that agent or friend of that agent, if you're not going to contact them in over 2 months.

And his strategy of playing towards our existing strengths at the expense of our weaknesses has not helped the club.

Or an outfielder who was injured and due a $2M raise.

Or a catcher who had a tendency to wear down late in the season.

Or a reliever who had been overused two of the past years.

Or many a slap-hitters being paid over $4M.

 

There's very few things that have soured me on the Loria ownership, but Loria/Beinfest evaluation talent is ridiculous. They're dedicated individuals and all. However I wouldn't exactly scrap the scouting department quite yet.

 

I know many here would like to commend Beinfest for his efforts in building a competitive club despite the small payroll, or for the simple fact that he's a Marlin, but we've got the worst GM when it comes to showing personnel respect (as in actually calling current players/coaches/scouts and letting them know if they intend to re-sign them or not). Many pro ballplayers are pampered. They have been since they were the star player on their elemetary school squad. You can't expect to re-sign a player, or any friend of that player or any player under that agent or friend of that agent, if you're not going to contact them in over 2 months.

And his strategy of playing towards our existing strengths at the expense of our weaknesses has not helped the club.

627813[/snapback]

 

 

All of which is your opinion, which you're entitled to, but certainly not facts, or at least anything that comes to be the whole truth.

No Prat

 

PHILADELPHIA -- Backup catcher Todd Pratt is returning to the Philadelphia Phillies, agreeing Monday to a $750,000, one-year contract.

 

Pratt hit .258 with three home runs and 16 RBIss in 45 games with the Phillies last season and didn't make an error in 267 chances. With Pratt catching, Philadelphia's pitchers had a 3.95 ERA.

 

Pratt, 37, has a .255 average with 38 homers and 182 RBIss in 12 seasons with the Phillies (1992-94, 2001-04), Chicago Cubs (1995) and New York Mets (1997-2001).

Give the job to Treanor !!

628404[/snapback]

 

I have no problem with Treanor earning the job but one has to believe if the Marlins were interested in Pratt they are going to continue to look for a more experienced backup elsewhere.

I have no problem with Treanor earning the job but one has to believe if the Marlins were interested in Pratt they are going to continue to look for a more experienced backup elsewhere.

628406[/snapback]

 

Yeah, you're probably right. I hope Treanor impresses in Spring Training though. He can be a cheap option as a backup catcher and I think he can handle the job too.

The only other name that really comes to mind that would be an asset to the team is Todd Greene of the Rockies but they really want him back and will assuredly offer him arbitration, which doesn't mean we shouldn't try to sign him. Since we already have the Redmond draft choice from the Twins we could afford to give ours to the Rockies if we could make a deal.

 

It's an outside possibility at best but IMO, worth considering.

Treanor is serviceable at the backup spot

 

i see no reason to have any remorse for not landing todd pratt

I have been and will continue to be a supporter of Matt Treanor. His is one of those great stories you tell your kid about how hard work and never giving up pays off so if I say the jury is still out whether Treanor can make it as a backup catcher in the bigs it is not because I don't like the guy personally or professionally.

 

He made it to the bigs and that in itself says something.

 

But I do think the Marlins may be able to do better, or at least provide some competition this spring, and to not do so could prove to be a mistake. Treanor's numbers, even his biggest fans would have to admit, have been less than great. And we really haven't seen enough of him to form an edecated opinion of what kind of contribution he's capable of making.

 

I am "remorseful" we didn't sign Todd Pratt. I'm not about to go jump off a bridge (much to the disappointment of some here) but I'm in the camp that thinks veteran's like him can be a important asset to our team. The very fact that the Marlins FO was interested in him says to me they aren't sold on Treanor just yet and regardless of what we think, they will continue to look elsewhere.

 

So don't be surprised if you hear other names popup in trade or free agent discussions, I think it's inevitable.

Point well taken.

 

What other free agent backup catchers are in the free agent market right now? I saw Gregg Zaun's name somewhere, which I think would be great. I was always a big Zaun fan... But who else?

 

And do you think the Marlins are in need of a backup catcher so much that they would try to trade for one?

Brook Fordyce, Henry Blanco and Kelly Stinnett are all decent back-ups...

628574[/snapback]

 

Stinnett may never play again after surgery but if his elbow is recovered someone will definitely sign him. The other two guys have already prven they can't hit a lick. While you get more experience behind the plate you're not getting an upgrade offensively from Fordyce or Blanco.

most backup catchers can't hit a lick anyway. as long as they can call a decent game their main purpose is just keeping Lo Duca fresh.

 

If we're talking about Greene, maybe it's worth the bother, but otherwise....

 

having a Greg Zaun-type over Treanor is pretty much pointless.

Which is quite silly IMO. A backup catcher usually spends as much time pinch-hitting than he does behind the plate.

 

Unless your starting catcher is truly terrible defensively that you intend to spell him after the 6th inning, or have pitchers that refuse to pitch with him, there's no point in even considering the backups' defensive skills.

Obviously I was overstating there. You can't show up in ST and just designate Lenny Harris or Mike Mordecai your back-up catcher. A Jason Phillips or mid-Brewer tenure Brian Banks would be fine.

 

Mike Redmond is one of my favorite players, but it is my opinion that if he couldn't hit as well he does he'd be in the same spot as Treanor. Just another AAA back-up with no shot at a long MLB career.

Again,

 

Catching ain't broken, don't fix it.

Pitching is broken, fix it.

 

Get real. Stay focused.

Assuming Lo Duca can catch most of the games(i.e. barring injury) then we don't need the focus we've given to backup catching when our bigger problems still loom large, namely Pavano, bullpen & big bat.

Obviously I was overstating there. You can't show up in ST and just designate Lenny Harris or Mike Mordecai your back-up catcher. A Jason Phillips or mid-Brewer tenure Brian Banks would be fine.

 

Mike Redmond is one of my favorite players, but it is my opinion that if he couldn't hit as well he does he'd be in the same spot as Treanor. Just another AAA back-up with no shot at a long MLB career.

628865[/snapback]

 

 

 

lol

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.