March 1, 200521 yr Author Listen Randy Johnson was 16-14 with a 2.6 ERA now if he was 18-10 or 19-10 you win the Cy Young and the only reason you lose the Cy is because your team has a bad offense
March 1, 200521 yr I don't think Wins is stupid. If you win 20 games, I don't care how great your offense was, you did your job. If you went 10-18, and you had a 1.50 ERA, you are a fine pitcher, but you're pretty damn irrelevant. As has been said, though, you got to take it in context with everything else. Wins aren't the whole story, but I think its even dumber if you pay no attention to wins at all.
March 1, 200521 yr no starter with an ERA under 2 is going to have a 10-18 record though. perspective.
March 1, 200521 yr quick quiz... who's the better pitcher / guy you'd rather have on your team: ismael valdez (14-9, 5.19 ERA, 1.48 WHIP, 3.55 K/9) or ben sheets (12-14, 2.70 ERA, 0.98 WHIP, 10.03 K/9)
March 1, 200521 yr Thanks for explaining your position and pointing out why it's still not a accurate measurement. As for one pitcher who was able to escape the stigma of a poor o rather average record, Nolan Ryan is a fine example. 698861[/snapback] Nolan Ryan is probably the most overrated pitcher of all time. He was nothing more than a slightly above average pitcher who just stuck around for a really long time.
March 1, 200521 yr quick quiz... who's the better pitcher / guy you'd rather have on your team: ismael valdez (14-9, 5.19 ERA, 1.48 WHIP, 3.55 K/9) or ben sheets (12-14, 2.70 ERA, 0.98 WHIP, 10.03 K/9) 699144[/snapback] Wins evaluate how good a year the pitcher had. The other stats show who's the better pitcher. Since Valdez had a better record, that means he performed better last year, but since Sheets had better secondary stats, he's more likely to have a better this year and I would rather have him on my team.
March 1, 200521 yr no starter with an ERA under 2 is going to have a 10-18 record though. perspective. 699128[/snapback] Fine. More to the point, then...Randy Johnson was irrelevant last year. If you throw a great game in the forest, and no was there to see it, did it really happen??? :mischief2
March 1, 200521 yr Author Thanks for explaining your position and pointing out why it's still not a accurate measurement. As for one pitcher who was able to escape the stigma of a poor o rather average record, Nolan Ryan is a fine example. 698861[/snapback] Nolan Ryan is probably the most overrated pitcher of all time. He was nothing more than a slightly above average pitcher who just stuck around for a really long time. 699159[/snapback] How the Hell is the alltime Ks leader teh most overrated pitcher ever and if one .pitcher had a 8ERA with 10 wins and another guy had a 2.5 era with 6 wins and 10 losses how did the pitcher with the 8 ERA have a better year
March 2, 200521 yr quick quiz... who's the better pitcher / guy you'd rather have on your team: ismael valdez (14-9, 5.19 ERA, 1.48 WHIP, 3.55 K/9) or ben sheets (12-14, 2.70 ERA, 0.98 WHIP, 10.03 K/9) 699144[/snapback] Wins evaluate how good a year the pitcher had. The other stats show who's the better pitcher. Since Valdez had a better record, that means he performed better last year, but since Sheets had better secondary stats, he's more likely to have a better this year and I would rather have him on my team. 699173[/snapback] How can you say Valez had a better year. Ben Sheets had an outstanding season last year, better than most NL pitchers. There are certain situations where you can't judge a guy be his wins if he has an amazing offense or no offense.
March 2, 200521 yr a pitcher should not be judged by wins because winning depends on too many things that are completely beyond the pitcher's control. it might be revealing to compare a pitcher's winning percentage to his team's overall winning percentage, but ultimately ERA is a much better indicator of what a pitcher contributes. contrary to what other people on this thread have said, a pitcher isn't there to win, he's there to pitch, and ERA is the best measurement of how he pitches. if his team can't hit or can't hold a lead, that's not his fault. of course no measurement is perfect - different park sizes, rangier defenses etc. affect ERA as well. but there is obviously much more non-pitcher influence on wins than ERA. i also think strikeouts are an overrated stat. sure they're more impressive than groundouts, and they are marginally more effective than groundouts because there's no chance for an error, but i think the amount of outs a pitcher records is more important than the method of getting them.
March 2, 200521 yr I think you can argue that just about any stat in baseball is stupid...but that's why there are so many of them. You cant judge a player or a team by any one single statistic...but you can use several stats together to get an idea of how good a player or team is. Im a big statistics person..I like to compare players and teams stats alot during the season...I spend alot of time doing it too...but I would never decide a pitcher or a hitter was better than another just because of one statistic...you cant do that. The only way you can really know how good someone is..would be to watch them play consistently...but stats HELP you judge teams and players that you dont get a chance to watch. I wouldnt need stats at all to tell how good the players on the Marlins are...cause I listen to or watch almost every game...so I know who performs well and who is clutch...and who is strong defensively. But I could tell you very little about how good player on the Padres were...I need those stats to help me get an idea about what my team is up against. :confused
March 2, 200521 yr Author Good Point :thumbup :notworthy but this is about W's being a bad stat which they are because they give you absolutely no insight into how well the pitcher performed
March 2, 200521 yr Look, wins don't tell the whole story. But, in essence, isn't the point of playing the game to win? (Hermand Edwards agrees with me here) Getting 20 wins isn't going to say you're an elite pitcher, because Russ Ortiz had 21 wins in 2003, and Russ Ortiz isn't an elite pitcher. However, Alky, who had the better year in 2003? Russ Ortiz (21-7, 3.81, 149 K, 102 BB) or Josh Beckett (9-8, 3.04, 152 K, 56 BB)? Only one of these two pitchers was a finalist for Cy Young's award.
March 2, 200521 yr But, in essence, isn't the point of playing the game to win? (Hermand Edwards agrees with me here) 700216[/snapback] You play to win the game.
March 2, 200521 yr But, in essence, isn't the point of playing the game to win? (Hermand Edwards agrees with me here) 700216[/snapback] You play to win the game. 700218[/snapback] That's my new sig
March 2, 200521 yr But, in essence, isn't the point of playing the game to win? (Hermand Edwards agrees with me here) 700216[/snapback] You play to win the game. 700218[/snapback] That's my new sig 700221[/snapback] Yeah it is pretty sweet.
March 2, 200521 yr Thanks for explaining your position and pointing out why it's still not a accurate measurement. As for one pitcher who was able to escape the stigma of a poor o rather average record, Nolan Ryan is a fine example. 698861[/snapback] Nolan Ryan is probably the most overrated pitcher of all time. He was nothing more than a slightly above average pitcher who just stuck around for a really long time. 699159[/snapback] Yeah you're right... Seven no-hitters and the all-time strike out record that's more than 1500 more than second place is just a product of longevity. :confused
March 2, 200521 yr no starter with an ERA under 2 is going to have a 10-18 record though. perspective. 699128[/snapback] Fine. More to the point, then...Randy Johnson was irrelevant last year. If you throw a great game in the forest, and no was there to see it, did it really happen??? :mischief2 699212[/snapback] :blink:
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.