August 8, 200521 yr no, because you worded the question alot better and DTrain shouldnt really be on the list right now anyway
August 8, 200521 yr Oswalt should be there. I'm going Clemens all the way with this one. (I am surprised Das Fascist didn't shut this thread down just on principle :mischief )
August 8, 200521 yr No dought so far Clemens is the Cy Young.... The guy is shutting down the whole League.... His ERA is in the low 1's and the reason why he doesn't have more wins is because they weren't scoring any runs for him..
August 8, 200521 yr Yeah, the only reason Clemens may not win the CY is because of his record. He had absolutely no run support in the 1st half. Otherwise he probably wouldn't have a single loss.
August 8, 200521 yr they all deserve it. I'm rooting for D-Train, but it'll probably be Carpenter or Clemens.
August 8, 200521 yr Clemens also lacks the strikeouts of Carpenter and Martinez I find it laughable that people have Willis up there with those guys...it's those those three, then there's everyone else....Willis isn't even in the top 10 right now
August 8, 200521 yr Clemens also lacks the strikeouts of Carpenter and Martinez I find it laughable that people have Willis up there with those guys...it's those those three, then there's everyone else....Willis isn't even in the top 10 right now 893604[/snapback] come on willis is still in the top ten but clemens will get his 8th this year if the astros would score he could have 5-7 more wins already
August 8, 200521 yr First off, Mays24Bonds25 should not being laughing at anything poll related. I remember some of your previous polls with people that you've put on there, so please stfu about what this dude put on his. You, of all people, have no right to do that. Anyway, this poll should be who is going to come in 2nd to Clemens. You can use strikeouts, IP or whatever but its all moot. Clemens is on his way to having the lowest ERA since 1968 for the love of god. You're kidding yourself if you don't think he wins it, or deserves it.
August 8, 200521 yr I really don't know what the arguements are for anyone other than Carpenter or Clemens. I picked Carpenter, but they're neck-and-neck right now, and my hunch is that Clemens will end up winning.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.