Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Goldberg said something interesting...

Featured Replies

Not only that but the interference from fans moving around would still be terrible. Have you ever watched a game from the terrace box seats, or from a similar position in the upper deck? Anytime somebody gets up in any of the rows from your seat to home plate your view is blocked because of the oblique angle. It's frustrating as hell.

 

Dolphin Stadium is a terrible baseball venue...one of the worst in MLB.

Couldn't this sight line problem be easily fixed if you put in a new seat with 2 positions. One position as is for football. One ratchet over and they could face home plate in the baseball configuration.

LOL, that has always been what I thought too. It seems so obvious !!! :thumbup

The cost to build an automated design would be very high. Whether manual or automatic, its maintenance incredibly expensive and difficult to keep up (like finding a broken bulb in a string of christmas lights). To rotate just one section of the RFK's lower bowl cost over $50,000 each time. You guys are talking a couple thousand individual seats. Good sightlines are one thing, but the cost would probably not be worth it.

Do the Dolphins really need a roof? I always thought the South Florida heat was a big advantage for them in home games.

I've said it before, but I'd rather go through the whole process, including the prospect of the Marlins leaving town (there are decent markets out there capable of building a quality facility for a reasonable amount), than lock myself of 20-30 years under Huizenga's terms at some site surrounded by parking lots and highways. Even a South Florida fan who wants to see more than one .500 season every 6 years or fully enjoy what Florida Marlins baseball can be would agree. It's a gamble, but in life you have to take gambles to get what you want. The passive and scared become destitute.

I think we probably all agree that being under Huizenga's terms (as they are currently or anything similar) is completely unacceptable. However, as far as the team leaving town, I don't get what you mean by "what Florida Marlins baseball can be". If they leave they're not the Florida Marlins anymore so what are we rooting for, the owner?

It's impossible for me to disguise my disgust for PPS.

 

It is one of the most god-awful, unfriendly stadiums I have ever been in from the moment you enter until you leave in fifty years of attending ballgames up and down the eastern half of this country. Maybe only Veterans Stadium was worse.

 

But at the same time, the loss of the Florida Marlins here in South Florida would be life-altering and profoundly depressing. So I'm conflicted.

 

In my mind, the only way for PPS to become a true dual-use stadium is to level the playing field, and the only way to accomplish that is for the county to own the facility and enter into two unique but equitable leases with the two tenants. That of course makes little sense for the existing owner.

 

One of the problems for the Marlins is that PPS is just too damn big for the Marlins' purposes. One needs to understand that one thing a 38,000 stadium does for the team is create a "demand" for seats.

 

Certainly fans in Boston have proven through the decades how rabid they are about "their" Red Sox. Fans regularly pay exorbitant prices to gleen a ticket or two a few times a year, so scarce are those ducats. But the reason they are scarce is not because there are so many fans (although there are, in no way am I taking anything away from Sox fans throughout New England) but rather because there are so few available seats. After corporate season ticketholders are done gobbling up their annual quota, the number of "retail" seats is negligible. With only 35,000+/- seats it's pretty easy to see why virtually every game is sold out.

 

The Marlins are marching to the same game plan. By physically limiting attendance to 38,000 in a smallish ballpark the effect is to drive up demand. "Buy season tickets or else you run the risk of not gaining access when the playoffs or god be willing, the World Series rolls around" will be the marketing mantra.

 

As long as the Marlins have access to 65,000 seats it is impossible to create a "demand" for tickets. As long as you're pretty much guaranteed a seat for the important events there is no reason to purchase season tickets as "insurance". You can cover all the seats you want with blue tarps in the outfield or most of the upperdeck but people know in their hearts what's underneath. Any business major will tell you supply (in this case the lack thereof) creates demand.

 

Then there's the issue of concessions, advertising, skyboxes and clubseats, parking and the rest. In order for things to work for the Fish what has to happen is to allow the organization complete control, and revenue derived from selling skyboxes and clubseats (that $$$ currently pledged in part to bond payments on the stadium) with no prohibition on whom they enter into contractural arrangements with (under the existing lease the Marlins cannot solicit many of the largest corporations in South Florida, they are held out as being the sole province of Huizenga Holdings).

 

The same goes for advertising. Until the day arrives where at end of football season every ad placard sold by HH is taken down and the Marlins allowed to resell that space, they aren't going to make any $$$, and let's face it that's whats needed to run a successful baseball operation in the 21st century.

 

Ditto concessions, parking and the rest. What the Marlins need is to be able to cut their own deal with their concessioneer(s) of choice, not those hand-picked by their landlord and obliged to the latter without a second thought to the former.

 

In sum, that's why PPS doesn't work for the Marlins. Too many seats, too little control over operations. Existing on scraps left on the table by the landlord.

 

You can out lipstick on a pig but it's still a pig. You can put a roof on PPS but unless the rest of the economic components change, it's still a problem not a solution for the Marlins.

 

Now if the county were to buy out PPS and the surrounding land perhaps some of these issues could be addressed but I fear the biggest issue will remain unresolved, what to do with 30,000 or so unneeded seats. I suppose there there may be an answer to that but I haven't been able to figure one out.

 

Some will say "well all they need is a roof and a new lease and maybe some amenties to make the fans feel more at home" but there is so much more (as I've tried to lay out above) to successfully marketing a major league franchise.

 

Then there's the problem with location. I know it will upset my friends in Broward and Palm Beach to know that every marketing survey the Marlins have conducted points to the same conclusion, moving their location closer to the center of Miami-Dade county will translate into an increase in gross tickets sales, not a net loss. Some here forget how many people live south and west of the city of Miami and the densities of that part of the county. That's why the Orange Bowl site, warts and all, made such economic sense for the team.

 

I could go on and on. No doubt some, perhaps many will disagree. But those of you who are in business or those of you studying business development will understand of which I speak. For the Marlins its all or nothing.

 

I don't like it but I understand it.

  • Author

who listens to goldberg these days?

 

 

some who is still half a sleep and on their way to class.

Do the Dolphins really need a roof? I always thought the South Florida heat was a big advantage for them in home games.

What does that have to do with them making money? Winning is a nice incentive, but they've established their fan base and are in the business of sucking every last dollar out of them and anyone else who enters the stadium (as a fan or business partner). Throw a roof on JRS/PPS/DS, the Orange Bowl or *fingers crossed* a new baseball stadium */fingers crossed* and you've won the rights to a number of concerts, conventions and other events (i.e., Super Bowl) at a higher price than ever received before. Why? Because with a roof, fewer people will stay home. That's not to say he needs it. He's making money. He's quite well off. The Super Bowl will keep coming. The Orange Bowl will keep coming. Larger events will keep coming. Until there is another comparable facility (the Orange Bowl committee has already rejected moving the bowl game back to any of the proposed new Orange Bowl). I don't see Huizenga giving up anything right now.

 

 

I've said it before, but I'd rather go through the whole process, including the prospect of the Marlins leaving town (there are decent markets out there capable of building a quality facility for a reasonable amount), than lock myself of 20-30 years under Huizenga's terms at some site surrounded by parking lots and highways. Even a South Florida fan who wants to see more than one .500 season every 6 years or fully enjoy what Florida Marlins baseball can be would agree. It's a gamble, but in life you have to take gambles to get what you want. The passive and scared become destitute.

I think we probably all agree that being under Huizenga's terms (as they are currently or anything similar) is completely unacceptable. However, as far as the team leaving town, I don't get what you mean by "what Florida Marlins baseball can be". If they leave they're not the Florida Marlins anymore so what are we rooting for, the owner?Well, continuing from my thought above. Huizenga's not about to relax lease terms in exchange for little substace to him and certainly not to partners he'd probably view as weak and lacking in options.

What I mean by what the Florida Marlins can be is exactly that. Something more than a low-revenue team going through a lineup of owners striking out with the fan base and local politicians and finishing .500 every few years.

We don't know really if the team will have to leave town yet. I hope they don't, but for the sake of the Marlins and their fans in South Florida and elsewhere, I hope they find some help somewhere. Because MLB's not going to give South Florida a free pass when it comes to the stadium game, and it seems like some local politicians think they hold all the cards right now. Unfortunetly we don't own stock in the Marlins, or MLB, and we are powerless to stop them should an owner wants to move a team, sell the team or not, and to whom.

It's impossible for me to disguise my disgust for PPS.

 

It is one of the most god-awful, unfriendly stadiums I have ever been in from the moment you enter until you leave in fifty years of attending ballgames up and down the eastern half of this country. Maybe only Veterans Stadium was worse.

 

But at the same time, the loss of the Florida Marlins here in South Florida would be life-altering and profoundly depressing. So I'm conflicted.

 

In my mind, the only way for PPS to become a true dual-use stadium is to level the playing field, and the only way to accomplish that is for the county to own the facility and enter into two unique but equitable leases with the two tenants. That of course makes little sense for the existing owner.

 

One of the problems for the Marlins is that PPS is just too damn big for the Marlins' purposes. One needs to understand that one thing a 38,000 stadium does for the team is create a "demand" for seats.

 

Certainly fans in Boston have proven through the decades how rabid they are about "their" Red Sox. Fans regularly pay exorbitant prices to gleen a ticket or two a few times a year, so scarce are those ducats. But the reason they are scarce is not because there are so many fans (although there are, in no way am I taking anything away from Sox fans throughout New England) but rather because there are so few available seats. After corporate season ticketholders are done gobbling up their annual quota, the number of "retail" seats is negligible. With only 35,000+/- seats it's pretty easy to see why virtually every game is sold out.

 

The Marlins are marching to the same game plan. By physically limiting attendance to 38,000 in a smallish ballpark the effect is to drive up demand. "Buy season tickets or else you run the risk of not gaining access when the playoffs or god be willing, the World Series rolls around" will be the marketing mantra.

 

As long as the Marlins have access to 65,000 seats it is impossible to create a "demand" for tickets. As long as you're pretty much guaranteed a seat for the important events there is no reason to purchase season tickets as "insurance". You can cover all the seats you want with blue tarps in the outfield or most of the upperdeck but people know in their hearts what's underneath. Any business major will tell you supply (in this case the lack thereof) creates demand.

 

Then there's the issue of concessions, advertising, skyboxes and clubseats, parking and the rest. In order for things to work for the Fish what has to happen is to allow the organization complete control, and revenue derived from selling skyboxes and clubseats (that $$$ currently pledged in part to bond payments on the stadium) with no prohibition on whom they enter into contractural arrangements with (under the existing lease the Marlins cannot solicit many of the largest corporations in South Florida, they are held out as being the sole province of Huizenga Holdings).

 

The same goes for advertising. Until the day arrives where at end of football season every ad placard sold by HH is taken down and the Marlins allowed to resell that space, they aren't going to make any $$$, and let's face it that's whats needed to run a successful baseball operation in the 21st century.

 

Ditto concessions, parking and the rest. What the Marlins need is to be able to cut their own deal with their concessioneer(s) of choice, not those hand-picked by their landlord and obliged to the latter without a second thought to the former.

 

In sum, that's why PPS doesn't work for the Marlins. Too many seats, too little control over operations. Existing on scraps left on the table by the landlord.

 

You can out lipstick on a pig but it's still a pig. You can put a roof on PPS but unless the rest of the economic components change, it's still a problem not a solution for the Marlins.

 

Now if the county were to buy out PPS and the surrounding land perhaps some of these issues could be addressed but I fear the biggest issue will remain unresolved, what to do with 30,000 or so unneeded seats. I suppose there there may be an answer to that but I haven't been able to figure one out.

 

Some will say "well all they need is a roof and a new lease and maybe some amenties to make the fans feel more at home" but there is so much more (as I've tried to lay out above) to successfully marketing a major league franchise.

 

Then there's the problem with location. I know it will upset my friends in Broward and Palm Beach to know that every marketing survey the Marlins have conducted points to the same conclusion, moving their location closer to the center of Miami-Dade county will translate into an increase in gross tickets sales, not a net loss. Some here forget how many people live south and west of the city of Miami and the densities of that part of the county. That's why the Orange Bowl site, warts and all, made such economic sense for the team.

 

I could go on and on. No doubt some, perhaps many will disagree. But those of you who are in business or those of you studying business development will understand of which I speak. For the Marlins its all or nothing.

 

I don't like it but I understand it.

 

Everything you said is valid and I completely agree with your point about supply and demand. I visited Camden Yards for the first time last July and I was torn between enjoying it and feeling depressed that we don?t have that. Still, I?d rather watch games at JRS for the rest of my life than lose the Marlins. Baseball can succeed here ? the only question is can it be worked out in time.

Still, I?d rather watch games at JRS for the rest of my life than lose the Marlins. Baseball can succeed here ? the only question is can it be worked out in time.

 

I'm very sorry you feel that way. You'll be living your life watching a low-revenue team incapable of putting a consistent winner on the field, fearing that they may leave at any time. Without a new lease at JRS or a new stadium, the issue will continue to arise, under the administration of Henry, Loria/Samson or any new owner approved by MLB.

Still, I?d rather watch games at JRS for the rest of my life than lose the Marlins. Baseball can succeed here ? the only question is can it be worked out in time.

 

I'm very sorry you feel that way. You'll be living your life watching a low-revenue team incapable of putting a consistent winner on the field, fearing that they may leave at any time. Without a new lease at JRS or a new stadium, the issue will continue to arise, under the administration of Henry, Loria/Samson or any new owner approved by MLB.

 

I think he meant watching the team in JRS with a new lease for the rest of his life.

Still, I?d rather watch games at JRS for the rest of my life than lose the Marlins. Baseball can succeed here ? the only question is can it be worked out in time.

 

I'm very sorry you feel that way. You'll be living your life watching a low-revenue team incapable of putting a consistent winner on the field, fearing that they may leave at any time. Without a new lease at JRS or a new stadium, the issue will continue to arise, under the administration of Henry, Loria/Samson or any new owner approved by MLB.

 

Okay, what if the team gets a favorable lease and the team can make money with a payroll of 80 million?

Hank was probably reiterating a blurb in the Herald this morning. It said the same thing--officials are working on a deal for a stadium next to DS...And Huizenga is all for making a retractable roof, but the Marlins do not want that under any circumstances.

 

Really, the only possibility at this point is the stadium next to DS.

 

Unless I missed something in the Herald, you may be talking about this blurb from the Sun-Sentinel:

 

" ...Samson said the team continues to talk with Miami-Dade Manager George Burgess. Talks with Dolphins Stadium owner H. Wayne Huizenga about building near the stadium have not resulted in a deal. And sources say talks are now more focused on having the team remain in the stadium with a roof and touches to make it more baseball-friendly, an option that does not appeal to the Marlins.

 

"We cannot contemplate a scenario where we would stay in Dolphins Stadium beyond 2010," Samson said."

 

 

 

Well it's similar in the Herald (out today btw, if you get it check it out). What I wrote wasn't verbatim, but it's a good summary.

Marlins2003....have you ever been to Shea Stadium? I can't imagine anything worse. Just take Joe Robbie, add lots of rails and low flying jets landing at LaGuardia. Yet somehow it succeeds.....when the team wins....even though it's not downtown. I think your point about supply and demand is not valid in the case of Joe Robbie Stadium. Yes, it CAN seat 70,000.....but there's only 20-30K good seats. The rest are for bandwagon jumpers. Give the pig(as you call it) a roof and give the Marlins a better lease and the season ticket base can grow.

.

.

.

Rferry.....what downtown do you envision the Marlins going to. There really is no downtown Miami-Ft. Lauderdale-Palm Beach. You think they can only succeed downtown? Tell that to the Yankees and many other teams not "downtown". There's no place for the Marlins to go....all the downtowns are taken in the big cities. How about downtown Northern New Jersey....or downtown Northern Virginia....downtown San Antonio...downtown Portland....downtown Tijuana? In my mind a move to these places would just temporarily relieve the pressure. A move to San Antonio would be like a fart from too many refried beans. A move to Portland would be like sticking your finger in the hole in the dike. Eventually the pressure would build back and the result for the team would not be good.

Marlins2003....have you ever been to Shea Stadium? I can't imagine anything worse. Just take Joe Robbie, add lots of rails and low flying jets landing at LaGuardia. Yet somehow it succeeds.....when the team wins....even though it's not downtown. I think your point about supply and demand is not valid in the case of Joe Robbie Stadium. Yes, it CAN seat 70,000.....but there's only 20-30K good seats. The rest are for bandwagon jumpers. Give the pig(as you call it) a roof and give the Marlins a better lease and the season ticket base can grow.

 

Lol, I know you're probably right about Shea, I've heard the war stories (I haven't been there in 25-30 years) but I'm not wrong about the rationale behind a smaller stadium.

As a seasoned veteran of Pro Player...I only have only heard of two meaningful complaints pertaining to the stadium itself:

 

1) The sightlines once you get into the terrace box are terrible for baseball.

 

2) The walls are too high making it not feel like a baseball stadium (anyone who's been to a traditional ballpark where the lower level slopes onto the field knows what I mean).

 

The stadium isn't going to get built downtown, the team isn't going to be owned by a hispanic owner, and the weather patterns aren't going to be changed in the summer to accomidate baseball, so let's all stop wasting time on those topics.

 

If a roof is added to Pro Player, and somehow the site-lines are amended and the walls lowered, that would be ideal for the Marlins. As it is, Pro Player isn't nearly as bad for baseball as people would have you believe.

Since when is John Henry a weasel???... I've missed the part of it being Henry's fault that we got the bad lease agreement...When did he ever a choice?...Wakeup Huizenga has always screwd the Marlins from day 1

2) The walls are too high making it not feel like a baseball stadium (anyone who's been to a traditional ballpark where the lower level slopes onto the field knows what I mean).

 

 

 

What are you talking about?

Still, I?d rather watch games at JRS for the rest of my life than lose the Marlins. Baseball can succeed here ? the only question is can it be worked out in time.

 

I'm very sorry you feel that way. You'll be living your life watching a low-revenue team incapable of putting a consistent winner on the field, fearing that they may leave at any time. Without a new lease at JRS or a new stadium, the issue will continue to arise, under the administration of Henry, Loria/Samson or any new owner approved by MLB.

Okay, what if the team gets a favorable lease and the team can make money with a payroll of 80 million?

That's what we're all hoping for.

 

Rferry.....what downtown do you envision the Marlins going to. There really is no downtown Miami-Ft. Lauderdale-Palm Beach. You think they can only succeed downtown? Tell that to the Yankees and many other teams not "downtown". There's no place for the Marlins to go....all the downtowns are taken in the big cities. How about downtown Northern New Jersey....or downtown Northern Virginia....downtown San Antonio...downtown Portland....downtown Tijuana? In my mind a move to these places would just temporarily relieve the pressure. A move to San Antonio would be like a fart from too many refried beans. A move to Portland would be like sticking your finger in the hole in the dike. Eventually the pressure would build back and the result for the team would not be good.

 

I still think a ballpark near downtown Miami is possible. I see politicians in Miami and Tallahassee bending when the Marlins come up with serious options outside their jurisdictions. After all there's a lot of other funding options that haven't been considered (ballpark tax, business tax, entertainment tax, immediate cash flow by selling off parking or other services). That said, I'm not opposed to a ballpark elsewhere. I just think the area around Dolphins Stadium is very poor. It COULD work, but you're relying entirely on road traffic from the still far-off affluent northern suburbs and those to the south who choose to fight traffic. There's no close large population center to draw from and very few options to get there in a reasonable amount of time and amount of stress from anywhere else (it's still like a hour from WPB).

And I don't think any of the other markets you mentioned or have been mentioned have any more questions to be answered than South Florida does. Since 1991 when South Florida was awarded a ballpark, MLB teams have been more reliant on broadcast contracts (below-average for the size of its media market), ballpark revenues (Huizenga's stealing those) and their (Huizenga thwarts that). Then, like now, the market has a lot of promise and could be something great, but it may not be worth the headache.

 

Since when is John Henry a weasel???... I've missed the part of it being Henry's fault that we got the bad lease agreement...When did he ever a choice?...Wakeup Huizenga has always screwd the Marlins from day 1

 

The lease originally goes back to when Huizenga divested much of JRS/PPS/DS' gameday revenues into dummy companies in his attempt to defraud the city into building him a stadium.

The area by Dolphin stadium is ok it would help to extend the rail there somehow...I no longer live in S. Florida (I live in Orlando now) but it was sooo easy for me to go to the Heat games when I lived in the Kendall area even when I moved to the metrozoo area but to go to PPS back then was a huge trek but even with the traffick it was ok...Lets get the stadium period and then access can be worked out. I hope it's a smaller park so that it will be full even in the week

2) The walls are too high making it not feel like a baseball stadium (anyone who's been to a traditional ballpark where the lower level slopes onto the field knows what I mean).

 

 

 

What are you talking about?

 

If you've been to a game at Yankee Stadium, or Fenway or even Shea, you can see the difference. Those stadiums on the lower level even out so that the seats are on the field, at the height of the founder's field or batter's box seats. Pro Player's lower bowl ends with the wall that is built for football (and understandably higher). It makes the vantage point higher, affecting some of the site-lines for people sitting in certain sections of the lower bowl.

 

It's just a quirk that Marlins fans who haven't experienced a lot of other stadiums are used to...

And part of what it does is decrease the angle of seating in the lowel bowl, which has always been a pet peeve of mine. TSwift is correct that newer stadium aren't constructed this way.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.