March 13, 200620 yr Who is Dukes? A damn good OF in the Rays system who also happens to be insane. Of course if he stepped out of line here, Shadez would put him in his place. But seriously, no thanks. Kid has mental issues.
March 13, 200620 yr This looks to set up nicely for the Marlins - they can offer a B level pitching prospect for Gaithright and if Tampa holds out for the Olsen...the Marlins can counter and ask for Dukes. What's the consensus here on Dukes? Would most be in favor of dealing a top pitching prospect for Elijah??? :mischief2
March 13, 200620 yr Author This looks to set up nicely for the Marlins - they can offer a B level pitching prospect for Gaithright and if Tampa holds out for the Olsen...the Marlins can counter and ask for Dukes. What's the consensus here on Dukes? Would most be in favor of dealing a top pitching prospect for Elijah??? :mischief2 I would deal Olsen for Dukes
March 13, 200620 yr MarlinsLou if you are ready to deal Gathright for Olsen why do you mention is Olsen worth Dukes? I would pull the trigger for Dukes though I would still like another player because Olsen is someone among the top 50 baseball prospects. Evene if we can't get another player from the Rays I'll pull the trigger. Dukes is no defense liability in CF either. This is his scoutingreport form baseball america. Weaknesses: If he can?t accept authority and develop discipline, Dukes will fall short of his potential. That said, he?s dedicated to the game. His average suffers when he tries too hard to hit for power. The Future: From a tools standpoint, everything is in place for Dukes to be a prototype right fielder. The Devil Rays are working with him to help him reach that potential. On the field, Delmon Young will be a formidable roadblock to Dukes playing right field in Tampa Bay. [/quoted] I'm not ready to pull the trigger with Olsen, I'm ready to pull the trigger for Johnson or Nolasco, which is a much fairer deal for Gathright. The scouting report says he is going to be a corner player, and his pecota defensive translations, link posted above, for CF are not good. That says red flag to me once you read over all the "oh he's got tools" scout nonsense. Olsen is worth Dukes because of the power potential and ability to improve in CF. It doesn't matter if Olsen is ranked 30 on BA's list, he is still a complete unknown as all pitchers are. Hitters are much more projectable. Dukes could be as highly regarded as Granderson this time next year. He could cost more then Olsen in a few more months.
March 13, 200620 yr This looks to set up nicely for the Marlins - they can offer a B level pitching prospect for Gaithright and if Tampa holds out for the Olsen...the Marlins can counter and ask for Dukes. What's the consensus here on Dukes? Would most be in favor of dealing a top pitching prospect for Elijah??? :mischief2 No, that dudes crazy.
March 13, 200620 yr Olsen for Gaithright is a decent deal that benefits both teams, the Marlins have a surplus of young pitchers and don't have a young leadoff hitter worth a dime. what about shades? is he incapable of leading off or is he old?
March 13, 200620 yr what about shades? is he incapable of leading off or is he old? what does being old have to do with anything? I say Shadez has the potential but is still to raw to be a leadoff hitter even if he belted 2 yesterday
March 13, 200620 yr This looks to set up nicely for the Marlins - they can offer a B level pitching prospect for Gaithright and if Tampa holds out for the Olsen...the Marlins can counter and ask for Dukes. What's the consensus here on Dukes? Would most be in favor of dealing a top pitching prospect for Elijah??? :mischief2 I would deal Olsen for Dukes as would I.... but the deal would have to include Dukes' new shrink too...
March 14, 200620 yr This looks to set up nicely for the Marlins - they can offer a B level pitching prospect for Gaithright and if Tampa holds out for the Olsen...the Marlins can counter and ask for Dukes. What's the consensus here on Dukes? Would most be in favor of dealing a top pitching prospect for Elijah??? :mischief2 I would deal Olsen for Dukes as would I.... but the deal would have to include Dukes' new shrink too... Bring us the Prophet and bring back Harvey Dorfman! :notworthy
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.