March 13, 200620 yr ...move Johnson instead. PB, I nearly fell off my chair when I read this. :lol Just stirring the pot. Emotions run high with many of our prospects. Honestly though, it's almost impossible to predict which one(s) will eventually become Aces. We have to give something worthwhile to get something worthwhile back. I have confidence the FO will make the best choice once they've had a chance to evaluate all of the talent.
March 13, 200620 yr Hear hear! Mitre to the pen, Olsen & Johnson to the rotation. :thumbup Also, just give Borowski the closer job for now. Bowyer looks like he's not quite ready to step into this kind of role yet. If he's not getting it done, someone else will get a shot, as happened with Mota & Jones last season. As for Gathright-Olsen.... if it wasn't happening before I don't know why it would now after Olsen's looking so well in spring training.
March 13, 200620 yr Olsen for Gathright? The Cubs are looking to unload Hairston or Walker on the Fish. If Abercrombie and Uggla do nothing else for us this spring training they are keeping the trade market honest.
March 13, 200620 yr Hear hear! Mitre to the pen, Olsen & Johnson to the rotation. :thumbup Also, just give Borowski the closer job for now. Bowyer looks like he's not quite ready to step into this kind of role yet. If he's not getting it done, someone else will get a shot, as happened with Mota & Jones last season. As for Gathright-Olsen.... if it wasn't happening before I don't know why it would now after Olsen's looking so well in spring training. not true. Rumors have said in the papers that they're waiting for the end of spring break to properly evaluate players.
March 13, 200620 yr Mitre has good value Tampa is Pitching starved but they want another steal of a deal like the one in which they got Kazmir...Yeah they are asking for Olsen ... However Olsen's value continues to increase (and I know many people are jumping on my comment that Gathright is having a lousy spring) while Gathright's is dropping He has not really wowed anyone. He is fast but his defense is just ok with a subpar arm...Yes he has had very limited at bats but if anyone has paid attention Elijah Dukes has dropped him even further down the depth chart. Right now he has to be traded, they rather keep Dukes with the parent club Don't forget Young should be about ready to come up in June
March 13, 200620 yr Author Mitre has good value Tampa is Pitching starved but they want another steal of a deal like the one in which they got Kazmir...Yeah they are asking for Olsen ... However Olsen's value continues to increase (and I know many people are jumping on my comment that Gathright is having a lousy spring) while Gathright's is dropping He has not really wowed anyone. He is fast but his defense is just ok with a subpar arm...Yes he has had very limited at bats but if anyone has paid attention Elijah Dukes has dropped him even further down the depth chart. Right now he has to be traded, they rather keep Dukes with the parent club Don't forget Young should be about ready to come up in June I agree you Eddie. By the way someone in the espn Tampa Bay message board claims a Devil Ray-Marlin deal might get done by Friday. Take it by what its worth. He said his sources and he seems to be respected in that site.
March 13, 200620 yr Tampa knows they can't get Olsen but you cant really blame them for trying...that is whats called negotiating a deal. I believe We will lose a prospect or two. No one by the name of Olsen is going anywhere. How about maybe Sean West and Mitre for Gathright and Jon Matulia?
March 13, 200620 yr Hear hear! Mitre to the pen, Olsen & Johnson to the rotation. :thumbup Also, just give Borowski the closer job for now. Bowyer looks like he's not quite ready to step into this kind of role yet. If he's not getting it done, someone else will get a shot, as happened with Mota & Jones last season. As for Gathright-Olsen.... if it wasn't happening before I don't know why it would now after Olsen's looking so well in spring training. not true. Rumors have said in the papers that they're waiting for the end of spring break to properly evaluate players. Well first of all I'm just giving an opinion, but which are you referring to?
March 13, 200620 yr If there's one thing I know, it's that Spring Training is not necessarily an indicator of a player's ability See: Abraham Nunez, Marlins 2003
March 13, 200620 yr If there's one thing I know, it's that Spring Training is not necessarily an indicator of a player's ability See: Abraham Nunez, Marlins 2003 See: Ramon Castro, Marlins 2004
March 13, 200620 yr Tampa knows they can't get Olsen but you cant really blame them for trying...that is whats called negotiating a deal. I believe We will lose a prospect or two. No one by the name of Olsen is going anywhere. How about maybe Sean West and Mitre for Gathright and Jon Matulia? I dont think we can trade Sean West yet and if we could I would be hesitant. If there's one thing I know, it's that Spring Training is not necessarily an indicator of a player's ability See: Abraham Nunez, Marlins 2003 See: Ramon Castro, Marlins 2004 See: Brian Moehler, Marlins 2005 :whistle
March 13, 200620 yr OMGNUNEZ had his massive spring in 2004, not 2003. And if we're going to chase a young OF, lets go get Granderson.
March 13, 200620 yr I don't get why we're (allegedly) in such a hurry to get Gathright, with the way Abercrombie has been playing.
March 13, 200620 yr OMGNUNEZ had his massive spring in 2004, not 2003. And if we're going to chase a young OF, lets go get Granderson. not really a speed lead off hitter but I like his swing it is pretty. I wouldnt mind reed for his defense still.
March 13, 200620 yr OMGNUNEZ had his massive spring in 2004, not 2003. And if we're going to chase a young OF, lets go get Granderson. He is absolutely untouchable and one of their core young building block players with Shelton/Bonderman/Verlander/Zumaya/Giarratano. Not even worth mentioning. It's like us moving Hermida or Hanley. I think they can pry Taveras if they want to give up Olsen. I don't believe the Jeremy Reed talk, they need him and he's going to be good. Gathright, or Dukes, is probably the best OF they will get based on who has what on their current team and system. I don't think baltimore would move Majewski or Markakis, or DBacks Quentin or Chris Young (and if they did, either is Olsen and Gaby). Mets Milledge, Cubs Pie, Choo Mariners, Anderson Chi Sox. I'm just going off the top of my head of top prospecs around - I'm sure there are more out there above single A - but I really don't see many teams excited to exchange OF prospects for minor league pitching. Those franchises need those players. KC has some bats, and they for sure need pitching, but they need hitters just as bad. I don't see them trading right now. I know everyone hates Joey, but does Olsen/Dukes piss anyone off? I think he projects pretty solidly into a 20/20, .340-.360 OBP player, and he'll be stuck behind Delmon, Crawford, Baldelli, and probably Upton (when he moves from SS) in a year. Again, defensive red flags in CF, but he is Gathright minus 20-30 SB for 20 HR. That's a substantial upgrade. http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/D/elijah-dukes.shtml http://www.baseballprospectus.com/pecota/DUKES19840626A.php
March 13, 200620 yr I would prefer Dukes over Gathright... although Elijah is a bit of a headcase Well, any sane person would prefer Dukes over Gathright, but the question is, is it worth Olsen? All news I have seen from Rays camp has said Dukes is focused, playing great, and seems to be getting over Milton Bradleyitis. I'd do it. Bat them Hanley, Hammer, Hermida, Cab, Jacobs, Dukes (LF), Aguila (CF), and Uggla. Dukes could play CF, but if we have to start Aguila or Reed - might as well take the defensive upgrade in CF for 2006 before Dukes takes over CF.
March 13, 200620 yr Olsen for Gaithright is a decent deal that benefits both teams, the Marlins have a surplus of young pitchers and don't have a young leadoff hitter worth a dime.
March 13, 200620 yr Author I would prefer Dukes over Gathright... although Elijah is a bit of a headcase Well, any sane person would prefer Dukes over Gathright, but the question is, is it worth Olsen? All news I have seen from Rays camp has said Dukes is focused, playing great, and seems to be getting over Milton Bradleyitis. I'd do it. Bat them Hanley, Hammer, Hermida, Cab, Jacobs, Dukes (LF), Aguila (CF), and Uggla. Dukes could play CF, but if we have to start Aguila or Reed - might as well take the defensive upgrade in CF for 2006 before Dukes takes over CF. MarlinsLou if you are ready to deal Gathright for Olsen why do you mention is Olsen worth Dukes? I would pull the trigger for Dukes though I would still like another player because Olsen is someone among the top 50 baseball prospects. Evene if we can't get another player from the Rays I'll pull the trigger. Why do I like Dukes over Gathright? -Dukes has more power -3 years younger -has a good arm -has good range -30/30 potential -Baseball America even says he is a better athlete than Gathright Dukes is no defense liability in CF either. This is his scoutingreport form baseball america. Background: Dukes continues to move through the minors and have disciplinary problems along the way. He set career highs in several categories in 2005 but was suspended twice and ejected from five games. He also had legal problems in Tampa, declined an invitation to the Southern League all-star game because he wasn?t selected to start and missed the Arizona Fall League in order to complete anger-management classes. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Strengths: Dukes is an incredible athlete with all-star ability. He makes solid contact, has at least 20-homer power and plays with all-out aggression. He has plus speed and range, as well as one of the strongest arms in the organization. He has demonstrated improved control of the strike zone. Weaknesses: If he can?t accept authority and develop discipline, Dukes will fall short of his potential. That said, he?s dedicated to the game. His average suffers when he tries too hard to hit for power. The Future: From a tools standpoint, everything is in place for Dukes to be a prototype right fielder. The Devil Rays are working with him to help him reach that potential. On the field, Delmon Young will be a formidable roadblock to Dukes playing right field in Tampa Bay. Olsen for Gaithright is a decent deal that benefits both teams, the Marlins have a surplus of young pitchers and don't have a young leadoff hitter worth a dime. It is not a decent deal. Its strongly favors the Rays.
March 13, 200620 yr Olsen for Gaithright is a decent deal that benefits both teams, the Marlins have a surplus of young pitchers and don't have a young leadoff hitter worth a dime. You don't trade a quarter for 15?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.