Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2006 NL East Predictions

Featured Replies

This isn't last year. We don't have even a 1/6th of the offensive capability that our lineup had in 2005. Miguel Cabrera has no protection around him, and odds are he's going to get walked most of the time. We're going to have powerless hitters like Aguila, Eric Reed, Hanley Ramirez, etc. making up over a third of the lineup.

 

 

Capability is different than production. Last year's Marlin team didn't produce, only 3 players hit more than 10 home-runs and only two drove in over 100 and after that nobody even cracked 80.

 

You're telling me that Hanley, Hermida, Willingham and Jacobs can't combine to surpass 27 homeruns (AKA LoDuca, Gonzalez and Encarnacion's combined 2005 total)? Or that we can't find one regular to make up for Lowell's .236 average?

 

I'm sorry, but last year's team didn't produce at all outside of three players (Castillo, Cabrera, Delgado) and we still almost made the playoffs. So now I'm being told that after ridding ourselves of 6 underachievers (LoDuca, Gonzalez, Encarnacion, Pierre, Lowell and Burnett) we're substantially worse off than last season! For the love of God, look at what we have to replace from the everyday lineup:

 

A shortstop who will swing at the rosin bag and not produce any power numbers.

A thirdbaseman who mysteriously lost, well everything, and couldn't hit water if he fell out of a boat.

A catcher whose 'grittiness' in a big market and a baseball town that loves players with 'heart' leading him to be one of the most overrated players of the past decade.

A rightfielder who if he ever broke a sweat during a game was reason to stop the presses.

And a pitcher who thinks it's better to throw it through a wall than to pitch, especially when being spotted an early lead.

 

I'm not saying we're not going to miss Beckett, Castillo, Delgado and Jones...but if we're seriously upgrading, slightly upgrading, or at least breaking even at 6 positions with departed players while retaining (statistically) last season's two best players...that's not good (or if you prefer bad) enough for a 30 win swing in the standings.

I always look to Yahoo for my baseball analysis! :thumbup

 

and local Channel 7 news for balanced informed reporting! :thumbup

 

*surfs over to AOL chat for intelligent political debate*

 

Where in Fort L? I lived in Coral Springs 9 years and I'm moving back this year.

 

Actually I'm in Coral Springs/Margate now...

  • Author

I always look to Yahoo for my baseball analysis! :thumbup

 

and local Channel 7 news for balanced informed reporting! :thumbup

 

*surfs over to AOL chat for intelligent political debate*

 

Where in Fort L? I lived in Coral Springs 9 years and I'm moving back this year.

 

Actually I'm in Coral Springs/Margate now...

Really?! I was born in Margate! Wow. Its a small word, isn't it? 110th Ave. all the way.

What's the difference who the writer is? It could be some kid writing for his high school newspaper, or Tony Kornheiser. The bottom line is whether it's well written, and has solid reasoning behind it. In my opinion, what this person has written about all the teams in the NL East IN JUST A FEW SENTENCES....is concise, well written, and on the mark. I challenge anyone here to write in a few short words something with better reasoning. You can hope all you want that the Braves will lose.....but the writer is correct in saying it's the right thing to pick them to win until proven otherwise. You can pray and wish all you want about the Marlins team of excellent prospects + Dontrelle & Cabrera winning 70 or 80 games. But years of history tell us that the prospects will need more time...the pitching beyond Dontrelle will wilt in the summer....and it's accurate to predict 56 wins. I'll be hoping for more....but I'll be satisfied with 56 wins AND some nice progress from our prospects AND keeping Dontrelle around for many years.

We won't lose 100 games.

 

And, while not in the original story, nothing will top the comment that 25 year old Mike Jacobs is washed up. I laughed out loud at that one.

I always look to Yahoo for my baseball analysis! :thumbup

 

and local Channel 7 news for balanced informed reporting! :thumbup

 

*surfs over to AOL chat for intelligent political debate*

 

 

 

:lol :lol :lol :lol

 

:notworthy

I challenge anyone here to write in a few short words something with better reasoning.

 

Since you asked:

 

NL East 2006 Preview ? Trent Swift Marlinbaseball.com beat writer

 

1. Atlanta Braves 100-62

 

The skinny: After 14 consecutive division titles, we should know better than to pick against Atlanta. The team returns the nucleus that helped win it?s most satisfying division title in some time, and after receiving a 2005 outing from new staff ace Tim Hudson that was below his career averages, Atlanta has every reason to think that 2006 will be brighter than 2005. With Kyle Davies, Jeff Francoeur and Brian McCann looking like franchise corner-stones, Atlanta certainly appears to be the prohibitive favorite yet again.

 

2. New York Mets 86-76

 

The Skinny: Flaunting perhaps the National League?s most imposing offense, the Mets look to take over New York?s back-pages and end the Braves run of dominance; only one problem: wheeling dealing general manager Omar Minaya did little to improve an aging rotation that features more question marks than certainties. Pedro Martinez has yet to throw one spring inning and Tom Glavine has been erratic in limited action this spring. While the offense may be good enough to carry the team through tough times, the lack of reliable front end pitching outside of an aging and injured Pedro will be enough to see this team wilt down the stretch.

 

3. Philadelphia Phillies 82-80

 

The skinny: 2005 was another disappointing season for the continuously ?almost there? Phillies save for one player, Ryan Howard. In Howard, the Phillies have one of the premier young power hitters in baseball, but the team around him is a unit where the sum of its parts is greater than the whole. Spurned in their efforts to add a top flight rotation arm, the Phillies seemed reluctantly resigned to see if they can out-slug the competition and keep pace in a division built around offense.

 

4. Florida Marlins 75-87

 

The skinny: After being rebuffed in their attempts to get a baseball only facility in South Florida, the Marlins decided to basically start over with a cheaper and younger, but not necessarily worse, group of players. All-Stars Dontrelle Willis and Miguel Cabrera return to lead a crop of rookies headlined by 5 tool super-prospects Jeremy Hermida and Hanley Ramirez. Statistically, the 2005 Marlins were one of the most disappointing teams in all of baseball, and this group of talented youngsters should be one of the surprises of 2006.

 

5. Washington Nationals 73-89

 

The skinny: The feel good story of the first half of 2005, the surprising Nationals took the nation?s capital by storm. However, the team?s lack of offensive production around Jose Guillen caught up with the Nationals as they faded in the second half. 2006 doesn?t look much better as Guillen and newly acquired starter Brian Lawrence are expected to miss substantial time due to injury and new ?outfielder? Alfonso Soriano is already disrupting the team because of his reluctance to play leftfield.

This isn't last year. We don't have even a 1/6th of the offensive capability that our lineup had in 2005. Miguel Cabrera has no protection around him, and odds are he's going to get walked most of the time. We're going to have powerless hitters like Aguila, Eric Reed, Hanley Ramirez, etc. making up over a third of the lineup.

 

 

Capability is different than production. Last year's Marlin team didn't produce, only 3 players hit more than 10 home-runs and only two drove in over 100 and after that nobody even cracked 80.

 

You're telling me that Hanley, Hermida, Willingham and Jacobs can't combine to surpass 27 homeruns (AKA LoDuca, Gonzalez and Encarnacion's combined 2005 total)? Or that we can't find one regular to make up for Lowell's .236 average?

 

I'm sorry, but last year's team didn't produce at all outside of three players (Castillo, Cabrera, Delgado) and we still almost made the playoffs. So now I'm being told that after ridding ourselves of 6 underachievers (LoDuca, Gonzalez, Encarnacion, Pierre, Lowell and Burnett) we're substantially worse off than last season! For the love of God, look at what we have to replace from the everyday lineup:

 

A shortstop who will swing at the rosin bag and not produce any power numbers.

A thirdbaseman who mysteriously lost, well everything, and couldn't hit water if he fell out of a boat.

A catcher whose 'grittiness' in a big market and a baseball town that loves players with 'heart' leading him to be one of the most overrated players of the past decade.

A rightfielder who if he ever broke a sweat during a game was reason to stop the presses.

And a pitcher who thinks it's better to throw it through a wall than to pitch, especially when being spotted an early lead.

 

I'm not saying we're not going to miss Beckett, Castillo, Delgado and Jones...but if we're seriously upgrading, slightly upgrading, or at least breaking even at 6 positions with departed players while retaining (statistically) last season's two best players...that's not good (or if you prefer bad) enough for a 30 win swing in the standings.

 

 

agreed.... The reason we are worse off this year then last year is just the inexperience we have in the starting rotation and our lack of depth in the bullpen. The team we have is very competive and we wont lose 100 games. I say in 2 or 3 years we are back to the top in the NL. EAST

I didn't know the T stood for Trent.

 

I will call you Double Down from now on.

That's well written Swift....I'll give you credit for that. But I'm sorry I can't give you credit for better reasoning. To think the Marlins will win 75 games this year is just a fan's wishful thinking. I'm a fan too, but I don't think this wish will come true. The pitching is just not there...not this year. Anyway, what's the difference really. If it makes any of you feel better to think the Marlins will win 75 games and/or not finish in last place...then be my guest. I really don't care if we finish ahead or behind the Nationals this year. I'd rather see progress....NO INJURIES from rushing along the youngsters...and we'll compete again in another year.

I didn't know the T stood for Trent.

 

I will call you Double Down from now on.

 

:lol

 

Swingers!

while the offense wasnt all there last year besides the bash brothers, the team kept it self in game through pitching, something that besides Willis isnt all that reliable

the team kept it self in game through pitching, something that besides Willis isnt all that reliable

 

 

Is that really all that different than last year, though?

 

I love Josh Beckett to death, but he couldn't beat Colorado or Milwaukee when we needed him to, nor could the same be said for AJ when we needed wins in September or Moehler for most of the second half.

 

The way I see it, if Dontrelle is 3/4 of the pitcher he was last season, and Moehler is on a short leashe in the rotation with Olsen/Nolasco waiting to take his spot, the rotation may not feature a bona-fide ace, but it won't be a tremendous step backwards at least by regular season standards.

Beckett still gave the quality start and AJ did the same for well over half the season ... add dontrelle and thats 3 out of 5 days that you will at least get a quality start and stay in the game regardless of the W/L

 

It takes time for young pitchers to come to develop this ... we have seen Beckett and AJ and Penny do it in the past and it took them a while to figure things out . You cant expect that much from the young marlin staff

Beckett still gave the quality start and AJ did the same for well over half the season ... add dontrelle and thats 3 out of 5 days that you will at least get a quality start and stay in the game regardless of the W/L

 

It takes time for young pitchers to come to develop this ... we have seen Beckett and AJ and Penny do it in the past and it took them a while to figure things out . You cant expect that much from the young marlin staff

 

 

I don't think you're quite understanding the point I'm making, of the much vaunted rotation we had last season, only one pitcher was as close to a sure thing as it gets: Dontrelle Willis.

 

Add in that Al Leiter basically handicapped the opposing team in the first half and that Brian Moehler/Ismael Valdez took that role in the second half and you're down to 4 pitchers. Of those 4, Beckett and Burnett were a roller-coaster of injury/inconsistency and Vargas was, to the tee, a .500 pitcher.

 

So you're telling me that two rookies, at alternating times, can't get hot for a little bit? Or that one can't be a .500 pitcher? Or that Mitre can't even conceivably be an upgrade over Moehler? Or that one won't just flat out get flogged like Leiter/Moehler/Valdez?

 

Point is, last year's rotation was anchored by one pitcher all the way through, another one when he was healthy and a third when his head was in the game. If you honestly believe that Willis is an ace, then this rotation is in pretty good shape given the production that needs to be replaced.

 

And that's all my point is...it's hard to replace the talent that we had last year, but it isn't going to be incredibly hard to replace most of the production.

than I would be extactic if the Jason Vargas, Josh Johnson and Olsen/Mitre can produce the rollercoaster that Beckett and AJ did last year

 

give that "mediocrity" and we can again win 80+ games ... im sorry but its not that easy

Just using the term of "quality start" being thrown around here:

 

2005 Florida Marlins Quality Starts: 85 of 162 games (52.5%)

2005 Dontrelle Willis Quality Starts: 25 of 34 (73.5%)

2005 Rest of Team Quality Starts: 60 of 128 (46.9%)

2005 Quality Starts by non-Big Three: 17 of 67 (25.3%)

 

So, to summarize, take away Dontrelle and our quality start percentage is less than half. Are we going to lose some from not having Beckett and Burnett? Absolutely. But I think it's also fair to say that the other 2 spots in the rotation will do better than 25%.

I myself am not a big fan of the quality start stat. You could start 33 games, go 0-33 with a 4.5 era, and still have 33 quality starts.

 

It's too deceptive to be a determining factor on how good a pitcher is and isnt.

You could start 33 games, go 0-33 with a 4.5 era, and still have 33 quality starts.

 

 

 

 

thats a pretty bad team you are playing there

I myself am not a big fan of the quality start stat. You could start 33 games, go 0-33 with a 4.5 era, and still have 33 quality starts.

 

It's too deceptive to be a determining factor on how good a pitcher is and isnt.

 

 

So basically your point is it's pretty easy to get a quality start and yet we did it barely over 50% of the time.

Just using the term of "quality start" being thrown around here:

 

2005 Florida Marlins Quality Starts: 85 of 162 games (52.5%)

2005 Dontrelle Willis Quality Starts: 25 of 34 (73.5%)

2005 Rest of Team Quality Starts: 60 of 128 (46.9%)

2005 Quality Starts by non-Big Three: 17 of 67 (25.3%)

 

So, to summarize, take away Dontrelle and our quality start percentage is less than half. Are we going to lose some from not having Beckett and Burnett? Absolutely. But I think it's also fair to say that the other 2 spots in the rotation will do better than 25%.

 

 

:thumbup

And I'm saying you're wrong.

 

Of course, I like to look at it as the opposite, basically the non-quality start part. Basically, 47.5% of the time we took the field, our SP either couldn't make it 6 innings or gave up more than 3 earned runs in those 6 innings.

 

That's not useless info.

Just using the term of "quality start" being thrown around here:

 

2005 Florida Marlins Quality Starts: 85 of 162 games (52.5%)

2005 Dontrelle Willis Quality Starts: 25 of 34 (73.5%)

2005 Rest of Team Quality Starts: 60 of 128 (46.9%)

2005 Quality Starts by non-Big Three: 17 of 67 (25.3%)

 

So, to summarize, take away Dontrelle and our quality start percentage is less than half. Are we going to lose some from not having Beckett and Burnett? Absolutely. But I think it's also fair to say that the other 2 spots in the rotation will do better than 25%.

 

 

 

Okay so Beckett and Burnett got 43 QS. You think this year's #2 and #3 will even put up anything near that? I mean Beckett and Burnett are kinda border line 1/2 pitchers. The guys we have starting 2 and 3 this year are not quite borderline 1/2 starters. We will lose a lot of QS there. And do I trust a couple of rookies to outperform journey men pitchers in terms of QS? Maybe on par.

 

The pitching will be decent if not good til halfway through the season. Once the innings start to kick in it's going to get painful.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.