Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2006 NL East Predictions

Featured Replies

We just have a disagreement in philosophy. Any stat that can be used as a measure of success yet doesn't require a win or even a decision for that matter and can be accomplished with an era above the league average(or below...or right at...not sure what league average era was in the NL last year), should not be taken seriously.

And I'm telling you that I use it as a measure of failure. Thus it's still not useless.

 

Try thinking outside the box sometimes.

That's well written Swift....I'll give you credit for that. But I'm sorry I can't give you credit for better reasoning. To think the Marlins will win 75 games this year is just a fan's wishful thinking. I'm a fan too, but I don't think this wish will come true. The pitching is just not there...not this year. Anyway, what's the difference really. If it makes any of you feel better to think the Marlins will win 75 games and/or not finish in last place...then be my guest. I really don't care if we finish ahead or behind the Nationals this year. I'd rather see progress....NO INJURIES from rushing along the youngsters...and we'll compete again in another year.

 

 

I am not sure you understand how bad a team has to be to win only 56 games. From a statistical perspective, if the team is slightly below average offensively (say 700 runs scored) the pitching would have to give up about 1000 runs to lose 106 games. That's an ERA of over 6. I don't think a single team in the NL last year even came close to that. It just won't happen. They may lose 95-98 games, but I doubt it.

This is actually a topic of discussion over @ cardsclubhouse.com. A guy picked the Marlins to have the worst record in the NL and gave this reason:

Which is exactly why the Marlins won't win.

 

Terrible pitching staff. With the exception of Willis (who still lost 10 games even with a good offense last year)... So young rookies that have never played a full season and Miguel Cabrera and only one proven pitcher that will make the Marlins have the worst record in baseball

 

That bolded part made me chuckle.

We just have a disagreement in philosophy. Any stat that can be used as a measure of success yet doesn't require a win or even a decision for that matter and can be accomplished with an era above the league average(or below...or right at...not sure what league average era was in the NL last year), should not be taken seriously.

All a Quality Start measures is a starter's ability to keep his team in the ballgame. A starter can go 3 IP and give up one run every time out, but that doesn't keep a team in a game at all because pens get taxed like that. Conversely, a starter can go 7 innings, give up 5 runs, and win the game - but that one is squarely on the offense. He just happened to be the pitcher of record.

 

Going 6+ innings and allowing 3 earned runs or less keeps your team in the game. That's the only thing that stat should be used for. And if you're keeping your team in the game, that isn't too bad right?

Delgado, Cabrera, Pierre and Easley were butchers. I'm talking bottom five at their positions. LoDuca's right there as well. Lowell has no range. Gonzalez had an off-year. Our only quality defender was Castillo and he was out much of the year. It was awful. With Reed, Aguila, Ramirez, Cabrera comfortable, hermida we have plus defenders again.

Good to see we are talking baseball again. I think though the starting pitching will tire down the stretch we have options to replace them, Petit and Sanchez are waiting in the wings and will likely be ready. Also giong with 6 starters at the beginning of the season will allow someone to get skipped once in a while. I really wont be shocked if we win 75 games and really think we can crack .500 if we have a great season.

Delgado, Cabrera, Pierre and Easley were butchers. I'm talking bottom five at their positions. LoDuca's right there as well. Lowell has no range. Gonzalez had an off-year. Our only quality defender was Castillo and he was out much of the year. It was awful. With Reed, Aguila, Ramirez, Cabrera comfortable, hermida we have plus defenders again.

 

 

There is an article on mlb.com saying the Marlins had the worst defense in the NL. So, like you said, yes, we can only improve.

I dont care how good we do in spring training, we could win every game for all I care. I still think we are going to fold in the long run. :drunks

Delgado, Cabrera, Pierre and Easley were butchers. I'm talking bottom five at their positions. LoDuca's right there as well. Lowell has no range. Gonzalez had an off-year. Our only quality defender was Castillo and he was out much of the year. It was awful. With Reed, Aguila, Ramirez, Cabrera comfortable, hermida we have plus defenders again.

 

 

There is an article on mlb.com saying the Marlins had the worst defense in the NL. So, like you said, yes, we can only improve.

 

Exactly, can't fall any farther from the bottom.

Delgado, Cabrera, Pierre and Easley were butchers. I'm talking bottom five at their positions. LoDuca's right there as well. Lowell has no range. Gonzalez had an off-year. Our only quality defender was Castillo and he was out much of the year. It was awful. With Reed, Aguila, Ramirez, Cabrera comfortable, hermida we have plus defenders again.

 

 

There is an article on mlb.com saying the Marlins had the worst defense in the NL. So, like you said, yes, we can only improve.

 

Exactly, can't fall any farther from the bottom.

 

 

does experience ever play a part of conversations? ... even if all the players had the worst defensive year in their lives and had as many errors as anyone in the league, they still had the experience and the longetivity they had together ... chemistry and years of working together

 

regardless of the defensive skills that Hanley/Andino/Uggla have, they have nothing on the the 4/5 years that Gonzo and Luis had. talking about one of the greatest defensive combo's in the league for many years ... we all know how much of a joy it was to watch those two at work on a daily basis. Also Lowell won a gold glove ... talk about lack of range, im sorry but you dont win a gold glove because simply because of your good looks and overthrown throws to 1st base

 

and as underacheiving as LoDuca was and blah blah blah ... he is still more trustworthy and skilled behind the plate than Willingham

 

 

(waits for someone to not understand and post all the stats on how much better their def % was in the MINORS)

Experience doesn't count for crap on defense.

 

100% of the time when a kid is brought up, you always see him having his glove ahead of his bat.

 

Hanley Ramirez has been "major league ready" defensively for a while now, same with Reed and Hermida.

 

Add in that you could pretty much put a glove on a chair at first and left and get more or less the same Cabrera/Delgado defensive output and we're upgrading, substantially, across the board, even if we're falling backwards at second base.

 

There is no such thing as necessary experience on defense when talking about capable prospects. The only time that comes into play is with astro turf or a weird dome like the Twins have.

 

Also Lowell won a gold glove ... talk about lack of range, im sorry but you dont win a gold glove because simply because of your good looks and overthrown throws to 1st base

 

No, in this case you win a gold glove because there was no one else to give it to. Lowell's range factor last year was 2.59...Scott Rolen, at his worst, was 2.66 and he's routinely over 3. If Rolen plays last year, it's his, and if Aramis Ramirez didn't overthrow first base a dozen or so times, the award's probably his too.

 

Besides, a golden-glove means nothing, Rafael Palmeiro won a gold-glove in '99 while appearing in 28 games at first base and 135 at DH. Awesome. :cool

yeah I totally forgot how much Lowell sucked at the hot corner

 

 

I never said he sucked defensively, but he got a lot more credit than he deserved last year.

 

Steady but unspectacular is the best way to describe Lowell, Cabrera, at the very least, brings a stronger throwing arm and a bit more range to the position.

yeah I totally forgot how much Lowell sucked at the hot corner

 

He doesn't suck. He's very solid and reliable. He has an accurate arm. I'd say average as far as arm strength. He has good reactions to balls hit towards him, but you have to admit that he is not what you'd call "quick". But Cabrera can certainly be his equal defensively there, and meanwhile you're getting him out of left field where he was way below average.

yeah I totally forgot how much Lowell sucked at the hot corner

 

He doesn't suck. He's very solid and reliable. He has an accurate arm. I'd say average as far as arm strength. He has good reactions to balls hit towards him, but you have to admit that he is not what you'd call "quick". But Cabrera can certainly be his equal defensively there, and meanwhile you're getting him out of left field where he was way below average.

 

Exactly.

 

Cabrera at third and a puppy in left-field >>>>> Lowell at third and Cabrera in left-field.

My predictions for the NL East:

 

1 Altanta Braves - Over 90s wins once more and they make the playoffs bfore getting pretty much nowhere again

2 Washington Nationals- Yeah I think their defense and pitching will surprise folks again with a solid year

3 Philadelphia Phillies - Their bats and pitching actually will carry them I think Madisen does well and ends up the closer

4 NYM - They will have injury problems with Pedro, Wagner and some others. I think they falter early and then late. Heck they are the mets.

5 Marlins - 100 losses I think, but I will enjoy watching the kids anyways

Delgado, Cabrera, Pierre and Easley were butchers. I'm talking bottom five at their positions. LoDuca's right there as well. Lowell has no range. Gonzalez had an off-year. Our only quality defender was Castillo and he was out much of the year. It was awful. With Reed, Aguila, Ramirez, Cabrera comfortable, hermida we have plus defenders again.

 

There is an article on mlb.com saying the Marlins had the worst defense in the NL. So, like you said, yes, we can only improve.

From the data I've seen, the Reds did, but who's counting anyway?

 

Experience plays a part for sure. But remember the numbers include these intangibles in their measurements, they don't ignore them, they simply don't put spotlight them like some wish they would. Two other key attributes to good defense is athleticism and dedication. With fresh legs fighting to prove themselves, this club should be expected ti improve on the defense. And that should help the pitching.

they might be hungry and talented but just remember that there will be PLENTY of rookie mistakes out there ... lots of singles that turn into doubles or triples and such which leads to runs which could also affect the pitchers concentration ... you cant simply rule out that all these things will happen, history tells us that

 

im not putting down the capabilities of these kids but like you said rferry ... but there are all those intangibles involved also dont foret about stadium dimensions and how unfamiliar they are to them

True. Their eagerness might cause them to get to more balls that an overpaid veteran with a good reputation in the middle of his contract, but some of those are not going to played right. Their concentration (or lack of it) will result in a few misplayed balls too. However, it's a not a stretch to say these players are better defenders. Whether their careers last as long or they still hold these skills then, we shall see (and frankly, is half the fun).

That's well written Swift....I'll give you credit for that. But I'm sorry I can't give you credit for better reasoning. To think the Marlins will win 75 games this year is just a fan's wishful thinking. I'm a fan too, but I don't think this wish will come true. The pitching is just not there...not this year. Anyway, what's the difference really. If it makes any of you feel better to think the Marlins will win 75 games and/or not finish in last place...then be my guest. I really don't care if we finish ahead or behind the Nationals this year. I'd rather see progress....NO INJURIES from rushing along the youngsters...and we'll compete again in another year.

 

 

I am not sure you understand how bad a team has to be to win only 56 games. From a statistical perspective, if the team is slightly below average offensively (say 700 runs scored) the pitching would have to give up about 1000 runs to lose 106 games. That's an ERA of over 6. I don't think a single team in the NL last year even came close to that. It just won't happen. They may lose 95-98 games, but I doubt it.

I understand. I sat through 1998, which was not all that horrible for a true fan. It's not all about wins. We had Derrick Lee, Renteria, Cliff Floyd, and you could arguably include Craig Counsell on that team.....all prospects that went on to be productive players. If 4 of our 7 everyday player prospects turn out this good, it will be fine. That year the team ERA was 5.20. The team scored an average of 4 runs per game. And they lost 108 games. I think projecting out how these youngsters with just a handful of games in the Majors will do over the course of a long season is crazy. Offensively or defensively. But the main problem is the inexperienced pitchers with great potential. To expect these pitchers to perform well consistently is out of the question..impossible. Yea, we'll see good starts from Vargas, Mitre, Olsen, Johnson. But we'll also see many starts where the team finds itself down 5 runs in the third. Especially past the 100 inning mark. Things could get ugly. But it could still be a rewarding season for a fan if we see progress from the youngsters, and NO INJURIES.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.