Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Trade Anyone

Featured Replies

You never did say what you think a fair asking price for Freel is.

 

If I was the Reds I would want 1 or 2 bullpen pitchers depending on who they are. That is our most glaring weakness right now,

 

We'll give you Nate Bump.

No, but I will give you Tony Womack for him.

 

How about you take them both and give us a Griffey signed baseball.

blue ink, on the sweet spot

Only if you throw in an autograph to be named later.

 

Done.

 

 

*fails to mention it will be a Franklyn Gracesqui signed ball*

Seems fair. I'm not really sure what BP arms you'd consider...guys that are on club right now, guys in the system that are starting but could go fit nicely into a bullpen?

 

I'll tell you who I'd rather have from the Reds, is Chris Denforia...moreso than Freel because of age and potential.

Seems fair. I'm not really sure what BP arms you'd consider...guys that are on club right now, guys in the system that are starting but could go fit nicely into a bullpen?

 

I'll tell you who I'd rather have from the Reds, is Chris Denforia...moreso than Freel because of age and potential.

 

Not getting Deno.

Going into today, Miguel Olivo was batting .273/.333/.364 with 1 BB, 1 K, and 1 2B. Reggie Abercrombie was hitting .250/.333/.250 with 1 BB and 0 K. They were tied for the third highest OBP on the team behind Shadez and Hermida, tied at .500.

 

Not exactly gaping holes in the offense.

I like Josh Willingham and want to see him in the lineup everyday. That said, I don't know how anyone can't see the difference between Olivo's and Willingham's catching skillsets and think for a minute Josh is in the same league (no pun intended).

 

 

I've been surprisingly impressed with Olivo's defense behind the dish. His arm throwing out runners is fantastic. He does need to improving his blocking skills though.

 

And then Willy had a web-gem type diving catch in LF the other day, so his LF defense is quite serviceable so far (certainly better than Cabrera's when they tried him in RF a few years back).

 

All being said, I wouldn't be surprised if they decide to leave Willingham in LF on a permanent basis.

Going into today, Miguel Olivo was batting .273/.333/.364 with 1 BB, 1 K, and 1 2B. Reggie Abercrombie was hitting .250/.333/.250 with 1 BB and 0 K. They were tied for the third highest OBP on the team behind Shadez and Hermida, tied at .500.

 

Not exactly gaping holes in the offense.

 

They'll get their shots, but I doubt they're long-term options for us. Like always, I hope for breakout seasons for our guys.

 

Also, the Olivo/Abercrombie lines as of today...

 

Olivo .200/.250/.267

Abercrombie .167/.167/.231

 

This doesn't much matter because of the small sample size, except when you consider Abercrombie's blah minor league numbers and Olivo's terrible major league numbers in the AL...140 or so NL at bats notwithstanding. I definitely think Olivo has a better shot at sticking than Abercrombie, though, because of those successful NL at bats.

I'd love to get Brandon Moss from Boston, although not sure if he can play center, and the asking price would probably be high(although, with the trade for WMP, and the acquisition of Crisp, he might be much more attainable).

 

I disagree about Willingham sticking permanently behind the plate, not due to lack of skill in LF but because if he can learn the C position well enough then we can add another potential big bat in Retsko or Harvey @ LF and also leave Hammer @ C.

Going into today, Miguel Olivo was batting .273/.333/.364 with 1 BB, 1 K, and 1 2B. Reggie Abercrombie was hitting .250/.333/.250 with 1 BB and 0 K. They were tied for the third highest OBP on the team behind Shadez and Hermida, tied at .500.

 

Not exactly gaping holes in the offense.

They'll get their shots, but I doubt they're long-term options for us. Like always, I hope for breakout seasons for our guys.

 

Also, the Olivo/Abercrombie lines as of today...

 

Olivo .200/.250/.267

Abercrombie .167/.167/.231

 

This doesn't much matter because of the small sample size, except when you consider Abercrombie's blah minor league numbers and Olivo's terrible major league numbers in the AL...140 or so NL at bats notwithstanding. I definitely think Olivo has a better shot at sticking than Abercrombie, though, because of those successful NL at bats.All you have to do is look at the difference between the stats I posted and the ones you posted to know this topic has zero reason to exist right now. In the course of just one game look how much those stat lines dipped (which, btw, Reggie's OBP in yours is wrong). Let's have this talk again in a month, maybe.

 

Regardless of the stats, I think Olivo is a guy we should want to have around for a long time. Catchers of his defensive prowess are very difficult to come by, and they have such an effect on the rest of the game that whatever they produce with the bat is a plus. By the time we settle in to our long term options at 2B and CF, I hope we come to realize that what he brings to the table is worth the lack of production if for some reason that happens to be the case. Then again, he's liked the NL so far, so let's not assume the new Bass just yet.

Going into today, Miguel Olivo was batting .273/.333/.364 with 1 BB, 1 K, and 1 2B. Reggie Abercrombie was hitting .250/.333/.250 with 1 BB and 0 K. They were tied for the third highest OBP on the team behind Shadez and Hermida, tied at .500.

 

Not exactly gaping holes in the offense.

They'll get their shots, but I doubt they're long-term options for us. Like always, I hope for breakout seasons for our guys.

 

Also, the Olivo/Abercrombie lines as of today...

 

Olivo .200/.250/.267

Abercrombie .167/.167/.231

 

This doesn't much matter because of the small sample size, except when you consider Abercrombie's blah minor league numbers and Olivo's terrible major league numbers in the AL...140 or so NL at bats notwithstanding. I definitely think Olivo has a better shot at sticking than Abercrombie, though, because of those successful NL at bats.All you have to do is look at the difference between the stats I posted and the ones you posted to know this topic has zero reason to exist right now. In the course of just one game look how much those stat lines dipped (which, btw, Reggie's OBP in yours is wrong). Let's have this talk again in a month, maybe.

they're the numbers as posted by mlb.com and I think they're correct.

 

The convo can happen when anyone wants to take it up...for CF especially, since neither Reed or Abercrombie are legit long-term options for the future.

 

 

Going into today, Miguel Olivo was batting .273/.333/.364 with 1 BB, 1 K, and 1 2B. Reggie Abercrombie was hitting .250/.333/.250 with 1 BB and 0 K. They were tied for the third highest OBP on the team behind Shadez and Hermida, tied at .500.

 

Not exactly gaping holes in the offense.

They'll get their shots, but I doubt they're long-term options for us. Like always, I hope for breakout seasons for our guys.

 

Also, the Olivo/Abercrombie lines as of today...

 

Olivo .200/.250/.267

Abercrombie .167/.167/.231

 

This doesn't much matter because of the small sample size, except when you consider Abercrombie's blah minor league numbers and Olivo's terrible major league numbers in the AL...140 or so NL at bats notwithstanding. I definitely think Olivo has a better shot at sticking than Abercrombie, though, because of those successful NL at bats.All you have to do is look at the difference between the stats I posted and the ones you posted to know this topic has zero reason to exist right now. In the course of just one game look how much those stat lines dipped (which, btw, Reggie's OBP in yours is wrong). Let's have this talk again in a month, maybe.

 

Regardless of the stats, I think Olivo is a guy we should want to have around for a long time. Catchers of his defensive prowess are very difficult to come by, and they have such an effect on the rest of the game that whatever they produce with the bat is a plus. By the time we settle in to our long term options at 2B and CF, I hope we come to realize that what he brings to the table is worth the lack of production if for some reason that happens to be the case. Then again, he's liked the NL so far, so let's not assume the new Bass just yet.

Completely disagree on your opinion of a catcher's defense impacting greatly on a game, especially when negated by a non-existent bat. Olivo is not a lost cause because he's young enough to breakthrough and had a very good 2nd half last year in an extreme pitcher's park. All-glove no-hit catchers arn't that tough to find on the FA pile, though, so if he doesn't start hitting this year I hope you wouldn't advocate a long-term deal (when's his FA day come up?) for something we could get at the veteran minimum.

after 5 games at least the guys are playing the best they can Now at least they get some Home Town crowd.

So, Shamrock, who would you like to see us get as a real long term answer in CF then?

 

Not really sure, but I don't think the answer is in-house. I also think we're a good ways off from making a trade because we need to first slide Olsen/Johnson/Nolasco into the rotation to see what we've got. I'm quite certain that the FO will trade for a CFer this season, though.

So, Shamrock, who would you like to see us get as a real long term answer in CF then?

 

Ryan Freel

:mischief

So, Shamrock, who would you like to see us get as a real long term answer in CF then?

 

Ryan Freel

:mischief

He's one of my favorite players in the game, but he just doesn't align with our rebuilding phase. =[

Completely disagree on your opinion of a catcher's defense impacting greatly on a game, especially when negating by a non-existent bat. Olivo is not a lost cause because he's young enough to breakthrough and had a very good 2nd half last year in an extreme pitcher's park. All-glove no-hit catchers arn't that tough to find on the FA pile, though, so if he doesn't start hitting this year I hope you wouldn't advocate a long-term deal (when's his FA day come up?) for something we could get at the veteran minimum.

Well I only say that those aren't accurate because I vividly remember seeing Abercrombie be walked at least once earlier this week. Not attacking the messenger, I'm throwing stones at the message.

 

Catchers that call good games, throw 98 MPH to second base, and have Olivo's glove are not dime a dozen, and they have enough of an impact on the game that they should be made room for. They manage the staff better than others, which in and of itself negates the lack of offensive production because when a catcher behind the plate is doing his thing properly it's having a rather large impact on the amount of runs scored by the other team. A run saved (-1 for them) is just as good as a run scored (+1 for you) in my book, because they're the same when you consider the +/- of it all. We've seen all too often in 2004 and 2005 runners running around at will behind inept throwing catchers and pitchers who seemed more interested in their radar reading than the guy at first. With a catcher that can not only keep the runners at bay by checking them with snap throws and throwing them out at a good rate but also gets the pitchers to shorten their moves and calls timely throws to first, runs are held back because runners can't get in scoring position. If the catcher is keen on calling a good game, the offense of the other team will be stimied.

 

At any other position you may be right, but since catchers along with pitchers have such a large say in the offensive production of the other team, the defensive aspect of their presence is much more important than their offense. From a LF I could see the great bat and whatever glove you can get is a plus argument working, but not for a catcher. Catchers need to gun down baserunners, they need to be experts with the glove, and they need to be able to manage a pitching staff flawlessly. And catchers like that are very hard to find so when you get one you hang onto him for as long as you possibly can.

 

Besides, it isn't guaranteed Olivo isn't going to bat anyways.

What do you think about Moss from Boston...I think he'd be easier attainable now with the Sawx additions to the OF this offseason.

 

I agree that the option isn't in house, unless we can just find a complete stud college CF in the draft that will be ready in a year or two.

What do you think about Moss from Boston...I think he'd be easier attainable now with the Sawx additions to the OF this offseason.

 

I agree that the option isn't in house, unless we can just find a complete stud college CF in the draft that will be ready in a year or two.

 

Granderson and Gathright can both be had

Not a big fan of Gathright, which is well known...and all said, Gathright isn't hitting worth a crap right now. Why even bring him up...it's just easy access to another MarlinsLOu/My3Username debate over the potential greatness/ineptitude of the guy.

 

And are you sure Granderson is available...playing well right now.

 

I'd still rather have Moss, if he can indeed play CF.

.318/.400/.682 for Granderson, I really do doubt he is available.

 

6 games, and wasn't he available before the season?

We'll have to agree to disagree then. We might be getting caught up in the velocity that Olivo throws the ball with, I dunno. I don't think I've seen one snap throw this entire season so far. I just don't think the defense or gamecalling of a catcher has as big an affect on the game as you're arguing. I'd much rather have an average defender/gamecaller with above average defensive skills. I don't know where Olivo gained the reputation as an incredible defensive catcher anyway..I knew he was above average, but people are starting to talk like he's a god or something. Did I miss a scouting report or are we just going on homeristic, subjective observation?

We'll have to agree to disagree then. We might be getting caught up in the velocity that Olivo throws the ball with, I dunno. I don't think I've seen one snap throw this entire season so far. I just don't think the defense or gamecalling of a catcher has as big an affect on the game as you're arguing. I'd much rather have an average defender/gamecaller with above average defensive skills. I don't know where Olivo gained the reputation as an incredible defensive catcher anyway..I knew he was above average, but people are starting to talk like he's a god or something. Did I miss a scouting report or are we just going on homeristic, subjective observation?

 

 

i think we're just comparing him to lo duca. that's why we're easily impressed.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.