April 10, 200620 yr Granderson and Gathright can both be had There is absolutely no way Curtis is avaliable. None. 0%. And that was before this season. He and Shelton are their cornerstone offensive players they are building around. Ryan Freel would also be tremendous for the Marlins. He makes $1.3 and $1.7-2 (incentives) the next two seasons, and then has an arbitration year after that. Marlins would be wise to get a 2B/CF that can produce a .360+ OBP and excellent defense.
April 10, 200620 yr We'll have to agree to disagree then. We might be getting caught up in the velocity that Olivo throws the ball with, I dunno. I don't think I've seen one snap throw this entire season so far. I just don't think the defense or gamecalling of a catcher has as big an affect on the game as you're arguing. I'd much rather have an average defender/gamecaller with above average defensive skills. I don't know where Olivo gained the reputation as an incredible defensive catcher anyway..I knew he was above average, but people are starting to talk like he's a god or something. Did I miss a scouting report or are we just going on homeristic, subjective observation? i think we're just comparing him to lo duca. that's why we're easily impressed. that's not an arugment worth having, because Lo Duca was far too old and expensive to be on this club. Those factors aside, I'd take Lo Duca. Granderson and Gathright can both be had There is absolutely no way Curtis is avaliable. None. 0%. And that was before this season. He and Shelton are their cornerstone offensive players they are building around. Ryan Freel would also be tremendous for the Marlins. He makes $1.3 and $1.7-2 (incentives) the next two seasons, and then has an arbitration year after that. Marlins would be wise to get a 2B/CF that can produce a .360+ OBP and excellent defense. Maybe with the acquisition of Phillips and the hot start of Womack, Freel could be had...
April 10, 200620 yr We'll have to agree to disagree then. We might be getting caught up in the velocity that Olivo throws the ball with, I dunno. I don't think I've seen one snap throw this entire season so far. I just don't think the defense or gamecalling of a catcher has as big an affect on the game as you're arguing. I'd much rather have an average defender/gamecaller with above average defensive skills. I don't know where Olivo gained the reputation as an incredible defensive catcher anyway..I knew he was above average, but people are starting to talk like he's a god or something. Did I miss a scouting report or are we just going on homeristic, subjective observation? I can honestly say I haven't read a single of his scouting reports, but I used to periodically watch White Sox and Mariner games to partially to see how he was doing. What can I say, I'm a sucker for catchers - I watch certain teams just because I like their backstops. As far as the snap throws go, no he hasn't done one yet this masterfully long six game season. But he did it several times in ST and he always seemed to do at least one or two when I would catch his games. As far as "homeristic, subjective view"...maybe. But defensive stats are just as reliable as the naked eye, mainly because they're just as subjective. Who decides passed ball or wild pitch? A scorekeeper. Not like a homer or a ground out that is determined by the players on the field. And when it comes to catching I prefer to judge my own experience rather than the subjectivity of someone else, because I don't know what the experience is of whoever else is judging him play. And in my own time watching Olivo and watching several others catch, I'd easily put Olivo ahead of 2/3 of the league defensively and as far as general skills are concerned. Also easily the best we've had since Pudge was here. As a sidebar, I'm kind of confused by the bolded statement though I'm guessing it was a slip of the hand. Clarify, please? i think we're just comparing him to lo duca. that's why we're easily impressed. I'm not, but maybe that's just me. The only time I think about Olivo compared to our previous catchers is when I consider the amount of base runners we've let run wild.
April 10, 200620 yr We'll have to agree to disagree then. We might be getting caught up in the velocity that Olivo throws the ball with, I dunno. I don't think I've seen one snap throw this entire season so far. I just don't think the defense or gamecalling of a catcher has as big an affect on the game as you're arguing. I'd much rather have an average defender/gamecaller with above average defensive skills. I don't know where Olivo gained the reputation as an incredible defensive catcher anyway..I knew he was above average, but people are starting to talk like he's a god or something. Did I miss a scouting report or are we just going on homeristic, subjective observation? i think we're just comparing him to lo duca. that's why we're easily impressed. that's not an arugment worth having, because Lo Duca was far too old and expensive to be on this club. Those factors aside, I'd take Lo Duca. ok. you asked specifically about his defense and that was my answer. i wasn't saying he's a better all around player than lo duca.
April 10, 200620 yr I'm sure Sham meant that he'd rather have an average defensive catcher who can hit, over an above average defensive catcher who can't.
April 10, 200620 yr I'm sure Sham meant that he'd rather have an average defensive catcher who can hit, over an above average defensive catcher who can't. ya, did, sorry bout that. just one final thing. only reason i mentioned that there hasn't been a snap throw yet this season was to show the incredibly minimal affect that event has on a game's outcome...6 games or not.
April 10, 200620 yr We'll have to agree to disagree then. We might be getting caught up in the velocity that Olivo throws the ball with, I dunno. I don't think I've seen one snap throw this entire season so far. I just don't think the defense or gamecalling of a catcher has as big an affect on the game as you're arguing. I'd much rather have an average defender/gamecaller with above average defensive skills. I don't know where Olivo gained the reputation as an incredible defensive catcher anyway..I knew he was above average, but people are starting to talk like he's a god or something. Did I miss a scouting report or are we just going on homeristic, subjective observation? Olivo is very athletic, which people confuse with general defensive abilities. He does not rate as anything more then a league average defender, nothing notable. He's probably a decent upgrade over Willingham, but that's just because Josh has his own issues. I take the offense at catcher versus whatever weak hitting/defensive upgrade Olivo/decent starting C brings to the table. I'm speaking long term also. I have no problems letting Olivo catch 100 games this season, but when this franchise decides to get real outfielders besides an assortment of AA and AAA players, Willingham should be catching, even if we lose 30+ games of his offense. What's better in these scenarios, assuming we get a decent LF in a year or two, whether it's Restko, Harvey, or some FA when we (or San Antonio) can expand payroll. Option A C Willingham 125+ Games, .800+ OPS Below Average Def C Backup Dude 30+ Games, .650+ OPS Good Def LF Starting Guy, 150+ Games, .782+ OPS Average-League Def (16th best OPS LF) Option B C Some Average Starter, 125+ Games .728+ OPS Good Def (16th best OPS C) C Backup Dude, 30+ Games, .650+ OPS Good Def LF Willingham 150+ Games, .800+ OPS Below Average Def I choose the 16th guy for a realistic projection of an average league starter the Marlins could stumble into in a year or two. They were Ibanez and Piersynski in 2005 for curiosity's sake. What does all of this mean? It's a blowout. Option A is going to turn out better offensively and defensively. On offense, I'll take a real LF for 150 games over a normal catcher and 25 extra games of Willingham. Most sane people would do this as well. Likewise on defense, having a guy that can play defense in LF versus a bad LF presence in Willingham makes up for any lost defense from the catcher position. I personally think this is better, but I can understand if anyone wants to give defense a "wash" in this scenario depending on how bad a catcher you think Willingham is. I'm talking Piazza bad here also. As Rferry usually points out when these threads pop up, there is way more runs to be lost on defense with a bad LF versus a bad C. He's right. Defense at catcher does not kill you. Obviously you want as much defense as possible, but catcher is pretty much the one position you can live without it IF Willingham is going to be a Varitek level hitter. I do believe that. It is far and away better to lose his bat for part of the season and take the smaller defensive hit, rather then getting starts in LF and taking a larger defensive hit. When we get any sort of OF better then Olivo on offense, Willingham should immediatly catch 5 days a week. Isn't that an amazing statement. When we get an OUTFIELDER that can hit better then OLIVO. (There is one variable to this scenario longterm, if the Marlins trade SP to the Dodgers for Martin/Navarro, or the Braves don't care about trading McCann in a year when Saltamacchia is ready, sure, throw Hammer in LF. But I think the odds of us finding a viable catcher that will produce at excellent levels is going to be a lot harder to find then a LF down the road. It's pretty much common sense.) Getting this back to the thread, we really need to bring anything into the outfield, specifically CF because we atleast have hope with Restko and Harvey in a few years. I'm open to getting practically anyone, because the 3 of them we have now in LF/CF are not short or long term answers, and combined with Uggla, create the worst 6-7-8 in the National League. I would look for short term options in a corner outfielder (still have to be careful with Willingham as a catcher and don't want to entirely block him from a starting slot with a young alternative in LF right now if he indeed can't catch at all), and more long term options in CF. Don't really want to speculate on names, but I hope this gets done sooner rather then later.
April 10, 200620 yr Pretty much agree with you...my 2nd bolded comment was a mistake on my part. I'd prefer offense ala Willingham.
April 10, 200620 yr I prefer Willingham mainly because we can have his bat @ C and we have 2 guys...Retsko or Harvey...who could provide good offense from the left corner in the very near future.
April 10, 200620 yr It's been 5 games. :o Common sense? :mischief I know you're just joking around, but the three amigos have never shown much in the minor leagues, except Aguila with some nice years in the PCL. Common sense is to have atleast 1 veteran OF on the roster to be able to log innings, and not have three guys that have low chances of being bench players. :confused
April 10, 200620 yr It's been 5 games. :o Common sense? :mischief I know you're just joking around, but the three amigos have never shown much in the minor leagues, except Aguila with some nice years in the PCL. Aguila had a good year in Carolina too(believe he won the batting title) just sayin..
April 10, 200620 yr It's been 5 games. do u really trust in olivo or abercrombie or agila ? No, but I trust in Abercrombie and Aguila.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.