Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2006 All-Star Game Selection Show

Featured Replies

The fact the team with the 3rd best record in the NL gets 1 player, and the Pirates, Phillies, Braves, Rockies, and Marlins get multiple players is a joke

 

The All Star game is an individual showcase...whether or not a player has better guys around him should not be a factor (not to mention the Reds wouldn't be doing so well if they didn't have the easiest schedule in baseball up to this point)

Pirates got the second all star game just because it's in Pittsburgh, that's understandable...with the rest of the teams, you can't really say Chase Utley, Ryan Howard, Brian Fuentes, Matt Holliday, Miguel Cabrera, and Dan Uggla aren't deserving....The Braves getting two is kind of questionable, but McCann definitely deserves it and ANdruw Jones got it due to being a name player...No way does Renteria deserve it over Bill Hall

Normally, I'm not against the one player on every team rule, but when there isn't anyone close to deserving to be on the team, they have to make an exception to the rule and say the team doesn't get any all stars, i.e. Mark Redman this year and Mike Williams in 03. I have no problems with guys like Brian Fuentes last year or Barry Zito this year making it because of that rule.

The fact the team with the 3rd best record in the NL gets 1 player, and the Pirates, Phillies, Braves, Rockies, and Marlins get multiple players is a joke

 

The All Star game is an individual showcase...whether or not a player has better guys around him should not be a factor (not to mention the Reds wouldn't be doing so well if they didn't have the easiest schedule in baseball up to this point)

Pirates got the second all star game just because it's in Pittsburgh, that's understandable...with the rest of the teams, you can't really say Chase Utley, Ryan Howard, Brian Fuentes, Matt Holliday, Miguel Cabrera, and Dan Uggla aren't deserving....The Braves getting two is kind of questionable, but McCann definitely deserves it and ANdruw Jones got it due to being a name player

How about catcher?

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...=34&compare.y=9

 

How about Andruw Jones?

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...erLocator=Jones

The fact the team with the 3rd best record in the NL gets 1 player, and the Pirates, Phillies, Braves, Rockies, and Marlins get multiple players is a joke

 

The All Star game is an individual showcase...whether or not a player has better guys around him should not be a factor (not to mention the Reds wouldn't be doing so well if they didn't have the easiest schedule in baseball up to this point)

Pirates got the second all star game just because it's in Pittsburgh, that's understandable...with the rest of the teams, you can't really say Chase Utley, Ryan Howard, Brian Fuentes, Matt Holliday, Miguel Cabrera, and Dan Uggla aren't deserving....The Braves getting two is kind of questionable, but McCann definitely deserves it and ANdruw Jones got it due to being a name player

How about catcher?

 

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...=34&compare.y=9

 

How about Andruw Jones?

http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/stats/sortab...erLocator=Jones

Lo Duca only got in because he was voted in, so there's no point in discussing him, but McCann definitely deserved the backup catcher spot...Ross has put up great numbers, but you can't really put someone on the all star game with just 130 plate appearances

As for Andruw Jones, read the part I bolded

All stars former teams:

Marlins: 6

Red Sox: 5

Pirates: 4

Rangers: 4

Yankees: 4

Athletics: 4

Padres: 3

Royals: 3

Astros: 3

Braves: 3

Dodgers: 3

Twins: 3

Indians: 2

Phillies: 2

Cubs: 2

White Sox: 2

Mariners: 2

Expos/ Nationals: 2

Angels: 2

Mets: 2

Orioles: 2

Blue Jays: 2

Brewers: 1

Diamondbacks: 1

Cardinals: 1

Tigers: 1

Reds: 1

 

By farm system:

Yankees: 5

Blue Jays: 5

Braves: 5

Mariners: 5

Phillies: 4

Mets: 3

Expos/ Nationals: 3

Diamondbacks: 3

Dodgers: 3

Indians: 2

Twins: 2

Rangers: 2

Athletics: 2

Angels: 2

Astros: 2

Red Sox: 2

Marlins: 2

White Sox: 2

Reds: 2

Royals: 2

Brewers: 1

Padres: 1

Cardinals: 1

Rockies: 1

Pirates: 1

Cubs: 1

I know how ya feel FeLo.. you had other deserving players.. to the Mets fans and team, congrats.. but just because you have a lot of Mets on the team may seem cool it's not always the best of things for an ASG (Cards in 2004 Example)..

 

Anyways I would have just been fine with Pujols making it.. Carpenter may not look All-Star worthy with his 6-4 record but he's had a hell of a year despite missing time.. just hasnt had the team support.. and I'm really glad for Rolen who was on the edge of missing mainly because the 3B position is just that damn good in this league.. leaving him off woulda been a little tough considering he's having one hell of a comeback year honestly.. so I'm glad they made it.. woulda been fine with just one Card though..

Who would your NL All-Star Team be?

 

Here's how I wouldv'e done it:

C - Brian McCann (Atl)*

C - David Ross (Cin)

 

1B - Albert Pujols (StL)*

1B - Nomar Garciaparra (LA)

1B - Lance Berkman (Hou)

 

2B - Chase Utley (Phi)*

2B - Dan Uggla (Fla)

 

SS - Jose Reyes (NyM)*

SS - Edgar Renteria (Atl)

 

3B - Miguel Cabrera (Fla)*

3B - David Wright (NyM)

3B - Scott Rolen (StL)

 

OF - Matt Holliday (Col)*

OF - Carlos Beltran (NyM)*

OF - Carlos Lee (Mil)

OF - Jason Bay (Pit)* (Gets the start because the game is in Pittsburgh. If not, Lee would get the start for me)

OF - Adam Dunn (Cin)

OF - Brad Hawpe (Col)

OF - Alfonso Soriano (Was) (Without any limitations, would not be picked. Selected to fill Washington's spot)

 

* = Starter

I know how ya feel FeLo.. you had other deserving players.. to the Mets fans and team, congrats.. but just because you have a lot of Mets on the team may seem cool it's not always the best of things for an ASG (Cards in 2004 Example)..

 

 

No doubt. Smart baseball fans who think their team has a chance at making the playoffs should vote for the best players in their league and the worst players in the other league that have a chance at winning the fan vote. At least as long as WS home field advantage is determined by the ASG.

Carl Crawford getting the royal screwjob.

I know how ya feel FeLo.. you had other deserving players.. to the Mets fans and team, congrats.. but just because you have a lot of Mets on the team may seem cool it's not always the best of things for an ASG (Cards in 2004 Example)..

 

Anyways I would have just been fine with Pujols making it.. Carpenter may not look All-Star worthy with his 6-4 record but he's had a hell of a year despite missing time.. just hasnt had the team support.. and I'm really glad for Rolen who was on the edge of missing mainly because the 3B position is just that damn good in this league.. leaving him off woulda been a little tough considering he's having one hell of a comeback year honestly.. so I'm glad they made it.. woulda been fine with just one Card though..

 

 

Wait ... a Cards fan is upset because the Mets fans stuffed the boxes? You'll have to excuse for not crying for you. 5 out of 6 Mets that made the team deserve their spots. One is questionable, and if there was any player having a great year at catcher in the NL they would have made it instead. And before we get all weepy about David Ross, the guy isn't even starting fulltime for the Reds. Now why don't you go vote for So Taguchi another 25 times.

Wait ... a Cards fan is upset because the Mets fans stuffed the boxes? You'll have to excuse for not crying for you. 5 out of 6 Mets that made the team deserve their spots. One is questionable, and if there was any player having a great year at catcher in the NL they would have made it instead. And before we get all weepy about David Ross, the guy isn't even starting fulltime for the Reds. Now why don't you go vote for So Taguchi another 25 times.

 

 

Did I say anything about being upset? hell f'n no.. like I said the ASG means sh*t if you dont win.. doesnt always work out because your whole team is on the NL team.. that's all I was saying but put words in my mouth if ya wish.. but yes I'm crying even though I said I'd be just fine with one all-star from the Cards on the team :rolleyes: ..

If Jose Reyes is out of the game, who is taking his place? Eckstein?

 

Brandon Phillips can play SS.........

If Jose Reyes is out of the game, who is taking his place? Eckstein?

 

 

Either Bill Hall, Omar Vizquel, David Eckstein or Hanley. I'd pick Vizquel, but Eckstein will probably get the nod if Reyes is out.

If Jose Reyes is out of the game, who is taking his place? Eckstein?

 

 

Either Bill Hall, Omar Vizquel, David Eckstein or Hanley. I'd pick Vizquel, but Eckstein will probably get the nod if Reyes is out.

Hall--.270/17/41

 

Omar--.303/3/27

 

Eck--.311/1/19

 

i'll give my vote to david..

If Jose Reyes is out of the game, who is taking his place? Eckstein?

 

 

Either Bill Hall, Omar Vizquel, David Eckstein or Hanley. I'd pick Vizquel, but Eckstein will probably get the nod if Reyes is out.

Hall--.270/17/41

 

Omar--.303/3/27

 

Eck--.311/1/19

 

i'll give my vote to david..

Or

 

.315/7/44

 

Now who does your vote go to?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.