Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Another CF Idea

Featured Replies

Sullivan has simply put up better #s than Taveras, so Im not sure what you're talking about

Trading Dontrelle for Milledge is probably the worst idea I've ever heard.

As far as Taveras is concerned, I would like to think 2 or all 3 of Mitre, Vargas, & Petit could get it done, and niether really have a place or role here, so no meaningful loss. I agree that if significant pitching is required for this deal then I wouldn't do it.

Edmonds would be nice, but I'm not yet convinced that someone like him would be anything more than a pipe-dream. I don't see the team throwing another 7-10M on top of the payroll for a FA and I also don't think they are trading Willis or Cabrera.

 

It's actually not if they get Pelfrey in the deal as well. If that's all you value Willy at, I have no problem. But I don't see that happening. Petit in a flyball park is a terrible idea, and the other two are throw in types, not main pieces. I can see them asking for Nolasco + Pinto or J. Garcia for him. Let alone one one of them. I'd be very surprised if Edmonds gets more then $7, which is expensive, but that's 40% less of what he was making last year and that's affordable to the Marlins if they move to the $25ish payroll level. Lofton, Payton, and Dellucci are probably all in the $3-4 annual range looking for 2-3 year deals. They won't be guaranteed starting spots in a lot of places, but here they would be. I think that's a very big positive the Marlins can offer CF free agents - playing time.

I'll just ask the obvious - why would Sullivan be cheaper than Taveras? Not like Taveras plays for Tampa or something.

 

 

Sullivan's relative cheapness tradewise is due to a number of things. First, he is coming off a somewhat off year offensively, getting less hits and striking out at a higher rate (though he did show improvement in his power numbers, hitting more doubles and triples). Second, there has been conflict recently between the Rockies FO and Sullivan. This September, the Rockies requested he play winterball in Mexico to work on his hitting and he refused. Not the best idea to flatout refuse a request like this if you plan on staying with a club longterm. Third, Swift noted that he heard rumors the Rockies are going to be trying to sign Edmonds this coming offseason (a definite sign Sullivan is on his way out if it is true). Lastly, the Rockies have no shortage of backup CF. The primary backup is Choo Freeman, but besides Freeman they also have Ryan Spilborghs and Jeff Salazar. I think all of these factors would work toward making a deal for Sullivan cheaper than Taveras. At least that is my take on the situation.

I'd be very surprised if Edmonds gets more then $7, which is expensive, but that's 40% less of what he was making last year and that's affordable to the Marlins if they move to the $25ish payroll level. Lofton, Payton, and Dellucci are probably all in the $3-4 annual range looking for 2-3 year deals. They won't be guaranteed starting spots in a lot of places, but here they would be. I think that's a very big positive the Marlins can offer CF free agents - playing time.

 

If the Marlins signed either Edmonds or Payton, that would be great. But I would have some concerns about Lofton and Dellucci. With Lofton, it is mainly the age factor. He had a good 2006 campaign, but how much longer will it be before he starts his decline? He will be turning 40 in May. With Dellucci, we would be signing a corner outfielder to play CF regularly. Not only that, but a corner outfielder to playing CF regularly who is pretty much useless vs LHP facing alot of LHP (that is if we make that guarantee you mention of getting a starting spot). If we are talking about free agents at the Jay Payton type level, I'd add Dave Roberts to the mix and rank him very near Payton as CF free agent the Marlins should consider signing.

I can't recall how good Dave Roberts is defensively, but if he's even above average, i'd love that signing. I've always been a fan of his.

I can't recall how good Dave Roberts is defensively, but if he's even above average, i'd love that signing. I've always been a fan of his.

I'd like to see him too. But I don't think he's really that great of a player, and I don't think he could help us much. I just like the guy.

I can't recall how good Dave Roberts is defensively, but if he's even above average, i'd love that signing. I've always been a fan of his.

Roberts is damn good defensivly. Finally I agree with someone. He'd be an awesome addition.

I wonder what Mr. Fox thinks of him, he got to watch him for a full season with the BoSox.

  • Author

I'll just ask the obvious - why would Sullivan be cheaper than Taveras? Not like Taveras plays for Tampa or something.

 

Sullivan's relative cheapness tradewise is due to a number of things. First, he is coming off a somewhat off year offensively, getting less hits and striking out at a higher rate (though he did show improvement in his power numbers, hitting more doubles and triples). Second, there has been conflict recently between the Rockies FO and Sullivan. This September, the Rockies requested he play winterball in Mexico to work on his hitting and he refused. Not the best idea to flatout refuse a request like this if you plan on staying with a club longterm. Third, Swift noted that he heard rumors the Rockies are going to be trying to sign Edmonds this coming offseason (a definite sign Sullivan is on his way out if it is true). Lastly, the Rockies have no shortage of backup CF. The primary backup is Choo Freeman, but besides Freeman they also have Ryan Spilborghs and Jeff Salazar. I think all of these factors would work toward making a deal for Sullivan cheaper than Taveras. At least that is my take on the situation.

Maybe I'm wrong, but that sounds just like an argument as to why another team might expect us to give up pitching for lower value (because we have a surplus). Just because they have more than they can use doesn't mean they will be giving it away. And what needs are the Rockies trying to fill?

And on a side note, do you think it wise for the FO to pursue a guy who already has problems with the team he's on?

I'll just ask the obvious - why would Sullivan be cheaper than Taveras? Not like Taveras plays for Tampa or something.

 

Sullivan's relative cheapness tradewise is due to a number of things. First, he is coming off a somewhat off year offensively, getting less hits and striking out at a higher rate (though he did show improvement in his power numbers, hitting more doubles and triples). Second, there has been conflict recently between the Rockies FO and Sullivan. This September, the Rockies requested he play winterball in Mexico to work on his hitting and he refused. Not the best idea to flatout refuse a request like this if you plan on staying with a club longterm. Third, Swift noted that he heard rumors the Rockies are going to be trying to sign Edmonds this coming offseason (a definite sign Sullivan is on his way out if it is true). Lastly, the Rockies have no shortage of backup CF. The primary backup is Choo Freeman, but besides Freeman they also have Ryan Spilborghs and Jeff Salazar. I think all of these factors would work toward making a deal for Sullivan cheaper than Taveras. At least that is my take on the situation.

Maybe I'm wrong, but that sounds just like an argument as to why another team might expect us to give up pitching for lower value (because we have a surplus). Just because they have more than they can use doesn't mean they will be giving it away. And what needs are the Rockies trying to fill?

And on a side note, do you think it wise for the FO to pursue a guy who already has problems with the team he's on?

 

The difference is they have a surplus of MLB-ready centerfielders. We do not have a surplus of MLB-ready pitchers. However, that surplus wasn't the only reason I gave for why I think Sullivan would be cheaper than Taveras. One position the Rockies are evidently trying to fill is, like I wrote, CF. I don't think we'll need to trade any players on our 25-man roster to get him. As for the whole Rockies FO-Sullivan situation, maybe Sullivan saw the writing on the wall that he was on his way out as the starting CF and wanted to speed along the process of getting on a team that will give him a chance to start. I really couldn't say for sure, though. Here is the latest on the Rockies CF search:

 

"10/29/06

The club has discussed ways to piece together trades for Toronto's Alex Rios, Boston's Coco Crisp and Houston's Chris Burke, while Dave Roberts, Darin Erstad and Jay Payton rank high on its wish list." Post

 

---Alex Rios is an interesting name. It might take a high level prospect to get him but he is only 25, with 3 years in the bigs, so the Rox would have control of him for a few more years. He has some power and can play center. RH"

 

Source -- http://www.roxhead.com/Rockies.html

I'll just ask the obvious - why would Sullivan be cheaper than Taveras? Not like Taveras plays for Tampa or something.

 

Sullivan's relative cheapness tradewise is due to a number of things. First, he is coming off a somewhat off year offensively, getting less hits and striking out at a higher rate (though he did show improvement in his power numbers, hitting more doubles and triples). Second, there has been conflict recently between the Rockies FO and Sullivan. This September, the Rockies requested he play winterball in Mexico to work on his hitting and he refused. Not the best idea to flatout refuse a request like this if you plan on staying with a club longterm. Third, Swift noted that he heard rumors the Rockies are going to be trying to sign Edmonds this coming offseason (a definite sign Sullivan is on his way out if it is true). Lastly, the Rockies have no shortage of backup CF. The primary backup is Choo Freeman, but besides Freeman they also have Ryan Spilborghs and Jeff Salazar. I think all of these factors would work toward making a deal for Sullivan cheaper than Taveras. At least that is my take on the situation.

Maybe I'm wrong, but that sounds just like an argument as to why another team might expect us to give up pitching for lower value (because we have a surplus). Just because they have more than they can use doesn't mean they will be giving it away. And what needs are the Rockies trying to fill?

And on a side note, do you think it wise for the FO to pursue a guy who already has problems with the team he's on?

 

The difference is they have a surplus of MLB-ready centerfielders. We do not have a surplus of MLB-ready pitchers. However, that surplus wasn't the only reason I gave for why I think Sullivan would be cheaper than Taveras. One position the Rockies are evidently trying to fill is, like I wrote, CF. I don't think we'll need to trade any players on our 25-man roster to get him. As for the whole Rockies FO-Sullivan situation, maybe Sullivan saw the writing on the wall that he was on his way out as the starting CF and wanted to speed along the process of getting on a team that will give him a chance to start. I really couldn't say for sure, though. Here is the latest on the Rockies CF search:

 

"10/29/06

The club has discussed ways to piece together trades for Toronto's Alex Rios, Boston's Coco Crisp and Houston's Chris Burke, while Dave Roberts, Darin Erstad and Jay Payton rank high on its wish list." Post

 

---Alex Rios is an interesting name. It might take a high level prospect to get him but he is only 25, with 3 years in the bigs, so the Rox would have control of him for a few more years. He has some power and can play center. RH"

 

Source -- http://www.roxhead.com/Rockies.html

 

holy f***. rios. that would be amazing.

I would lovvvvve to have Rios. Can't see why the Jays would want to trade him though..

OF Choo Freeman, Yaquis de Obregon (Mexican Pacific League, Rockies)

 

A 1998 first-round pick who has developed at a snail's pace, Freeman spent his first full year in the majors this season, appearing in 88 games as a bench outfielder and batting just .237/.298/.341. Sent to Mexico to get consistent at-bats for the first time all year, Freeman began the season with eight straight multi-hit games and is batting .500 (22-for-44) overall with a gaudy 1310 OPS south of the border. Scouts have always loved Freeman as an athlete, but his offensive skills have never been enough, and at 27, the projection is gone. All the Rockies can hope for at this point is his possibly becoming more attractive on the trade market.

 

Could this guy solve our problems?

 

Could he also have a sweet Nickname?

 

Choo Choo & the D'Train

He's finally learned to hit, He's got crazy plus speed to cover the caverns of Dolphin Stadium, and he's going to be DIRT cheap, as the Rocks have nowhere to put him.

 

Why WOULDN"T we be interested?

  • Author

How comparable is the talent in the Mexican Winter leagues? Those numbers are nasty, and I think if he's doing it against a high-enough level of competition, we should go for it. If he only hits 2/3rds of that at the MLB level it should still be good.

I've read that the Mexican League is littered with AA and AAA level pitching, including some ML talent.

 

I'm not saying he's gonna be a super star for us, but he might just be a solid avg major leauge hitter with power potential AND be able to Cover CF VERY well, with PLUS range and a PLUS arm.

 

ALso, he will cost VERY little.

 

 

 

Here are his complete Minor League Stats.

 

Obviously he was a 'toolsy' guy that took a LONG time to develop.

 

The thing is,,,,HE MIGHT ACTUALLY HAVE DONE SO.

 

Choo Stats

He sounds like an only marginally better version of Reggie Abercrombie (aka Reggie 2.0).

 

I'll pass. Let's deal Jacobs and Nolasco and get a real CFer.

bingo

Comparing him to Reggie Abercrombie isn't very accurate.

 

Choo put up a .291 AA season over 430 atbats.

 

Choo put up a .297 AAA season over 360 atbats.

 

Reggie had ONE good mark in the California league for 120 at bats. That was a whole 29 games.

 

I think you're being very dismissive.

Comparing him to Reggie Abercrombie isn't very accurate.

 

Choo put up a .291 AA season over 430 atbats.

 

Choo put up a .297 AAA season over 360 atbats.

 

Reggie had ONE good mark in the California league for 120 at bats. That was a whole 29 games.

 

I think you're being very dismissive.

After watching about 30 or so of his at bats this year, he look exactly like Reggie at the plate. They are a very similar player, with Choo putting up some better numbers, but not much better. I'd pass on him.

He sounds like an only marginally better version of Reggie Abercrombie (aka Reggie 2.0).

 

I'll pass. Let's deal Jacobs and Nolasco and get a real CFer.

:thumbup

  • Author

He sounds like an only marginally better version of Reggie Abercrombie (aka Reggie 2.0).

 

I'll pass. Let's deal Jacobs and Nolasco and get a real CFer.

So let me get this right - you want to get rid of Jacobs and Nolasco when ther could be cheaper options? Or do you really expect the DRays to take that deal?

 

After watching about 30 or so of his at bats this year, he look exactly like Reggie at the plate. They are a very similar player, with Choo putting up some better numbers, but not much better. I'd pass on him.

So because he "looks" like Reggie we should pass. His numbers look a lot better. And lets face it, if Reggie could hit around 280 consistently, we would have a lot less problems with him. If we can fill CF defensively without downgrading offense or giving up major talent, why not?

  • Author

I never said the name Carl Crawford anywhere. That's a pipe dream because the Devil Rays would ask far too much and the Marlins are too smart to bite. I have no problem dealing Jacobs and Nolasco because I'm too high on either of them and I say sell them while their stock is high.

 

 

And it sounds like Choo would be an offensive downgrade from the platoon...

 

Answer this question for me:

 

Do you actually expect the Marlins expect the Marlins to risk the entire CF position on some scrub in the Mexican leagues who is already 27 years old and the Rockies are desperately trying to dump him? Do you think the Marlins will go after someone so unproven, take the risk of him amounting to absolutely nothing, and be placed into the very same situation as they were in 2006 (Reggie Abercrombie)?

 

Basically I'm saying that even if they acquire this guy, they will need to pick up a legitimate CF for insurance. And that will involve ML talent. You have to give up talent to get talent. Dan Ugglas don't grow on trees.

There was NO CF Platoon in 2006. There was Reggie batting under 215 the first half of the season and Amezaga batting under 100 vs LHP through the second half. Cody started 18 games in CF, and his OBP (vs LHP) is 281.

 

I assumed the DRays because everyone and their mother likes to point out that the DRays want a power lefty bat at 1B.

 

But anyway, if not from them, who eactly do you expect to give us a "legitimate" CF for Jacobs & Nolasco.

 

But then there's the problem of filling the new holes left over...either you need a new 1B or you move Hammer there and you need a new LF. Maybe you can fill that spot by platooning Borchard & Cody, but then you better have a CF who can play vs LHP & RHP. And the 5th Starter spot....what should we do then? Let Pinto start? Throw another rookie with no MLB experience into the rotation? or heaven forbid, have to resort to a "veteran" pitcher ala Ismael Valdez and Brian Moehler to fill in that spot? Needless to say (I hope) that I would prefer to have Nolasco back than tinker with the rotation.

I dont expect Nolasco to be back, but most definitely not Jacobs

 

and getting Choo as our starting CF would be very disappointing, no matter how much I like the guy

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.