Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Another CF Idea

Featured Replies

  • Author

If the team can't land a proven CF (who doesn't need to be platooned) then I wouldn't mind Choo being among a few cheap options acquired. No, I don't think he should be our chosen target. But it might be worth a look for the right price.

 

Now, I'm not trying to argue that the combo should be the CF answer for next year, but I'm saying they are indeed platoon players even though Girardi didn't use them properly.

It's not a question about whether or not they are "platoon players". What I am saying is that there was NO PLATOON. Whenever people talk about the CF platoon, or comparing other CFs in the league to our CF platoon, they are talking about/comparing something that never existed and will probably never exist (a full time Amezaga/Cody platoon in CF).

 

About Nolasco, he got hurt, and then tired by season's end. Not much different from JJ & Olsen if you look at it. He had a few worse games, but he still won 11 starts in his rookie year without even being in the rotation for a good chunk of it. Most of his problems were toward the end of the season when (lets face it) we expected all the rookies to hit a wall. He's not an ace, but for a #5, I think he's quite a bit better than adequate.

  • Author

So what's the point of even making the point that Girardi did not use platoon players in a platoon situation? I fail to see your logic.

Ok let me try to explain this a different way.

 

Suppose I were to ask people to compare Reggie Abercrombie's big HR in Cincy with the HR Scott Olsen hit in LA, asking which was more impressive and went further - there would be a problem. Scott Olsen never hit a HR, in LA or elsewhere. I am comparing something real (Reggie's HR) to something that doesn't/didn't exist/never happened. Something that is not real.

 

That's what it's like to compare a Ross/Amezaga CF platoon (something not real, and that will probably never be real) to other CFs around the league (something real).

 

Does that help?

 

I disagree with you about Nolasco, but that's another discussion entirely.

  • Author

What guy? I started this thread because the response to every suggested defensive upgrade in CF is "he would be an offensive downgrade and give the team no net improvement", so I proposed an offensive CF platoon of Borchard and Ross, which realistically can't be that much worse defensively than Amezaga considering that both of these guys are OFers by trade, and represent a signiificant improvement offensively.

 

But whatever. Whenever someone suggests another CF be pursued they are compared to the platoon that never existed and will never exist of AA & Ross. The offense from CF during the second half of the season was for all intents and purposes, exclusively coming from Amezaga, and someone like Taveras wouldn't be downgrade in comparison.

 

It might be if you compare it to a Ross/ Amezaga platoon, but then there was no platoon. So it's not like we were getting so much from it last year, because it didn't happen. We wouldn't become an inferior run-scoring team in that scenario.

 

And it's not as though you couldn't still fit Cody in vs LHP. Aside from platooning him Hermida, who is also less than spectacular vs LHP, you could plug Cody into LF and move Hammer to 1B vs LHP with Jacobs sitting.

I dont expect Nolasco to be back, but most definitely not Jacobs

 

and getting Choo as our starting CF would be very disappointing, no matter how much I like the guy

Choo is not even a full step up from Reggie. And, call me crazy, but I think Reggie has more natural potential than Choo.

I dont expect Nolasco to be back, but most definitely not Jacobs

 

and getting Choo as our starting CF would be very disappointing, no matter how much I like the guy

Choo is not even a full step up from Reggie. And, call me crazy, but I think Reggie has more natural potential than Choo.

 

I could call you a cab too :rolleyes:

 

I'm usually the first one to suggest players mature at different ages and someone isn't necessarily over the hill at 25 as some think, but having watched way too much of Reggie in the last year, I don't even see the tools he was touted as having, nevermind being as to put them to good use.

 

It was an experiment in a developmental year, it failed, we move on.

So what's the point of even making the point that Girardi did not use platoon players in a platoon situation? I fail to see your logic.

Ok let me try to explain this a different way.

 

Suppose I were to ask people to compare Reggie Abercrombie's big HR in Cincy with the HR Scott Olsen hit in LA, asking which was more impressive and went further - there would be a problem. Scott Olsen never hit a HR, in LA or elsewhere. I am comparing something real (Reggie's HR) to something that doesn't/didn't exist/never happened. Something that is not real.

 

That's what it's like to compare a Ross/Amezaga CF platoon (something not real, and that will probably never be real) to other CFs around the league (something real).

 

Does that help?

 

I disagree with you about Nolasco, but that's another discussion entirely.

We discussing something that's not real. The Marlins' 2007 season hasn't started yet.

  • Author

We discussing something that's not real. The Marlins' 2007 season hasn't started yet.

Yes. But we aren't sitting here comparing it saying "the team in 2007 was/will be better than 2003". Comparing something real to something not real is what I'm talking about. Why is that so complicated?

I dont expect Nolasco to be back, but most definitely not Jacobs

 

and getting Choo as our starting CF would be very disappointing, no matter how much I like the guy

Choo is not even a full step up from Reggie. And, call me crazy, but I think Reggie has more natural potential than Choo.

 

I could call you a cab too :rolleyes:

 

I'm usually the first one to suggest players mature at different ages and someone isn't necessarily over the hill at 25 as some think, but having watched way too much of Reggie in the last year, I don't even see the tools he was touted as having, nevermind being as to put them to good use.

 

It was an experiment in a developmental year, it failed, we move on.

We move on? Adding Choo would not be moving on. It would be taking a step back. It would be taking on another "experiment" that most likely would not work, either.

We move on? Adding Choo would not be moving on. It would be taking a step back. It would be taking on another "experiment" that most likely would not work, either.

 

My comments were about Reggie not Choo. Acquiring Choo never crossed my mind.

We discussing something that's not real. The Marlins' 2007 season hasn't started yet.

Yes. But we aren't sitting here comparing it saying "the team in 2007 was/will be better than 2003". Comparing something real to something not real is what I'm talking about. Why is that so complicated?

I don't think anyone else is under the impression they're talking about anything more than projections.

We move on? Adding Choo would not be moving on. It would be taking a step back. It would be taking on another "experiment" that most likely would not work, either.

 

My comments were about Reggie not Choo. Acquiring Choo never crossed my mind.

Trust me, I have no problem at all replacing Reggie. My comments to which you responded by calling me a "cab" were about replacing Reggie Abercrombie with Choo.

We move on? Adding Choo would not be moving on. It would be taking a step back. It would be taking on another "experiment" that most likely would not work, either.

 

My comments were about Reggie not Choo. Acquiring Choo never crossed my mind.

Trust me, I have no problem at all replacing Reggie. My comments to which you responded by calling me a "cab" were about replacing Reggie Abercrombie with Choo.

 

I think you missed my joke.

 

In your post, to which I originally replied, you said "call me crazy..." and there's an old joke that goes "call me a cab"..."okay, you're a cab". It was just meant as a little play on words and not an insult towards you.

I see Cliff Floyd is a free agent. How much is he going to cost, do you think?

 

I wouldn't mind something like this:

 

Jacobs and a pitcher (not sure which) for a CFer. Willingham at 1B. Floyd in left. He'd add a nice bat to our lineup.

I see Cliff Floyd is a free agent. How much is he going to cost, do you think?

 

I wouldn't mind something like this:

 

Jacobs and a pitcher (not sure which) for a CFer. Willingham at 1B. Floyd in left. He'd add a nice bat to our lineup.

Nolasco.

I have a better chance of starting in leftfield for the Florida Marlins next April than Cliff Floyd.

 

And I have zero chance :lol

Its too late now, but i would've liked to have seen us try and get FA CFer Luis Terrero(right handed). The White Sox already signed him. He has great tools he just has never put them all togeather at the ML level. He has a great glove in CF, defense has never been a question. This is what he put up at AAA Ottawa(IL) in 84 games.

 

.318/.367/.560, 16BB/61SO, 16HR 44RBI, 18SB/9CS

 

o well :(

We should field a team of former Marlins next year.

I really don't understand it, either. Why is it that whenever a trade is mentioned, every single former Marlin is automatically mentioned? Example: Juan Pierre.

Because some people care more about individual players than for the team itself.

I think you're right. But Juan Pierre? Why? I don't get it.

I'll just ask the obvious - why would Sullivan be cheaper than Taveras? Not like Taveras plays for Tampa or something.

 

Sullivan's relative cheapness tradewise is due to a number of things. First, he is coming off a somewhat off year offensively, getting less hits and striking out at a higher rate (though he did show improvement in his power numbers, hitting more doubles and triples). Second, there has been conflict recently between the Rockies FO and Sullivan. This September, the Rockies requested he play winterball in Mexico to work on his hitting and he refused. Not the best idea to flatout refuse a request like this if you plan on staying with a club longterm. Third, Swift noted that he heard rumors the Rockies are going to be trying to sign Edmonds this coming offseason (a definite sign Sullivan is on his way out if it is true). Lastly, the Rockies have no shortage of backup CF. The primary backup is Choo Freeman, but besides Freeman they also have Ryan Spilborghs and Jeff Salazar. I think all of these factors would work toward making a deal for Sullivan cheaper than Taveras. At least that is my take on the situation.

Maybe I'm wrong, but that sounds just like an argument as to why another team might expect us to give up pitching for lower value (because we have a surplus). Just because they have more than they can use doesn't mean they will be giving it away. And what needs are the Rockies trying to fill?

And on a side note, do you think it wise for the FO to pursue a guy who already has problems with the team he's on?

 

The difference is they have a surplus of MLB-ready centerfielders. We do not have a surplus of MLB-ready pitchers. However, that surplus wasn't the only reason I gave for why I think Sullivan would be cheaper than Taveras. One position the Rockies are evidently trying to fill is, like I wrote, CF. I don't think we'll need to trade any players on our 25-man roster to get him. As for the whole Rockies FO-Sullivan situation, maybe Sullivan saw the writing on the wall that he was on his way out as the starting CF and wanted to speed along the process of getting on a team that will give him a chance to start. I really couldn't say for sure, though. Here is the latest on the Rockies CF search:

 

"10/29/06

The club has discussed ways to piece together trades for Toronto's Alex Rios, Boston's Coco Crisp and Houston's Chris Burke, while Dave Roberts, Darin Erstad and Jay Payton rank high on its wish list." Post

 

---Alex Rios is an interesting name. It might take a high level prospect to get him but he is only 25, with 3 years in the bigs, so the Rox would have control of him for a few more years. He has some power and can play center. RH"

 

Source -- http://www.roxhead.com/Rockies.html

 

holy f***. rios. that would be amazing.

 

 

ACTUALLY! It sounds very possible, but I think the Marlins will prob get our CF job from the FA market, it just won't be nothing special, but passive! I forgot his name, but their was a guy the Marlins were interested in (a Phillies player) before they pulled the trigger in 2003 to get Juan Pierre, maybe we'll be seeing him in Florida next year.

I'll just ask the obvious - why would Sullivan be cheaper than Taveras? Not like Taveras plays for Tampa or something.

 

Sullivan's relative cheapness tradewise is due to a number of things. First, he is coming off a somewhat off year offensively, getting less hits and striking out at a higher rate (though he did show improvement in his power numbers, hitting more doubles and triples). Second, there has been conflict recently between the Rockies FO and Sullivan. This September, the Rockies requested he play winterball in Mexico to work on his hitting and he refused. Not the best idea to flatout refuse a request like this if you plan on staying with a club longterm. Third, Swift noted that he heard rumors the Rockies are going to be trying to sign Edmonds this coming offseason (a definite sign Sullivan is on his way out if it is true). Lastly, the Rockies have no shortage of backup CF. The primary backup is Choo Freeman, but besides Freeman they also have Ryan Spilborghs and Jeff Salazar. I think all of these factors would work toward making a deal for Sullivan cheaper than Taveras. At least that is my take on the situation.

Maybe I'm wrong, but that sounds just like an argument as to why another team might expect us to give up pitching for lower value (because we have a surplus). Just because they have more than they can use doesn't mean they will be giving it away. And what needs are the Rockies trying to fill?

And on a side note, do you think it wise for the FO to pursue a guy who already has problems with the team he's on?

 

The difference is they have a surplus of MLB-ready centerfielders. We do not have a surplus of MLB-ready pitchers. However, that surplus wasn't the only reason I gave for why I think Sullivan would be cheaper than Taveras. One position the Rockies are evidently trying to fill is, like I wrote, CF. I don't think we'll need to trade any players on our 25-man roster to get him. As for the whole Rockies FO-Sullivan situation, maybe Sullivan saw the writing on the wall that he was on his way out as the starting CF and wanted to speed along the process of getting on a team that will give him a chance to start. I really couldn't say for sure, though. Here is the latest on the Rockies CF search:

 

"10/29/06

The club has discussed ways to piece together trades for Toronto's Alex Rios, Boston's Coco Crisp and Houston's Chris Burke, while Dave Roberts, Darin Erstad and Jay Payton rank high on its wish list." Post

 

---Alex Rios is an interesting name. It might take a high level prospect to get him but he is only 25, with 3 years in the bigs, so the Rox would have control of him for a few more years. He has some power and can play center. RH"

 

Source -- http://www.roxhead.com/Rockies.html

 

holy f***. rios. that would be amazing.

 

 

ACTUALLY! It sounds very possible, but I think the Marlins will prob get our CF job from the FA market, it just won't be nothing special, but passive! I forgot his name, but their was a guy the Marlins were interested in (a Phillies player) before they pulled the trigger in 2003 to get Juan Pierre, maybe we'll be seeing him in Florida next year.

David Dellucci?

BTW, I forgot to post this when I heard...but every Marlins broadcaster will be back in 2007 in the same roles.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.