June 22, 200719 yr I am not giving them Pinto for a guy who will be out of baseball in the very near future.
June 22, 200719 yr You conveniently cut out my point which was that he put up a .889 OPS as a 22 year old in AAA. Thats crazy. I cut it out because that wasn't what I was responding too. Nobody denies his skill, he is a very talented 5 tool player. Nobody on this forum has said "Elijah Dukes sucks, we shouldn't get him" (Outside of the 1-2 people talking about his .BAA), everybody who has said that they don't want him has said it's because of he's bat sh*t insane.
June 22, 200719 yr Sent to AAA and put on the inactive list, so basically they are going to trade him. Anybody with a .900 OPS as a 22 year old in AAA can play. If somebody can get his head on straight, it'll be a steal.
June 22, 200719 yr I am not giving them Pinto for a guy who will be out of baseball in the very near future. Ban bet that Pinto is out of baseball before Dukes?
June 22, 200719 yr I am not giving them Pinto for a guy who will be out of baseball in the very near future. No he won't. This ain't the NFL.
June 22, 200719 yr But it's not going to be a huge investment. We can offer them Renyel Pinto and they'll do it in half a second. With Logan, Martinez, and Gardner all available soon with the ability to provide relief help, we have to do this. It makes too much sense. If he messes up, we cut him and we lost a marginal reliever. Big deal. That's fine. But who knows what the D-Ray are asking for him, and what someone will be willing to pay. If Beinfest inquires into his availability, and makes it clear that we won't offer more than Pinto, then I don't have a big problem with it. We also cannot indulge his behavior. Keep him on a short leash, and if he screws up, cut him.
June 22, 200719 yr Why would anyone think he will change? You ask him and he'll say he's never done anything wrong. I really hope our GM doesnt look at stats and uses common sense. This guy would tear apart this team in 5 minutes, get arrested at some point to alienate our management all in the meanwhile dividing our fanbase. I'm not wasting anymore time on dukes and this thread. I sincerely hope we dont add him to our team.
June 22, 200719 yr Even before his latest crap (the new baby and all that) the Rays were reportedly only looking for a reliever for him.
June 22, 200719 yr I must have missed the part where he told you he is bipolar. My bad. I've seen it in multiple stories and honestly just look at his record. Their's more at work their than a bad upbringing. Link? http://www.withleather.com/index.phtml?t=ELIJAH+DUKES But this won't change anything he's a certified basketcase but OMG look at his OPS. Half the people at mental facilities dude are their because they did not take their medication. But hey if they can hit.
June 22, 200719 yr Why would anyone think he will change? You ask him and he'll say he's never done anything wrong. I really hope our GM doesnt look at stats and uses common sense. This guy would tear apart this team in 5 minutes, get arrested at some point to alienate our management all in the meanwhile dividing our fanbase. I'm not wasting anymore time on dukes and this thread. I sincerely hope we dont add him to our team. He's 23, there is plenty of time for him to change his life around. A big part is making sure he stays medicated.
June 22, 200719 yr I am not giving them Pinto for a guy who will be out of baseball in the very near future. Ban bet that Pinto is out of baseball before Dukes? Out of baseball completely? Oh yes, i agree to that.
June 22, 200719 yr Why would anyone think he will change? You ask him and he'll say he's never done anything wrong. I really hope our GM doesnt look at stats and uses common sense. This guy would tear apart this team in 5 minutes, get arrested at some point to alienate our management all in the meanwhile dividing our fanbase. I'm not wasting anymore time on dukes and this thread. I sincerely hope we dont add him to our team. Wait, so let me get this straight, youdon't want Dukes? How is he going to tear the team apart? Chemistry is way overrated in baseball. Winning teams have good chemistry. And if they don't, it doesn't matter because they are winning. I don't care if you have 25 guys who hate each other if they are 25 guys who can play baseball really well. And thats what Dukes can do.
June 22, 200719 yr If Dukes comes in and causes some trouble, I dont see our team just deciding to stop trying on the field.
June 22, 200719 yr http://www.withleather.com/index.phtml?t=ELIJAH+DUKES But this won't change anything he's a certified basketcase but OMG look at his OPS. Half the people at mental facilities dude are their because they did not take their medication. But hey if they can hit. YES! I don't know if you've been paying attention to professional sports in America for the last 20 years, but if you are an above average athlete, you can do pretty much anything you want. It's not right, but thats how it is. I highly doubt the Marlins are looking to be trendsetters there.
June 22, 200719 yr Clubhouse cancer.. its not new. I guess i put more stock in that than others. But youre right, id love to get a guy who assaults woman and threatens children on my team. I guess it will take another one to get the crap kicked out of her for some to change their minds.
June 22, 200719 yr Clubhouse cancer.. its not new. I guess i put more stock in that than others. But youre right, id love to get a guy who assaults woman and threatens children on my team. I guess it will take another one to get the crap kicked out of her for some to change their minds. I'm not saying it's right or that I support it, but more like it doesn't have any effect on what happens on the field, and since we're only going to be giving up a crappy reliever to get him, most likely, there's no reason why we shouldn't do it. Clubhouse cancer is a bulls*** term that has no place in baseball. In 1977 Reggie Jackson got into a fight with his manager during a game. Like, you know, a fist fight. And he had a .925 OPS and the Yankees won the World Series. Jeff Kent is a pretty well known a**hole, and probably a racist, and he's been on some great teams. It doesn't mean anything.
June 22, 200719 yr Clubhouse cancer.. its not new. I guess i put more stock in that than others. But youre right, id love to get a guy who assaults woman and threatens children on my team. I guess it will take another one to get the crap kicked out of her for some to change their minds. I'm not saying it's right or that I support it, but more like it doesn't have any effect on what happens on the field, and since we're only going to be giving up a crappy reliever to get him, most likely, there's no reason why we shouldn't do it. Clubhouse cancer is a bulls*** term that has no place in baseball. In 1977 Reggie Jackson got into a fight with his manager during a game. Like, you know, a fist fight. And he had a .925 OPS and the Yankees won the World Series. Jeff Kent is a pretty well known a**hole, and probably a racist, and he's been on some great teams. It doesn't mean anything. If I can't cheer the player on, it means something. I'd rather lose and have a team I can root for then sell out to win.
June 22, 200719 yr Clubhouse cancer.. its not new. I guess i put more stock in that than others. But youre right, id love to get a guy who assaults woman and threatens children on my team. I guess it will take another one to get the crap kicked out of her for some to change their minds. I'm not saying it's right or that I support it, but more like it doesn't have any effect on what happens on the field, and since we're only going to be giving up a crappy reliever to get him, most likely, there's no reason why we shouldn't do it. Clubhouse cancer is a bulls*** term that has no place in baseball. In 1977 Reggie Jackson got into a fight with his manager during a game. Like, you know, a fist fight. And he had a .925 OPS and the Yankees won the World Series. Jeff Kent is a pretty well known a**hole, and probably a racist, and he's been on some great teams. It doesn't mean anything. If I can't cheer the player on, it means something. I'd rather lose and have a team I can root for then sell out to win. Doesn't mean he is a clubhouse cancer.
June 22, 200719 yr Clubhouse cancer.. its not new. I guess i put more stock in that than others. But youre right, id love to get a guy who assaults woman and threatens children on my team. I guess it will take another one to get the crap kicked out of her for some to change their minds. I'm not saying it's right or that I support it, but more like it doesn't have any effect on what happens on the field, and since we're only going to be giving up a crappy reliever to get him, most likely, there's no reason why we shouldn't do it. Clubhouse cancer is a bulls*** term that has no place in baseball. In 1977 Reggie Jackson got into a fight with his manager during a game. Like, you know, a fist fight. And he had a .925 OPS and the Yankees won the World Series. Jeff Kent is a pretty well known a**hole, and probably a racist, and he's been on some great teams. It doesn't mean anything. Unless, of course, your name is Jeremy Hermida. :mischief
June 22, 200719 yr If I can't cheer the player on, it means something.I'd rather lose and have a team I can root for then sell out to win. How is it selling out? It is putting the best available players on the field. Baseball is played on the field, and the point of putting together a baseball team isn't to have a bunch of boy scouts. It's to put 25 good ball players out there every night. All of the other stuff is secondary. I could put together a list of the best ballplayers of all time and I'd bet 30% of them would be easily considered a**holes. It doesn't matter. Because there were good at baseball.Clubhouse cancer.. its not new. I guess i put more stock in that than others. But youre right, id love to get a guy who assaults woman and threatens children on my team. I guess it will take another one to get the crap kicked out of her for some to change their minds. I'm not saying it's right or that I support it, but more like it doesn't have any effect on what happens on the field, and since we're only going to be giving up a crappy reliever to get him, most likely, there's no reason why we shouldn't do it.Clubhouse cancer is a bulls*** term that has no place in baseball. In 1977 Reggie Jackson got into a fight with his manager during a game. Like, you know, a fist fight. And he had a .925 OPS and the Yankees won the World Series. Jeff Kent is a pretty well known a**hole, and probably a racist, and he's been on some great teams. It doesn't mean anything.Unless, of course, your name is Jeremy Hermida. :mischief Huh?
June 22, 200719 yr There's a difference between an a**hole and someone who's seriously mentally unstable. It's one thing to have a bunch of Curt Shillings, who you love if he's on your team but hate if he's not. It's another to have someone who's just not right upstairs. If he were to try and get help, try to get better, that'd be one thing. But he has shown that he doesn't think anything is wrong with him, so I doubt he will. And I really hope he does get help, regardless if he's on the Marlins/still in baseball.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.