Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Something to chat about... Re: Cantu.

Featured Replies

Gotta love the posters who KNOW for sure what Dallas' OPS would be if he were called up from the PCL.

 

What's even more comical is that some of the posters whining about Cantu's defensive liability are the same ones who last year were telling everyone how defense is overrated. :banghead

 

 

Cantu isn't our problem (no one is saying this team will be a dynasty with him @ 3B).

 

 

Badenhop and Miller burying their team in the 2nd inning is our problem. Starting pitching is the problem. We have a 5 game lead in the NL East if Badenhop and Miller are even below average.

 

Badenhop needed to go down 3 weeks ago and Volstad needs to come up.

I'm not sure what all the hate is for McPherson.

Frankly I don't understand the love. The guy hasn't done anything yet and for some reason everyone here is making the drastic assumption that he can match Cantu's current level of performance.

I'm not sure what all the hate is for McPherson.

Frankly I don't understand the love. The guy hasn't done anything yet and for some reason everyone here is making the drastic assumption that he can match Cantu's current level of performance.

 

Right, and if the guy never has a chance, how can you possibly judge his major leauge production? He's been injured a lot and it seems like he's finally healthy.

I think the problem with bringing McPherson up is you have to find consistent playing time for him and not exile him to the end of the bench for five or six games or ten games at a time. Part of his rehab process from back surgery is playing everyday and I'd be concerned what might happen if his playing time was curtailed. Unless Cantu's arm worsens or Jacobs is hurt again (please God, no. :notworthy) or either of those players just falls off the stats ledge I can't see him being called up any time soon, which is in a sense unfortunate, I have a feeling he'd fit in well with this team

I think Uggla would not be much better at third than Cantu is, but Cantu will be much worse than Uggla is at second.

 

Considering 2nd is the more important defense posistion, it'd be better to have Uggla at second.

 

Based on what? Its no secret that Uggla has a stronger throwing arm and that the majority of Cantu's errors have been poor throws. I'm not saying Cantu is necessarily a defensive upgrade over Uggla (who is definitely an underrated defender) at second but based on his track record he will commit less errors from that position. Note that Cantu's career fielding percentage at third is around the .916 area as compared to the low .970's at second base. There is a big enough sample size with a big enough difference between the totals to show you that he is better suited to play second base. Not sure what you have to back up your assertion that Cantu will be "much worse" than Uggla at second when there is a difference of about 10 points in their career fielding percentages at the position.

 

There is nothing to indicate that Uggla, who came up playing third base in the minors, would not do a better job than Cantu at third. Ultimately you're getting the same defense from second base while receiving a significant upgrade at third by getting Cantu out of there. Claiming that Cantu would do a much worse job than Uggla at second is completely baseless.

 

Apparently it is a secret. If Cantu's errors were because of short throws, you maybe would have a point. But almost everyone of them has been over throwing, and those throws would have beat the runner. Some say that's because of arm slot, I say it's because he has a tendency to hurry his throws and dosen't plant his feet first. And I don't see how anyone can be saying he has no reaction time. Those back handed snags of hard lines are a thing of beauty, and I like the way he positions himself right in front of grounders hit to his left instead of using the Ole' type defense we have witnessed in the past couple years.

 

In any case, it's irrelevant. You don't move your 2B to play 3B for a couple years. Cantu and Dallas most likely will be gone by then and Uggla will still be playing 2B, if he is even here.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.