May 18, 200818 yr I was seaching around rotoworld looking for some info on Jones and I came across this little tidbit... Jorge Cantu committed his ninth error in 41 starts at third base on Sunday. Cantu has been a decent enough hitter this year, but his defense at third base has been just as much of a problem as expected. Wes Helms isn't much better, so it's possible the Marlins will go to Dallas McPherson at some point. They could also give Alfredo Amezaga time at the position sinec he'll see less action in center field after Jacque Jones signs. Do you think the Marlins bring up McPherson or do you think they will just put up with Cantu's horrible defense? Something to chat about. How is Dallas doing down in the minors?
May 18, 200818 yr I was seaching around rotoworld looking for some info on Jones and I came across this little tidbit... Jorge Cantu committed his ninth error in 41 starts at third base on Sunday. Cantu has been a decent enough hitter this year, but his defense at third base has been just as much of a problem as expected. Wes Helms isn't much better, so it's possible the Marlins will go to Dallas McPherson at some point. They could also give Alfredo Amezaga time at the position sinec he'll see less action in center field after Jacque Jones signs. Do you think the Marlins bring up McPherson or do you think they will just put up with Cantu's horrible defense? Something to chat about. How is Dallas doing down in the minors? Dallas is doing "alright"... Year Age Tm Lg Lvl Aff G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS SB CS SB% SH SF IBB HBP GDP 2008 27 ABQ PCL AAA FLA 33 110 23 31 2 0 11 25 22 49 .282 .398 .600 .998 2 3 40% 0 1 0 0 4 His SLG is inflated due to the thing air... and 49 Ks through 33 games isn't so "sexy", but his defense hasn't been horrible, I go so far as to say it'd obviously be better (if only because you can't do much worse)
May 18, 200818 yr I wouldn't consider experimenting with MacPherson until Cantu goes into a long, terrible slump.
May 19, 200818 yr I wouldn't consider experimenting with MacPherson until Cantu goes into a long, terrible slump. do defensive slumps count?
May 19, 200818 yr His defense isn't that much of a liability and he is performing well offensively at the ML level, which is something MacPherson has never done. Cantu earned the spot and overall he is playing well enough to have job security.
May 19, 200818 yr His defense isn't that much of a liability and he is performing well offensively at the ML level, which is something MacPherson has never done. Cantu earned the spot and overall he is playing well enough to have job security. I dont think his defense is costing us any games, though one person I think really needs to stop getting so many AB's (atleast while on the bench) is Andino. You just KNOW its an out when he is up, either he starts a game or he gets sent down, because other than that he is a waste of time on the bench.
May 19, 200818 yr im sure andino goes down when jones signs and and alfredo moves back to the infiels. a platoon of jones and ross has some nice pop.
May 19, 200818 yr I've been toying with this idea in my head for a while. Because Cantu has been decent at the plate (and he deserves credit for that much), I doubt McPhearson will be called up any time soon. Unless, like penguino says, he goes into a terrible slump and his average dips into the .230 area. I've been playing with the idea of a position swap between Cantu and Uggla. I don't expect that it will actually happen nor do I think it necessarily should, but hear me out. Cantu has been concievabley worse than Cabrera at third and Uggla played there for a good part of his minor league career. I don't know how well he can play third, but honestly he can't be any worse than Cantu. As for Cantu, his defensive numbers at second were average in his tenure with Tampa and it's probably more of a natural position for him. This might be thinking a little far ahead, but putting Cantu at second as a temporary solution frees up the position for Coghlan when he is ready. Without Uggla blocking him, the team will be encouraged to bring him up and it also makes the idea of signing Uggla realistic. An infield core of Uggla, Hanley, Coghlan, and Jacobs sounds more than decent. This is all just speculation because I don't know how Uggla will peform at third without being familiar with him in the minors. When it comes to Cantu at second, it's reasonable to assume he will play at about the same level as Uggla defensively from that position, thus cutting back on his error total. Edit: Just read another thread where Marlins2003 suggested the same thing. I guess other people have had the same thought about a possible swap but I wonder if it has occurred to Fredi.
May 19, 200818 yr I'd perfer to keep Mac down there atleast till the ASB so he can really get into the feel for playing the game after being out for so long. I like Cantu and not many of his errors have been mind blowing game-costers.
May 19, 200818 yr From what I've seen, and I haven't **checked** his stats or even if there are easily accessible stats on this, but my sense is, my guess is, of the nine errors at least six and maybe seven are throwing errors. It's no secret, it's been reported and discussed widely that his arm is ailing from the long throws. It's one thing and okay to complain about someone's defensive skills, but it's another if it's common knowledge he's hurt.
May 19, 200818 yr From what I've seen, and I haven't check his stats or even if there are easily accessible stats on this, but my sense is, my guess is, of the nine errors at least six and maybe seven are throwing errors. It's no secret, it's been reported and discussed widely that his arm is ailing from the long throws. It's one thing and okay to complain about someone's defensive skills, but it's another if it's common knowledge he's hurt. Just from memory, it does seem like the majority of his errors have been bad throws. That kind of ties back to the idea that he will improve defensively from having to make shorter, easier throws from second base.
May 19, 200818 yr His defense isn't that much of a liability and he is performing well offensively at the ML level, which is something MacPherson has never done. Cantu earned the spot and overall he is playing well enough to have job security. I really don't understand how a mid .700 OPS is performing well offensively when it comes to your thirdbaseman. It'd be one thing if we were talking about catcher or something, but third base is one of the top power posistions, and he's almost getting out OPS'd by Matt Freakin' Treanor. I could survive his defense if he could hit ala Cabrera. I could even survive his offense given our situation if he could defense. But he's below average in both catagories. And for as much as you say McPherson hasn't done anything on the ML level, he has a career OPS of over 800 against RHP. Have him and Helms platoon and you should have over .800 OPS from third base with an increase in defense.
May 19, 200818 yr My guess is the longer throw across the diamond is probably a major factor in this.
May 19, 200818 yr His defense isn't that much of a liability and he is performing well offensively at the ML level, which is something MacPherson has never done. Cantu earned the spot and overall he is playing well enough to have job security. I really don't understand how a mid .700 OPS is performing well offensively when it comes to your thirdbaseman. It'd be one thing if we were talking about catcher or something, but third base is one of the top power posistions, and he's almost getting out OPS'd by Matt Freakin' Treanor. I could survive his defense if he could hit ala Cabrera. I could even survive his offense given our situation if he could defense. But he's below average in both catagories. And for as much as you say McPherson hasn't done anything on the ML level, he has a career OPS of over 800 against RHP. Have him and Helms platoon and you should have over .800 OPS from third base with an increase in defense. I think you're falling into a trap by assigning "must have" stats by position. This is a team sport as much as sabrmetricians want to individualize it. If you said as a team the numbers look like this or that I would think there would be value in that. It's sort of like when someone complained years ago about Juan Pierre's OPS. Every shoe doesn't fit every foot. That said Cantu can and needs to do better.
May 19, 200818 yr His defense isn't that much of a liability and he is performing well offensively at the ML level, which is something MacPherson has never done. Cantu earned the spot and overall he is playing well enough to have job security. I really don't understand how a mid .700 OPS is performing well offensively when it comes to your thirdbaseman. It'd be one thing if we were talking about catcher or something, but third base is one of the top power posistions, and he's almost getting out OPS'd by Matt Freakin' Treanor. I could survive his defense if he could hit ala Cabrera. I could even survive his offense given our situation if he could defense. But he's below average in both catagories. And for as much as you say McPherson hasn't done anything on the ML level, he has a career OPS of over 800 against RHP. Have him and Helms platoon and you should have over .800 OPS from third base with an increase in defense. I think you're falling into a trap by assigning "must have" stats by position. This is a team sport as much as sabrmetricians want to individualize it. If you said as a team the numbers look like this or that I would think there would be value in that. It's sort of like when someone complained years ago about Juan Pierre's OPS. Every shoe doesn't fit every foot. That said Cantu can and needs to do better. And Jorge Cantu's weak OPS is hurting the team... there is a certain level that each position has to maintain, and Cantu isn't "pulling his weight", pardon the expression...
May 19, 200818 yr His defense isn't that much of a liability and he is performing well offensively at the ML level, which is something MacPherson has never done. Cantu earned the spot and overall he is playing well enough to have job security. I really don't understand how a mid .700 OPS is performing well offensively when it comes to your thirdbaseman. It'd be one thing if we were talking about catcher or something, but third base is one of the top power posistions, and he's almost getting out OPS'd by Matt Freakin' Treanor. I could survive his defense if he could hit ala Cabrera. I could even survive his offense given our situation if he could defense. But he's below average in both catagories. And for as much as you say McPherson hasn't done anything on the ML level, he has a career OPS of over 800 against RHP. Have him and Helms platoon and you should have over .800 OPS from third base with an increase in defense. McPherson did not hit RHP well since 2005, the season where Cantu hit 28 home runs and OPSed .832 against RHP. If you are going to make this argument based upon career numbers (granted we are talking about three seasons ago), Cantu easily has him beat. Cantu has repeatedly put up greater numbers againt RHP in the past which easily trumps McPherson's limited (if you even want to call it that) success. I see no indication (and you are basing your argument on 150 ABs in 2005) that McPherson could even match Cantu's current performance. Cantu at least has a full successful season in the major leagues and fought for the spot in spring training (you can't discredit him on McPherson's injury). Most importantly he isn't playing terribly right now. Did we expect him to hit like Cabrera? Absolutely not. He's obviously a temporarily fix. Right now we want to send the best guy out there and he is simply making a better case than McPherson is. His numbers for a 3B aren't nearly as bad as you make them out to be, either. Of the 14 qualified 3B, his OPS is ranked 8th, which means he's merely average. No one expected him to be anything more. He's obviously just a one year fix. Essentially what I'm saying is that the belief that McPherson could match or even surpass Cantu's current performance is completely unfounded. Furthermore, his current performance is certainly adequate for a one year replacement. If the Marlins pull him out of a job that he earned, they have to be damn sure that McPherson can do any better. What the Marlins should have done if they wanted to give him a chance was demote Andino and keep Cantu in the lineup but at first base when Jacobs was out.
May 19, 200818 yr I just find it ridiculous that Cantu is being singled out at the moment while the starting pitcher gives up 5 ER in three innings while giving up seven hits. Meanwhile, our lead off hitter has an OBP of exactly .300. Cantu is far from the best bat in the lineup but if this argument is about "people hurting the team" I'd say that there are certainly more dire areas that need to be addressed.
May 19, 200818 yr I just find it ridiculous that Cantu is being singled out at the moment while the starting pitcher gives up 5 ER in three innings while giving up seven hits. Meanwhile, our lead off hitter has an OBP of exactly .300. Cantu is far from the best bat in the lineup but if this argument is about "people hurting the team" I'd say that there are certainly more dire areas that need to be addressed. thats what Im sayin, 100% agreed. Its not Cantu with his errors costing us games, there are much bigger reasons.
May 19, 200818 yr .272/.330/.426 with 5 home runs and 17 RBIs. All things considered, a .330 OBP is not terrible from your 6th hitter. That said, his production, at it's current pace, won't even get close to the numbers he put up in 2005. If he continues on this pace, he'll finish with 19 home runs and about 66 RBI's. I'm not demanding he should drive in 117 like he did in 05, but you would like to see him finish with 75-85 RBI's to say he was a productive enough to accept a mediocre OPS.
May 19, 200818 yr Right now we want to send the best guy out there and he is simply making a better case than McPherson is And there's just where we're just going to keep disagreeing. Yes, we're not going to have a Cabrera out there, but the best option should be sent out there. I don't care what a player did 3 years ago, I care what a player will do today (and it doesn't help I'm under the belief that those numbers are tainted anyway). I don't know why one year of major league success three years ago is enough for a player, but even then McPherson has already shown he can hit at that level against RHP, and possibily higher now that his back is better. Cantu's numbers continue to decline, this isn't exactly the way you want a player to trend. McPherson will very likely increase offense, he'll increase defense. What the Marlins should have done if they wanted to give him a chance was demote Andino and keep Cantu in the lineup but at first base when Jacobs was out. I agree with that, and I think it shows that they'll be sticking with Cantu for awhile. I just find it ridiculous that Cantu is being singled out at the moment while the starting pitcher gives up 5 ER in three innings while giving up seven hits. Meanwhile, our lead off hitter has an OBP of exactly .300. Cantu is far from the best bat in the lineup but if this argument is about "people hurting the team" I'd say that there are certainly more dire areas that need to be addressed. I don't think anyone is saying Cantu is our biggest problem, but it's also something we can easily fix. We can't fix our SP until June at the earliest, and it seems JJ will be a Marlin soon, and the only way to increase our C is via a trade, whereas we can increase 3B with a simple callup.
May 19, 200818 yr .272/.330/.426 with 5 home runs and 17 RBIs. All things considered, a .330 OBP is not terrible from your 6th hitter. That said, his production, at it's current pace, won't even get close to the numbers he put up in 2005. If he continues on this pace, he'll finish with 19 home runs and about 66 RBI's. I'm not demanding he should drive in 117 like he did in 05, but you would like to see him finish with 75-85 RBI's to say he was a productive enough to accept a mediocre OPS. Having near 20 HR's from your 6th hitter, while having lets say Hanley Uggla Jacobs and Willingham(barring further injuries) hit +30 each, with Really any of Uggla Hanley and Jacobs hitting a chance at 40? I would say, his extra HR's are awsome.
May 19, 200818 yr Cantu's numbers are mediocre because he struggled in the fourth spot in the line up, a place he should never have been in the first place.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.