May 19, 200818 yr Show me some tangible evidence that McPherson will match Cantu's production. PCL numbers are not very convincing. Stripping Cantu from his job and installing McPherson is a rather audacious move and it takes very good reasoning in order to to do. Obviously the Marlins are very satisfied because I've heard few talks since the acquisition of Helms regarding a potential upgrade at third base. Again, Cantu's case is also made stronger that he earned the job and is putting up league average numbers for third basemen. And let's not forget this franchise contemplated having Jason Wood be the starting third baseman after Cabrera was traded. If anyone in the offense should be bashed it should be Amezaga, Rabelo, and to a slightly lesser extent, Ross.
May 19, 200818 yr I don't see how McPherson is an upgrade over Cantu, at this point. Don't let PCL #'s fool you...the PCL made Brett Carroll look like Lance Berkman. McPherson's K's are at an alarming rate, and would only get worse facing major league pitching. And while his defense might be somewhat better, McPherson's never been known for his glove. He's been known for his raw power.
May 19, 200818 yr I'm ok with his K rate, because he's also got that nice BB rate and he's hitting for power. There's no doubt in my mind that McPherson could step in right now and OPS > .761. Given that it would also see improved defense, this is a no brainer. Of course, I'm probably the world's biggest Cantu hater, mostly because he had one "good" season that is inflated by counting stats, while his rate stats were rather pedestrian.
May 19, 200818 yr His .808 OPS in 2005 was third best for all AL 2B and 3B (400+ PA), where he split time almost evenly. I wouldn't go that far, unless you want to place a large emphasis on strikeout numbers. He had a very solid 2005 season even if you look beyond HR, doubles, and RBI.
May 19, 200818 yr His defense isn't that much of a liability and he is performing well offensively at the ML level, which is something MacPherson has never done. Cantu earned the spot and overall he is playing well enough to have job security. Agree. He's still learning the position. The errors are high but they are mostly throwing errors. And most of them sailing high which means he is getting a little excited and not setting his feet properly. The throwing error Sunday was on a very nice attempt. A real good 1B would have dug that one out, IMO. Jake is progressing nicely fielding the balls hit his way, but needs alot of work on digging balls out of the dirt. Whoever covers the hot corner is still just a stopgap for a couple years. Cantu should stay right where he is. IMO this team isn't a play off contender. Still too young and making silly blunders in the field and on the base paths. The bats are hiding alot of flaws right now, but they can't hide the fact they are still a young team making youngster mistakes.
May 19, 200818 yr Cantu's numbers are mediocre because he struggled in the fourth spot in the line up, a place he should never have been in the first place. Cantu is just horrible!!!
May 19, 200818 yr Cantu has been average at the plate for a third baseman. He's made some great plays defensively, as well as a few bad ones. But he's earned the job, and while McPherson is hitting a ton in triple-A, he still needs some more AB's down there. Not to mention the last thing this team needs is another 150 strikeout bat in the lineup. And to address the person who thought of switching Cantu and Uggla in the field, what's the point? Uggla's offense at second is that of a great third baseman. Cantu's numbers at third are that of an above average second baseman. It all evens out.
May 19, 200818 yr Cantu has been average at the plate for a third baseman. He's made some great plays defensively, as well as a few bad ones. But he's earned the job, and while McPherson is hitting a ton in triple-A, he still needs some more AB's down there. Not to mention the last thing this team needs is another 150 strikeout bat in the lineup. And to address the person who thought of switching Cantu and Uggla in the field, what's the point? Uggla's offense at second is that of a great third baseman. Cantu's numbers at third are that of an above average second baseman. It all evens out. C'mon Wild, Dallas has had a resurgence in his career in Albuquerque and we're all happy to see that but to say he's hitting "a ton" is stretching it especially when you look at his strikeouts, which weren't any early in the season phenomenon, it continues up to today. But if he could just get the bat on the ball more even if he's making outs by contact, he would have a much better chance of getting a call this summer. Something like 60 strikeouts in forty games has to be a concern. The other flukey thing is he has about forty hits with 12 homeruns and only five doubles. It sounds like he just misses perfect contact and loops one into shallow outfield or he connects and the ball is out of there.
May 19, 200818 yr And to address the person who thought of switching Cantu and Uggla in the field, what's the point? Uggla's offense at second is that of a great third baseman. Cantu's numbers at third are that of an above average second baseman. It all evens out. What do their offensive numbers in correlation with their positions have to do with anything? The point I was making was that the team's defense would improve as a result from a positional switch. Uggla has played some third base in the minors and Cantu has played more games at second base at the major league level while putting up better defensive numbers from second. Alot of his errors have been accounted for from poor throws so I was suggesting a move to second would result in easier throws and less errors. I don't remember mentioning anything about matching their offensive numbers with the appropriate positions they should play on the field. It has to do with the idea that Cantu will cost the team less errors from second base while Uggla has shown the ability to play third in the past. At least try reading my post before saying my argument is pointless.
May 20, 200818 yr I think Uggla would not be much better at third than Cantu is, but Cantu will be much worse than Uggla is at second. Considering 2nd is the more important defense posistion, it'd be better to have Uggla at second.
May 20, 200818 yr I think Uggla would not be much better at third than Cantu is, but Cantu will be much worse than Uggla is at second. Considering 2nd is the more important defense posistion, it'd be better to have Uggla at second. Based on what? Its no secret that Uggla has a stronger throwing arm and that the majority of Cantu's errors have been poor throws. I'm not saying Cantu is necessarily a defensive upgrade over Uggla (who is definitely an underrated defender) at second but based on his track record he will commit less errors from that position. Note that Cantu's career fielding percentage at third is around the .916 area as compared to the low .970's at second base. There is a big enough sample size with a big enough difference between the totals to show you that he is better suited to play second base. Not sure what you have to back up your assertion that Cantu will be "much worse" than Uggla at second when there is a difference of about 10 points in their career fielding percentages at the position. There is nothing to indicate that Uggla, who came up playing third base in the minors, would not do a better job than Cantu at third. Ultimately you're getting the same defense from second base while receiving a significant upgrade at third by getting Cantu out of there. Claiming that Cantu would do a much worse job than Uggla at second is completely baseless.
May 20, 200818 yr Cantu isn't bad just because of his arm, but his poor range and reaction times, both of which Uggla is supperior in and 2B demands more of from both of those.
May 20, 200818 yr Yes but his arm is the reason he has been a disaster at third. By placing him in the position where he has traditionally comitted less errors (and alot of that is probably because of the shorter throws), it enables the defense to improve as a whole. His career numbers suggest he can play at the same level of defense Uggla has over the past couple years. If Uggla is superior in both range and reaction time, which is important in any position (particularly for third when you consider how it helps out Shortstop), then putting him there will be a drastic improvement over Cantu. Even if Cantu is not the equivalent of Uggla at second and he is slightly worse then your defense has still improved because Uggla is considerabley better than Cantu at third.
May 20, 200818 yr Fielding isn't just about errors. Range is a lot more important. When Cantu played 2nd, he was one of the worst 2B's in the league, doing a LOT worse than Uggla is now. Cantu 2005 RZR/OOZ: .764/19. 2006: .751/22. Uggla's 2006: 861/39. 2007: .776/55 Look at that huge difference in range. 2B requires a lot more range than 3B does, and Uggla has a lot more range than Cantu does. Plus Uggla does not have very good arm accuracy and the problems your addressing would still be there. Putting Cantu at 2nd greatly decreases our 2B defense. Putting Uggla at 3B barely does anything for our 3B defense. It greatly drops our team defense overall.
May 20, 200818 yr Offensively, all things considered, Cantu's done better than I expected. We knew he wasn't going to walk, but at least he's hitting some. Teams were apparently giving up on him so at least he hasn't bombed. The throwing errors just eat at me. Defense was supposed to be this big focus in the offseason.... and here we are again. Lowest fielding % in the NL, nearly the most errors, etc, etc, etc...
May 20, 200818 yr if we did call up mcpherson, cantu would be a pretty valuable bench player as he can play 1B, 2B and 3B. however thats why we have wes helms to fill in at 1B and 3B and if amezaga goes back to being a utilty he covers everywhere. presuming when hammer and jones come back/come up, then andino and carroll make way wot im saying is, hoo goes down out of cantu/helms/amezaga/ross/gonzo if we called up mcpherson? (imo it would have to be cantu, even tho he has done ok)
May 20, 200818 yr Right now we can accommodate two active roster moves by sending Andino and Carroll back down. But how the forty man roster plays out is a bit murkier. We could 60 day DL DeAza back to his injury date and the same with Willingham, or remove Barone, or another player. I'm not sure why Anibal Sanchez is still on the 15 day DL vs 60 but he is. With Jones about to join the team and the assumption that the media has is he is your new starting centerfielder. I've read that Andino is expected to be the casualty if and when Jones joins the team. One one level I'm sure he'll enjoy playing again everyday and hopefully catching someone's eye and increasing his value for himself and the Marlins, but I suspect the adjustment back to the minors after the major league lifestyle is going to leave a bad taste in his mouth as he bus rides to Round Rock, Texas.
May 20, 200818 yr If the Marlins are certain that Amezaga will become a full-time bench player, it would make sense to send Andino down. Seems like there would be a heavy preference toward the third base position but I suppose Cantu could also play second, if ever necessary. Andino isn't contributing to this team. I'm still against handing McPherson the starting job at third base but I'd like to see him used as a pinch hitter or a potential replacement player.
May 20, 200818 yr McPherson hit 3 bombs yesterday and is now up to 15 on the season... Damn the PCL really is a softball league!
May 20, 200818 yr Cantu is a pleasant suprise, but lets not pretend he's anything other than a band-aid. McPherson, might be better, and we can call him up and keep Cantu on the roster to avoid having to waive him by sending Andino down. I would not be inclined to do this until we get Jacque Jones on the team, so that we will have 'fredo as a backup SS option
May 20, 200818 yr I'm not sure what all the hate is for McPherson. Everyone says he is in a hitter friendly league, but maybe you can point us to some stats of other players doing the same thing in this league? Also people say that he hasn't been as good as hitter at the major league level as Cantu has. Well of course, but that's no saying much considering Cantu has had a LOT more opportunities at the major league level. McPherson was hurt and hasn't gotten a real shot at an everyday job.
May 20, 200818 yr McPherson hit 3 bombs yesterday and is now up to 15 on the season... Damn the PCL really is a softball league! There are some wild misconceptions about the PCL which turn out to be fantasies and when I post the facts I think you and everyone will be suprised. It surprised the heck out of me. It really has more to do with the level of talent than a number of other commonly referred to factors. I've been meaning to clean it up and post but alas work gets in the way.
May 20, 200818 yr McPherson hit 3 bombs yesterday and is now up to 15 on the season... Damn the PCL really is a softball league! There are some wild misconceptions about the PCL which turn out to be fantasies and when I post the facts I think you and everyone will be suprised. It surprised the heck out of me. It really has more to do with the level of talent than a number of other commonly referred to factors. I've been meaning to clean it up and post but alas work gets in the way. THe PCL had 3 players in 4 days hit 3 homers in one game! I am sure the level of talent is good but most are just AAAA players
May 20, 200818 yr There are a few dominant pitchers this season like Adenhart, Kyle Davies and Giancarlo Alvarado but the pitching in the PCL is mostly throw and duck. If it is because pitches don't break and the ball travels better when hit I do not know, but it just is, it can be rationalized in any way but the bottom line is the PCL is a softball league
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.