May 31, 200818 yr Hi, I am new to the board but have been a Marlins Fan my whole life. I wanted to make this thread to see if the Marlins luck can change. Hanley has to step up his game, I knew we should have waited until the end of the season to lock him up. Pitching is our problem and the GM should do everything possible at this moment to fix this! I saw the rumors of Livan, my favorite pitcher all time, great! sure he can be a good 4 or 5th starter but not an ace. I also saw rumores that alot of pitchers such as Sabathia and ( forgot weather it was halladay or oswalt) will be up for grabs. Those are the type of pitchers we need. I also agree calling up some of the youngsters, give volstad a chance and send down the players doing bad to teach them they gotta step it up this is the big leagues, lol. I love this team which is why I'm saying this. I hate it when they get off to a good start and then get lazy. Hopefully once hammer gets back we will start rolling again but this series is important they gotta attack and show them why they are in 1st well after tonight probably be in second. Hopefully we take the next 2. This thread was made more as an introduction and a discussion for us members to talk about trades and rumors so thanks for reading. :cool
May 31, 200818 yr a) Hanley getting that contract, imo, doesn't have much to do with his struggles. b) Getting pitchers like Sabathia would be dumb, no offense. There's no point in trading your best prospects for a "shot" at the playoffs, this year. If you're gonna trade your best prospects, it should be a long-term thing, and there's no way Sabathia would re-sign with us. Right now, if you're looking at a pitcher...it should be Livan or Greg Maddux, etc. The "top-tier" guys earn too much money, and aren't really worth it. You want to build a consistent winner...not a "shot" at 1 year wonder.
May 31, 200818 yr It's to early to tell. I wouldn't make any trades until the trade deadline. We may be so far out of it that we will be sellers, who knows, it's early. It might be time to move Hendrickson to the bullpen or the minors and call up Volstad. Hendrickson is losing it. One more start and he's outta there!
May 31, 200818 yr Author Thank you holly and erick, none taken,lol. I guess I am just upset on how the pitching has been doing, I mean they did good but right now they should be doing good in this series if you catch my drift. But if Maddux and Livan can do the job then I would be glad. What I meant about Sabathia like if we only have to trade a few prospects that we don't really need( I know they will ask for alot just setting an example). The GM has to get pitcherst hat can get us a win like Livan and I hope we get him ASAP!!!! lol
May 31, 200818 yr Thank you holly and erick, none taken,lol. I guess I am just upset on how the pitching has been doing, I mean they did good but right now they should be doing good in this series if you catch my drift. But if Maddux and Livan can do the job then I would be glad. What I meant about Sabathia like if we only have to trade a few prospects that we don't really need( I know they will ask for alot just setting an example). The GM has to get pitcherst hat can get us a win like Livan and I hope we get him ASAP!!!! lol I think everything becomes more clear, in July. Teams know if they're buying, selling, etc. Btw, solid 1st post. Saying LET'S GO MARLINS when they're getting beat bad, just shows loyalty to the team. Tomorrow is another day. Baseball is a marathon, not a sprint. We'll see...hopefully, we're better tomorrow.
May 31, 200818 yr Author Thanks man. Yea I'm a marlins fan in the good times and bad times. I can't really call this a bad time because thier in second( correct me if I'm wrong) and it's very close. Met fans haven't given up, well at least the ones I know and their in fourth....so to early to throw in the towel. I agree on calling up volstad and such. Tomorrows another day and hopefully we get off to a hot start like today...just keep the lead this time though lol
May 31, 200818 yr I think Sabathia would be good pickup.Trade Olsen and Hendrickson and use some their would be salary next year on Sabathia.
May 31, 200818 yr I think Sabathia would be good pickup.Trade Olsen and Hendrickson and use some their would be salary next year on Sabathia. this isn't a video game.
May 31, 200818 yr a) Hanley getting that contract, imo, doesn't have much to do with his struggles. b) Getting pitchers like Sabathia would be dumb, no offense. There's no point in trading your best prospects for a "shot" at the playoffs, this year. If you're gonna trade your best prospects, it should be a long-term thing, and there's no way Sabathia would re-sign with us. Right now, if you're looking at a pitcher...it should be Livan or Greg Maddux, etc. The "top-tier" guys earn too much money, and aren't really worth it. You want to build a consistent winner...not a "shot" at 1 year wonder. The 97 and 03 Marlins disagree with your Point B
May 31, 200818 yr a) Hanley getting that contract, imo, doesn't have much to do with his struggles. b) Getting pitchers like Sabathia would be dumb, no offense. There's no point in trading your best prospects for a "shot" at the playoffs, this year. If you're gonna trade your best prospects, it should be a long-term thing, and there's no way Sabathia would re-sign with us. Right now, if you're looking at a pitcher...it should be Livan or Greg Maddux, etc. The "top-tier" guys earn too much money, and aren't really worth it. You want to build a consistent winner...not a "shot" at 1 year wonder. The 97 and 03 Marlins disagree with your Point B ...and those trades were made in July. The '03 team did trade Adrian Gonzalez for Urbina...yet, Sabathia will demand WAY MORE than that...so will Ben Sheets, Oswalt, etc. Those guys have proven they can be elite SP in this league. ...it's not worth it, especially now...only in May. Plus, no team is gonna trade their players in early June, basically telling their fans they've given up on the season. And...by July, it's possible we could be sellers...who knows? If we are, I don't want to trade prospects...I want to trade Hendrickson, Kevin Gregg, Justin Miller, etc. if that's the case.
May 31, 200818 yr obviously you only buy when your in the hunt. But if the marlins are holding a playoff spot in mid-late July and only need 1-2 pieces in order to really legitimize their shot, then they should and would make a move. Only way I see this happening is if one of our June 20th SP call ups has a Dtrain type effect and either Miller or Olsen really step up. Then we would be one Ace and one CFer away from being a complete team. Lots of "ifs" there, for sure. Just arguing your point that you don't trade a top prospect for a rental. We've done it before to our benefit.....many teams do.
May 31, 200818 yr obviously you only buy when your in the hunt. But if the marlins are holding a playoff spot in mid-late July and only need 1-2 pieces in order to really legitimize their shot, then they should and would make a move. Only way I see this happening is if one of our June 20th SP call ups has a Dtrain type effect and either Miller or Olsen really step up. Then we would be one Ace and one CFer away from being a complete team. Lots of "ifs" there, for sure. Just arguing your point that you don't trade a top prospect for a rental. We've done it before to our benefit.....many teams do. if we trade for Sabathia, and give up 2-3 of our best prospects, I think it would be a terrible move, even if we are in the hunt. He won't re-sign here at the end of the year. The guy could easily make 15-20 mill a year, elsewhere next year. I'm not for trading 2-3 prospects for a guy who will only spent half a year here to "try" to get us in the playoffs...and fact is, he'll only be pitching once every 5 days.
May 31, 200818 yr Author Thanks for the greetings guys and yea im glad we are talking scenarios, anything is possible. Let's beat them phils tomorrow, go Marlins!
May 31, 200818 yr a) Hanley getting that contract, imo, doesn't have much to do with his struggles. b) Getting pitchers like Sabathia would be dumb, no offense. There's no point in trading your best prospects for a "shot" at the playoffs, this year. If you're gonna trade your best prospects, it should be a long-term thing, and there's no way Sabathia would re-sign with us. Right now, if you're looking at a pitcher...it should be Livan or Greg Maddux, etc. The "top-tier" guys earn too much money, and aren't really worth it. You want to build a consistent winner...not a "shot" at 1 year wonder. I agree with everything but that first point. I think it does have something to do with it. How many times has he struck out looking this month(25)?? How many dingers in May(1)? I just get the feeling he is trying to do too much and needs to get back to the Hanley basics. The alternative reason scares me. It would mean pitchers have figured out that to get Hanley to K means just get 2 strikes on him and then throw a strike fastball down and away. He will watch it go by because he won't protect the plate.
June 1, 200818 yr Author we should have had the game today, but no problem. Marlins win series in atlanta or sweep we good say it with me. LET'S GO MARLINS!!!!!!!!!!
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.