July 31, 200917 yr Jason Vargas was never considered an elite pitcher like Andrew Miller. I don't think you realize how young 24 years old is. I mean, you say it as if has a couple of years left in the big leagues. Like I said, even the great Randy Johnson didn't figure it out till he was 26. I see that you are sticking with "he's still young." Jason Vargas might not have been billed quite as highly as Miller was (however, as I've insinuated, Miller's reputation might have been unfounded), but he was a second round pick, had amazing success in the minors, and was a BA top ten for the Marlins. And this Randy Johnson comparison is laughable. Johnson didn't receive innings in the majors until the age of 25, which negates your point completely. And he had a solid minor league career. Johnson did not struggle whatsoever to the extent Miller has. All that Miller and Johnson have in common is that they are both LHP.
July 31, 200917 yr NOTE: All the follows is just my opinion. Miller, at this point, is at least another year (as in 2011) away from rejoining the rotation. He needs to show in the minors consistency before we call him up again. He doesn't need to be lights out, but he needs to prove that he can pitch adequately every 5 days. Currently, we have 3 pitchers who are either consistently good-to-great (JJ), good after the months of April and May (Ricky), and steady, if not spectacular (Volstad). Except for JJ, they have red flags, like Ricky's slow start the past two seasons and Volstad's HRs this season. But let's assume those get straightened out next season (and that may be a big assumption). So we have two spots left for whoever. Now, Miller has shown us the past two seasons that he isn't quite ready to be up here, at least, as anything more than a spot starter. West this year had some good moments, but may need some more seasoning. But we gotta fill two spots, right? Maybe not this year, but soon. So, getting to the crux of my post, I would not be opposed to trading Miller for a proven, back of the rotation guy. Not a bullpen arm though. Why? Because we already have young pitchers that we talk about potential and upside and waiting for consistency. At some point, we need at least one veteran SP as the rest of our rotation finds their consistent footing.
July 31, 200917 yr Jason Vargas was never considered an elite pitcher like Andrew Miller. I don't think you realize how young 24 years old is. I mean, you say it as if has a couple of years left in the big leagues. Like I said, even the great Randy Johnson didn't figure it out till he was 26. I see that you are sticking with "he's still young." Jason Vargas might not have been billed quite as highly as Miller was (however, as I've insinuated, Miller's reputation might have been unfounded), but he was a second round pick, had amazing success in the minors, and was a BA top ten for the Marlins. And this Randy Johnson comparison is laughable. Johnson didn't receive innings in the majors until the age of 25, which negates your point completely. And he had a solid minor league career. Johnson did not struggle whatsoever to the extent Miller has. All that Miller and Johnson have in common is that they are both LHP. That doesn't negate his point at all. In fact, it makes his point for him. Johnson had 3 full seasons to develop before he pitched to big leaguers. And it wasnt pretty. At 22, Randy walked 94 batters in 119.2 innings. The next year he walked 128 in 140 innings. After that, 72 in 113. So yes, he struggled. He didn't find any control until he was 29. Andrew could've used a few seasons to figure it out too, but his contract all but guaranteed that wouldnt happen. Is he still a cant miss top end starter? Probably not. But he still could be a solid #2 or very good #3. I dont think you trade an Andrew for a Heath Bell when you've got a 'pen as good as we have.
July 31, 200917 yr Id put West ahead of Miller right now. West has a consistent delivery, better control, and his velo is right there if not better than Millers. Just so its clear. Andrews' MiLB line: 3.08 ERA, 7.7 H/9, 0.3 HR/9, 3.5 BB/9, 8.0 K/9 Wests' MiLB line: 3.46 ERA, 8.3 H/9, 0.9 HR/9, 3.8 BB/9, 9.6 K/9 Andrews' MLB line: 5.50 ERA, 9.7 H/9, 0.7 HR/9, 5.0 BB/9, 7.2 K/9 Wests' MLB line: 4.91 ERA, 8.7 H/9, 1.1 HR/9, 4.6 BB/9, 4.7 K/9
August 1, 200917 yr Miller23, you need to come up with something other than he's still young or "he's only 24." That really proves nothing. You know who else is 24? Emilio Bonifacio. Should we be patient waiting for his potential too? Andrew Miller isn't the pitcher with GREAT stuff anymore. GREAT stuff were the days when he threw 95-96...the real reason people actually compared him to Randy Johnson. He no longer does that. Can he still be a good big league pitcher? Sure. But to suggest that he still has the potential of an ace caliber pitcher...he really doesn't, at this point. PS (MrMarlinPride) - This isn't Bell's first good/great year. It's actually his 3rd consecutive good year, which started in '07 when he was flat out dominant as a middle reliever. Trading Miller for Bell straight up wouldn't have been stupid. Some people overvalue closers, sure. But Bell's a lights out closer, and you have to give to get. The only reason the deal didn't go down had a lot more to do with Cameron Maybin than it did with Andrew Miller, I'm sure.
August 1, 200917 yr Yea, because Bonifacio has the same potential as Andrew Miller right? Andrew Miller still has the chance to be that #2 pitcher we all envisioned him to be. Some of you may not believe that, but I do. And you do not trade that for a reliever you do not need.
August 1, 200917 yr Yea, because Bonifacio has the same potential as Andrew Miller right? Andrew Miller still has the chance to be that #2 pitcher we all envisioned him to be. Some of you may not believe that, but I do. And you do not trade that for a reliever you do not need. No but it just shows how silly it sounds. Just b/c a player is 24, doesn't mean he will automatically be something special one day. (and that seems to be your only argument) Fact is, he doesn't have the same stuff he once did, and he seems to be regressing. At some point, he needs to start, at least, progressing.
August 1, 200917 yr That's the same argument you were making for Hermida. So, how doesn't it work for Miller? You guys also have to consider that he didn't get much time in the minors. He's not going to figure it all out as fast as other prospects. Which is why my argument is he is only 24 years old and that we need to have patience with him.
August 1, 200917 yr That's the same argument you were making for Hermida. So, how doesn't it work for Miller? You guys also have to consider that he didn't get much time in the minors. He's not going to figure it all out as fast as other prospects. Which is why my argument is he is only 24 years old and that we need to have patience with him. B/c Hermida has proven a lot more than Miller (despite the hatrid for him on this board).
August 1, 200917 yr Hopefully in the offseason we could package Jeremy Hermida and Andrew Miller and make a good trade.Andrew Miller = Scott Olsen.
August 1, 200917 yr Hopefully in the offseason we could package Jeremy Hermida and Andrew Miller and make a good trade.Andrew Miller = Scott Olsen. Miller has more potential than Olsen...not to mention, Olsen has a torn labrum now.
August 1, 200917 yr Jason Vargas was never considered an elite pitcher like Andrew Miller. I don't think you realize how young 24 years old is. I mean, you say it as if has a couple of years left in the big leagues. Like I said, even the great Randy Johnson didn't figure it out till he was 26. I see that you are sticking with "he's still young." Jason Vargas might not have been billed quite as highly as Miller was (however, as I've insinuated, Miller's reputation might have been unfounded), but he was a second round pick, had amazing success in the minors, and was a BA top ten for the Marlins. And this Randy Johnson comparison is laughable. Johnson didn't receive innings in the majors until the age of 25, which negates your point completely. And he had a solid minor league career. Johnson did not struggle whatsoever to the extent Miller has. All that Miller and Johnson have in common is that they are both LHP. That doesn't negate his point at all. In fact, it makes his point for him. Johnson had 3 full seasons to develop before he pitched to big leaguers. And it wasnt pretty. At 22, Randy walked 94 batters in 119.2 innings. The next year he walked 128 in 140 innings. After that, 72 in 113. So yes, he struggled. He didn't find any control until he was 29. Andrew could've used a few seasons to figure it out too, but his contract all but guaranteed that wouldnt happen. Is he still a cant miss top end starter? Probably not. But he still could be a solid #2 or very good #3. I dont think you trade an Andrew for a Heath Bell when you've got a 'pen as good as we have. This post makes absolutely no sense. How do his single A numbers indicate anything? His original example was talking about his major league performance. He made this explicitly clear when referring to him not providing results until he was 26. What does the fact that Miller advanced faster prove? Nothing. Randy Johnson had a WHIP of 1.34 (more than acceptable) at the age of 26, or his second full season in the big leagues. Until the age of 29 (the year where you say Johnson finally found his control) he consistently put up WHIPs lower than Miller's. His highest was better than Miller's lowest. Miller's problems are not attributed to walks. It is a result of a lack of command that causes him to give up too many walks and hits that lose ballgames. I agree that Johnson did not establish himself until his late twenties but you two are trying to equate Johnson's situation to Miller's and that's just pure nonsense. Not to mention the ridiculousness of assuming that Miller will pan out just because Randy Johnson didn't win a CY Young at 24. That's logically fallacious.
August 1, 200917 yr Yea, because Bonifacio has the same potential as Andrew Miller right? Andrew Miller still has the chance to be that #2 pitcher we all envisioned him to be. Some of you may not believe that, but I do. And you do not trade that for a reliever you do not need. We are criticizing the fact that the only defense for your "belief" is that "he's still young." That's incredibly simplistic. That's the same argument you were making for Hermida. So, how doesn't it work for Miller? You guys also have to consider that he didn't get much time in the minors. He's not going to figure it all out as fast as other prospects. Which is why my argument is he is only 24 years old and that we need to have patience with him. Hermida at least put up a .296/.369/.501 at the age of 23 indicating that he has it in him. The most Miller has done is have a stretch of games where he put up generally league average numbers despite still being terribly inconsistent. If Miller is still the Marlins thought they were getting, we would have seen better results by now. The fact that he has regressed so terribly makes skepticism even more warranted.
August 1, 200917 yr Yea, because Bonifacio has the same potential as Andrew Miller right? Andrew Miller still has the chance to be that #2 pitcher we all envisioned him to be. Some of you may not believe that, but I do. And you do not trade that for a reliever you do not need. We are criticizing the fact that the only defense for your "belief" is that "he's still young." That's incredibly simplistic. That's the same argument you were making for Hermida. So, how doesn't it work for Miller? You guys also have to consider that he didn't get much time in the minors. He's not going to figure it all out as fast as other prospects. Which is why my argument is he is only 24 years old and that we need to have patience with him. Hermida at least put up a .296/.369/.501 at the age of 23 indicating that he has it in him. The most Miller has done is have a stretch of games where he put up generally league average numbers despite still being terribly inconsistent. If Miller is still the Marlins thought they were getting, we would have seen better results by now. The fact that he has regressed so terribly makes skepticism even more warranted. My argument is legit. You do not give up on 24 year left handed pitcher with his potential. Especially for a Relief Pitcher/closer that you do not need. I realize Andrew Miller hasn't had a great season like Hermida has had, but that doesn't mean you flip him for a closer that you do not need. If Andrew Miller was packaged in a deal that brought us Gonzalez and Bell, then I wouldn't mind.
August 1, 200917 yr Jason Vargas was never considered an elite pitcher like Andrew Miller. I don't think you realize how young 24 years old is. I mean, you say it as if has a couple of years left in the big leagues. Like I said, even the great Randy Johnson didn't figure it out till he was 26. I see that you are sticking with "he's still young." Jason Vargas might not have been billed quite as highly as Miller was (however, as I've insinuated, Miller's reputation might have been unfounded), but he was a second round pick, had amazing success in the minors, and was a BA top ten for the Marlins. And this Randy Johnson comparison is laughable. Johnson didn't receive innings in the majors until the age of 25, which negates your point completely. And he had a solid minor league career. Johnson did not struggle whatsoever to the extent Miller has. All that Miller and Johnson have in common is that they are both LHP. That doesn't negate his point at all. In fact, it makes his point for him. Johnson had 3 full seasons to develop before he pitched to big leaguers. And it wasnt pretty. At 22, Randy walked 94 batters in 119.2 innings. The next year he walked 128 in 140 innings. After that, 72 in 113. So yes, he struggled. He didn't find any control until he was 29. Andrew could've used a few seasons to figure it out too, but his contract all but guaranteed that wouldnt happen. Is he still a cant miss top end starter? Probably not. But he still could be a solid #2 or very good #3. I dont think you trade an Andrew for a Heath Bell when you've got a 'pen as good as we have. This post makes absolutely no sense. How do his single A numbers indicate anything? His original example was talking about his major league performance. He made this explicitly clear when referring to him not providing results until he was 26. What does the fact that Miller advanced faster prove? Nothing. Randy Johnson had a WHIP of 1.34 (more than acceptable) at the age of 26, or his second full season in the big leagues. Until the age of 29 (the year where you say Johnson finally found his control) he consistently put up WHIPs lower than Miller's. His highest was better than Miller's lowest. Miller's problems are not attributed to walks. It is a result of a lack of command that causes him to give up too many walks and hits that lose ballgames. I agree that Johnson did not establish himself until his late twenties but you two are trying to equate Johnson's situation to Miller's and that's just pure nonsense. Not to mention the ridiculousness of assuming that Miller will pan out just because Randy Johnson didn't win a CY Young at 24. That's logically fallacious. I am not equating Johnson's situation to Miller's. I realize both were in different situations. The fact of the matter is, not even the HOFer Randy Johnson was lights out in the beginning. He struggled, too. Andrew Miller is struggling, but he can still turn it around. He is young enough to do so and has the upside, which is why I keep saying he is only 24 years old.
August 1, 200917 yr My argument is legit. You do not give up on 24 year left handed pitcher with his potential. Especially for a Relief Pitcher/closer that you do not need. I realize Andrew Miller hasn't had a great season like Hermida has had, but that doesn't mean you flip him for a closer that you do not need. If Andrew Miller was packaged in a deal that brought us Gonzalez and Bell, then I wouldn't mind. Who said anything about giving up on him? It's called making a wise investment. Right now Miller does not project to be nearly the pitcher the Marlins thought he was. If the Marlins can get a lights out closer for him, it's a move you have to consider. Take Hermida for example. If the Marlins traded him one year ago, they would have gotten much more in return. The Marlins took a risk and now his value has diminished to nothing. You need to weigh the probability of the player panning out. However, the Hermida supporters actually had a case to be made in taking the risk to wait because Hermida had at least performed well at the major league level. Miller, on the other hand, is being lit up in AAA. I am not equating Johnson's situation to Miller's. I realize both were in different situations. The fact of the matter is, not even the HOFer Randy Johnson was lights out in the beginning. He struggled, too. Andrew Miller is struggling, but he can still turn it around. He is young enough to do so and has the upside, which is why I keep saying he is only 24 years old. I'm fully aware of what you are trying to say. The argument makes no sense because: 1. Johnson never struggled as much or for as long as Miller has. He never regressed as considerably. Right now Miller's stock is rock bottom. 2. The probability or occurrence of young pitchers not panning out is far greater than the probability of pitchers matching or exceeding their potential. It's simply a logical miscalculation.
August 1, 200917 yr I guess I can see your point of trading him now because the offer is for a great relief pitcher. I just don't like that idea because I have high hopes for Miller, and still expect him to be a great pitcher.
August 1, 200917 yr Also Heath Bell's career ERA away from Petco: 4.14! Are we ever going to reach a point where people actually look at the parks guys play in? Heath Bell would probably not be a 4 ERA with us, but he wouldn't be a sub-3 either, and I don't want to trade Andrew Miller for like Leo Nunez. Heath bell would be better than Leo Nunez, but of course his HR rates might normal playing outside of Petco, so who knows how much better he'd be.
August 1, 200917 yr I will say that no player is ever who he will be at 24. Of course not. I've said repeatedly here that Miller is not as bad as he's pitching now. People don't seem to understand that being skeptical is not the same as dubbing him as worthless. Also Heath Bell's career ERA away from Petco: 4.14! Are we ever going to reach a point where people actually look at the parks guys play in? Heath Bell would probably not be a 4 ERA with us, but he wouldn't be a sub-3 either, and I don't want to trade Andrew Miller for like Leo Nunez. Heath bell would be better than Leo Nunez, but of course his HR rates might normal playing outside of Petco, so who knows how much better he'd be. Not in 2009, though. His splits are virtually the same with only a marginal increase in ERA. 2009 is the first season Bell has been in this role so I don't think you are being entirely fair in considering career numbers outside of Petco (although they cannot be completely ignored). Bell would be a considerable upgrade over Leo Nunez. That's probably even an understatement.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.