Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Olney: Marlins pushing for Heath Bell

Featured Replies

It is guaranteed that the Marlins will not make a trade involving any of the following players: Stanton, Morrison, Maybin, Dominguez.

 

I just can't see Beinfest trading away any of these players as they literally are the backbone of our future.

 

I don't see any realistic scenario that has the Marlins coming out on top if we lose any of those four, especially if the main piece in return is a 32-year old reliever.

To be honest, there aren't any big fish out there right now worth the asking price. If we make a move, get a modest bat at a modest price. I'm not willing to give up any of the prospects we're mentioning. Too many are too close to helping this ballclub. If anything, I'd like to deal Hermida to make room for Maybin, add by subtraction, and that's about it.

West, Miller, Cousins, and Raynor for Bell and Gonzalez

 

 

 

Do the Padres get to laugh at the offer before hanging up?

The Padres are getting all kinds of hits on closer Heath Bell -- almost a dozen teams have expressed interest -- and not surprisingly, the Florida Marlins have been among the most aggressive teams, reports ESPN The Magazine's Buster Olney.

 

The Marlins have had issues at the back end of their bullpen for much of the season, and Bell would solidify that spot. The Padres have made it clear to other teams that while they are not intent on moving Bell, they will be willing to make a trade if somebody makes an aggressive offer that can help the San Diego organization in the long run. Bell, an NL All-Star this year, has converted 25 of 26 save chances, while compiling a 2.01 ERA. Baseball Prospectus

Bell is worth paying a premium "Finding year-to-year consistency from relievers is no easy thing. Enter Bell, in the top 10 in Fair Runs Allowed (which includes a reliever's rates of inherited runs he lets score) this season with a 1.78 FRA, that after giving the Pad people a 3.55 FRA in 2008 and a 1.66 FRA in 2007. In short, he's someone with a multi-year track record for success, and he'd be under team control for two more (arbitration-eligible) seasons beyond this year. As a result, between his relative durability and his performance track record, he's a reliever worth paying a premium to add." - Christina Kahrl

 

I'd love a real closer at the end of the pen and maybe everyone else back a peg; what a difference it'd make to have Bell at the CL, Nunez/Lindstrom at 8th, Lindstrom/Calero/Myers 7th, Donnelly/Ayala/Pinto 6th/7th

 

Oh man Heath Bell would be awesome in a Marlins uniform! Please Sampson make this happen! Then go get us Victor Martinez!

 

Man if we could get those two without giving up a West or Stanton it would be an amazing thing!

 

 

The only thing Sampson's going to do is critique another movie this weekend.

Trade Maybin, West, Miller and Cantu for Gonzalez and the Marlins future is this year and next year and the year after. By the way, I'm expecting Badenhop to start on Saturday.

A more fair trade is Andrew Miller + Jeremy Hermida + low level prospect for Adrian Gonzalez.

 

 

Gonna take more than that.

 

 

 

Heath Bell would be nice, but like just about everyone else, I'd prefer a bat or a starting pitcher.

 

Wonder if they'd take a pitcher below Miller/West, like an Aaron Thompson...

Trade Maybin, West, Miller and Cantu for Gonzalez and the Marlins future is this year and next year and the year after. By the way, I'm expecting Badenhop to start on Saturday.

 

How does trading Cantu help us..

Teams Hot After Heath

By Eddie Schmid [July 29 at 10:44pm CST] Echoing Buster Olney's earlier reports, Ken Rosenthal and Jon Paul Morosi at FOX Sports are saying that the Marlins are indeed the most aggressive of 10 to 15 teams looking to add Heath Bell. The Marlins have the prospects to get a deal done and "could easily absorb" the $400k left owed to Bell this season. However, the Padres are said to want the Marlins' top pitching prospects in Sean West and Andrew Miller if such a deal were to happen, a high price to pay.

 

 

Probably more bad syntax than anything else, "and" becomes "or" in a quick rewrite and confusion reigns until it gets sorted out. Frankly I see the need for at least another arm at the ready down the stretch but someone has to go to AAA to make room, or a trade then you're where you are, they might be better this with a Rhodes (who I've mentioned before and only will again because the Reds have lost eight of their last ten). Not that I see Rhodes and Hermida as equivalents because I don't but it did dawn on me last night watching Hermida's long out to right center how much better a career he might have in Cincy than Miami.

West + Miller + Hermida for AGon + Bell? Too much or too little?

 

 

New poster here.....

 

In response to: West + Miller + Hermida for AGon + Bell? Too much or too little?

 

WAY too little. We have to remember a few things when going after the best players on other teams, and I think that we can use ourselves in previous years as a compare. Upside and potential is all well and good, but proven commodities are also significantly more valuable to team that is trying to win now. Take our Willis/Cabrera for Maybin/Miller/etc deal a few years back. At the time, the upside potential was far greater on our side with Maybin and Miller, but Detriot got the proven commodity in Cabrera. Looking back, who would you rather have, Cabrera or Miller and Maybin? Miller has been far from the player we thought he could be, and although Maybin tears it up the minors, he is very inconsistent in the big leagues. What's my point? Adrian is a top 5 or 6 1b in baseball, playing is a bad hitter's park, who is making a fraction of what player's with similar production are making. Sure, West has been pretty good, and Miller may have a little bit of upside (which I doubt at this point), but Hermida is almost nothing. To ask for a team's best two players in return for three players who may never contribute, is asking too much.

 

Trust me, being a die-hard Fish fan, I'd love to see this happen, but it just won't. The Padres would want something like (assuming we keep Stanton untouchable) Morrison/Dominguez, West, Miller, and Maybin for Gonzalez, not even Bell. Bell is going to cost us Miller and a mid-level prospect, and I think it's worth it. Thoughts?

A more fair trade is Andrew Miller + Jeremy Hermida + low level prospect for Adrian Gonzalez.

 

 

My Lord Magnus, I read your post and just drooled over that prospect. Get that done, but alas we know its but a dream.

West + Miller + Hermida for AGon + Bell? Too much or too little?

 

 

New poster here.....

 

In response to: West + Miller + Hermida for AGon + Bell? Too much or too little?

 

WAY too little. We have to remember a few things when going after the best players on other teams, and I think that we can use ourselves in previous years as a compare. Upside and potential is all well and good, but proven commodities are also significantly more valuable to team that is trying to win now. Take our Willis/Cabrera for Maybin/Miller/etc deal a few years back. At the time, the upside potential was far greater on our side with Maybin and Miller, but Detriot got the proven commodity in Cabrera. Looking back, who would you rather have, Cabrera or Miller and Maybin? Miller has been far from the player we thought he could be, and although Maybin tears it up the minors, he is very inconsistent in the big leagues. What's my point? Adrian is a top 5 or 6 1b in baseball, playing is a bad hitter's park, who is making a fraction of what player's with similar production are making. Sure, West has been pretty good, and Miller may have a little bit of upside (which I doubt at this point), but Hermida is almost nothing. To ask for a team's best two players in return for three players who may never contribute, is asking too much.

 

Trust me, being a die-hard Fish fan, I'd love to see this happen, but it just won't. The Padres would want something like (assuming we keep Stanton untouchable) Morrison/Dominguez, West, Miller, and Maybin for Gonzalez, not even Bell. Bell is going to cost us Miller and a mid-level prospect, and I think it's worth it. Thoughts?

 

I say do it in a heartbeat. In my opinion, Miller is done in this organization.

I would love for us to get Bell and then go get Adam Kennedy from Oakland to play third.

 

I think those moves along with the possibility of Maybin coming up at some point this season and contributing would guarantee us the wild card.

guys please dont bash me for suggesting this but is it possible that we, speaking in terms of the organization, are over valuing stanton? agreed 150% that his numbers are tough to argue but no one can empirically say that he is a cant miss prospect. so what i am merely suggesting is that if trading stanton and miller or west could net us gonzalez, a proven on the cusp superstar, you have to at least take gander.

Miller and maybin then?if you guys want to get bell your going to have to give up 2 or 3 top prospects so give maybin or well take stanton

 

-Padresfan44

 

 

 

mlbtraderumors.com

 

 

:lol

guys please dont bash me for suggesting this but is it possible that we, speaking in terms of the organization, are over valuing stanton? agreed 150% that his numbers are tough to argue but no one can empirically say that he is a cant miss prospect. so what i am merely suggesting is that if trading stanton and miller or west could net us gonzalez, a proven on the cusp superstar, you have to at least take gander.

 

If he's not a can't miss prospect, then noone is (which is probably true, there is no such thing as can't miss). Baseball America just named him the 2nd top prospect in all of baseball, so I don't know if we're really overvaluing him that much.

Adding Bell would be nice since he should be cheap for awhile, but it would be stupid to overpay,we don't actually need him.

 

To have any chance of contending we need another bat, whether that be Maybin or someone in a trade. The current lineup is not getting it done. Problem is I really can't think of many possible trade options for a bat, considering we can't add much payroll.

Trust me, being a die-hard Fish fan, I'd love to see this happen, but it just won't. The Padres would want something like (assuming we keep Stanton untouchable) Morrison/Dominguez, West, Miller, and Maybin for Gonzalez, not even Bell. Bell is going to cost us Miller and a mid-level prospect, and I think it's worth it. Thoughts?

 

 

welcome to the site :thumbup

 

I think your Gonzalez estimate is a bit too much, but I think the Bell proposal is pretty close.

guys please dont bash me for suggesting this but is it possible that we, speaking in terms of the organization, are over valuing stanton? agreed 150% that his numbers are tough to argue but no one can empirically say that he is a cant miss prospect. so what i am merely suggesting is that if trading stanton and miller or west could net us gonzalez, a proven on the cusp superstar, you have to at least take gander.

 

If he's not a can't miss prospect, then noone is (which is probably true, there is no such thing as can't miss). Baseball America just named him the 2nd top prospect in all of baseball, so I don't know if we're really overvaluing him that much.

 

I dont think were over valuing Stanton but from what Ive been hearing on MLBN and ESPN theres a split among baseball people who feel overall teams are over valuing their prospects while others dont.

West + Miller + Hermida for AGon + Bell? Too much or too little?

 

 

New poster here.....

 

In response to: West + Miller + Hermida for AGon + Bell? Too much or too little?

 

WAY too little. We have to remember a few things when going after the best players on other teams, and I think that we can use ourselves in previous years as a compare. Upside and potential is all well and good, but proven commodities are also significantly more valuable to team that is trying to win now. Take our Willis/Cabrera for Maybin/Miller/etc deal a few years back. At the time, the upside potential was far greater on our side with Maybin and Miller, but Detriot got the proven commodity in Cabrera. Looking back, who would you rather have, Cabrera or Miller and Maybin? Miller has been far from the player we thought he could be, and although Maybin tears it up the minors, he is very inconsistent in the big leagues. What's my point? Adrian is a top 5 or 6 1b in baseball, playing is a bad hitter's park, who is making a fraction of what player's with similar production are making. Sure, West has been pretty good, and Miller may have a little bit of upside (which I doubt at this point), but Hermida is almost nothing. To ask for a team's best two players in return for three players who may never contribute, is asking too much.

 

Trust me, being a die-hard Fish fan, I'd love to see this happen, but it just won't. The Padres would want something like (assuming we keep Stanton untouchable) Morrison/Dominguez, West, Miller, and Maybin for Gonzalez, not even Bell. Bell is going to cost us Miller and a mid-level prospect, and I think it's worth it. Thoughts?

 

I say do it in a heartbeat. In my opinion, Miller is done in this organization.

 

 

How? It's his second year with us.

SI's Jon Heyman tells us the Marlins are "are in serious discussions to try to land Padres closer Heath Bell." Heyman says it looks like it could be Andrew Miller or Sean West. Either young lefty seems like a solid return for Bell. Heyman notes that the Yanks also have interest, but the Fish "are in good position to make a deal."

http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2009/07/marlins-in-serious-talks-for-heath-bell.html

Cubs are also interested in Hermida, and apparently we're interested in Teahen.

why is everyone so f***ing intrigued by teahen? the only thing i like about him is he is versatile. he doesnt walk and he strikes out a lot, we have enough of those players on our team

why is everyone so f***ing intrigued by teahen? the only thing i like about him is he is versatile. he doesnt walk and he strikes out a lot, we have enough of those players on our team

Apparently we declined their offer for Miller or West, and apparently we went fishing for Halladay?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.