Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Olney: Marlins pushing for Heath Bell

Featured Replies

It would be completely retarded to trade Andrew Miller for a RP.

 

No way.

 

Miller's potential has fallen considerably over the last month.

 

 

How? Because he's not pitching lights out? Give him time, and he'll figure it out.

It would be completely retarded to trade Andrew Miller for a RP.

 

No way.

 

Miller's potential has fallen considerably over the last month.

 

 

How? Because he's not pitching lights out? Give him time, and he'll figure it out.

 

I like Miller, but his drop in velocity certainly hasn't helped his potential status as a #1-2

Id put West ahead of Miller right now. West has a consistent delivery, better control, and his velo is right there if not better than Millers.

It would be completely retarded to trade Andrew Miller for a RP.

 

No way.

 

Miller's potential has fallen considerably over the last month.

 

 

How? Because he's not pitching lights out? Give him time, and he'll figure it out.

 

I like Miller, but his drop in velocity certainly hasn't helped his potential status as a #1-2

 

Patience my friend, patience.

Id put West ahead of Miller right now. West has a consistent delivery, better control, and his velo is right there if not better than Millers.

 

 

Everything was right except the part in bold.

It would be completely retarded to trade Andrew Miller for a RP.

 

No way.

 

Miller's potential has fallen considerably over the last month.

 

 

How? Because he's not pitching lights out? Give him time, and he'll figure it out.

No, because he has pitched over 200 innings in the major leagues and still doesn't know how to find the plate. He has not shown any ability to live up to his stated potential. The brightest moment of his career was a stretch of 10 starts or so where he managed to put up roughly league average numbers while being terribly inconsistent.

 

Since then he has regressed terribly. To say that he hasn't been "lights out" is a huge understatement and you know it. He was absolutely hammered in AAA until the injury.

 

I'm not calling him a bust, but he certainly has a rough road ahead of him if he expects to be a fraction of the pitcher the Marlins thought they were getting in the Detroit deal.

It would be completely retarded to trade Andrew Miller for a RP.

 

No way.

 

Miller's potential has fallen considerably over the last month.

 

 

How? Because he's not pitching lights out? Give him time, and he'll figure it out.

 

I like Miller, but his drop in velocity certainly hasn't helped his potential status as a #1-2

 

Patience my friend, patience.

You always say these things but your failure to substantiate them makes one wonder if you know what you are even talking about.

 

First you were whining about Miller criticisms after only one bad start. Then, it became two. Then it was three (in AAA mind you). Now, it has become four.

 

Maybe if you are so committed to lobbying for Miller you should come up with something more substantial than "he's only 24!" or "it's only 1/2/3/4 bad start(s)."

It would be completely retarded to trade Andrew Miller for a RP.

 

No way.

 

Miller's potential has fallen considerably over the last month.

 

 

How? Because he's not pitching lights out? Give him time, and he'll figure it out.

No, because he has pitched over 200 innings in the major leagues and still doesn't know how to find the plate. He has not shown any ability to live up to his stated potential. The brightest moment of his career was a stretch of 10 starts or so where he managed to put up roughly league average numbers while being terribly inconsistent.

 

Since then he has regressed terribly. To say that he hasn't been "lights out" is a huge understatement and you know it. He was absolutely hammered in AAA until the injury.

 

I'm not calling him a bust, but he certainly has a rough road ahead of him if he expects to be a fraction of the pitcher the Marlins thought they were getting in the Detroit deal.

 

 

If you had an ounce of knowledge, then you would know that Andrew Miller can still turn it around. You're acting as if he's heading into his 30s. He is only 24 years old with good stuff. He can still be a very good number 3 starter, and that is something you do not trade for a closer that you do not need.

You always say these things but your failure to substantiate them makes one wonder if you know what you are even talking about.

 

First you were whining about Miller criticisms after only one bad start. Then, it became two. Then it was three (in AAA mind you). Now, it has become four.

 

Maybe if you are so committed to lobbying for Miller you should come up with something more substantial than "he's only 24!" or "it's only 1/2/3/4 bad start(s)."

 

 

What are you talking about? We shouldn't have patience for a 24 year old pitcher with good upside? Sorry if he isn't Felix Hernandez.

You always say these things but your failure to substantiate them makes one wonder if you know what you are even talking about.

 

First you were whining about Miller criticisms after only one bad start. Then, it became two. Then it was three (in AAA mind you). Now, it has become four.

 

Maybe if you are so committed to lobbying for Miller you should come up with something more substantial than "he's only 24!" or "it's only 1/2/3/4 bad start(s)."

 

 

What are you talking about? We shouldn't have patience for a 24 year old pitcher with good upside? Sorry if he isn't Felix Hernandez.

 

I think this is the last time anyone needs to say it- he doesn't have high upside anymore. Not unless the sky falls.

When a pitcher has struggled as badly has struggled as badly as he has and has no minor league career to speak of (his reputation is from mostly college scouting reports alone), he is projected to have little upside.

 

I think Sirspud is right on here. His actual performance is what's important. To clutch onto the fact that he's "only 24" is ignorant. At least Jeremy Hermida has had some success in the major leagues. Miller had a couple of average starts. Even over that stretch he was inconsistent.

You always say these things but your failure to substantiate them makes one wonder if you know what you are even talking about.

 

First you were whining about Miller criticisms after only one bad start. Then, it became two. Then it was three (in AAA mind you). Now, it has become four.

 

Maybe if you are so committed to lobbying for Miller you should come up with something more substantial than "he's only 24!" or "it's only 1/2/3/4 bad start(s)."

 

 

What are you talking about? We shouldn't have patience for a 24 year old pitcher with good upside? Sorry if he isn't Felix Hernandez.

 

I think this is the last time anyone needs to say it- he doesn't have high upside anymore. Not unless the sky falls.

 

 

To each his own then. I stil see a pitcher with high upside, you guys do not.

When a pitcher has struggled as badly has struggled as badly as he has and has no minor league career to speak of (his reputation is from mostly college scouting reports alone), he is projected to have little upside.

 

I think Sirspud is right on here. His actual performance is what's important. To clutch onto the fact that he's "only 24" is ignorant. At least Jeremy Hermida has had some success in the major leagues. Miller had a couple of average starts. Even over that stretch he was inconsistent.

 

 

It's not ignorant. He isyoung enough to say he has upside and potential.

Sh!t, even the great Randy Johnson struggled early on. I know, not the greatest comparison. But, I'm just saying people need to have patience with Andrew Miller.

And your only supporting argument to his "upside" is the fact that "he's only 24." You are entitled to your own opinion, but you do a poor job of backing yourself up.

 

 

And your only supporting argument is that he's been terrible with us so far. That is a terrible argument with a pitcher like Andrew Miller.

No, he didn't.

 

The reason why you are being ignorant is that you are clutching only to Miller's age and do not even bother to assess his struggles, his minor league career, or the blatant mechanical problems that should not be plaguing a pitcher at his age after being in the MLB for several seasons now.

 

Again, you are entitled to your opinion, but your request to "have patience" is backed up with very little.

And your only supporting argument to his "upside" is the fact that "he's only 24." You are entitled to your own opinion, but you do a poor job of backing yourself up.

 

 

And your only supporting argument is that he's been terrible with us so far. That is a terrible argument with a pitcher like Andrew Miller.

:lol

 

No, I've said more than that.

 

I've mentioned the fact that he was rushed through the minor leagues. He has consistently struggled. Has obvious problems with his mechanics. And he has trouble with his command and making his pitches. These are glaring problems that aren't as easy to fix as you are trying to claim.

Although Miller has better stuff than Jason Vargas does, there were many people clutching to your silly logic in the midst of Vargas' struggles here. Many people said back in 2007 "he's only 23!" or "he can work out the kinks!" but people often fail to realize that this isn't always easy.

I still like Miller's potential too but it certainly isn't "retarded" to consider trading him for Bell. Bell isn't just a run-of-the-mill reliever, he has to be considered a top-notch closer at the moment, and - should the Marlins want to - could be kept for a few more years.

 

I'm not sure I'd do it personally, mostly because I would rather keep our trade pieces for spots that we really need (and I don't think bullpen is one of them), but it certainly wouldn't be unheard of.

 

 

 

I just feel like, if the Marlins don't make the postseason it won't be because they failed to pick up Heath Bell. Maybe we'll blow a bunch of leads in the 9th inning and I'll be proven wrong.

Although Miller has better stuff than Jason Vargas does, there were many people clutching to your silly logic in the midst of Vargas' struggles here. Many people said back in 2007 "he's only 23!" or "he can work out the kinks!" but people often fail to realize that this isn't always easy.

 

Hey the Mariners still have time with Vargas his only 25!!

Did anyone here mention yet that the Padres demanded both Miller AND MAYBIN for Bell? I think someone's been smoking something in that San Diego FO.

Jason Vargas was never considered an elite pitcher like Andrew Miller.

I don't think you realize how young 24 years old is. I mean, you say it as if has a couple of years left in the big leagues. Like I said, even the great Randy Johnson didn't figure it out till he was 26.

The bottom line is that if the best you can come up with in defense of a player's potential is "he's still young," you know next to nothing about the game of baseball.

 

Is Miller as bad as he's pitching right now? Absolutely not. However, this recent performance should be an eye-opener to some in regard to the future of his career. In the midst of these struggles, if the Marlins can get a lights-out reliever in return, it's a move you make in a heartbeat.

The bottom line is that if the best you can come up with in defense of a player's potential is "he's still young," you know next to nothing about the game of baseball.

 

Is Miller as bad as he's pitching right now? Absolutely not. However, this recent performance should be an eye-opener to some in regard to the future of his career. In the midst of these struggles, if the Marlins can get a lights-out reliever in return, it's a move you make in a heartbeat.

 

 

You really are ignorant .Andrew Miller has the stuff to be a very good pitcher, and he is young. That is a good enough argument to keep him over a relief pitcher that we do NOT need.

 

Seriousely, we don't need Heath Bell. Yes, he is great. But he is a relief pitcher we do not need. Great, he can close. We don't need a closer. Leo Nunez is doing a fine job there. Then we have Calero, Meyer, Donelly, Sanchez, Ayala and Badenhop, who are all doing a fine job. Maybe we need a LOOGY, but not a closer.

I still like Miller's potential too but it certainly isn't "retarded" to consider trading him for Bell. Bell isn't just a run-of-the-mill reliever, he has to be considered a top-notch closer at the moment, and - should the Marlins want to - could be kept for a few more years.

 

I'm not sure I'd do it personally, mostly because I would rather keep our trade pieces for spots that we really need (and I don't think bullpen is one of them), but it certainly wouldn't be unheard of.

 

 

 

I just feel like, if the Marlins don't make the postseason it won't be because they failed to pick up Heath Bell. Maybe we'll blow a bunch of leads in the 9th inning and I'll be proven wrong.

 

 

Right now it doesn't look like we're saving our pieces for anything. Except for when we deal all of our starters this year for relievers or bad players with speed.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.