Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Daily Farm Report Thread -- 8/16-8/22

Featured Replies

not to mention he walks a lot of people and gives up too many hr's for a sinkerballer with such great promise. at best he is sergio mitre.

I'm not counting on him and I never said he was likely to be a future middle of the rotation starter. In fact, I deliberately said elsewise.

 

And for the upteenth time he'd be claimed. Why wouldn't he be claimed? You have yet to make a solid arguement against it. He has been a good prospect since he was in high school, and has lost the past couple of years because of injuries. Why in the hell would we give up on a 23 year old good pitching prospect because he's been injured for two years?

 

The "Depth" you listed is not good depth. good depth is what the Red Soxs have. We're no where close to good depth. Look at the pieces of sh*t that had to make starts for us since '06 because of our lack of depth. That include this year with sending out John Koronka, Hayden Penn, Graham Taylor. I mean, you yourself just listed why we don't have good depth.

 

And where would Morrison be getting a lot of starts? You say 1b and LF. Yes. Taking starts away from our second best hitter (1b), starts away from our lead off hitters (lf), starts away from our best power bat (2b), starts away from our clean up hitter (3b). again, again, AGAIN, look at how we have treated prospects in the same situation in the past when we have called them up in september. The past repeats itself. Look. See. Watch.

not to mention he walks a lot of people and gives up too many hr's for a sinkerballer with such great promise. at best he is sergio mitre.

 

 

Yes, the guy with a BB/9 of 2.73 pre-pitching injured and a HR/9 of 0.55 gives up too many walks and hrs. Wait, what?

I'm not counting on him and I never said he was likely to be a future middle of the rotation starter. In fact, I deliberately said elsewise.

 

And for the upteenth time he'd be claimed. Why wouldn't he be claimed? You have yet to make a solid arguement against it. He has been a good prospect since he was in high school, and has lost the past couple of years because of injuries. Why in the hell would we give up on a 23 year old good pitching prospect because he's been injured for two years?

 

The "Depth" you listed is not good depth. good depth is what the Red Soxs have. We're no where close to good depth. Look at the pieces of sh*t that had to make starts for us since '06 because of our lack of depth. That include this year with sending out John Koronka, Hayden Penn, Graham Taylor. I mean, you yourself just listed why we don't have good depth.

 

And where would Morrison be getting a lot of starts? You say 1b and LF. Yes. Taking starts away from our second best hitter (1b), starts away from our lead off hitters (lf), starts away from our best power bat (2b), starts away from our clean up hitter (3b). again, again, AGAIN, look at how we have treated prospects in the same situation in the past when we have called them up in september. The past repeats itself. Look. See. Watch.

 

 

first off, im pretty sure elsewise isnt a word. lol

 

and he wont be claimed because he has been continually injured and bad for the past 2 years, and even when he was in the tigers organization he had a bad whip and gave up too many hr's for a sinkerballer. he wasnt really a good prospect in high school if he was drafted in the 30th round.

 

and morrison would give guys days off which would be good enough to give him 2-4 starts a week, which is good enough for a guy just getting some seasoning after his aa season.

not to mention he walks a lot of people and gives up too many hr's for a sinkerballer with such great promise. at best he is sergio mitre.

 

 

Yes, the guy with a BB/9 of 2.73 pre-pitching injured and a HR/9 of 0.55 gives up too many walks and hrs. Wait, what?

 

 

the guy had a 1.4 whip even in his good years in the tigers organizations, and gave up 20 hr's last year. even in alb., a sinkerballer shouldnt give up that many hr's. the guy just hasnt pitched well in 2 years, and definitely wouldnt get claimed.

I'm not counting on him and I never said he was likely to be a future middle of the rotation starter. In fact, I deliberately said elsewise.

 

And for the upteenth time he'd be claimed. Why wouldn't he be claimed? You have yet to make a solid arguement against it. He has been a good prospect since he was in high school, and has lost the past couple of years because of injuries. Why in the hell would we give up on a 23 year old good pitching prospect because he's been injured for two years?

 

The "Depth" you listed is not good depth. good depth is what the Red Soxs have. We're no where close to good depth. Look at the pieces of sh*t that had to make starts for us since '06 because of our lack of depth. That include this year with sending out John Koronka, Hayden Penn, Graham Taylor. I mean, you yourself just listed why we don't have good depth.

 

And where would Morrison be getting a lot of starts? You say 1b and LF. Yes. Taking starts away from our second best hitter (1b), starts away from our lead off hitters (lf), starts away from our best power bat (2b), starts away from our clean up hitter (3b). again, again, AGAIN, look at how we have treated prospects in the same situation in the past when we have called them up in september. The past repeats itself. Look. See. Watch.

 

 

first off, im pretty sure elsewise isnt a word. lol

 

and he wont be claimed because he has been continually injured and bad for the past 2 years, and even when he was in the tigers organization he had a bad whip and gave up too many hr's for a sinkerballer. he wasnt really a good prospect in high school if he was drafted in the 30th round.

 

and morrison would give guys days off which would be good enough to give him 2-4 starts a week, which is good enough for a guy just getting some seasoning after his aa season.

 

I'm sorry but this just shows that 1) you don't know what a good HR/9 is and 2) that you don't know about Dallas Trahern. He was drafted in the 30th round because nobody thought he would sign, he was expected to go to college. Yes, he was a good high school prospect. He was a second team high school all american by Baseball America.

 

And again, look at how we have treated prospects in the past. There is no way morrison would be getting 4 starts a week unless somebody is injured. Again look at the guys you'd be taking out of the line up. Again, look at how we have traded them in the past.

not to mention he walks a lot of people and gives up too many hr's for a sinkerballer with such great promise. at best he is sergio mitre.

 

 

Yes, the guy with a BB/9 of 2.73 pre-pitching injured and a HR/9 of 0.55 gives up too many walks and hrs. Wait, what?

 

 

the guy had a 1.4 whip even in his good years in the tigers organizations, and gave up 20 hr's last year. even in alb., a sinkerballer shouldnt give up that many hr's. the guy just hasnt pitched well in 2 years, and definitely wouldnt get claimed.

 

For the umpteenth time he was pitching while injured with a blister on his finger. For the umpteenth time look at all the pitchers with worse potential than Trahern that gets quickly nabbed on waivers. Again why wouldn't he be picked up by Pitt, by Nationals, by Padres, by Royals, by ect ect ect ect ect ect ect who can easily just sit him on their 40 man roster until he's healthy? The only reasoning you have brought up is that he's been injured. So? We should give up on a 23 year old pitcher with upside at our weakest depth because he's been injured the past two years?

I mean, can you even show examples? Can you show a player that was a september call up that'd be in the same position as morrison (aka blocked) that got 4 starts a week for us? Can you show a player filled with options and less potential than Trahern that passed through waivers? You're completely ignoring what has happened in the past and simply saying "this is what I'd do, so this is what would happen"

not to mention he walks a lot of people and gives up too many hr's for a sinkerballer with such great promise. at best he is sergio mitre.

 

 

Yes, the guy with a BB/9 of 2.73 pre-pitching injured and a HR/9 of 0.55 gives up too many walks and hrs. Wait, what?

 

 

the guy had a 1.4 whip even in his good years in the tigers organizations, and gave up 20 hr's last year. even in alb., a sinkerballer shouldnt give up that many hr's. the guy just hasnt pitched well in 2 years, and definitely wouldnt get claimed.

 

For the umpteenth time he was pitching while injured with a blister on his finger. For the umpteenth time look at all the pitchers with worse potential than Trahern that gets quickly nabbed on waivers. Again why wouldn't he be picked up by Pitt, by Nationals, by Padres, by Royals, by ect ect ect ect ect ect ect who can easily just sit him on their 40 man roster until he's healthy? The only reasoning you have brought up is that he's been injured. So? We should give up on a 23 year old pitcher with upside at our weakest depth because he's been injured the past two years?

so he was injured then as well? it just seems like he is always injured. we shouldnt give up on him, i just dont think he will be claimed. at best i think he has the same value as hayden penn who didnt get claimed;. and we dont have a lot of depth, but we have it mostly figured out for a while. jj, nolasco, and volstad, to go along with west,rvh, tucker, james in a couple years, and others who we can pick up in trades in the future, he is low on the totem pole. the only thing we are really arguing is if he will get claimed, and neither of us really know, so it really isnt worth continuing this argument

I'm not counting on him and I never said he was likely to be a future middle of the rotation starter. In fact, I deliberately said elsewise.

 

And for the upteenth time he'd be claimed. Why wouldn't he be claimed? You have yet to make a solid arguement against it. He has been a good prospect since he was in high school, and has lost the past couple of years because of injuries. Why in the hell would we give up on a 23 year old good pitching prospect because he's been injured for two years?

 

The "Depth" you listed is not good depth. good depth is what the Red Soxs have. We're no where close to good depth. Look at the pieces of sh*t that had to make starts for us since '06 because of our lack of depth. That include this year with sending out John Koronka, Hayden Penn, Graham Taylor. I mean, you yourself just listed why we don't have good depth.

 

And where would Morrison be getting a lot of starts? You say 1b and LF. Yes. Taking starts away from our second best hitter (1b), starts away from our lead off hitters (lf), starts away from our best power bat (2b), starts away from our clean up hitter (3b). again, again, AGAIN, look at how we have treated prospects in the same situation in the past when we have called them up in september. The past repeats itself. Look. See. Watch.

 

 

first off, im pretty sure elsewise isnt a word. lol

 

and he wont be claimed because he has been continually injured and bad for the past 2 years, and even when he was in the tigers organization he had a bad whip and gave up too many hr's for a sinkerballer. he wasnt really a good prospect in high school if he was drafted in the 30th round.

 

and morrison would give guys days off which would be good enough to give him 2-4 starts a week, which is good enough for a guy just getting some seasoning after his aa season.

 

I'm sorry but this just shows that 1) you don't know what a good HR/9 is and 2) that you don't know about Dallas Trahern. He was drafted in the 30th round because nobody thought he would sign, he was expected to go to college. Yes, he was a good high school prospect. He was a second team high school all american by Baseball America.

 

And again, look at how we have treated prospects in the past. There is no way morrison would be getting 4 starts a week unless somebody is injured. Again look at the guys you'd be taking out of the line up. Again, look at how we have traded them in the past.

 

he also has poor control, and walks way to many people. how many top prospects have we called up in the past?

Trahern would be a quick claim. No doubt about it. Penn was a MLB claim, this would be a MiLB claim which is a huge difference. That's a bad example. Teams would love to stash him and see if he develops into "at best Mitre." Who can be a solid MLB pitcher when healthy.

 

No way Morrison starts for this ball club right now.

Hayden Penn was out of options. There's a HUGE difference between a player with options and without options.

  • Author

Thanks Mountains_of_Teal. I still without internet at my apartment, so it's difficult for me to get the DFRs in on time. If you wouldn't mind, I could really use the extra help for a couple of days, because I'm having problems with my computer. Hopefully I will get internet going on my computer soon, tomorrow at the soonest and next weekend at the latest. Thanks!

Miami Fan, glad to help out. I've enjoyed following this thread, props to you for starting it and keeping it going. Good luck with the rest of your move.

 

Daily Farm Report - 8/21

 

AAA -- New Orleans

Salt Lake at New Orleans, PPD RAIN

 

 

AA -- Jacksonville

Jacksonville 5, Carolina 1

 

Bryan Peterson - LF: 2-5, 2B, HR, 3RBI (.302ba/year)

Logan Morrison - 1B: 0-5, K

Mike Stanton - RF: 0-1, 3BB, K

Matt Dominguez - 3B: 1-3, 2B, BB,

Scott Cousins - CF: 1-3, RBI, BB, K

 

Advanced A -- Jupiter

Jupiter 4, Palm Beach 0

 

Nobody had multiple hits on offense.

 

J.C. Marinez - RP: 2IP, 1H, K, Win, (3.35 ERA, 37IP, 24H, 33K, .186 b/a against on season) Don't know much about this guy, but not a bad stat line for a 21 y/o reliever.

 

A -- Greensboro

Greensboro 12, Lexington 3

 

Isaac Galloway - CF: 2-4, 2B, BB

Thomas Hickman - LF: 2-4, 2B, HR, 3RBI, BB, K (.390 BA in Greensboro)

 

Brad Hand - SP: 5IP, 5H, R, 0BB, 3K (Win)

 

Short Season A -- Jamestown

Jamestown 10, Vermont 9

 

Kyle Jensen - PH: 0-0, BB

Carlos Paulino - C: 3-5, 2-2B, RBI (.326ba/year) 20 y/o catcher, not much pop, but hits for average

 

Rookie League -- Marlins

Nationals 3, Marlins 2

 

Marquis Cooper - CF: 0-4, BB

Marcell Ozuna - RF: 0-4, BB, 3K

im thinking peterson might have a future as the marlins starting lf in the near future. maybe even next year. but most likely the year after that. i wouldnt mind a platoon between him and carroll in lf next year. sure would get great defense

Mike Stanton walking THREE times??? That is impossible!

 

And I feel Matt Dominguez is starting to figure things out in AA, and it also seems that almost all of his hits are doubles when I check.

im thinking peterson might have a future as the marlins starting lf in the near future. maybe even next year. but most likely the year after that. i wouldnt mind a platoon between him and carroll in lf next year. sure would get great defense

 

I would say the Marlins hope the 2011 outfield is Stanton-Maybin-Cousins/Petersen left to right.

 

For 2010, I suspect they keep Ross, and have a 2B platoon of Coghlan/Bonifacio, and a LF platoon of Coghlan/Carroll/Vet

im thinking peterson might have a future as the marlins starting lf in the near future. maybe even next year. but most likely the year after that. i wouldnt mind a platoon between him and carroll in lf next year. sure would get great defense

 

I would say the Marlins hope the 2011 outfield is Stanton-Maybin-Cousins/Petersen left to right.

 

For 2010, I suspect they keep Ross, and have a 2B platoon of Coghlan/Bonifacio, and a LF platoon of Coghlan/Carroll/Vet

 

I honestly don't expect Coghlan to be platooning with anyone, 2b or LF. Is Morrison still a possibility to play LF or has that plan gone by the wayside? I think he is going to be a factor to start somewhere by the middle of next year.

im thinking peterson might have a future as the marlins starting lf in the near future. maybe even next year. but most likely the year after that. i wouldnt mind a platoon between him and carroll in lf next year. sure would get great defense

 

I would say the Marlins hope the 2011 outfield is Stanton-Maybin-Cousins/Petersen left to right.

 

For 2010, I suspect they keep Ross, and have a 2B platoon of Coghlan/Bonifacio, and a LF platoon of Coghlan/Carroll/Vet

 

 

i can definitely see peterson developing a rep as one of our better prospects with his bat and his fielding especially.

 

maybe by mid year next year we could see

peterson/carrol-maybin-ross

 

with our 2011 being

peterson/cousins-maybin-stanton

All of this minor league talent makes me giddy with excitement. And I know I am not the only one...

 

 

 

especially outfield depth. to me, our future lineup kind of reminds me of the phils.

 

i can see stanton being howard like, hanley is kind of comparable to utley, maybin is what rollins use to be, dominguez good as feliz with better offense hopefully. not the greatest comparison but most applicable comparison to me is stanton to howard. hopefully he has a better average and less k' though, but if he is like howard, its not like its the worst thing to happen.

 

but i do think we need to sprinkle in some veterans into the lineup, at say, 1b or 3b.

im thinking peterson might have a future as the marlins starting lf in the near future. maybe even next year. but most likely the year after that. i wouldnt mind a platoon between him and carroll in lf next year. sure would get great defense

 

I would say the Marlins hope the 2011 outfield is Stanton-Maybin-Cousins/Petersen left to right.

 

For 2010, I suspect they keep Ross, and have a 2B platoon of Coghlan/Bonifacio, and a LF platoon of Coghlan/Carroll/Vet

 

I honestly don't expect Coghlan to be platooning with anyone, 2b or LF. Is Morrison still a possibility to play LF or has that plan gone by the wayside? I think he is going to be a factor to start somewhere by the middle of next year.

With the organizations infatuation with Bonifacio (look at Michael Bourn 2008-2009. I guarantee you they will be hammering Bonifacio with that all offseason), I can see them having a moveable parts order again.

 

I think Morrison is a June 2010 callup if someone is struggling offensively. And I really do mean someone, because we can shuffle all sorts of players elsewhere and make room for him at 1B or LF if need be.

im thinking peterson might have a future as the marlins starting lf in the near future. maybe even next year. but most likely the year after that. i wouldnt mind a platoon between him and carroll in lf next year. sure would get great defense

 

I would say the Marlins hope the 2011 outfield is Stanton-Maybin-Cousins/Petersen left to right.

 

For 2010, I suspect they keep Ross, and have a 2B platoon of Coghlan/Bonifacio, and a LF platoon of Coghlan/Carroll/Vet

 

I honestly don't expect Coghlan to be platooning with anyone, 2b or LF. Is Morrison still a possibility to play LF or has that plan gone by the wayside? I think he is going to be a factor to start somewhere by the middle of next year.

With the organizations infatuation with Bonifacio (look at Michael Bourn 2008-2009. I guarantee you they will be hammering Bonifacio with that all offseason), I can see them having a moveable parts order again.

 

I think Morrison is a June 2010 callup if someone is struggling offensively. And I really do mean someone, because we can shuffle all sorts of players elsewhere and make room for him at 1B or LF if need be.

 

 

i understand, but i guess we just differ on him. i definitely think he is ml ready and can be our #2 or #5 hitter depending on whether cm is hitting leadoff or coghlan.

 

and i think they will keep bonifacio as super util man.

 

i think an opening day 2010 hitters will be

 

c-baker, paulino

1b-cantu

2b-coghlan

ss-hanley

3b-veteran addition/ beinfest miracle under the radar signing

lf- morrison

cf- maybin

rf- ross

bench- boni, helms, peterson or veteran bench addition, carroll. or they could just do morrison at 1st with cantu at 3rd and a free agentin lf or carroll and peterson platooning, which i would love.

im thinking peterson might have a future as the marlins starting lf in the near future. maybe even next year. but most likely the year after that. i wouldnt mind a platoon between him and carroll in lf next year. sure would get great defense

 

I would say the Marlins hope the 2011 outfield is Stanton-Maybin-Cousins/Petersen left to right.

 

For 2010, I suspect they keep Ross, and have a 2B platoon of Coghlan/Bonifacio, and a LF platoon of Coghlan/Carroll/Vet

 

I honestly don't expect Coghlan to be platooning with anyone, 2b or LF. Is Morrison still a possibility to play LF or has that plan gone by the wayside? I think he is going to be a factor to start somewhere by the middle of next year.

With the organizations infatuation with Bonifacio (look at Michael Bourn 2008-2009. I guarantee you they will be hammering Bonifacio with that all offseason), I can see them having a moveable parts order again.

 

I think Morrison is a June 2010 callup if someone is struggling offensively. And I really do mean someone, because we can shuffle all sorts of players elsewhere and make room for him at 1B or LF if need be.

 

 

i understand, but i guess we just differ on him. i definitely think he is ml ready and can be our #2 or #5 hitter depending on whether cm is hitting leadoff or coghlan.

 

and i think they will keep bonifacio as super util man.

 

i think an opening day 2010 hitters will be

 

c-baker, paulino

1b-cantu

2b-coghlan

ss-hanley

3b-veteran addition/ beinfest miracle under the radar signing

lf- morrison

cf- maybin

rf- ross

bench- boni, helms, peterson or veteran bench addition, carroll. or they could just do morrison at 1st with cantu at 3rd and a free agentin lf or carroll and peterson platooning, which i would love.

 

I would think right now

 

C - Baker

1B - G. Sanchez

2B - Coghlan/Bonifacio

SS - Hanley

3B - Cantu

LF - Coghlan/Carroll

CF - Maybin

RF - Ross

B - Bonifacio, Helms, Paulino, Raynor/J. Miller/De Aza Battle for backup OF slot, and "Veteran Bat 1B/OF"

 

I think you are rushing Morrison and Petersen a bit much. With Morrison, deflecting his arbitration long term is really important. If the O's and Rays do it with higher rated prospects such as Wieters and Price, it's likely the Marlins do it with Morrison till June even if he's ready. We have no reason to rush Petersen at all. He needs to hit for some more power before coming up.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.