Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Anyone else not feeling comfortable with 1st?

Featured Replies

I am not happy. But I like out 1B + 3B better than I liked last year's "plan."

 

 

Exactly. Worse case scenario is maybe moving Cantu to 1B and Jimenez standing tall at 3B. At least it's guys that have played the positions before. They went into this ST with a plan, and then contingency plans. Far better than last season.

 

There comes a time when you have to stop filling in a defensive position just because the guy has a decent bat. Their mantra remains pitching, defense, and speed. You get away from what you have been building on too much and other things start to happen. None of them good. Sort of a domino affect.

 

 

Defense can be taught and improved over the course of a year. Hitting, on the other hand, cannot. Give me the good hitter, anyday of the week.

You're way too caught up in the whole "pitching, defense, speed" thing. "Defense, speed" doesn't mean, "lets sacrificice hitting for some more defense and speed." Never does, and when it does...you learn the hard way (as the Marlins did with Bonifacio last year).

 

There's a reason why Chris Coghlan starts...and Brett Carroll doesn't. There's a reason why Adam Dunn plays the field. And every other horrible fielding slugger plays the field, when necessary. A bat is the priority.

 

 

First of all, it's not me. It's the FO and coaches that have been preaching that. There is an email you can write to tell them how wrong they are. Doubt they will listen, but you can try. They will tell you what other teams have found out. A bat is a nice addidtion, but we are out of the long ball era and teams are slideing towards exactly what the Marlins are attempting to accomplish. Pitching and defense. It's how you neutralize those big bats to some extent.

 

Hitting can't be taught? There are a bunch of hitting coaches around the baseball world that are now worried about their jobs. And I guess guys like Logan ought to just trade their gloves in for a job in the real world with the rest of us.

 

I do agree that defense can be taught. If the player is capable of performing it. You can't teach talent, you can only teach technique.

Like others have said, I'm confident in the hitting and I'm confident in Sanchez at 1st base. I love Morrison, but he's not ready yet and I wanna see if Gaby can run with the job for a bit.

 

Like others... the starting rotation behind Johnson and Nolasco scares me and if Ricky gets off to a slow start like he did last year... I'd be even more scared.

 

 

Although still kinda early, it's beginning to look like it. And that may not be such a bad thing in the long run. But Jimenez not stepping up yet is not a good thing. After everything the team did to get him here I was hoping for a better showing that we are getting up to this point.

via MLBTradeRumors

 

The Florida Marlins had scouts on hand to watch Mike Lowell's Grapefruit League debut at first base today, writes Clark Spencer of the Miami Herald. Although the club's level of interest in the 36-year-old is unclear, Spencer entertains the notion of a possible reunion between the Marlins and their all-time home run leader.

 

Considering how minuscule their payroll is, it's hard to imagine the Marlins making a play for Lowell unless Boston is willing to take on virtually the entire $12MM that he'll make in 2010. As Spencer points out though, the corner infield situation in Florida is still in flux. Jorge Cantu is capable of manning either side of the diamond and is penciled in at third base for now, while unproven youngsters Logan Morrison and Gaby Sanchez compete for the first base job.

 

Lowell looked solid in his debut, collecting a hit in two at-bats and playing three innings in the field. Of course, it'll take more than a single game to show that he's back to full health after battling thumb and hip issues. It was Lowell's thumb injury that resulted in a trade to Texas being called off earlier in the winter.

 

In that proposed deal, the Red Sox showed a willingness to pay a significant chunk ($9MM) of Lowell's salary. If Lowell displays good health this spring, and the Sox will still pay that price to move him, the Marlins and Twins could be among the teams interested.

 

 

 

This may also be for a backup for Cantu. We still aren't really sure about his wrist.

Like most, I'm more worried about the starting pitching. It looks like Gaby at first now and Cantu at third, but the other option would appear to be Jimenez at third and Cantu at first. I'm fine with either of those options, really, as I'm hoping we at least hold on to Jimenez. Unless Morrison hits the tar out of the ball in the next week, I'd assume he's out of the running for first. Either way, no, I'm not worried about first base.

I am not happy. But I like out 1B + 3B better than I liked last year's "plan."

 

 

Exactly. Worse case scenario is maybe moving Cantu to 1B and Jimenez standing tall at 3B. At least it's guys that have played the positions before. They went into this ST with a plan, and then contingency plans. Far better than last season.

 

There comes a time when you have to stop filling in a defensive position just because the guy has a decent bat. Their mantra remains pitching, defense, and speed. You get away from what you have been building on too much and other things start to happen. None of them good. Sort of a domino affect.

 

I disagree with the posited cause-and-effect relationship. Baseball is such an individualized sport. If Gaby starts one year and struggles defensively with a serviceable bat, I don't see how it has any impact on the style or substance of their plans moving forward. They still look for the player who brings the best overall package with a similar "lean" toward speed/defense.

 

I'm refering to the amount of IF throwing "errors" as much as anything else. And with little trust going to the abilities of your 1B, guys will be rushing a little harder to make plays, both getting to and releasing the ball. Baseball an individualized sport?? At times. But try to convince the IFers of that. I see Gaby as Jake Part II. The similarities should not be ignored. And people should not forget how trading Jake was pretty much well taken. And to stress how much that was the right move, one only needs to see how Jake has done since leaving here.

 

But you did touch on a point. If Gaby makes the Opening Day roster, it is still just a stop gap move until Logan's bat is ready. Even going into ST last season it was known he would be there for 1 or 2 years and probably gone after that.

 

 

How are they similar in any way?

I am not happy. But I like out 1B + 3B better than I liked last year's "plan."

 

 

Exactly. Worse case scenario is maybe moving Cantu to 1B and Jimenez standing tall at 3B. At least it's guys that have played the positions before. They went into this ST with a plan, and then contingency plans. Far better than last season.

 

There comes a time when you have to stop filling in a defensive position just because the guy has a decent bat. Their mantra remains pitching, defense, and speed. You get away from what you have been building on too much and other things start to happen. None of them good. Sort of a domino affect.

 

 

Defense can be taught and improved over the course of a year. Hitting, on the other hand, cannot. Give me the good hitter, anyday of the week.

You're way too caught up in the whole "pitching, defense, speed" thing. "Defense, speed" doesn't mean, "lets sacrificice hitting for some more defense and speed." Never does, and when it does...you learn the hard way (as the Marlins did with Bonifacio last year).

 

There's a reason why Chris Coghlan starts...and Brett Carroll doesn't. There's a reason why Adam Dunn plays the field. And every other horrible fielding slugger plays the field, when necessary. A bat is the priority.

 

 

First of all, it's not me. It's the FO and coaches that have been preaching that. There is an email you can write to tell them how wrong they are. Doubt they will listen, but you can try. They will tell you what other teams have found out. A bat is a nice addidtion, but we are out of the long ball era and teams are slideing towards exactly what the Marlins are attempting to accomplish. Pitching and defense. It's how you neutralize those big bats to some extent.

 

Hitting can't be taught? There are a bunch of hitting coaches around the baseball world that are now worried about their jobs. And I guess guys like Logan ought to just trade their gloves in for a job in the real world with the rest of us.

 

I do agree that defense can be taught. If the player is capable of performing it. You can't teach talent, you can only teach technique.

 

 

I meant to say that defense is easier to teach. And when a guy can really hit, he'll still start, regardless of how bad he is, defensively.

I don't have to tell the FO anything. Regardless of what they're preaching, fact of the matter is, the strength of the team is still the lineup. So much for "pitching, defense, and speed."

 

If "defense and speed" is sooooo important, why is Bonifacio not starting again this year? Oh, that's right. Because he didn't produce last year, offensively...

 

If the philosophy was all "defense and speed" Gaby Sanchez wouldn't be the primary candidate to win the last corner infield spot, at the moment. You wanna know why he's going to win it, though? Because unlike last year, he's now HITTING in Spring Training.

 

HITTING MATTERS...A LOT. More than defense, and definitely a lot more than speed.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.