Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Did Loria and the FO set Freddi up ?

Featured Replies

Not sure I'd say Loria is a "fan" of the Marlins in the same sense Steinbrenner is a fan of the Yankees. I'd say he's a fan of business, money, and art way before he is a fan of baseball and of the Marlins.

 

Many people around baseball simply remember him as the reason the Nationals (Expos) aren't still in Montreal.

Not sure I'd say Loria is a "fan" of the Marlins in the same sense Steinbrenner is a fan of the Yankees. I'd say he's a fan of business, money, and art way before he is a fan of baseball and of the Marlins.

 

Many people around baseball simply remember him as the reason the Nationals (Expos) aren't still in Montreal.

 

 

I can see that, but I also remember (maybe distorted) his absolute euphoria in Yankee Stadium after the Marlins won the World Series in 2003 on the DVD.

 

Plus the fact that he watches the home games near the dugout and apparently was so involved in the game that he was jabbing at the ump so much that Girardi (or whoever) yelled at him to shut up and lead to that fiasco...

 

Maybe the Marlins aren't number one on his list of things he is passionate about, but he has proven, to me at least, not to be dispassionate.

  • Author

Not sure I'd say Loria is a "fan" of the Marlins in the same sense Steinbrenner is a fan of the Yankees. I'd say he's a fan of business, money, and art way before he is a fan of baseball and of the Marlins.

 

Many people around baseball simply remember him as the reason the Nationals (Expos) aren't still in Montreal.

 

 

I can see that, but I also remember (maybe distorted) his absolute euphoria in Yankee Stadium after the Marlins won the World Series in 2003 on the DVD.

 

 

Well DOH ! He could see the $$$$ signs that win meant. :shifty

 

Seriously he probably does want them to win, but I stand by my thoughts its possible this season was sacrificed for longer term goals.

As far as I can see Fredi is a mediator type manager.

He does not spark the team but he does not let it go down.

He always delivers what the team is capable of doing.

In Atlanta he will be able to constantly lead them to 1st or 2nd place in the division but there will be hiatus in WS championships.

 

 

You mean like the 15 year hiatus since the last time the Braves won a WS? And the 38 year hiatus between their last championship and the one before that?

 

It's not like Fredi'd be anything different than Bobby Cox, it sounds like.

This is ridiculous.

 

 

Not as ridiculous as you might think. This owner and FO are quite Machievellian.

 

This is still ridiculous.

Why wouldn't they just fire him in the offseason?

 

 

Well that is the million dollar question isn't it ?

 

This whole thing just doesn't seem to be making any sense. That is why I am trying to grab at straws, anything to make sense of it.

 

Why did they fire Freddi when they did when its been obvious they didn't have anyone in place to come right in ? The timing is just screwed up and its all making the Marlins FO and Loria look even more Mickey Mouse than they already are percieved. I don't know if you relize it, most MLB fans accross the country think our team and especially owner are a joke.

 

How also does this messy situation play out this close to the new stadium being opened ? The team doesn't seem to have any distinct plan for 2012. Its not like its a big deal to them, other than it will produce more revenue (supposedly).

 

Did it ever occur to you that Loria actually wants to win? The team was 34-36 after an 87 win season. Loria might not spend much money, but the fact he's at almost every home game makes you think he cares, somewhat. You're making a big deal about this for no reason. Who cares? He got rid of Fredi Gonzalez, not Josh Johnson.

 

Its a known fact Loria wanted Freddi out after last season. He talked to Valentine about it, and that is well known as well.

 

If Loria had fired Freddi after an 87 win season, it would have been a sh*tstorm worse than after firing Girardi. He couldn't do that, as MLB would start getting involved. They do have a stake in what goes on in every one of their franchises. Not a monetary one, but they don't wish it to be a total sh*thole (Pittsburgh is an exception I guess). So perhaps they set Freddi up in the expectations that this team would tank, and then getting rid of Freddi doesn't look so bad.

 

Not saying this is what happened, but just speculating it could have happened. Just a theory, just like the theory that Loria wants to win, we hear about it all the time, yet haven't seen proof of it for years now. :shifty

 

 

The opinion he wants to win is supported by the fact that he's at nearly every home game.

Your speculating is stupid because it makes no sense. An owner isn't going to purposely lose to have an excuse to fire a manager. If he wanted to fire the manager so badly, he would've done it in the offseason. You don't lose on purpose. Losing only makes the business worse for the business man.

Why wouldn't they just fire him in the offseason?

 

 

Well that is the million dollar question isn't it ?

 

This whole thing just doesn't seem to be making any sense. That is why I am trying to grab at straws, anything to make sense of it.

 

Why did they fire Freddi when they did when its been obvious they didn't have anyone in place to come right in ? The timing is just screwed up and its all making the Marlins FO and Loria look even more Mickey Mouse than they already are percieved. I don't know if you relize it, most MLB fans accross the country think our team and especially owner are a joke.

 

How also does this messy situation play out this close to the new stadium being opened ? The team doesn't seem to have any distinct plan for 2012. Its not like its a big deal to them, other than it will produce more revenue (supposedly).

 

Did it ever occur to you that Loria actually wants to win? The team was 34-36 after an 87 win season. Loria might not spend much money, but the fact he's at almost every home game makes you think he cares, somewhat. You're making a big deal about this for no reason. Who cares? He got rid of Fredi Gonzalez, not Josh Johnson.

 

Its a known fact Loria wanted Freddi out after last season. He talked to Valentine about it, and that is well known as well.

 

If Loria had fired Freddi after an 87 win season, it would have been a sh*tstorm worse than after firing Girardi. He couldn't do that, as MLB would start getting involved. They do have a stake in what goes on in every one of their franchises. Not a monetary one, but they don't wish it to be a total sh*thole (Pittsburgh is an exception I guess). So perhaps they set Freddi up in the expectations that this team would tank, and then getting rid of Freddi doesn't look so bad.

 

Not saying this is what happened, but just speculating it could have happened. Just a theory, just like the theory that Loria wants to win, we hear about it all the time, yet haven't seen proof of it for years now. :shifty

 

 

Loria stood the storm when he fired Girardi after Girardi winning NL coach of the year. Now true it is a little different but I don't think if the FO wasn't so adamently opposed to firing Fredi in the offseason it would have happened before this season. If I remember correctly there were several members here who wanted Fredi ousted last year. So I don't agree there would have been such a firestorm. So Loria gets ridiculed by the media? Won't be the first time and probably won't be the last.

 

It's interesting who has gained support in the last few years has been Samson and how he worked/talked gaining us the stadium. He had a lot more potential than I could imagine. But that's another subject.

 

Beinfest admitted in his 790theticket interview HE went to the others in the FO and then Loria after Beinfest realized "something was missing" while the team was playing in Texas. It wasn't Loria clamoring for the firing this time.

Ah, it's an at-will employment situation.

 

Loria needed absolutely no reason or justification of any kind to fire Freddi, all he's obligated to do is pay him under the terms of his contract whether he's managing the Marlins or not (assuming he's not dead, hasn't committed some offense qualifying as "moral turpitude" and hasn't refused to work.)

 

Loria could (and perhaps did) wake up one morning and decide that we need a new manager for whatever reason(s) having absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with Freddi, and that's it. Period, end of story.

 

This thread is beyond ridiculous.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.