March 3, 201214 yr with 2 wild card spots, that's actually pretty likely. can't wait to see how the MLB handles that in a panic.
March 3, 201214 yr Still a little confused on how this will work. Wish someone would make a playoff bracket so I can visualize it. :lol
March 3, 201214 yr OK. WC2 @ WC1 WC2 @ WC1 WC Winner vs #1 Seed #2 Seed vs #3 seed LCS WS Bam Simple enough. I was complicating it in my head way to much. Was thinking theres was more to it.
March 3, 201214 yr OK. WC2 @ WC1 WC2 @ WC1 WC Winner vs #1 Seed #2 Seed vs #3 seed LCS WS Bam Simple enough. I was complicating it in my head way to much. Was thinking theres was more to it. Change that to just WC2 @ WC1 once, only a 1 game playoff.
March 5, 201214 yr with 2 wild card spots, that's actually pretty likely. can't wait to see how the MLB handles that in a panic. That's another reason why this plan is stupid.
March 5, 201214 yr can't wait to see how the MLB handles that in a panic. Yeah, they probably haven't thought of that one. What will they do?
March 5, 201214 yr can't wait to see how the MLB handles that in a panic. Yeah, they probably haven't thought of that one. What will they do? They've certainly thought about it, but to have a couple of 1-game playoffs in a row like that maginifies the un-baseball-ness of this whole scenario.
March 5, 201214 yr 2 or more teams might be tied by W-L for the 2nd WC, but surely MLB was smart enough, at this very late date in terms of the long history of designing play-off structures and rules in all ML sports to think of enough tie-breakers to eliminate ANY possibility of any tie, no matter how many teams are involved. They can't have any possibility of adding 2 more days to an already too-long schedule, after adding a day (net) for a second WC by eliminating a travel day from the Divisional play-off.
March 5, 201214 yr Under the old (pre-2012) system is there anything in the rulebook that says what MLB would have done in the case of a 3-way tie for the WC?
March 5, 201214 yr 3-team game. 6 innings. Team A fields when Team B bats, team B fields during Team C's batting, Team C fields during Team A's batting. [Team C is home team] Nah, I joke, I have no idea.
March 5, 201214 yr Author Interesting... So now if you have the best record in your league outside of the 3 division winners then you have to beat a second wild card team before proceeding with the playoffs as normal...That's annoying if you're the real wild card team (with the better record)...But I guess if you're the second wild card team then it's pretty awesome that you still have a chance to go all the way despite (possibly) finishing 3rd in your very own division.
March 5, 201214 yr Sounds like the "anti's" are saying basically the same things as they did when the original WC was established. Guess we will just have to wait and see how it works out.
March 5, 201214 yr Under the old (pre-2012) system is there anything in the rulebook that says what MLB would have done in the case of a 3-way tie for the WC? I haven't found anything specifically covering 3 (or more)-way ties, and while it's not authoritative, here's one description of the previous rules: The tiebreaker rules start simply with the head-to-head marks, which usually do the trick. If they don't, they're followed by records each club has within its own division, which is followed if necessary by intra-league records for the second half of the season, adding another game to the sample if even that's tied. http://mlb.mlb.com/n...ent_id=14991826 "Head-to-head" rules might be problematic when it comes to 3 or more teams. If A beat B, and B beat C, and C beat A, then what? Don't know if they covered that possibility. Divisional record would probably eliminate 1 of the 3, reducing the tie to 2 teams, and may eliminate 2 teams, ending the problem, but that may mean nothing in view of the "head-to-head." Intra-league record would certainly determine it, if they can get beyond the head-to-head and divisional things. Here's a shocker: Assuming the article to be correct on the facts, we never knew that it could possibly have mattered in which order you lost games in the middle of the season, as the last tie-breaker (in the days of one one wild-card) looks at the record going backwards one game at a time from the 82nd game if the last 81 games don't determine it.
March 5, 201214 yr It has its pros and cons. Should be interesting no matter your stance on the switch.
March 10, 201214 yr I don't like it. To have a 162 game season only to be eliminated in a one-game playoff series sounds stupid. I guess the upside is it puts more emphasis on winning the divisions. As far as I could tell, the baseball playoffs had very little correlation between being a high playoff seed and being a World Series Champion, at least compared to other sports. That wasn't a necessarily good or bad thing, it just was. I'm thinking now that might not be the case anymore. If the wild card teams have to play their best pitcher, the winner won't play him again on the next round, at least not in the first game.
March 10, 201214 yr Im I correct in saying that the game would be a one game playoff? if thats the case, my only concern would be that a bad ump call, injured player, bad hope, could spell the end to everything for that team. No second chance.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.