Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Casey McGehee

Featured Replies

You truly are an idiot.

 

Lookup why Escobar was traded.

 

 

 

I know why he was traded, he wouldn't play third base. Players will play where you make them. See: Ramirez, Hanley

I know why he was traded, he wouldn't play third base. Players will play where you make them. See: Ramirez, Hanley

 

 

 

Look again.

Look again.

 

 

 

I don't have to, I remember. They asked him to play third, he said no thanks, they sent him to Tampa.

I think the reasoning was just posted in here in picture form, which is, I believe, what the reason to which Piazza is referring.

 

 

I don't have to, I remember. They asked him to play third, he said no thanks, they sent him to Tampa.

 

 

 

You remember nothing.

Or they wanted to move all the money they owed, [deleted].Of course that replacement couldn't have been Escobar because he was also making money, so he was flipped to Tampa and Hech was given the job.

.

 

 

So you say you know why he was traded, but you spew this non factual shit?

 

Good to know.

 

WildCard Gonna WildCard

 

prv11576_pg1.jpg

I think the reasoning was just posted in here in picture form, which is, I believe, what the reason to which Piazza is referring.

 

 

 

If that was the reason they never admitted it. They probably wouldn't have acquired him to begin with had that been a big enough issue.

 

Piazza, I suggest you do some research yourself and see what the FO had to say. The only thing I ever heard them say publicly was he won't play third base, we need a third baseman, so we are trading him to Tampa.

So you say you know why he was traded, but you spew this non factual shit?

 

Good to know.

 

WildCard Gonna WildCard

 

 

 

The public reason was he wouldn't play third and they were committed to Adeiny at SS. Considering we made the trade to unload all committed money, most people here assumed they dealt Escobar to Tampa for the same reason, so they could be completely rid of any substantial salary.

 

How about you go read up a little bit more and let me know what you find.

If that was the reason they never admitted it. They probably wouldn't have acquired him to begin with had that been a big enough issue.

 

Piazza, I suggest you do some research yourself and see what the FO had to say. The only thing I ever heard them say publicly was he won't play third base, we need a third baseman, so we are trading him to Tampa.

 

 

 

Research is for those who don't know shit.

 

 

You don't know shit.

 

prv11576_pg1.jpg

Research is for those who don't know shit.

 

 

You don't know shit.

 

 

 

You don't have to go far to be proven wrong. Just find an old thread from the trade and read it. You're an idiot and you're absolutely incorrect about this.

I deal in facts--- it's a currency that never goes out of style and can always be redeemed for respect.

 

I suggest you go looking for some facts of your own- you've lost a lot of respect these days.

I deal in facts--- it's a currency that never goes out of style and can always be redeemed for respect.

 

I suggest you go looking for some facts of your own- you've lost a lot of respect these days.

 

 

 

The only fact about this subject is that the Marlins dealt Escobar because he rejected the hot corner. It had zero to do with homophobic slander or salary according to the Marlins.

 

That is fact. It's not my opinion, it's what they publicly stated when they dealt him to Tampa.

You don't have to go far to be proven wrong. Just find an old thread from the trade and read it. You're an idiot and you're absolutely incorrect about this.

 

 

 

So... When I go looking for said "facts"..will it say they wanted to avoid paying him 5MM or will it say he didn't want to play 3B. You've changed your reasoning twice- so I just want to make sure.

 

Will I also pull up the facts that they wanted to reinvest the 5M in another 3B like Stewart or Reynolds but no one wanted to play in Miami?

 

What will I find?

 

Oh that's right- WildTurds "facts".... Hiding in the Batcaves Trophy room next to a giant coin and an animatronic T-Rex.

If he was traded for not being willing to play third base, then why the hell didn't we try and get a third baseman back for him?

 

 

 

If I recall it was unsure at the time whether Dietrich would pursue 2B or 3B in Miami.

 

That was the fact of the matter, though. They said they asked him to play 3B, he politely declined, and they dealt him.

 

Most felt it was because of money, few felt it was because of the slur, but those were just the opinions. The only fact was he wouldn't play third.

TBH I thought they traded escobar because of his price tag + they actually did/still do think Adeiny is a perennial all star + they used to like deitrich.

 

He was traded for to play 3B in Miami, but he changed his mind a few days after meeting with the Marlins in an effort to be traded. He didn't want to upset his "compatriot" as he put it and try to take the SS position- pretty much putting his writing on the wall.

 

What was happening infront of the stadium and elsewhere was a lot of people were upset about his homophobic comments and his trade TO Miami and were picketing and petiotioning to have him never suit up. In addition to the fact fan favorites were traded- him being a homophobe on top of that was just the icing on the cake.

 

The marlins, already facing a massive PR backlash from the trade alone- didn't want the added negative PR for having traded for a homophobic player in a market where the LGBT dollar is about 20% of the marketplace- in addition to their families who may feel it is against their principles to support a organization that pays and relys on a homophob.

 

They wanted to reinvest his contract in another 3B to show the Escobar trade wasn't about the money- but all the 3B options declined because they didn't want to be a part of a crummy team who just gutted a roster after a spending spree.

 

This was right around the time Samson said "Free Agents will go where the money is". Obviously this proved to be incorrect at the time.

 

The Marlins were a sinking ship that no one willingly wanted to jump aboard. Players like Kotchman, Polanco and Slowey saw it as rebuilding their careers. Reynolds and Stewart saw it as ending theirs.

 

Escobar was just trying to avoid playing in Miami, used the issue of a new position to force the move and wanted to avoid the public backlash the LGBT community was going to unleash on him when he would finally play.

 

No matter what WildTurd said before- the move was not about money. They couldn't find anyone to take theirs as a matter of fact.

 

The Marlins were the known AIDS patient, wanting to bareback an escort with a brand new hotel as the backdrop.

 

No one had a career death wish- except those who had their careers on life support and had nothing more to lose.

And this is my opinion-

I also wouldn't be surprised to find out the MLBPA had set a direct edict to not sign in Miami to free agents after prettying fucking Delgado, Buerhle and Reyes in the ass one season after signing and the commisioners office having to force Loria to open his checkbook in 2009/2010.

And everything you just wrote was and still is a theory and opinion except for the part about Escobar declining the option to play third base and being dealt soon after because of it.

 

The only FACT is he was traded because he did not want to play third base. Whether or not it's the real reason we will never know, but that is the reason given by the source itself.

  • Author

And everything you just wrote was and still is a theory and opinion except for the part about Escobar declining the option to play third base and being dealt soon after because of it.

 

The only FACT is he was traded because he did not want to play third base. Whether or not it's the real reason we will never know, but that is the reason given by the source itself.

 

 

If that is the reason why he was traded, it just makes the front office look even stupider because escobar > adeiny at SS by a mile

 

 

Here's the article WC is referring to: http://miamiherald.typepad.com/fish_bytes/2012/12/yunel-escobar-to-rays-for-minor-league-infielder.html

 

Makes you wonder about the marlins scouting office wanting to move Escobar and his 3.9 2013 SS WAR for the worst position player in baseball in 2013.

 

 

 

To get a full picture of the Escobar trade, you have to piece several video news reports, articles, and stories together.

 

A really good one was the private texts Lebatard was recieving from inside the organization for the reasonings why they made the larger trade, and two weeks later the smaller one.

 

With that piece of audio clip- everything fell into place neatly.

 

For those of us who bled Black and Teal, and now Black, Red-Orange, Blue and yellow.... We can pretty much identify the source of those texts.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.