October 5, 201412 yr Nicolino in the starting rotation to begin next year would make me sad. Also I disagree with ya Erick. Find it strange you mention in your post you think Beane would want to rebuild his farm, and then you go on to say you think he'd trade Donaldson for two guys who'll be starting in the majors next year and one pitching prospect. And while I think Eovaldi still holds value I don't think after this past season it holds as much value as you guys are making it out to be. I definitely believe it would take two of German/Romero/Urena/Nicolino at the very least to get the job done along with Heaney and Eovaldi.
October 5, 201412 yr Nicolino in the starting rotation to begin next year would make me sad. Also I disagree with ya Erick. Find it strange you mention in your post you think Beane would want to rebuild his farm, and then you go on to say you think he'd trade Donaldson for two guys who'll be starting in the majors next year and one pitching prospect. And while I think Eovaldi still holds value I don't think after this past season it holds as much value as you guys are making it out to be. I definitely believe it would take two of German/Romero/Urena/Nicolino at the very least to get the job done along with Heaney and Eovaldi. I would be almost as comfortable with Nicolino in the rotation as I am with Heaney...
October 5, 201412 yr I would be almost as comfortable with Nicolino in the rotation as I am with Heaney... It's statements like this man...
October 5, 201412 yr Heaney has proven nothing at the ML level and is every bit a question mark as Nicolino would be heading into next year.
October 5, 201412 yr Heaney has proven nothing at the ML level and is every bit a question mark as Nicolino would be heading into next year. Heaney's upside is way better than Nicolino's. Lets not do this Eovaldi/Hand thing again.
October 5, 201412 yr I would make that deal in a heart beat. Throw in Dietrich for good measure, since the A's would need another bat and the Marlins are all but guaranteed to move him. I could live with a rotation of Alvarez/Cosart/Koehler/Nicolino/Hand until Jose gets back in order to have Donaldson. Alvarez = more likely a #2 than the ace-like performance he turned in this year. Cosart = #3 at best, more realistically a #4 Koehler = a #4 Nicolino = a ???, gives up a lot of contact, who the hell knows? #4 at best, likely not ready yet. Hand = a #5 The rotation you could live with is one that I could probably die watching.
October 5, 201412 yr Alvarez = more likely a #2 than the ace-like performance he turned in this year. Cosart = #3 at best, more realistically a #4 Koehler = a #4 Nicolino = a ???, gives up a lot of contact, who the hell knows? #4 at best, likely not ready yet. Hand = a #5 The rotation you could live with is one that I could probably die watching. So without Jose, we have to make due. With Jose, in your estimation, we have a true #1, #2, #3, #4, and #4 with a #5 as depth. You might be frustrated for a few weeks, but the offense could be good enough to help the team sustain Jose's absence until July.
October 5, 201412 yr So without Jose, we have to make due. With Jose, in your estimation, we have a true #1, #2, #3, #4, and #4 with a #5 as depth. You might be frustrated for a few weeks, but the offense could be good enough to help the team sustain Jose's absence until July. I'd like to strive for higher than a league average starting rotation, wouldn't you? Just because you have a "1,2,3,4,5" doesn't mean that's what you want. Baseball doesn't work like that. You want to fill your rotation with as many Fernandez's and Alvarez's as possible. I actually think Alvarez/Heaney/Eovaldi/Cosart all have potential to be good #2 starter's in that order. I like our rotation, but if Nicolino is starting in our rotation next season even at the beginning and Koehler is our #3 pitcher something is horribly horrible wrong.
October 5, 201412 yr I'd like to strive for higher than a league average starting rotation, wouldn't you? Just because you have a "1,2,3,4,5" doesn't mean that's what you want. Baseball doesn't work like that. You want to fill your rotation with as many Fernandez's and Alvarez's as possible. I actually think Alvarez/Heaney/Eovaldi/Cosart all have potential to be good #2 starter's in that order. I like our rotation, but if Nicolino is starting in our rotation next season even at the beginning and Koehler is our #3 pitcher something is horribly horrible wrong. Actually, teams that have a true #1-5 in each rotation spot are usually always post-season contenders. Very few teams have that luxury, league average rotations generally don't have talent like Jose/Alvarez/Cosart leading the way. I agree, Nicolino is not Heaney and having him start the season in the rotation wouldn't be ideal, but having Stanton and Donaldson hitting back to back would be the definition of ideal. Btw, Koehler is probably better than you think. He just had a pretty good year and it probably wasn't a fluke.
October 5, 201412 yr Koehler is a mediocre 4th/5th starter at best IMO. Based on this season he is a superb 5th starter and a good 4th starter...
October 5, 201412 yr Based on this season, he was pretty mediocre no matter where he was in the rotation.
October 5, 201412 yr A 1,2,3,4,5 rotation is great, but a 1,1,1,1,1 rotation is even better. The Nationals seem to be doing just fine with probably the closest thing to a 1,1,1,1,1 rotation in MLB at the moment.
October 5, 201412 yr A 1,2,3,4,5 rotation is great, but a 1,1,1,1,1 rotation is even better. The Nationals seem to be doing just fine with probably the closest thing to a 1,1,1,1,1 rotation in MLB at the moment. . The Nats have the best rotation in the game, that's why they are where they are. But teams with a true 1-5 rotation generally are very competitive, most teams strive for that but few actually achieve it. The ones who do are usually post-season teams. And Spike, Eovaldi had a mediocre season. Koehler was better than that, and there's nothing that suggests it was all luck. Most everything was very solid, maybe a few too many walks, but that's about it. Considering he entered the season as a maybe for 5th starter, I'd say he finished it as one of the top #5 guys in all of baseball.
October 5, 201412 yr . The Nats have the best rotation in the game, that's why they are where they are. But teams with a true 1-5 rotation generally are very competitive, most teams strive for that but few actually achieve it. The ones who do are usually post-season teams. And Spike, Eovaldi had a mediocre season. Koehler was better than that, and there's nothing that suggests it was all luck. Most everything was very solid, maybe a few too many walks, but that's about it. Considering he entered the season as a maybe for 5th starter, I'd say he finished it as one of the top #5 guys in all of baseball. We are not doing this. I refuse. Our rotation needs to improve but it's very possible both eovaldi/alvarez/cosart will be better come next year. Due to the experience from one year in the league. Heaney will be better this year. Nicolino needs another year or two in the minors. He could be the next Phill hughes. Which works btw.
October 5, 201412 yr Sign shields, get Fernandez back, and thats all we need. That makes eovaldi and cosart 4/5. I'm very happy with that. Stop being a dick, Loria, and spend some fucking money. This core is real. Don't be a dick. Shields/Fernandez/Eovaldi/Alvarez/Cosart. Trade Koehler and urena for a bat. 3rd base? or SS? or Catcher? Or Second base?
October 5, 201412 yr Sign 1b trade for 2b. I don't see them moving shits mcgehee or hech In this fantasy we have signed shields(I don't expect to sign anyone else especially with giancarlo). 1b is either mcgehee or bour which is fine with me. And kike will be super utility. So 2b or 3b
October 5, 201412 yr In this fantasy we have signed shields(I don't expect to sign anyone else especially with giancarlo). 1b is either mcgehee or bour which is fine with me. And kike will be super utility. So 2b or 3b Id be pretty pissed if Kike is nothing more than Alfredo Amezega after the FO gave up Moran because they insisted he was in the deal... I would be VERY surprised if Kike is not our starting 2B next year. I fully expect Dietrich to be traded.
October 5, 201412 yr Hech was a centerpiece once so there's an example of what this fo values. I think that was more the FO putting a positive spin on things rather than the actual thought process. Clearly the center of that deal was Marisnick/Nicolino/DeSclafani and Hech was just the guy that was going to replace Reyes. Hernandez, on the other hand, was specifically sought after by the FO as a "must have" player and they literally gave up Moran to have him (and Austin Wates, but that's neither here nor there). If they value Hernandez over Moran, which seems to be the case, I certainly hope they view him as a starter and I don't have much doubt that's the way it will play out. I really hope he becomes our own Ben Zobrist rather than another Alfredo Amezega...
October 5, 201412 yr They wanted hech and had to trade Jose Reyes to get him. Dumb. Uh, I would say that they had 100 Million reasons to trade Reyes, and none of them are because they wanted Hech.
October 5, 201412 yr They wanted hech and weren't going to get him without moving Reyes. Or they wanted to move all the money they owed, with Reyes being $100 Million of it, and needed a cheap replacement for him. Of course that replacement couldn't have been Escobar because he was also making money, so he was flipped to Tampa and Hech was given the job. I really, REALLY, REALLY doubt that they traded Jose Reyes just so they could get Hechavarria. In fact, I'm pretty damn certain of it. They traded Reyes for two reasons, the first being money. The second was that he was our only leverage in the deal to begin with. Without him we probably would have been unable to unload the contracts of Johnson and Buerhle, and even if we could have done it without him, we would have gotten next to nothing instead of three pretty good prospects in Nico/Mars/Disco.
October 5, 201412 yr Or they wanted to move all the money they owed, with Reyes being $100 Million of it, and needed a cheap replacement for him. Of course that replacement couldn't have been Escobar because he was also making money, so he was flipped to Tampa and Hech was given the job. I really, REALLY, REALLY doubt that they traded Jose Reyes just so they could get Hechavarria. In fact, I'm pretty damn certain of it. They traded Reyes for two reasons, the first being money. The second was that he was our only leverage in the deal to begin with. Without him we probably would have been unable to unload the contracts of Johnson and Buerhle, and even if we could have done it without him, we would have gotten next to nothing instead of three pretty good prospects in Nico/Mars/Disco. You truly are an idiot. Lookup why Escobar was traded.
October 5, 201412 yr I love that he couldn't even use proper grammar in his bigotry. Read a book, morans.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.