February 3, 200422 yr I think he meant injury wise anyway I hope Pudge has a great year in Detroit....
February 3, 200422 yr i said two years, because i dont think he can take two more texas size losing seasons, especially after this year. Yes Detroit may have a few good players but there ace was 9-21 or something ridculuos like that. At this stage in his career you would think pudge would want to play for some winners. I think 2 years of losing will make him realize its not only about the money. Well i hope he learn that before the end of his career.
February 3, 200422 yr I think that this is a dead topic...whatever he signed with detroit, im happy for him, he got what he wanted. I wish him the best of luck.
February 3, 200422 yr Author Detriot in the weak division there in have a very good chance of winning 65-70 games this year which would be a big improvement for the franchise. If some of there young pitching comes around Bonderman, Maroth, Cornejo and there veteran hitters step it up, Pudge, White, Vina, Higgision and Young. They can field a competitive team instead of the laughingstock they were last year.
February 4, 200422 yr The ironic thing is that the deal is not as sweet as Boras would have us believe. Details from the Detroit Free Press: 2004 - $7M 2005 - $8M 2006 - $11M 2007 - $11M 2008 - $13M team option or $3M buyout If the injury clause comes into play, that will be 2 years/15 mill. the "injury clause" is still stacked in his favor, though. if he's on the DL for 35+ days due to "lower spine injury," the team can opt to cancel his contract with a "buyout" of $5 million after the 2005 or $4 million after 2006. essentially, that means he could injure himself on opening day and still collect $7M in 2004, $8M in 2005, and a $5M buyout if the tigers wish to cancel the contract. that's a minimum 2 years/$20 million guaranteed. not a bad deal at all.
February 4, 200422 yr You know what? LeBatard is exactly correct on this story. Just as he was a few weeks ago, he has hit the point exactly. He did a great job.
February 4, 200422 yr Pudge was with me last night and all I need to say is that I wont ever look at him the same way again. We drank together and this morning I wake up next to him. :thumbup
February 4, 200422 yr Pudge is the best... I don't get how you guys complain so much. He won the world series for you and this is how you pay him... *shakes head* BTW Jenna Honey, Pudge is only your in your dreams. My dad saw him last night at a strip club getting busy.
February 4, 200422 yr Yea, I was the one giving him the little private dance, if ya know what I mean, jelly bean.
February 4, 200422 yr 1) Apparently Le Retard has spent too long in the dark, dank recesses of ESPN's collective crotch to notice current baseball economics. Did Pudge sell out? Of course. But is this worthy of piling on? Of course not, it's not even news unless we step back into the late 80's. You could replace Pudge's name with at least a hundred different players in MLB over the last 10+ yrs who have done the same thing. The article is redundant, irrelevant, cachophonic, utterly devoid of original thought and a pathetic effort to pander at the local fans' emotionalism. 2) As for the need for Pudge to make more.... Apparently LeRetard is a card-carrying member of the socialist party now. He'll be able to tell you when you are making too much for your own good too. Here's an idea. Maybe Dan-O needs to ask himself when enough is enough. Does he really need to whore himself to ESPN, ESPN Mag and any other media outlet that'll give him the time of day? I'll apply his logic and bet he could make more in a couple of years just writing for the Herald than a guy tarring roofs could make in a career, so why isn't he pulling back? He's a neo-Marxist hypocrite. And thanks for the news flash that athletes have big egos. Exactly who is he to criticize anyone for having a big ego, anyway? 3) Pudge make more as a healthy Marlin? No DH in Miami, Le Retard. Pudge would have to mind the plate every day he played here. Also, the "out" in his Detroit contract only covers spinal injuries, not anything else. Plus, Detroit is a very loyal sports town, and he'll make tons more on local endorsements in the Metro Detroit area then he could ever in this baseball-indifferent market. Pudge had an opportunity to make more on a longer contract. Just like any other professional athlete he took it. Period. 4) Which brings me to the last point... Ripping on the Tigers as an "abysmal laughingstock." Sounds alot like the Marlins of the past, who couldn't draw flies and were a supposed target for contraction. The very same Marlins he's piled on for the last couple of years. The Marlins would kill for a tenth of the history, successes and fan loyalty that the Tigers have, even as putrid as they are and have been for the last 10 years. The Tigers will draw more winning 75 games this year that the Fish will draw winning 90. Having grown up in Detroit And then moving to SoFla (And becoming a diehard FishFan) I know that Detroit is a baseball town. Forget the Pistons in their parity-devoid league or the glorified roller-derby called hockey. The move makes sense for both the Tigers and Pudge, simple as that. Sorry for the rant, but God he pisses me off.
February 4, 200422 yr Guess good ole pudge will not get to kiss a man next season.....his wife must be thrilled
February 4, 200422 yr Mr. Filet O' Fish, personally I miss your rants and this one good buddy was right on the mark. I grew up a Red Sox fan, absolutely consumed by baseball (and forever broken-hearted by the Sox, at least I got to see Ted Williams) and as I said in an earlier post, either in this thread or another, the Detroit Tigers were fearsome in my youth. They came to play, every game was a war (back in the day when a homerun meant with 100% surety that the next guy up got knocked down). I for one would like to see the Tigers regain what's been missing for many years. If Pudge can help them do it, I say great! As for LeBatard and the Herald, let's face it, their coverage of the Marlins this off-season has been a subtle attempt at undermining the Fish every opportunity they had. D Lee signs with the Cubs, front page above the fold color banner. Marlins signing were relegated almost exclusively to inside the paper on a towards the back page. Their obsession with Pudge? To remind baseball fans in South Florida that he got away. You are 100% right that what transpired with Pudge has happened 100 times in the last decade. It's news because are Champs and he was a promiment face in our victory, but they overdid it bigtime. And as you said about LeBatard, his act is getting old, old, old, you hit the nail on the head. Keep posting Fishy, I for one miss ya. Come back soon.
February 4, 200422 yr he is right though on the two year issue, however i believe that pudge wanted a guarentee of 4 years and not have to renegociate.? However i think 2 years from now detroit will try to get him redo the deal or looking to trade him.? Just my opinion. Fudge wont make it through this year. This is a ridiculous contract and a shame that the Tigers have to be so desperate. I credit them for trying to turn their franchise around, but I think this is the wrong way to do it. You are already a losing franchise - go out and get the best talent you can. They should be building with the best college pitching the game can offer. Spend the money on scouting, player development. Fudge isnt going to help this franchise out - he is only in it for the money. The team is spending money on good college pitching. Last year they used the #3 overall pick in the draft on a college pitcher and they have the #2 pick this year which they will probably use on a pitcher. I don't buy this theory that you can't spend money on free agents to make your team respectable while spending money on player development/scouting. It is possible to do both at the same time. Even at the Press Conference yesterday, Dombrowski emphasized that player development is the key and that he has told everyone in the organization that. However, I am curious as to why you think Pudge won't last a year. I don't see him getting traded. I meant Fudge will go down with an injury. I am not up on the Tigers organization, and I am not one to hate on another team. I wish the Tigers luck and hope they turn the corner soon. That said, Fudge is not the best investment for this franchise - heck, they should have went after Vlad or Tejada or even Guillen. FishFan, good rant. I wish people would read my posts though...I mentioned the exact same things you did. The only thing I disagree on is bashing the S. Fl. market - this is a very knowledgeable market and they will support this franchise. The problem is economically, this market does not have a lot of money. Le Retard never will see that, and is just a big fat idiot who only cares about getting his gun off...
February 4, 200422 yr I kind of agree with The Message he's stating but why would Lebatard care? Only a year ago Pudge was... "Breast Implants on a corpse" Anyone else but HIM had the right to do this article not a fair weather ESPN whore.
February 4, 200422 yr that's gold Jerry, GOLD! Why do they call it ovaltine? The mug is round. The jar is round. They should call it "roundtine." BANIA!
February 4, 200422 yr Fudge wont make it through this year. This is a ridiculous contract and a shame that the Tigers have to be so desperate. I credit them for trying to turn their franchise around, but I think this is the wrong way to do it. You are already a losing franchise - go out and get the best talent you can. Two little letters....DH. He'll make it through. And even if he doesn't, chances are just as good that he'll injure something other than his "lower spine" and get paid anyways. As for the Tigers.... They are very desperate. This is a team that had to give Vina 6mil when no one else offered him more that 1mil because he didn't want to play in Detroilet. It's a common problem in Detroit with free agents, etc... and it's not only the Tigers that can't get talent, but the Pistons and Lions as well. But then again, great talent wasn't crowding the terminals at MIA or FLL the last couple of years trying to get in with the Marlins, either. Remember, the Marlins grossly overpaid (at the time) for Pudge and were going out on a limb too. And it is the right way to do it for the Tigers. Pudge puts a face and some glitz on a team whose average age is about 13 years old. The Tigers will make most of their money back on season tix and Pudge jerseys alone. They are already reaping the dividends.
February 5, 200422 yr Great article??? That was one of the worst articles I have ever read. There was nothing substantial to it at all. Just the usual Tiger bashing ... They were the worst team in baseball and one of the worst teams in Major League history last year. What do you want him to say? I don't have a problem with him saying that. I'm sick of hearing about it, but it's true. What I didn't like was how he compared the team/city to Siberia, Iraq and Hell. That wasn't necessary. He just went overboard with it. He could have gotten the point across without going to the extremes he did. In fact, he sounds like he has sour grapes. BTW, LeBatard was on Detroit radio this morning and they were bashing him pretty good over this article. I happen to agree with TigerFan. LeBatard so loves to pour salt on the wound, to belittle, to kick someone when they're down. He's the schoolyard bully with a keyboard. Is there a baseball fan in America who doesn't know how poorly the Tiger franchise has played in the last few years? Instead of focusing on what the owner and Dombrowski and Trammell are doing to try and right the ship, to rebuild this once glorious franchise, LeBatard does to them what he did for years to the Marlins. Shame on him. I suppose Marlins fans feel a relief that LeBatard has stopped bashing the Fish. Some of you forget the hateful, unjust and erroneous things had to say about our team not so many months ago just because he felt he could get away with sticking in the knife and turning it. He was a jerk then and he's a jerk now. A leopard doesn't change its spots. Thank you Dave Hyde for proving MY ACCURATE POINTS ABOUT PUDGE NOT BEING A GOOD HANDLER OF THE PITCHERS. Note the graph about Pudge not directing meetings with the pitchers. It was Mike Redmond as I first and accurately wrote. Note how Pudge was constantly a no show. Sorry to rain on your parade. Hyde proves who was right on the Pudge debate. CLEAR CUT DECISIVE WIN FOR :hat The champ HYDE: Money talks, Pudge walks Published February 5, 2004 How many of you want to earn more money? And how many think $16 million is a decent stack of money? Does everyone not named Mother Teresa have two hands up? Well? Then you shouldn't be spitting adjectives at Pudge Rodriguez today. Greedy. Grabby. Selfish. Mercenary. Shortsighted. That's the way the former Marlins catcher is being typecast after taking a four-year, $40 million offer from the Detroit Titanics. He's going to get a ton of money. But he's going to lose a ton of games. So the typical question in these cases is: Why in the name of Faustus would he make such a deal? But let's ask the necessary follow-up question: What was the alternative? And when you look at what else was out there, this wasn't just some high-ego player raking in the final top-dollar deal of his career. Nor was this a case of a superstar taking one obscene amount of money over another simply vulgar amount, as Alex Rodriguez did in signing with Texas. This was Pudge Rodriguez looking at Detroit's money, looking what else was out there and signing on a bit reluctantly. Exactly in the manner most people would have. And don't be so sanctimonious to think otherwise, unless you're living in an abbey and have taken a vow of poverty. Detroit was so desperate to make a splash it threw far more money at Rodriguez than anyone else in baseball considered. It had no choice. Over the past decade, Detroit has become as central as Gdansk to the baseball world. You don't just lose there. You don't just freeze there. You fall off the map. So the Tigers needed a trademark name to get people back, and Rodriguez became that. And to get him they had to match most every demand he made. Lucky him. And, well, unlucky him. Because while he got the money he had hoped -- surprising many among us -- he didn't get what he no doubt wanted. Which was a competitive team to jump up and come close to that offer. The Marlins wouldn't. Their best offer was reported to be three years and $24 million, though the final year wasn't guaranteed. That sounds in line with what was reported at the time. Plus only $1 million the first year and $2 million the second year was to be paid up front, according to what agent Scott Boras says. That makes sense, too. That's how the Marlins do business. The Orioles wouldn't come close to Detroit's offer either. They reportedly were close until Rodriguez made a public comment about getting more than Baltimore's three-year, $21 million offer. The Mariners, Cubs, Dodgers -- all of them were rumored to be chasing Rodriguez. But none put a big offer on the table. Rodriguez is turning 32. He has a bad back. He had missed chunks of the two previous seasons. That's why he went to the Marlins last winter in a one-year, $9.3 million marriage that worked out wonderfully for both sides. The Marlins got a healthy catcher, a good season and an October spark plug in Rodriguez. In turn, Rodriguez rebuilt his baseball name to the point that he received the bank-breaking multiyear deal no team would offer a year ago. But while Rodriguez is a significant loss to the Marlins, let's be careful about what exactly was lost. Again, he was the motor behind the Marlins' playoff run. Big hit after bigger hit, Rodriguez was the best Marlins player through October's first two series. Detroit expects to see that player from April through September too. But he hit a solid-but-mortal 16 home runs and .289 last year. Detroit also wants a leader for its players and a teacher for its pitchers. That would demand Rodriguez change. Rodriguez, for instance, didn't run the daily meetings where pitchers and catchers discussed opposing lineups. Backup catcher Mike Redmond typically did this. Truth is, Rodriguez often didn't show up for these strategy sessions. But there are no bad guys, no bad antics, no questionable conclusions to make from Rodriguez's deal. The Marlins had some tough decisions to make, as everyone knew, and Rodriguez became a casualty replaced by a talented, unproven and less expensive Ramon Castro. Detroit did what it had to, jumping higher than anyone else. Boras always gets some blame, but he was hired to strike the best deal and did just that. Finally, Rodriguez was faced with taking a potential $40 million deal over a potential $24 million deal (potential because all deals had various out-clauses largely based on his health). Every philosopher knows not to base important decisions in life only on money. But money has to play some significance. And how many people think a $16 million difference is significant? You can put your hands down now and understand why he's in Detroit.
February 5, 200422 yr that's gold Jerry, GOLD! Why do they call it ovaltine? The mug is round. The jar is round. They should call it "roundtine." BANIA! Read it and weep. Courtesy DAVE HYDE Detroit expects to see that player from April through September too. But he hit a solid-but-mortal 16 home runs and .289 last year. Detroit also wants a leader for its players and a teacher for its pitchers. That would demand Rodriguez change. Rodriguez, for instance, didn't run the daily meetings where pitchers and catchers discussed opposing lineups. Backup catcher Mike Redmond typically did this. Truth is, Rodriguez often didn't show up for these strategy sessions. -- VICTORY TO :hat The champ. You can run from me and try to get me banned. Truth be told, I was correct. There is your documentation
February 5, 200422 yr Mr. Filet O' Fish, personally I miss your rants and this one good buddy was right on the mark. I grew up a Red Sox fan, absolutely consumed by baseball (and forever broken-hearted by the Sox, at least I got to see Ted Williams) and as I said in an earlier post, either in this thread or another, the Detroit Tigers were fearsome in my youth. They came to play, every game was a war (back in the day when a homerun meant with 100% surety that the next guy up got knocked down). I for one would like to see the Tigers regain what's been missing for many years. If Pudge can help them do it, I say great! As for LeBatard and the Herald, let's face it, their coverage of the Marlins this off-season has been a subtle attempt at undermining the Fish every opportunity they had. D Lee signs with the Cubs, front page above the fold color banner. Marlins signing were relegated almost exclusively to inside the paper on a towards the back page. Their obsession with Pudge? To remind baseball fans in South Florida that he got away. You are 100% right that what transpired with Pudge has happened 100 times in the last decade. It's news because are Champs and he was a promiment face in our victory, but they overdid it bigtime. And as you said about LeBatard, his act is getting old, old, old, you hit the nail on the head. Keep posting Fishy, I for one miss ya. Come back soon. How convenient of you to omit parts of articles to make a case you win an argument. You don't get off the hook this easily, fraud. You so boldly proclaimed the Marlins didn't contact Urbina's agent. You quote the agent in a Jayson Stark story, but then leave out the following graph where Stark writes the Marlins had no interest in spending 4 to 5 mil on a closer. As I stated, the Marlins knew what it would take to sign the guy. Clearly 3 mil wouldn't get it done. So don't throw out how bright you are picking little parts of stories to win an argument. You are the undisputed fool of these boards. Victory again to :hat The champ
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.