Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. I'm staying out of this for my own sanity but a few things. There is no such thing as an interest free loan. Were it to happen the IRS would impute the interest so you pay one way or the other. Besides why would you loan money at zero when you can make 5% on it, not good business. The problem with taking on a limited partner is three-fold. 1. The existing minority shareholders will not want to be further diluted. 2. The existing minority shareholders may very well have language in their agreement that protects them from being captives, that they have the first right to be bought out at the same price the new investor would be willing to pay so the new investor's money goes in one door and out the other (which often how partnerships work) and winds up providing very little relief to the franchise and 3. no one comes into a situation like this as a new minority partner without being able to exert his or her control over operations, in effect becoming a minority partner with General Partner control and that's not good for anyone. This is a vulture situation. With the stadium in flux, with the worst lease in sports and existing dissident partners, you would demand (and get) alot to put your money into this organization right now. Carry on.
  2. I proudly admit I wouldn't want to belong to a club that had Spike for a member. Spike cannot get through a day without an ad hominem attack on me. I dont belong to any clubs...although I am a Libertarian Party member. As I was saying... I think Spike, you missed the point.
  3. BTW, Scott Patterson who re-signed with New York and is on their 40 man roster now continues to be lights out in Winter League play. Too bad he won't be available in the draft as earlier thought.
  4. ...I've always liked Schneider and Church and think Milledge is overrated. I agree on the first part. I'd take Schneider and Church on the Marlins without thinking twice. I think this could turn out to be an excellent trade for both teams depending on whether Milledge playing everyday gives him a chance to mature out of the New York spotlight.
  5. RFerry I would disagree. If I understand your contention it's that JL would not be allowed by MLB to make an infusion of capital into the franchise if he chose. Frankly I think MLB would welcome it. I suspect though, if it had a dilutive effect on the minority shareholders they would be vehemently against it, and remember it's not just the Canadians, there are SFL investors as well. The gift to Yale (good pizza there btw) has nothing to do with the Marlins.
  6. ...the money he donated is probably divorced from the Marlins. Nevertheless, he has the means to make an investment that will bring a return. In other words, he simply doesn't want to make the necessary investment. I think he's wrong to cry poverty and then give away money like that. I'm sorry, as a taxpayer it infuriates me. Oh come on Prin, I know you know better. Without knowing the by-laws and organization of the Marlins partnership you know you don't know that. And frankly I don't ever remember Loria crying poverty, ever. As a taxpayer you have to know building a new stadium is going to be a net positive for you the "taxpayer" since a) it allows the freeing of tourist dollars held exclusively for this purpose that you the taxpayer voted for and b) add revenue to the general fund over the thirty year term, and beyond.
  7. I proudly admit I wouldn't want to belong to a club that had Spike for a member. Prin, on the other hand I consider a friend even though we disagree on this issue, we agree on most. Spike cannot get through a day without an ad hominem attack on me. I ignore three-quarters of them. What can I do, respond to every sanity-challenged outburst? And Prin you have to know that I have been critical of David Samson a number of times and I've wanted to see him replaced for quite a while. I was hoping that Beinfest being named president of baseball operations was a move towards jettisoning Samson and frankly I was disappointed when it turned out not to be. So right there I fault Loria for keeping David Samson on. I think it's a huge mistake. As for Loria I am somewhat more sympathetic but I've been critical of him as well when I thought it appropriate. But I'm just not going to join the crazies here who threaten his life, accuse of him everything under the sun up to and including grand theft, misappropriation of funds, corporate malfeasance, all without real hard evidence. And for the record, Forbes is not evidence. Forbes is not fact. Forbes is at best well-reasoned speculation. (It's funny how people quote Forbes as fact but ignore at the other end of the spectrum the same magazine says the New York Yankees is a $100+ million losing operation.) If you don't understand the difference between fact and speculation, ask Prin, he's the lawyer. And ask him about "Post Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc", because that's what's happening here. There is a difference between what we think and what has been proved. (For the record, god knows how many times, I am not taking the position Loria is losing a fortune every year. What I do believe is he is either running at near break-even to positive side or retaining larger earnings, probably to protect the franchise in the event of huge cost overruns in the event a stadium is built.) And most of what is passed off here is wrong. For all the fiction about what happened in Montreal that spreads across the internet like another grassy knoll conspiracy theory by a group of people who have turned it into a cottage industry, Loria did not trade away players during his tenure in Montreal, a popular myth, that happened both before and after he was managing the the Expos organization (see Omar Minaya). The Toronto Globe and Mail, Canada's most respected newspaper did a five part series on the Montreal debacle concluding Loria was in fact brought in by the then majority owners to be their "fallguy", because they themselves had already destroyed the franchise and wanted to set up Loria to make it look like he was to blame, and when he turned the tables on them and they sued, both arbitration panels and the courts concluded the now minority owners were the party at fault and their allegation baseless. I believe the court's language was something like (speaking to the minority shareholders) "you did this to yourselves and you have no one to blame but yourselves". There are those who point to a financial settlement between the two parties as evidence that Loria was guilty of something. If you read further though, it was the minority owners agreeing to pay Loria (and the rest of the defendants) for having to defend himself themselves against these frivolous charges. But some people here would rather believe a bonafide Marlins and Loria hater like fringe columnist Jeff Passan than the findings of the courts or Canada's most respected newspaper. I can't do anything about that and I won't join in. It is the same code of conduct (mine) that says a guy who worked virtually his entire life to become one of the thousand or so best ball players in America at any given time by reaching the major league level, I am not going to refer to him as "garbage" or the various other vile names people use here. Nor am I going to call someone retarded or a moron, it's isn't my style nor my inclination. I've been here about five years I guess, I don't think I've ever called a single player "garbage" because even a Reggie Abercrombie, who I have never seen as major league capable doesn't deserve to be spoken about that way. It is about the work ethic that got the Abercrombies and the Joe Strongs and even the Junior Felix', the tens of thousands of ballplayers who made it and didn't stick to MLB. I stand to applaud their effort first and their contribution second. Most people don't get that. Look at Matt Herges' performance in 2007. It would be interesting to go back in the archives and count how many people here called him washed up, garbage and worse while he was a Marlin which of course speaks to their own baseball acumen and not his talent. Fourteen year olds and the lunatic fringe of haters don't make good talent evaluators and nor do they make good financial analysts either. The people in the middle here for the most part are well-reasoned and enjoyable to read and debate, but at the fringes there seems to be this lynch mob mentality I just can't join in on. If that means in some people's minds that I love Loria so be it, true or not. It would be impossible to dispel their delusions regardless of what I said. I often wonder what the haters and the faux fans will do when the Marlins are in the playoffs again. Will they continue to villify ownership? Will they recant all their names called? Will they admit their sins? I look forward to see who steps up and who doesn't.
  8. I've criticized a number of things the marlins, the FO and the ownership have done, and recently, but I guess because I don't call them names or scream obscenities about them or threaten their lives I'm not in sync with the mob here. Often times what is considered by some as being supportive of the organization or ownership is not based on the personalities involved but things like the tax consequences of XYZ or whatever. It wouldn't matter if it was Jeffrey Loria, Atilla the Hun or Mother Teresa, the law and principles of accounting apply across the board. If people have not read me to be critical at times, I can't do anything about that. As recently as yesterday or today was saying people here have every reason to be critical, I guess what the haters here want is more passion from me, but I prefer to be passionate about the team and the sport, and not the financial back story surrounding the team.
  9. We don't know what the partnership agreement states but regardless were he to make a capital contribution to the Marlins in the form a loan, secured, senior or whatever it no longer creates the tax advantage that Yale does. It either increases his basis or accomplishes something else but it's no longer a write-off. Another thing to consider is there were already partners (at least three I know of, South Florida residents) in the Marlins in place when the Loria and the minority partners from Montreal came in, so I'm assuming a whole new agreement had to be written when the two groups came together. People want to pass this off as more evidence of god knows what but this is very complex and isn't done because someone altruistically wants to dispose of $20 million.
  10. Well, don't expect me to defend Loria, but a $20 mill contribution may not mean an outlay of cash at this time. It could be a charitable trust whereby $20 mill is contributed, Yale is named as the beneficiary when Loria goes to the big free stadium in the sky. A present value tax deduction is taken currently, but the money is controlled by Loria and a portion paid back to him annually. What is left at death will go to the named charity. We all know Loria may need a big deduction since it is possible he has large taxable income not offset by prior losses-oh blashphemy to the Loria fans. Cmon, the back end deals is a Loria specialty, but this would be a legitimate tax maneuver-can't fault him. And it's probably just estate planning or related to his art business where he has given millions away in art work here in Miami and other places over the last few years. Were he to inject $20 million into the Marlins partnership which is what I hear people saying above - I would assume that would have a dilutive effect on the minority owners or force them to put up their share as well to stay at the same percentages they currently have. And if it's being done for tax purposes the write-off from charitable giving, either in the current year or later on, disappears. I hope all of you the success in the future that creates this kind of predicament for you. 03, I can see if we carry on this discussion we will just basically put everyone else to sleep as taxes, properly discussed, is coma inducing to those not interested in it. I believe the Marlins are an LLC, and Loria putting up money would not necessarily cause a change in ownership interests. The terms of the agreement would dictate ownership allocations and profit/loss allocations. He could put the money in as a loan and create a priority interest where his loan would be repaid, with interest, before any distributions are made to minority partners. Whether this would require approval by the minority partners again would be spelled out in the LLC agreement. I have to think that he has the right to make these decisions as the majority owner and the managing partner of the organization without approval of the minority group. At least that is how it seems he has run the operation to date. You know I thought they were an LLC as well, in fact for years, until someone (I think it was Prin) informed me I was wrong. He's an attorney, I assumed he was correct.
  11. Well, don't expect me to defend Loria, but a $20 mill contribution may not mean an outlay of cash at this time. It could be a charitable trust whereby $20 mill is contributed, Yale is named as the beneficiary when Loria goes to the big free stadium in the sky. A present value tax deduction is taken currently, but the money is controlled by Loria and a portion paid back to him annually. What is left at death will go to the named charity. We all know Loria may need a big deduction since it is possible he has large taxable income not offset by prior losses-oh blashphemy to the Loria fans. Cmon, the back end deals is a Loria specialty, but this would be a legitimate tax maneuver-can't fault him. And it's probably just estate planning or related to his art business where he has given millions away in art work here in Miami and other places over the last few years. Were he to inject $20 million into the Marlins partnership which is what I hear people saying above - I would assume that would have a dilutive effect on the minority owners or force them to put up their share as well to stay at the same percentages they currently have. And if it's being done for tax purposes the write-off from charitable giving, either in the current year or later on, disappears. I hope all of you the success in the future that creates this kind of predicament for you.
  12. I don't get this at all. You don't get the strikethroughs?? If it's that I reread what I wrote on the fly after posting it and realized it was FanFish who had posted something I thought you had. Or perhaps that's just your way of being cute.
  13. If you want to look further this is Huizenga's fault. Even further back and you can blame MLB for granting the city a franchise without a baseball-only stadium in the works. But mostly, it's Wayne fault. Because he's the devil. Even though I'm sitting in this gorgeous Business Building he built here at Nova with its leather seats, marble floors and auto-flush urinals and toilets. :confused :thumbup It was Henry who signed that ridiculous lease, promised South Florida he'd build his own stadium and who destroyed the season-ticket holding core base by inviting the riff-raff to sit in their seats while bad-mouthing (justifiably) the stadium. But yes, Wayne is the devil.
  14. We have John Henry to thank for all this.
  15. ...I can't argue with anything except to point out tha alot of this was leaked by the Loria camp to save themselves a few bucks, it was unjustified then and it is uncalled for now. BTW I do rectify my original posting, yes this is a column The only problem here is, at least for me, and we get into that my POV vs your POV thing is, we can guess who leaked what, or if there was even a leak (a reporter finally breaking his silence regarding something he knows is not necessarity a "leak") but we don't know if it was ownership, the FO, a disgruntled coach or someone scouting this team or others who "heard" something. We disagree on Loria and I'm not going there, in fact I'd like to avoid it, but I cannot see why an intelligent guy like Loria would purposely diminish the value of Cabrera because not only does he get less in return, he makes it harder to even move him. You can hate Loria, you can believe he's a horrible owner, you can believe he's pocketing $50 million a year but if he is doing the latter he has to be pretty smart to have pulled it off and not gotten caught by anyone, and if he's greedy, it makes no sense that he would bad-mouth Miggy because all it does is put less money in HIS pocket. There seems to be this belief (not necessarily with you) that everything is spontaneous, immediate with the Marlins. I bet the organization internally have been talking for more than a year, maybe two about what to do as Cabrera approaches the last years of arbitration I'm praying this doesn't start a day of Loria conspiracy theories and hate-mongering because the issue at hand is Miggy vs Manny as perceived by this writer.
  16. Seems to me a) Ramp's FanFish's perspective is correct and b) I'm sure someone would love to prove me wrong but I don't remember any (don't call me a liar for one) comments about Cabrera coming from ownership (Loria or Samson), and the very very few there have been have been attributed to the FO were addressing his weight issue, but sheesh even Guillen tried to intercede to get the guy back on track. Most of these comments that have been published have been third hand accounts, or quoting "a source with..." that someone else reported and picked up here after the fact. As for this particular reporter I suspect he's never seen a Marlins game, never spoken to Cabrera or the front office, and regurgitating the same stuff that's been in the press since Scott Boras' strike team started spreading accusations (as has been widely reported) about Miggy at the GM's meeting in an effort to devalue him while seeking to get ARod a new contract. Most of this stuff has its genesis there. I believe the "nightlife thing" really has to do with happening in Venezuela with his dad one night in the street outside some club. For all the South Beach inferences linked to Miggy in the "foreign" media and local newspapers and magazines (Ocean Drive, 944, etc.) runs tons of pages every issue of clubbing celebrities and sports stars, many of whom are in MLB and I don't remember any pics of Cabrera popping up. Which is not to say where there's smoke there's no fire. But I don't think there's a conspiracy of silence not only among local sport reporters AND local celeb paparazzi types who haunt South Beach. They have different agendas. The weight issue is real. But as Ramp FanFish said the FO wasn't force-feeding the guy. He's been in town, left, came back and I'm not sure where he is now, but I remain stunned no newspaper or the Sporting News who have photogs on the payroll in Miami, or CNN/SI ditto, and the rest, no one has gotten a recent picture of the guy. And I have to wonder why that is? Lastly, it's not an "article", it's a "column", it is one person's opinion based on whatever prejudices he has, what he had for breakfast, or anything he feels like opining. Nowhere is it written that columnists have to adhere to the truth or come close to it, it's the ramblings of one person who happens to be well-trained in using the language. What we really have here is an ethno-racist column based on the belief that all latins are the same or they are easily grouped together because they have some thing in common, no matter that it's only a fraction of the total man. Sean Deveney, that sounds Irish and you know what they say about the Irish. "What's the difference", the joke goes, "between an Irish wedding and an Irish wake? One less drunk". ***I think that applies here.*** ***Stereotypes are stereotypes regardless of enthncity***
  17. Isn't our old friend David Weathers still in Cincy and will be setting up for Cordero after a pretty good year on his own part as closer. I don't know their relief situation intimately but I wonder if the two mentioned above don't have more value here than there until things get sorted out. Frankly I would rather package prospect(s) for Hamilton than start to disassemble our bullpen for a player the Reds are willing to part with with a troublesome history of injury and we all know what else, not to mention his problems hitting lefties. That he's potentially on the block may be quite telling or it may mean nothing. But I would tread lightly.
  18. Lou, have you looked at Griffey's contract? He is in the last year of his deal. It's not bad. I think you forgot something...$57.5M in salary deferred at 4% interest, to be paid 2009-2024
  19. Lou, have you looked at Griffey's contract?
  20. Which park is the worse pitcher's park - Phillie or Cincy? Somehow Dontrelle does not strike me as the type of pitcher a GM could reasonably consider a good match to either ballfield.
  21. LoDuca's problems have more to do with his aggressiveness behind the plate and subsequently being injured to the extreme. He calls a good game, handles pitchers well and offensively is still right up there, his problem is staying healthy. This time around, were he to sign here I suspect you would see a lot more of Matt Treanor than his first hitch. I'm not in favor of his return nor against it, and neither am I Olivo's "if" he can prove that he's made strides defensively and is willing to take less money. The off-season provides a number of players here and elsewhere the time to work on their shortcomings and it's always interesting to see who invested in their futures (and themselves) during that period.
  22. I thought by now Ramp had let the front office know our decision to go with a Treanor/Baker tandem for 2008.
  23. my original post was more like "is there a chance he could be good up here? sure, but he won't be". don't know why i changed it. but i'll leave ya with that for now because arguing sucks. point is, i'd be real surprised if he did decent for a mlb team. :cheers
  24. the Northern League isn't AA minor league ball, sorry. he could have pitched 20 complete game shutouts last year and it wouldn't have meant sh*t. he's 29 and pitching in an independent league. And you became an expert on the Northern League when exactly? Chad Hermanson came from an independent league last season and had a respectable AAA year. Soria came from the mexican league last season that everyone says is like A ball when they want to put down player performances there (where btw Brandon Wood is stinking up the joint) to be a ml pitcher. For this guy to have an impact on the 2008 Marlins is absolutely the longest of longshots but hey. I openly admit I don't know but I also know you don't know either. And how you cannot be at least a little impressed by the guy's performance at this or any level is beyond me. Or what his age has to do with it for that matter. By your rationale Lee Gardner who is three years older should never have been given a shot either. When Gardner was 30 he was pitching A+ ball in Durham.
  25. And this is the opposite of the "Sky is falling" threads that have become popular this year. Different thread, but make no mistake, no less annoying. It's the same thinking as belittling the signing of a washed-up, AAA over-the-hill has-been named Lee Gardner. The guy may just not have the stuff to be competitive at the MLB level but damn, he's been the most dominating pitcher in his league for three straight years at what is functionally the AA level and we and other teams haven't had a problem bringing pitchers up from there. The question isn't can he pitch, his record shows that he can. Yes, yes I know it's the Northern League but these numbers are Steve Nebraska(ish) - 12-1 during the 2007 regular season, 4-0 with a 0.82 earned run average in four post-season starts, a three-hit complete game performance in the fifth and deciding game of the Championship Series. Over his final 13 starts including the playoffs, he went 9-0 with a 1.01 ERA, struck out at least 10 batters in eight starts in 2007 and struck out at least nine in 13 starts. Post-season record over 2006-'07 seasons, six starts, 6-0 with a 0.54 ERA, allowing just three earned runs in 50 innings. Who do we have in AA with numbers anywhere approaching his performance? You guys can laugh I think this is a good get by a team that needs to think outside the box when mediocre pitchers want $10+ million a year. The cost to find out is nothing. There is no downside to signing the guy and it isn't as if the Marlins are touting the signing, I don't think (quick search) it's ever been mentioned on their website. There's very little expectation here. And he's not on the 40 man roster so no one can accuse the front office of wasting a roster spot. I'll take another Lee Gardner thank you very much, or even another Justin Miller. And if he busts out NBD.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.