Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Josh Hamilton on the block?

Featured Replies

ESPN's Jayson Stark says the Reds are aggressively shopping Ryan Freel and will entertain offers for Josh Hamilton.

 

Will the Marlins make move? they went after him once...if the Marlins acquire Kemp, you could trade for Hamilton and move Willingham to 1B. Just a thought

ESPN's Jayson Stark says the Reds are aggressively shopping Ryan Freel and will entertain offers for Josh Hamilton.

 

Will the Marlins make move? they went after him once...if the Marlins acquire Kemp, you could trade for Hamilton and move Willingham to 1B. Just a thought

I'd be reluctant because of no track history of performance making it hard to predict what you're actually getting, absolute ineffectiveness versus LHP, and most importantly injury proneness.

ESPN's Jayson Stark says the Reds are aggressively shopping Ryan Freel and will entertain offers for Josh Hamilton.

 

Will the Marlins make move? they went after him once...if the Marlins acquire Kemp, you could trade for Hamilton and move Willingham to 1B. Just a thought

I'd be reluctant because of no track history of performance making it hard to predict what you're actually getting, absolute ineffectiveness versus LHP, and most importantly injury proneness.

 

A platoon with Cody would make me hot.

ESPN's Jayson Stark says the Reds are aggressively shopping Ryan Freel and will entertain offers for Josh Hamilton.

 

Will the Marlins make move? they went after him once...if the Marlins acquire Kemp, you could trade for Hamilton and move Willingham to 1B. Just a thought

I'd be reluctant because of no track history of performance making it hard to predict what you're actually getting, absolute ineffectiveness versus LHP, and most importantly injury proneness.

 

A platoon with Cody would make me hot.

At the price of Volstad or Thompson?

 

I'd rather send some crackers and peanuts to TB for Rocco or Dukes.

ESPN's Jayson Stark says the Reds are aggressively shopping Ryan Freel and will entertain offers for Josh Hamilton.

 

Will the Marlins make move? they went after him once...if the Marlins acquire Kemp, you could trade for Hamilton and move Willingham to 1B. Just a thought

I'd be reluctant because of no track history of performance making it hard to predict what you're actually getting, absolute ineffectiveness versus LHP, and most importantly injury proneness.

 

A platoon with Cody would make me hot.

At the price of Volstad or Thompson?

 

I'd rather send some crackers and peanuts to TB for Rocco or Dukes.

 

Oh, no. For the right price, that is. I'd much rather have Rocco or Dukes, all things being equal. But for the right price (a low prospect), he and Cody platooning would make me feel awfully good about CF.

Why would you want Rocco Baldelli?

 

He hasn't played over 100 games since 2004.

 

2004!

gotta think the Marlins are in on this.... or atleast exploring options

Isn't our old friend David Weathers still in Cincy and will be setting up for Cordero after a pretty good year on his own part as closer. I don't know their relief situation intimately but I wonder if the two mentioned above don't have more value here than there until things get sorted out.

 

Frankly I would rather package prospect(s) for Hamilton than start to disassemble our bullpen for a player the Reds are willing to part with with a troublesome history of injury and we all know what else, not to mention his problems hitting lefties. That he's potentially on the block may be quite telling or it may mean nothing. But I would tread lightly.

Blah, he's a phenom. Worst case you don't hit him vs lefties or you could see if those 74 at bats were more flukey than anything.

Isn't our old friend David Weathers still in Cincy and will be setting up for Cordero after a pretty good year on his own part as closer. I don't know their relief situation intimately but I wonder if the two mentioned above don't have more value here than there until things get sorted out.

 

Frankly I would rather package prospect(s) for Hamilton than start to disassemble our bullpen for a player the Reds are willing to part with with a troublesome history of injury and we all know what else, not to mention his problems hitting lefties. That he's potentially on the block may be quite telling or it may mean nothing. But I would tread lightly.

Or it could mean that the Reds have a cornucopia of outfield talent right now and could contend as soon as this season with the team they have.

Sure if we get back some pitching from a cabrera trade we would jump into this.

 

It would be interesting if we take the giants type of deal and do something with this.

 

If we add say a Lincecum and a sanchez to the rotation, could we then use a pitcher to get hamilton? I have no clue what the price would be on him but gotta at least ask. The kid is still younger and has potential tobe a stud. Gotta wonder how much park factors helped (will hurt here) to him. But the kid is so talented gotta wonder what he will turn into eventally

 

 

too bad we didnt get in him the rule 5 last year cincy was smart to trade ahead of us

I'm still pissed we didn't even try to create a bidding war for him at the Rule V

 

100k!

 

that's all cin paid for him

 

I mean I realize this is a cheap orgnization but 100k!

 

even if we didn't get him atleast we would have made his price raise for CIN

Hamilton would be a nice pickup.

 

If we can't work out a deal with the Angels as far as Miguel Cabrera, we should still attempt to pickup Reggie Willits, as he has been pushed out of the starting outfield in LA.

ESPN's Jayson Stark says the Reds are aggressively shopping Ryan Freel and will entertain offers for Josh Hamilton.

 

Will the Marlins make move? they went after him once...if the Marlins acquire Kemp, you could trade for Hamilton and move Willingham to 1B. Just a thought

I'd be reluctant because of no track history of performance making it hard to predict what you're actually getting, absolute ineffectiveness versus LHP, and most importantly injury proneness.

 

A platoon with Cody would make me hot.

At the price of Volstad or Thompson?

 

Dukes!!!!!!!!

 

Agreed.

The word is that Dukes will be a National.

 

Looks like he will be a D-Ray. Unless they are just being stupid and dealing all their outfield talent except for Rocco away.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.