Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Orioles at Marlins
Baltimore goes ahead 4-3, still top of the 8th.
-
Orioles at Marlins
Baltimore has tied it in the top of the eigth 3-3 and are still batting.
-
Orioles at Marlins
3-2 Fish, but Orioles scored a run in the top of the seventh
-
Box Score v. UM
You're right Hot, but it was the emphatic way he agreed with Weiner in post #76 ( http://www.marlinbaseball.com/forums/index...dpost&p=1060785 ) that led me to include him. I like Lou and while I think the stats thing is way over-rated (IMHO) he's capable of making a rational and enjoyable argument without them.
-
Box Score v. UM
Beast. Hermida was on the radio this morning, & when asked "give us a couple of scouting reports, some new players to keep an eye out for." he replied with Hanley & Dan Uggla. Said Uggla can really swing the bat. What does Hermida know? :whistle Weiner and Lou have already decided he's an over the hill minor league prospect who "...has no concept of the strikezone and he is going to be brutally punished for that failing...". I don't know why you'd think Hermida knows anything about hitting when these two have already made it abundantly clear they know more about Uggla than his teammates.
-
Uggla getting defensive
What I find wrong with stats as the end all and be all of determining player value is that it ignores so many factors. In horseracing for example, the condition of the track is included in stats. The other horses in the race, etc. In baseball, an error on an infielder may be determined on what the scorer sees or wants to see. Where player A may have gotten a hit because the scorer decided the SS couldn't get to a batted ball, the very same play may (or not) be scored an error if an overacheiving SS miraculously reaches that same ball but throws it over the first baseman's head. In short, until stats can take the human element out of scoring, and include factors like field condition (grass or turf, muddy or glassy), situational play, etc., stats will remain what they are, a fun tool for the obsessed and for the Billy Beanes of professional baseball, a useful one. There's too many variable not included for me to take it seriously. But for me, I'm reminded of the old business saying that "98% of the truth will kill you every time". Perhaps one day I'll embrace stats but not until they are more inclusive of factors they so far ignore.
-
How good is Dontrelle?
I've been following this OH thread since it's inception (in fact I mentioned it here in another thread a couple of days ago) but remained silent on their messageboard even though I was tempted to enter the debate. As Marlins fans yes we've had a rough off-season but O's fans have had a rough decade, watching their franchise underacheive year after year. Find fault all you want with with our ownership but at least we've been playing meaningful games (not to mention a WS championship) for the last three years. The Orioles have not. Their fans are desperate for a winner and so when a one line rumor comes out like this it's understandable why there's a stampede to their keyboards to find a way to land Miguel Cabrera, and now Dontrelle Willis. If you followed the comings and goings at OH this off-season it's the same debate over and over, only the name of the player(s) in the spotlight change. And following the debate, heartbreak as the coveted player goes elsewhere. It's a pity so ravenous a fan base is betrayed year after by Angelos and company. Generally, the people at OH hold the Marlins in contempt. They look down on us. The see us as easy pickings. What it really is though is contempt for their own organization which has made one wrong move after another. They look at us and in some respects see themselves in the mirror. Some there are so desperate they would want the Marlins contracted just on the hope that some of our players would wind up in Baltimore. At the end of the season I suspect our records will not be all that different. There's a lesson there. And more importantly, a hope in South Florida that the future will bring a competitive team and winning record in short order. In Baltimore there is no hope.
-
Uggla getting defensive
I paid $27.95 plus tax for the Baseball America Prospect Handbook that ranked Uggla as the Marlins 29th best prospect. Your welfare check came this week I assume?
-
Uggla getting defensive
I assume Lou, you've seen him play and you're not going by one review of the guy, from the drunkards (by their own admission) at BP. Only kidding Here's what's confusing to me, and I'm not asking this rhetorically. How can he be the Southern League second base (and utility player) end of season all-star and suck so badly? Either the other nine starting second baseman (nevermind utility players) in the league are just awful, which is hard to believe, I mean, there has to be one decent second baseman (better than him) in the best minor league in baseball doesn't there? Take a look at the company he's keeping on the list of league all-stars. That's pretty good company (talking about position players). From Russell Martin to Hermida, Murton, Guzman, Delmon Young, etc., virtually every guy on the list looks to have a future in major league ball. So, I say to myself, it can't be that he's THAT bad. I admit, and my dear friend the Shamster will attest, I'm old school. To me all this fancy stat stuff takes a distant second to onfield play, desire and dare I use the phrase so hated by statheads - clutch hitting and play. I don't subscribe to this nonsense that you can determine a player's value by simply plugging in some numbers and analyzing them. The problem with stats (at least for me) is they don't take into account anything but numbers and statisticians haven't been able to quantify intangibles, and probably never will. At this point it's only fair I admit I haven't seen Uggla (or most of these kids) field one ball, nevermind seen them play night in, night out. That's why I try to stay clear of predictions, whether they be starting lineups or pitching rotations or how many HRs some guy will hit this season. Will Uggla succeed? I honestly don't know, but he seems to have accomplished some pretty good credentials so far. I'm willing to see how things play themselves out before I say the kid will be great, or he sucks.
-
Uggla getting defensive
Every scouting report and story on Uggla says he has a long way to go to just be average as a fielder......Pokey Reese I last saw in 2004 when he was helping the Red Sox win a World Series as a defensive replacement, sometimes starter. I don't think Reese will hit over .250, but his defense will be very good.....he has won a couple Gold Gloves. "Every" scouting report and story? I'm sure you wouldn't mind publishing them here. Otherwise I'll assume you're just making up more stuff as is your want. I'm dieing to see these scouting reports you have access to. Here's the Year End All-Star team for the 2005 Southern League. Uggla was voted best second baseman AND utility player (he played three positions last season). It's an interesting list with a bunch of now familiar faces including Hermida. The Southern League is probably the premier AA+ level league in minor league baseball. Check it out. http://www.southernleague.com/nm/publish/news_71.shtml How he could be the best second baseman in the Southern League and still have "a long way to go to just be average as a fielder" is beyond me. Is he Luis Castillo in his prime? Nope. Is he going to leave fans in the seats breathless? Probably not. But does he have a chance to become a respectable major league second baseman, absolutely. He also performed well in the post season AFL where he hit .304, had an OBP of .390 and hit seven home runs. Maybe the scouting reports you have didn't indicate how well he performed in 2005, but it's hard to miss, if you really have an interest in looking. http://www.minorleaguebaseball.com/app/mil..._pbp&pid=462564
-
Starters for First 3 Exhibition Games
nice, I'm psyched to see Garcia pitch. I think he really got lost in all the pitching talent we've acquired this offseason. BTW, does anyone have Jose Garcia's 05' stats? There are about 12 Jose Garcia's listed on minorleaguebaseball.com, none of which seem to be associated with a team in the Marlins system. http://thebaseballcube.com/players/G/jose-garcia-7.shtml
-
Uggla getting defensive
Chum isn't here to talk baseball, Chum is here to stir the pot. There's no guarantees affixed to any ballplayer, at least none I've seen. Who knows how a particular player will pan out? No one, including Chum.
-
Uggla getting defensive
He's a 25 year-old AA prospect who strikes out at a frightening pace. 2B is going to be as big of an offensive concern for the Fish as CF. Frightening is Preston Wilson. Now there's a strike-out machine. Carlos Delgado struck out 121 last season, Miguel Cabrera 125. Uggla struck out 103 times in 500 ABs and still managed a .378 OBP. While you may have no hope, I'll reserve judgement.
-
Cabrera contract
John, I wasn't taking a shot at you in any way. Apologies if you thought that was my objective. :thumbup As for the MLBTR site I find it totally worthless but everyone is entitled to their opinion.
-
Cabrera contract
The mlbtraderumors.com (read, three guys on crack) have the Marlins jettisoning Cabrera at the end of the year. The folks over at Orioleshangout.com are having an orgasm trying to formulate a "good" trade ideas. I couldn't help laughing out loud over their conclusions. http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/ http://www.orioleshangout.com/forums/showthread.php?t=30618
-
Project lineup
I can't agree with the notion that having Olivo as the primary catcher in 2006 will be "brutal". He is clearly the catcher of choice defensively and the key to his offense will be where he bats and whether Girardi can fashion a lineup that affords him some protection. For example, assuming the above more or less, if Olivo bats sixth after Jacobs and Uggla seventh, he's going to see a reasonable number of hittable pitches.
-
Starting Rotation
Depending on how well Olsen does in spring training, and how his elbow holds up, Vargas may eventually be traded for another piece of the puzzle. The operative word in the preceding sentence BTW is "may". A Vargas trade could very well be the next Matt Clement type event where you look at it in the minute and scratch your head but he's the furthest along of the kids and may be expendable if Petit, Nolasco, Olsen and Johnson show significant promise in spring training. Again, I'm not advocating it, I'm not demeaning him in any way. We all know pitching is coin of the realm and his upside looks to be lower than some of the others, but with enough major league experience that another team may be willing to pay handsomely for a lefty fourth or fifth pitcher to solidify their rotation. Getting good value for him could significantly improve the team in future years or even immediately.
-
Mora to skip WBC over third-base snub
I'm not REALLY dissing Miggy but... Such is life among the egocentric. It's inconceivable how some spring games are going to affect his contract year post-season value. It sounds more like a temper tantrum than aything else. He'll probably wind up in CF when all is said and done. Makes those Orioles-Marlins Grapefruit League games all the more interesting.
-
Uggla getting defensive
The point is, winning is always important. You play to win the game. Which is of course exactly what Girardi has been saying (and some here found fault with). Whether Uggla contributes for one year or six, you get the feeling he (like so many others in camp) understands exactly the opportunity he's been handed. Clearly the manager is looking to get as much punch as he can out there, even at the cost of a little defense, realizing that pitching isn't going to win games this season, especially as the year wears on. Hopefully if we come up on the losing end of a 7-6 game it will at least be more entertaining than watching a group of $65 million superstars score two runs a night.
-
lineup still up in the air
While this is all fun and games we haven't heard word one about how Reed, Aguila, Hermida, Jacobs or Willingham are doing offensively so far this spring. While there are a few people here who enjoy playing these guessing games for myself I feel compelled to wait, as frustrating as that is, to get some idea of how well some of these guys are doing with the the bat in real game situations. It won't take long for someone to point out that spring training stats mean nothing (see one Abraham Nunez as exhibit A) but this season, like it or not, careers will be made or shattered between now and April. There's 59 guys out there literally playing for their lives. As much as Hermida, Cabrera, Jacobs looks as close to a lock as we can expect, what happens if Stokes comes in and sets the world on fire? Or Helms or Aguila ends March with a .395 OBP? The world turns upside down. I hate waiting as much as the next guy but like the starting rotation, before we find ourselves filling roster spots, the gamelogs will tell the story.
-
lineup still up in the air
I'm heartened to read Girardi is considering Miggy batting fourth with Hermida third and Jacobs fifth. It seemed to make so much sense, but when I read that Girardi wanted Miggy batting third, I said "okay, he's the guy who knows what he's doing...". I can hardly wait to see some of these guys play.
-
Spring training capsule for Marlins
It's Knight-Ridder. Perhaps you didn't see their Herald intro to spring training today that crucified the Marlins. The front page is pics of all the departed players and where they went. No mention of the Marlins players appears until page six (after full page stories on the Yankees and NY Mets), the first Marlins story titled "Picking up the Pieces" about how hard poor Perry Hill has it followed on page seven with a piece on Lenny Harris and his fighting to survive. The entire section is pretty much devoted to where ex-Marlins players have been sent and what spring training games you should go to (only one game has the Marlins playing, of course against the Red Sox so you can see Gonzo and Mikey and Joshy, etc.) where you can see them. One might think they would focus on the new players in town but that's not the Herald's agenda. It seems that everyday they have to remind South Florida that there's been a rebuilding effort. Get used to it. Clark Spencer and Kevin Baxter won't feel the season is complete until each of them makes sure they have mentioned Josh Beckett was traded away at least one thousand times each. You won't find a discussion of Travis Bowyer's 100 mph fastball or the fact virtually every Mets fan in America had Mike Jacobs penciled in as their ROY in 2006, heck Hermida gets less play than Juan Encarnacion's travels in the off-season. I wanted to puke as I read this, my only solice is that Knight-Ridder, being one the worst run, worthless piece of crap daily newspaper chains in America is about to be taken over and the pieces sold off because they are such dismal failures even in the monopoly market they serve (lol). It's like not being able to sell steaks in Dallas Texas and you have the only steakhouse in town.
-
Holly's Spring Training Pictures!
Geez, I hope Kranitz fixes Messenger's stride this spring.
-
To SoFlaFish & Co.
Help me Lord :banghead
-
To SoFlaFish & Co.
Wow. Cape, the guy is kind enough to spend his time answering your/our questions in a way they we lay people can understand and you keep arguing the law with a land use lawyer. It's like a car mechanic arguing with a vascular surgeon about how to replace a heart valve. Give it up.