Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. Speaking of upcoming games and their importance down the stretch Smoltz is being pulling from Monday's game against the Fish and will be replaced by our old friend Todd Wellemeyer.
  2. (re: Carroll) I don't see why/how people want him as an everyday starter, at a corner outfield spot. Maybe because he's the best defensive outfielder on the team and perhaps in the organization (that's MLB-ready) and maybe after a horrendous start and playing only sporadically his bat seems to be improving markedly giving hope that not only can he play superior MLB defense, he can hold his own at the plate as well. I know he's not the guy you want out there but thankfully you aren't making these decisions, in fact none of us are, so if people want to form their own opinions I say go for it.
  3. Good riddance, guy who is 4th on our team in OBP and had an .800 OPS over the last month. f*** you, Hermida. it's amazing how the same people who constantly scream about "small sample size, small sample size" when it's a player they are intent on trashing are happy to do the exact same thing when it makes their boffo point about their fave players. everyone is happy Hermida was on a roll and contributing in August but if you must ignore how he performed for most of the season (May/June/July = .325/.326/.305 OBP, .685/.698/.708 OPS) to make your sarcasm work, let me break the news to you, it doesn't.
  4. Darn, although I wonder though if since he was on the active roster and the Marlins make it into the post season, does he represent an exclusion to the Sept 1 rule and his roster spot could be filled with a similar player? Maybin came up a day early so it doesn't affect him one way or the other, and I know they changed the rules on roster replacements but theoretically this could be a blessing in disguise (for the marlins not hermida). Not sure, wish I could remember that rule change.
  5. Erick, I don't think that's what Uberschnell said. Following one player doesn't mean not following the team as a whole. We don't live in an either/or world - maybe you do but I never would've read that paragragh that way. As to the subject of this thread, and Donnelly's opinion on WC vs Division, obviously he's been in this situation before and been in the league long enough to have the qualifications to form an opinion. I'm not even sure I agree with it but why people here have a problem with him having one baffles me. To me it gives me pause to stop and reconsider my own opinion, that someone that close to what's happening, with knowledge of both our team, the competition, etc., sees things this way makes me believe I should be more open-minded in how I consider how things might play out.
  6. The Chewie thing is growing on me I have to admit :thumbup
  7. To be fair, Ken Rosenthal is a closet Marlins fan He must be way deep in the closet then :brigginbounce I remember that he picked us to win the Division last year a bit after the deadline I'm not sure which deadline you mean in 2008 but if memory serves by the first week in September he was picking the Mets to finish in first.
  8. To be fair, Ken Rosenthal is a closet Marlins fan He must be way deep in the closet then :brigginbounce
  9. There's a certain momentum that if Coghlan continues will force him onto the national stage. He's gone from total obscurity to being a darkhorse and next leap is to contender, etc., it just depends on how long he can stay on the roll he's on - and having NJ and then Hanley hitting behind him in the lineup certainly doesn't hurt the cause.
  10. Luckily the Marlins had the forethought to sign Helms for two seasons so if you expect to keep one of Gload/Helms that decision has already been made for you. I wouldn't be surprised if both return with Bonifacio replacing Amezaga as super utility guy. As for Coghlan playing the infield he hasn't proven he can yet (although he sure has proved he can swing a bat at this level). The best thing going for that argument is he's proven he can adapt and with a better level of coaching may be able in fact make that transition. We'll know pretty quickly after the season and the WS is over what Beinfest's intentions are regarding Uggla if history repeats itself, he starts early to get whatever arb issues he wants resolved out of the way.
  11. BTW anyone know the record for fastest 3 runs scored in a game...The Marlins may just made it in the record books I would imagine it was back to back to back jacks. And on the subject of the "lost" closer, the one who got away because the FO is too cheap, etc. blah blah blah it might be worth mentioning that it's no secret that seemingly every conversation with virtually every team since 14 months ago included a demand for Stanton or Morrison etc. Other GMs knew what we needed and what we had and the name of the game was get as much as you can for as little in return so I have no doubt if there was bargaining going on for a Heath Bell the asking price almost certainly included our most prized future stars.
  12. Donnelley will be back Volstad will be up as is RVH, Martinez who seems invisible to most people can be tried in a more limited role, you aren't going to jettison Nunez or Lindstrom but until one them can establish themselves again in the roll I think the next part of the schedule allows Fredi and Wiley to look to a closer by committee situation so some guys can get some rest or at least cut down on their innings.
  13. Occasionally the other team is going to win and today was the day they did. This is not a bad Nationals team, at least not as bad as their record might imply, we took two out three, we won the series and now we go to New York in hopes of doing the same. Don't get me wrong it's a painful loss not to mention the waste of an afternoon a) there's nothing that can be done now and b) I suppose the rest of the day will be spent playing the blame game. I hope not. The really disconcerting thing was how at peace Zimmerman appeared during that his last bat as if he knew what was coming, he was mentality already making the turn around first...
  14. All eyes should be on the Zephyrs today too with Volstad making his first and probably his one and only AAA start before I assume rejoining the club. edit: Miller was scheduled to pitch tomorrow's Zephyrs' finale. Obviously that changed.
  15. called comcast, pre-recorded message that there is an outage in dade and broward "and our technicians are working to restore service...you do not need to stay on the line...blah blah blah"
  16. the good news is (because I thought one of the guys said they were on sunshine tonight) there is only 2:00 left in the football game
  17. says marlins live is on 39 college football is on 38 comcast
  18. I have a black screen I assumed it was a blackout until the Fox game is over but this is actually pre-game so who knows...
  19. I mean, I work for FIU's student paper with the sports section and I'm the columnist. I guess I'm the Dave Hyde, or whatever. Either way, we were interviewing the team's starting quarterback and asked us to basically be completely positive in our coverage and stop criticizing and reporting negative stuff and basically act as Public Relations for the athletics department. The Director of Student Media had the best response: "Well, yeah. But that's Cuba." Any reporter who is in that club house has a duty to himself, his career, and his readers to report what happened. Is there a person covering the Marlins who you don't think has a bone to pick with the team? If they covered only the positive stuff, they'd just be PR for the team, and that is nobody's job. And it's not easy to report this kind of stuff, no matter how much you may believe that every person covering the team is just looking to destroy them. If you cover a team, you need them on your side so you can get the best possible stories. That being the case, why would anyone try to f*** them over? Because their job is to report on what happens, good or bad, and specifically report on what people want to hear. Seeing as this thread has 100+ replies, I'm guessing this is a big story for Marlins fans. It's not just "the media" digging the knife deeper. You'll do well in *in some other line of work* bobby but clearly journalism isn't your thing if you really believe your job is to report everything. Reporters or columnists with that attitude usually don't have long careers. You just *can't* keep burning every bridge you cross *by reporting everything* and expect people to trust or confide in you. As for my perception of many of the people covering the Marlins I'm able to separate opinion from fact and I have fifteen+ years experience reading their work as it comes to the Marlins, and newspapers are my forte. If you're your newspaper's Dave Hyde (lol) then who would you be fronting for because for a decade Hyde shilled for Wayne Huizenga and everyone knew it, which is okay, carrying his water any time Wayne needed something in the press. There's a number of people who cover the Marlins who do a good, sometimes excellent job - Capozzi, Rodriguez, Navarro and as others have matured, guys like Spencer and especially Dan LeBatard (who recently started writing again for Herald) who have grown out of the "let's be nasty because we can and that's what our editors expect from us" mentality into an excellent beat reporter and nationally recognized columnist respectively. But a Mike Phillips, to the end, despised the team he covered and made that abundantly clear right up to the day they ushered him out the door with early retirement. There are a ton of great print reporters around, South Florida unfortunately is not a Mecca for them. Almost to a man, at both papers in town Boston baseball guys are really good at their craft. Joe P in KC is the best, literally I think the best, there's plenty of quality reporters and colunists out there. The fact is reporters have no such obligation to report everything they see or hear especially in a clubhouse atmosphere. There are filters and decades old rules of conduct that they have to observe lest they be estranged from the sport they're paid to cover. Part of their job is to know what to and not to write, they are there first to cover the game, on the field, not be personality reporters for Us magazine. There's stuff much better left unsaid and while can be frustrating for readers and fans generally it's work for a century or more since reporters were allowed to mingle with players (clubhouse access really only became the norm thirty years ago or so, before that they had to grab players in a hallway or in the parking lot to get a quote. (Let me just slide this in here quickly - the recent Ramiez-Uggla dust up deserved to be reported. No argument there. It is a big story.) You asked a question to which the answer is obvious. First of all Dave Hyde as an example doesn't cover the Marlins, he covers sports from a columnists point of view, that's his job description, if the sport that day is baseball so be it, football or basketball he's paid to write his opinion (within ethical guidelines usually), but that doesn't mean he can't take something insignificant or tangental and put it under a microscope and because he has a bone to pick with a particular team or personnel within the organization blow it way out of proportion. He often does. And in the past he's done it for what a number of people *think* was the wrong reason. Secondly, part of a player's contract is they have to give a certain amount of access to the media. The reason you can pick up the three major daily newspapers and read a story that may differ in a few details but is essentially the same story written by different reporters is because there is very little one on one anymore. Players have learned that the best way to not be misquoted or to fulfill their media obligation with as little effort as possible is to talk to them all at once so that's why you'll see Fredi being interviewed some night with eight or ten microphones in his face, or similarly someone else in the clubhouse. If they have to give the press five minutes, they do everyone at the same time. Same with the front office. At various times of the year Admin Beinfest and Mike Hill have daily or regularly scheduled press conferences. And there is where the reporter or columnist gets most of his information. And a good bit is considered background or off the record. GMs and reporters don't hang out eating cheese sandwiches and drinking a beer as it was decades ago, these things are now tightly managed and scripted. And if you're one who regularly takes a negative slant when covering the team or you have spent the last six months looking under every rock for something embarrassing or negative, you're just frozen out of the questioning, not unlike White House press briefings where there are people who have sat there for years and never been called on to ask a question. With experience you'll understand that life's a two way street and if you stay in news coverage which is an honorable profession you'll find out for yourself where the edges are. I might suggest that your obligatory statement in your post is probably more better said by following the motto of the New York Times, "All the news that's fit to print". The operative phrase, the qualifier being "fit to print". If you think you can carve out a career by penning everything you know, see or hear, every little secret, you won't have a career long. Whether it be common sense or common decency or any other filter, there's a reason they exist. It's not a bad thing. Just because the star quarterback throughout your interview with him can't go five minutes without scratching his nuts doesn't mean you have to report that the star quarterback can't go five minutes without scratching his nuts. There's a number of reasons why but hopefully you understand the point. The same goes for a baseball clubhouse where you can't report every injury to every player, or tonight's starting pitcher still has a sore shoulder from his last outing, or a couple of guys had words, or whatever you were privy to. For example every reporter in the media a few years ago, broadcast and print, knew of Preston Wilson's family problems but decided among themselves not to take it public. There are boundaries. Self-imposed boundaries. Your response will no doubt be how much smarter you are than I am and I don't know what I'm talking about AND you have the stats to prove it (j/k). I'm comfortable in my own skin what my strengths and weaknesses are and as it pertains to the former one is publishing. You may be able to run circles around me when it comes to extrapolated stats and sabermetrics but this is not an area where you can compete. That's not a bad thing, but is a fact. We all have our areas of expertise. Woodward and Bernstein needed "Deepthroat" as much for direction as he knew were the bodies were buried, he understood the history, the story behind the story, he kept them pointed in the right direction. Experience does matter in this thing and when you have some you'll understand why it's so vital to being a good journalist. I never argued the story shouldn't be covered because frankly I'm as much a junkie for inside baseball stuff as the next guy and I always want to know more but I did find fault with parts of Hyde's column (I also complimented him on parts I thought he did a good job bringing public) and I don't mind saying so. ** portion deleted I don't comment on every column he writes, the vast majority I either read and that's that, or I ignore, but ** I reserve the right to comment on anything I find worth commenting on.
  20. Bob I'm usually unafraid to heap scorn on the media when I think they're at fault or prejudiced about a story but in this case I'm not sure they are here. No way was this going to stay under wraps if as many reporters as I suspect were there or thereabouts. The one thing I "hear" as I read more and more of these accounts is this didn't start Tuesday night, this very well may have been something festering for a while and may have wider implications than just a hamstring and a batting crown. This also sends a message through the clubhouse that for a good number of players this season isn't over yet which may have been something that the press in fact were covering up or at least not exposing to the light of day. Lastly, I'd like to believe that Hanley was being inarticulate in his second language when he said he was 10%. If you believe he had already gotten the message from something that conceivably took place the night before ("I have to have the respect of my teammates...") and he wanted to play, he didn't mean he was 10%, that would be the equivalent of being crippled, he meant he was 90%. It wasn't until he spoke with Fredi was a decision made not to play him last night. Possibly, but if he was indeed 90%, then how could he not play in the middle of the playoff race? I'm sure Fredi would have put him in there if he was 90%. The only logical options I can think of are that he really was 10%; or, the rest of his body was 100%, but his hamstring was only 10% recovered (this is odd, I know, but it is a bit different than the 1st situation); or, he just has absolutely no command of this aspect of the language, and he is neither 10% nor 90% but instead somewhere in between, and he just didn't know how to properly quantify it. And to Out of the Past too... None of us are ever objective when it comes to health and wellbeing issues because we rationalize the severity (in either direction) of something based on outside influences whether in this case perception he was losing the respect of his teammates, or if you think its the other side, he was mired in a slump and didn't want to play. Neither one has anything to do with how injured he really, medically is or was. I doubt he was 90% or 10%, that's my point I guess, he threw out a number that may or may not have been understood the way he meant, and even if it was, it was a self-diagnosis that may or may not have been particularly accurate. This whole thing is has an undercurrent that has little to do with Hanley's hamstring. I don't particularly like Dave Hyde's work as he always writes with a purpose not necessarily evident to the reader but to his credit he peeled back the onion a bit farther today. How much of it is supposition on Hyde's part (what does and doesn't happen in major league locker rooms for example or his semi-character assassination of Dan Uggla) but he did clear up the Wes Helms thing (if he's to be believed) a bit and a particular player's job being in part to babysit Hanley in 2008. All in all I thought after reading the piece two or three times it was just meant to stir the pot and see how much trouble he can cause. I haven't had my radio on all day but it wouldn't surprise me if Hyde popped up on a radio station retelling his column for some self-publicity as he likes to do usually at the Marlins expense. The Marlins and everyone involved would like to see this die and put it behind them, the media on the otherhand smells blood and if the wound isn't quite deep enough to really cause damage a number of them are more than happy to stick that knife in a little deeper to see how bad things can get. You do understand that that's the media's job, right? They're supposed to report everything they see/hear. Gee Erick, no that isn't their job. That might be your idealized view of it but that's what they do on the movie screen.
  21. The starting pitcher sets the tone. Is this some baseball truism I've missed all these years? What a strange concept in a team sport, and the idea of momentum isn't individual, it's collective. But again this is what happens when you have different ideas of what the word means and it shifts to fit any argument.
  22. Which leads me back to the initial quote I used in this thread: "Momentum is as good as your next day's starting pitcher." If Sean West sucks tonight...there goes that great "momentum." And I agree with your last sentence. But if Sean West does "suck" tonight and the Marlins still prevail in the end, then where are we :brigginbounce This is basically a semantics argument regarding what a word means and how it should be applied. There's no right answer here, not with conflicting definitions.
  23. Bob I'm usually unafraid to heap scorn on the media when I think they're at fault or prejudiced about a story but in this case I'm not sure they are here. No way was this going to stay under wraps if as many reporters as I suspect were there or thereabouts. The one thing I "hear" as I read more and more of these accounts is this didn't start Tuesday night, this very well may have been something festering for a while and may have wider implications than just a hamstring and a batting crown. This also sends a message through the clubhouse that for a good number of players this season isn't over yet which may have been something that the press in fact were covering up or at least not exposing to the light of day. Lastly, I'd like to believe that Hanley was being inarticulate in his second language when he said he was 10%. If you believe he had already gotten the message from something that conceivably took place the night before ("I have to have the respect of my teammates...") and he wanted to play, he didn't mean he was 10%, that would be the equivalent of being crippled, he meant he was 90%. It wasn't until he spoke with Fredi was a decision made not to play him last night. Possibly, but if he was indeed 90%, then how could he not play in the middle of the playoff race? I'm sure Fredi would have put him in there if he was 90%. The only logical options I can think of are that he really was 10%; or, the rest of his body was 100%, but his hamstring was only 10% recovered (this is odd, I know, but it is a bit different than the 1st situation); or, he just has absolutely no command of this aspect of the language, and he is neither 10% nor 90% but instead somewhere in between, and he just didn't know how to properly quantify it. And to Out of the Past too... None of us are ever objective when it comes to health and wellbeing issues because we rationalize the severity (in either direction) of something based on outside influences whether in this case perception he was losing the respect of his teammates, or if you think its the other side, he was mired in a slump and didn't want to play. Neither one has anything to do with how injured he really, medically is or was. I doubt he was 90% or 10%, that's my point I guess, he threw out a number that may or may not have been understood the way he meant, and even if it was, it was a self-diagnosis that may or may not have been particularly accurate. This whole thing is has an undercurrent that has little to do with Hanley's hamstring. I don't particularly like Dave Hyde's work as he always writes with a purpose not necessarily evident to the reader but to his credit he peeled back the onion a bit farther today. How much of it is supposition on Hyde's part (what does and doesn't happen in major league locker rooms for example or his semi-character assassination of Dan Uggla) but he did clear up the Wes Helms thing (if he's to be believed) a bit and a particular player's job being in part to babysit Hanley in 2008. All in all I thought after reading the piece two or three times it was just meant to stir the pot and see how much trouble he can cause. I haven't had my radio on all day but it wouldn't surprise me if Hyde popped up on a radio station retelling his column for some self-publicity as he likes to do usually at the Marlins expense. The Marlins and everyone involved would like to see this die and put it behind them, the media on the otherhand smells blood and if the wound isn't quite deep enough to really cause damage a number of them are more than happy to stick that knife in a little deeper to see how bad things can get.
  24. Well I didn't care for the article. Isn't it nice that we can each have our own opinions without some guy telling the other why he's wrong... :thumbup
  25. We need to go on a huge tear. I don't mean this to be argumentative but what we need to do is win tonight and worry about Friday's game tomorrow. The rest will take care of themselves but tonight's game is pivotal. BTW, I know what you meant.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.