Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Dontrelle or Lenny
The question is do you want to put Willis in harms way? 716454[/snapback] Jack didn't seem to mind doing it last year. 716457[/snapback] I didn't like it last year and I still don't but I understand why Jack did it on rare occasions. I remember Dennis Cook was also a h*lluva hitter when he was with the Marlins. It's one thing when your bench is used up and an important, vital win is on the line to call on a good-hitting pitcher to try and secure that victory. It's a completely different matter to be using DW frequently (such as baseball is played in the NL) as your regular lefty pinch-hitter.
-
Dontrelle or Lenny
The question is do you want to put Willis in harms way?
-
Taker for Encarnacion? Marlins after Sanchez?
All players have strengths and weaknesses. Pierre is no different. But when you weigh the pluses and minuses, he's as good it gets based on the talent he has. 712122[/snapback] Bill James once wrote, " Every form of strength covers one weakness and creates another, and therefore every form of strength is also a form of weakness and every weakness a strength" aside from that statement being pretty irrelevant, the point Im trying to make is, Marlins2003 is exactly right, I'll take a couple of runners advancing to third on a tag-up, if it means Pierre runs down what would've been a double :thumbup 715683[/snapback] What if your weak at everything... :plain 715744[/snapback] Then you're playing in an Independent League in Minnesota. :blink: :blink:
-
Marlins Make 3 Roster Moves
I don't think its a matter of Wathan not receiving a "good loook", rather they saw enough of him to confirm what they already knew about the guy, which is he a capable utility guy if the need arises.
-
Taker for Encarnacion? Marlins after Sanchez?
Encarnacion shouldn't start on a contending team. Also, a bench player shouldn't make $4.5 million dollars. Therefore, we have significant evidence to reject the claim that the Marlins should keep Encarnacion at the 1% level. 714070[/snapback] Huh?
-
Taker for Encarnacion? Marlins after Sanchez?
I don't think anyone is arguing that both Encarnacion and Conine can't make valuable contributions to the Fish in 2005, but the rumor being floated regarding Enc is not (at least this time) one created out of thin air or from disgruntled fans. It's been reported by several legitimate sources. Obviously the front office must see such a move as a way to upgrade the team, they aren't in the business of weakening a team that by all accounts is a post-season contender. I've not been a basher of Encarnacion and probably have more respect for his skills than the majority here, but if the FO feels they can improve the team by moving the guy then I'm all for it. I don't believe trading Encarnacion is under consideration purely for financial reasons. Let's just hope that whatever value we get in return strengthens the team overall. One of things that may be precipitating all this is the emergence of Chris Aguila who has gone out and proven that he belongs on a major league roster. Between Conine and Aguila, the Marlins would have a platoonable duo in rightfield. With Hermida a year or maybe two away, Aguila seems poised to be an everyday player somewhere, or as mentioned above, as a platoon player in the outfield. I guess it all comes down to who we'd receive in exchange Encarnacion if he is traded. My guess is it won't be another outfielder, although if it's Pittsburgh they have a bunch of young outfielders and someone is going to get traded. I've mentioned Tike Redman (who hit .312 in his last 99 games last season) but there are others as well. And they have some pretty good young pitchers and perhaps more importantly an excellent pitching prospect who might be included. If Encarnacion continues to do well in ST there may be more than one team interested in his services.
-
Taker for Encarnacion? Marlins after Sanchez?
Good post Chin, but if Enc is traded (since it's not our call) getting a kid like Tike in return would be a h*lluva move. I'm with you on Cabrera in right 100%. He's said so himself. He's a guy who needs to stay on the left side of the field. 711832[/snapback] Replace one unwanted player with another?? The Pittsburgh-friggin-Pirates dont want this guy... 712149[/snapback] Not being wanted by Dave "Let's hope I can make it one more year before the world realizes I'm a fraud" Littlefield is hardly a crown of thorns. McClendon loves the guy, it's DL who thinks he knows better. Littlefield is ready to bet the farm on Mackowiak. While Mach is batting almost .580 in spring training, Redman's no slouch batting and even .500. You'd think if Littlefield had a brain in his head he's find a place for Tike. Maybe the Marlins aren't the right fit for the guy but alot of teams could do worse than have Tike Redman in their everyday lineup.
-
Taker for Encarnacion? Marlins after Sanchez?
It's the exception that proves the point.
-
Marlins Make Seven Roster Moves
I too am surprised Bentz was moved so quickly to the minor league camp but that may be with a mind to get him more work.
-
Taker for Encarnacion? Marlins after Sanchez?
OK, then forget Sanchez. If you can trade Encarnacion and get something of value (even a middling prospect would be nice), it'd be nice. Clears some salary and opens up more playing time for Willingham, who may not be as great as an asset at corner outfield but is arguably better than Enc and Conine. And Aguila, who BaseballProspectus had this to say: "the difference between Aguila and Juan Encarnacion is virtually nil, save for the money guaranteed to the veteran." Also...who are you saying is below average defensively? Sanchez and who? God help you if you meant Pierre or Castillo..... 711947[/snapback] Pretty sure he means Pierre. He's not the only one who feels that way. He covers up a lot of his misplays with excellent speed. That noodle of an arm has cost the team some bases. 711955[/snapback] When you're roaming around in the deepest part of PPS it really doesn't matter whether it's Steve Finley, Juan Pierre or Preston Wilson, guys are going to move up a base regardless of who's out there. What Pierre does that is so masterfully is cover an enormous amount of territory, not just back and to either side, but in front of him as well. Sure his arm is not the strongest in the league and if someone wants to argue it's less than average, I'm not going to take up the fight to defend him. But for every runner that might advance solely because of his arm there's two guys sitting in the dugout having just flied out when most centerfielders would have allowed them to wind up at second base with a standup double. All players have strengths and weaknesses. Pierre is no different. But when you weigh the pluses and minuses, he's as good it gets based on the talent he has.
-
Taker for Encarnacion? Marlins after Sanchez?
Good post Chin, but if Enc is traded (since it's not our call) getting a kid like Tike in return would be a h*lluva move. I'm with you on Cabrera in right 100%. He's said so himself. He's a guy who needs to stay on the left side of the field.
-
Marlins-Yanks game
Following up on Moehler. If the Herald is correct that Moehler pitched 3 2/3 innings of scoreless ball and was credited with giving up three runs he must have left in the fourth with two outs and the bases loaded, and the next guy(s) couldn't get the job done.
-
Taker for Encarnacion? Marlins after Sanchez?
Maybe I'm wearing rose-colored glasses but it's inconceivable to me that JP and the Fish won't come to some agreement on 2006 and beyond without much trouble at all. Also, Tike is batting an even .500 right now and is working his butt off to make a team that seems to care less if he stays or goes. I'd love to see him in a Marlins uni although he would block Hermida's eventual ascent to the bigs but would be the heir apparent if Pierre was to go elsewhere.
-
Jeff Allison article
This article was a case of an editor, who having sent his writer to Massachusetts, and who then came up empty (it was after all about as a non-story story as you can find) felt compelled to show something for his expenditure and had the writer write it anyways. Carlos Frias might as well gone to Cleveland to research this one.
-
Marlins-Yanks game
It doesn't really look like Moehler got torched. He had three shut-out innings before giving up three in the fourth. Hard to tell what took place in that inning.
-
Harris or Dillon?
"The announcement of my demise has been greatly exaggerated" - Mark Twain After today's game with the Twins, Lenny Harris is batting .366 in spring training which is about what Dillon and Willingham are batting COMBINED. Lenny is out there trying to win a job, something these kids need to do. No one has to write to back saying that it's a statistical anomoly or that it's too early to be drawing any conclusions because I know that. But at the same time it gave me a good laugh to look at the box score today. Don't right-off the old man so quickly.
-
Bump is battling to make the team
The sooner Jack sends the kids and wannabes off to the minor league camp the better so the guys who really have a chance of making up the bullpen have a chance to show their stuff and get ready for the start of the season the better off everyone will be. I'm hoping we'll see this team down to 15-16 pitchers sooner rather than later. As for Bump, I couldn't be more ambivalent. I don't see him making the team, but if he does so be it. If Moehler continues to pitch well and Reidling and Jones do their thing, I don't see where he fits in. Bump either steps up and proves he belongs or he should be gone, for his and the team's good.
-
Beinfest is usually right on the money
People seem to like put Dave Dombrowski on a pedestal and say he really built this (2003-2004-2005) team and was responsible for developing a great farm system but at the same time they are willing to ignore why he was able to acquire the likes of Burnett, Lowell, etc. It's because he prostituted himself and did his master's bidding as the architect of the destruction of a world series team and his actions nearly destroyed major league baseball in South Florida in the process. If Admin Beinfest or any other competent GM had the major league talent Dombrowski had to dispose of one can assume they would have done equally (or if not better) than Dumbo Dave. Those same people also ignore the significant number of DD trades that didn't work out, the draft picks that went nowhere, the signing failures. All they want to point to are a handful of successes and ignore the other side of the equation. The scales of justice have two sides for a reason, to weigh the pro and con, the good and the bad, and from my perspective those scales aren't weighted in Dombrowski's favor.
-
Beinfest is usually right on the money
Before this last draft, Beinfest and the scouts had done arguably the worst job in the majors. Atleast the Yankees were taken their stiffs in the mid to late 20s. 709658[/snapback] "The worst job in the majors"? Wow :thumbdown
-
Ryan Jorgensen's Spring Training Journal - 3/12
Or LoDuca. Jorgy made it sound like the more secure players aren't expected to catch. Treanor, being on the 40-man roster and entering ST as one of favorites for the backup catcher (the other being aforementioned DiFelice), would seem to fit that title. It was probably Jason Hill. 708903[/snapback] I suspect your right. I don't think he was castigating either LoDuca or Treanor, and looking at the roster of wouldbe catcher lower down in the organization Hill looks like a likely culprit.
-
Ryan Jorgensen's Spring Training Journal - 3/12
Or LoDuca. Jorgy made it sound like the more secure players aren't expected to catch. Treanor, being on the 40-man roster and entering ST as one of favorites for the backup catcher (the other being aforementioned DiFelice), would seem to fit that title. It was probably Jason Hill. 708903[/snapback] I suspect your right. I don't think he was castigating either LoDuca or Treanor, and looking at the roster of wouldbe catcher lower down in the organization Hill looks like a likely culprit.
-
Complacency or Cockiness?
I happen to share a great deal of the concern Chin High comments on regarding this spring training. I'm of a mind that one of the reasons ticket sales (specifically regarding Opening Day) appear to be lagging is the absense of Carlos Delgado, and to a lesser degree LoDuca and others, combined with our pitiful showing so far in the 2005 Grapefruit League. Simply there is no excitement, no buzz, no nothing, coming from camp and that translates into lukewarm media coverage and poor would-be attendance. This team needs a jumpstart to get the 2005 season rolling and it needs it now.
-
Q & A with Dan Jennings
Ramp, congrats on a job well done! I enjoyed it immensely. :thumbup
-
This is not looking good for the Fish...
What their performance to date speaks to is the lack major-league ready guys we have in the organization below the major league level. None of the wunderkids - Hermida, Stokes, Reed, Wilson, Willingham, Dillon (really in a different category) are doing anything ala OMGNunez last spring. And the second-tier players like Treanor, Delgado, Aguila, aren't either. It might be better to start moving guys over to the minor league camp and keep 30-35+/- guys around in the ML camp so some cohesiveness starts to develop. But it's still early in the process and I'm sure Jack is just as frustrated as the players and fans that spring is not off to the start he anticipated. I understand Pierre is now one of the walking wounded joining CD and LoDuca. I wonder if Encarnacion will be showcased in center today or if Aguila or Reed will get the nod?
-
Back-up Back-Stop the issue
What Treanor has going for him is major league experience WITH much of the existing staff. It's his job to lose. Jorgy, DeFelice and Willingham have to convince the manager and the FO that what they have to offer has greater value over the course of the season than the experience Treanor got last season. That's a tough hill to climb. 703149[/snapback] Not really...In terms of making the team, there will be two backup catchers (most likely). Our one emergency catcher (Mordy) isn't on the team, and having Treanor doesn't guarantee a solid backup. We've gone with two backups for as long as I can remember. So really, Jorgy, DeFelice and Willingham just have to prove useful to the club--not compared to anyone else. I think Willingham has the advantage, only because he's versatile. 703166[/snapback] The problem with your theory is that according to virtually every written account, Willingham hasn't proven he can handle the signal-calling (or defensive) duties required of a major league catcher. 703176[/snapback] The problem is his defense, not his game calling. 703186[/snapback] Ramp, the parenthetical thought was meant to clarify not amplify the previous statement, my apologies. :notworthy Let me rephrase, he's got a h*lluva bat but he needs more experience behind the plate.