Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Dontrelle or Lenny

Featured Replies

We know lenny is the all time pinch hit leader but that doesn't say much considering he's been playing since the 1800's. then theres dontrelle that socks the hell out of the ball every time. who would you rather have?

 

continuation of post by batato

um

 

in a clutch situation definitely lenny

 

think about this for a second

 

if there's a clutch situation, you want the 22 year old good hitting pitcher, or the all time pinch hit leading veteran, even though he hits poorer nowadays

 

they hit for around the same avg, so if you take that into account, it's lenny easily

The question is do you want to put Willis in harms way?

716454[/snapback]

Jack didn't seem to mind doing it last year.

pinch hit lenny in late game situations

 

pinch hit dontrelle in early game situations (like in the 5th inning if our starter is having a tough time)

The question is do you want to put Willis in harms way?

716454[/snapback]

Jack didn't seem to mind doing it last year.

716457[/snapback]

 

I didn't like it last year and I still don't but I understand why Jack did it on rare occasions. I remember Dennis Cook was also a h*lluva hitter when he was with the Marlins.

 

It's one thing when your bench is used up and an important, vital win is on the line to call on a good-hitting pitcher to try and secure that victory. It's a completely different matter to be using DW frequently (such as baseball is played in the NL) as your regular lefty pinch-hitter.

The question is do you want to put Willis in harms way?

716454[/snapback]

Jack didn't seem to mind doing it last year.

716457[/snapback]

 

I didn't like it last year and I still don't but I understand why Jack did it on rare occasions. I remember Dennis Cook was also a h*lluva hitter when he was with the Marlins.

 

It's one thing when your bench is used up and an important, vital win is on the line to call on a good-hitting pitcher to try and secure that victory. It's a completely different matter to be using DW frequently (such as baseball is played in the NL) as your regular lefty pinch-hitter.

716488[/snapback]

 

I can understand the concern after watching Willis slide head first into 3rd in the NLDS against San Fran in 2003. He runs the bases with reckless abandon. :o

The question is do you want to put Willis in harms way?

716454[/snapback]

Jack didn't seem to mind doing it last year.

716457[/snapback]

 

I didn't like it last year and I still don't but I understand why Jack did it on rare occasions. I remember Dennis Cook was also a h*lluva hitter when he was with the Marlins.

 

It's one thing when your bench is used up and an important, vital win is on the line to call on a good-hitting pitcher to try and secure that victory. It's a completely different matter to be using DW frequently (such as baseball is played in the NL) as your regular lefty pinch-hitter.

716488[/snapback]

 

I can understand the concern after watching Willis slide head first into 3rd in the NLDS against San Fran in 2003. He runs the bases with reckless abandon. :o

716492[/snapback]

yeah, i also find it disturbing that he actually enrolled in chris carter's speed camp with JP during the offseason.

 

i would've rather he worked on his control.

The question is do you want to put Willis in harms way?

716454[/snapback]

Jack didn't seem to mind doing it last year.

716457[/snapback]

 

I didn't like it last year and I still don't but I understand why Jack did it on rare occasions. I remember Dennis Cook was also a h*lluva hitter when he was with the Marlins.

 

It's one thing when your bench is used up and an important, vital win is on the line to call on a good-hitting pitcher to try and secure that victory. It's a completely different matter to be using DW frequently (such as baseball is played in the NL) as your regular lefty pinch-hitter.

716488[/snapback]

 

I can understand the concern after watching Willis slide head first into 3rd in the NLDS against San Fran in 2003. He runs the bases with reckless abandon. :o

716492[/snapback]

yeah, i also find it disturbing that he actually enrolled in chris carter's speed camp with JP during the offseason.

 

i would've rather he worked on his control.

716551[/snapback]

I don't mind that so much, I think it was more of a getting in shape thing

 

I'm sure he had plenty of time to work on his control...not like he was doing the camp 8-5 monday through friday during the offseason

This is absurd that dontrelle is even close to winning this poll. The all-time pinch hit leader or a pitcher? Its not even just based on probability of getting a hit, its also based on, do you want dontrelle risking injury by runnign the bases and such in games where he isnt starting. Can pinch hitting duty affect him mentality? Lenny hands down should win this.

As contact hitters, they're probably equals. Willis has more pop in his bat and faster, although reckless, on the bases. Potential doesn't mean anything in this case. Willis will probably lose his bat as he focuses more on pitching. Lenny is declining.

 

Depends on the situation. If there's 1 out with a runner on second or third, I'd take my chances with Lenny. I think his bat control may be better. If you need a hit (2 outs, or bases loaded), Willis gives the best chance with his ability to get the ball past the infield and run down the line.

 

There's risk of injury to Willis, but if he does partially fill Lenny's role, a roster spot would be free for a younger faster better hitter or long reliever/spot-starter.

 

Toss a coin.

The reason I posted this was to mock Lenny...Granted Willis is a good hitting pitcher, however theres PLENTY of hitters that would fill Lenny's shoes MUCHHHHHHHHHHHHHH better than Lenny could. This is my point.

Mota can hit too, why don't we pinch hit him.

This is absurd that dontrelle is even close to winning this poll. The all-time pinch hit leader or a pitcher? Its not even just based on probability of getting a hit, its also based on, do you want dontrelle risking injury by runnign the bases and such in games where he isnt starting. Can pinch hitting duty affect him mentality? Lenny hands down should win this.

716624[/snapback]

 

Should win. But just goes to show you who fans believe has a better chance of coming through in the clutch. Harris should retire.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.